MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Geek Fuel EXP Subscription Box Review – Volume #1

Geek Fuel is now Geek Fuel EXP! EXP is a quarterly subscription box filled with tees, hoodies, comics, and goodies – they promised $100 in value for every box. Geek Fuel used to always feature a Steam game in their boxes – just a heads up, that isn’t the case anymore! UPDATE: The EXP box WILL feature a Steam game with every delivery – they will be delivered via email, and the game has yet to be sent out for Volume #1.

This box was sent for review purposes. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

About Geek Fuel

The Subscription Box: Geek Fuel

The Cost: $57 per quarter + $8 S/H

COUPON: $3 off your first quarter + exclusive collectible figure with an annual subscription – no coupon required, just use this link

If you want this box, you can still get it as a one-off purchase while supplies last!

The Products: Games, toys, collectibles and other exclusive gear.

Ships to: US, UK, Canada

Geek Fuel EXP Review Volume #1

This box was fully loaded and HEAVY! The first shipment comes with 7 items across 7 different fandoms.

For even a bit more of a surprise, a lot of the items came in their own little containers!

Pop them open to reveal the items!

The info card is HUGE – it’s like the size of a full-size calendar – and full of details about each item.

The Wade-Y Bunch T-Shirt – Value $15?

8 Deadpools on one shirt – yes, please! I love the idea of Deadpool in the Brady Bunch scenario as well – he can really show off his character range.

The back even has a little Deadpool logo on the upper neck.

Let’s just take a second to acknowledge the greatness of this packaging!

Both sides of the packaging have a little extra Bob’s Burgers flare and on the inside…

Bob’s Burgers Makin’ Apron – Value $20?

I am really into this big, bold, Bob’s Burgers graphic!

It’s really well made – the material feels very durable.

How awesome does it look!?

Again – the packaging is just top notch. It really adds that little bit more to the unboxing experience – it’s like opening a big gift full of little gifts.

Cowabunga Pizza Cutter – Value $15-20?

Geek Fuel felt like it was getting away from some of the great exclusives they’ve had in the past – so it was such a great unboxing experience to find this awesome exclusive in the first EXP!

What better way to cut the turtles’ favorite food than with Rafael’s sai inspired pizza cutter!

It definitely feels well-made, like all of the items in the box, too.

GITD Night King Titans Vinyl Figure – Value $5-10?

This item was one of the only items spoiled ahead of this box shipping – it’s a 3-inch exclusive glow-in-the-dark variant of the Night King.

If you’re familiar with Titan vinyl figures, then you know exactly what you’re getting. This is their body style for all of their vinyl figures.

The Geek Fuel box even inverts to give you the castle background scenery for your figure.

It looks very cool in the dark!

Wolverine #1 Comic Cover Canvas – Value $15-20?

I love me some canvas comic art – so this item was speaking my language.

It’s the cover of Wolverine #1 on stretched canvas – it’s about the same size as a typical print you’d get in a geek box – but this is much higher quality and ready to display.

Again, all of the material is high quality.

And it arrives with the hook for hanging it up. On the case, it mentions this is a part of a “Canvas Collection” – so I hope we see more in future boxes.

LEGO Star Wars “Chronicle of the Force” Collectible Book & Figure – Value $12-17 on Amazon

The only non-exclusive item is this big, 9×11, LEGO Star Wars book.

It wouldn’t be LEGO without a minifigure!

Here’s a better look at the minifigure itself


There are about 100 pages full of Star Wars lore told with LEGO characters.

This could be a fun coffee table book or a great way to introduce the younger generation to The Force.

Planet of the Apes Pin Palz – Value $15-20?

I used to value their single Pin Pals around $5-10 – with this being a double set + button pack, $15-20 felt fair.

You’ll get a mini ANSA button in your pack.

Then, everyone gets 2 of 6 possible pins – with one rare variant in the bunch – did anyone get it?

Verdict: My values add up to around $122 for the first-ever EXP Geek Fuel box – that leaves a bunch of room for value interpretation to still hit that $100 guarantee. On top of the value, I was happy that everything felt very well made – if you’re going to shell out $65 for a box, then it should feel high quality and without filler – I think they did that with their first box.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes! Join today and this will be your first box – just always check the banner on the top of their site to confirm.

Check out all of my Geek Fuel reviews if you’d like to see their old-style boxes. Check out all of our Geeky Subscription Boxes in the Subscription Box List. Rate, review, and follow this subscription on the Geek Fuel profile page.

What did you think abotu Volume #1 of Geek Fuel EXP?

Geek Fuel

How do subscribers rate Geek Fuel?

Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

per quarter
Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about Geek Fuel!

Enable notifications (On switch) to get the latest Geek Fuel spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Eric Cadman

Eric Cadman

Eric is the co-founder of My Subscription Addiction. He’s been hooked on geek subscription boxes since 2012 thanks to Loot Crate and Nerd Block. Geek boxes sparked his desire for collecting Funko Pops and comic book statues!

Posted in Geek Fuel Reviews, Geek Fuel Spoilers, Geek Subscription Boxes, Nerd Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Box Spoilers, UK Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: geek fuel | 15 comments

Comments (15)

  1. I was pleased with the first EXP box. They did say that they will be doing hoodies though when they switched from monthly so that better happen if they want to keep people. Looks like they are not adding one in the second box. Maybe waiting for the fall/winter quarters for hoodies but I live in michigan so you never know when I will need a hoodie LOL. Used the pizza cutter last night works great.

  2. this does not look like it’s worth $60+. don’t think I’ll be getting the next one without seeing a review first.

  3. I love all things Bob’s Burgers. It would be awesome if they included the cookbook sometime.

  4. Great items! Too many fandoms in one box, IMO. 7 items from 7 different fandoms at this price point means I’ll probably rarely sub, if ever. It would be unlikely that I’d like enough of the fandoms in each to justify the higher cost. Bummer, as this was my favorite Geek box.

  5. Honestly, most of this I’ll give away or try to sell but that being said there are a few things that I like. The shirt, the wolverine canvas art, the pizza cutter most definitely but most of the box wasn’t really stuff that I like. I’m hoping that the second edition has more within my fandom choices.

    • and I guess I like the pin too so more than half isn’t bad

  6. I could do without books, too many damn books from loot crate. Everything else looks pretty good though, especially that wolverine canvas

  7. The website said you also get a Steam game each quarter. I’m curious about this as it’s a significant bonus for me given how much my son loves Steam games. Do you know what the game was this quarter? I may need to order this box!

    • That may be old messaging because the monthly box used to always come with a Steam game – this box did not.

    • Just to follow up on this – there are Steam games in the EXP box! The owner let me know that they will be sent out via email instead of being in the box. They haven’t been sent out for this box yet.

      • That’s awesome! Will you update this review when you find out more about the game? Thanks so much for the reply!

    • Jessica from Geek Fuel here! As Eric said, the Steam game for EXP Vol #1 will be sent separately in an email soon. Steam games will still be included in future EXP volumes.

      • Is there any update as to when the steam game emails will be sent out?

  8. Haha I wanted to put Like on the picture of you with the apron! Looks good on you!
    Im happy to see this box being reviewed. I had been waiting to see how well theyll do in their comeback and it seems they have delivered. Im excited to see more of this box in the future. 🙂

  9. Wow, what a fun box!! Although not all these fandoms are my favorite, I really appreciate the curation and the great looking quality and exclusives! It feels like when Lootcrate used to be amazing, so that makes me extra excited! Really hope they keep this up! (And maybe lower the shipping so I can justify buying one!)

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.