Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
Sneak Peek #3 will have you following our motto this month: Eat, sleep & contour! Every charmer will receive 1 @purcosmetics Sculptor Highlight & Contour Palette (Retail value $30)! 💁♀️❤️
Sneak Peek #2 will have you winging it all month long 😉 This month every charmer will receive 1 @pretty_vulgar The Ink Gel Eyeliner (Retail value $24) & 1 @aestheticacosmetics Pro Brush Series: 3-Piece Eyeliner, Brow & Spoolie Brush Set (Retail value $45) 🎉❤️
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I love, love, love Boxycharm!!! Boxycharm is the best thing since sliced bread!! Omgosh how do they do it is what I want to know lol. I don’t at all need any of this makeup but I just can’t cancel this subscription, I’m addicted I just can’t cancel it, I have a major problem I think lol. I do use a lot of the makeup don’t get me wrong I just don’t need it. How can you not get excited by getting over $100+ worth of makeup for only $21?? And getting high end makeup, cheaper than any one product in the box, what I don’t use I either save and gift it later or I give some products to my daughter in law, she enjoys getting the products to, she just doesn’t wear makeup as much as I do. I’m just blown away with this box, I’ve been getting it over a year now and can’t bring myself to cancel it. This is my monthly treat to myself and I enjoy every last minute of it!! Thank you Boxycharm!!
Reply
Heidi
I fully understand. I have more makeup than I will ever need, but I could never cancel Boxycharm. I’m addicted to it! It’s so wonderful to have a surprise every month. It’s like gambling and always winning! 🌟😍😂
Reply
Mariah C Wilson
Not sure how anyone could be upset with this months box! All brands mentioned are very reputable and per the price point?! IT’S A STEAL! Happy Mothers Day to me, thanks Boxycharm!
Reply
RR
I got notification of my box being shipped today. I’ve had about 4 boxes including this one and so far I don’t get what people say is so great about boxycharm. Most of the items I don’t want or need. I’m tired of highlighters/contouring/glitter. don’t use any of that. Need: powder, moisturizing lip glosses, nail polish and skin care, skin care!!!! tired of all the highlighters. Giving them a few more months then onto another one.
Reply
Laura
Boxycharm is a makeup subscription service….hence no nail polish, very little skin care. If that’s what you are looking for Beauty Fix is a good option, Glossybox too. Maybe this just was not the right one for you 😀
Reply
Tracie
For skin care , BIrchbox and Sephora Play are better subs and less expensive ($10/mo). I actually cancelled both of those because I’m the opposite. I don’t like receiving skin care items and both of those are skin care heavy subs. I LOVE Boxycharm because of all the makeup.
Reply
A55magic
LOVE THIS BOX!
Reply
Redhed36
This will be my last box (for a while) from Boxy and I am really happy with it. Can’t wait!
Reply
Yvette
I am so freakin excited! NEVER underestimate @Boxycharm because they don’t play! I knew this box was going to be the Bomb.com 😍😍😍😍 If you haven’t enrolled or subscribed get with it.
Reply
Victoria
I’m excited for the primer, but honestly everything else is meh to me. This is a great value for $21.00 , I am far from complaining g this just does not scream birthday to me.
Reply
misfitmorgan
Super excited about this box and I can’t wait to get it!!
Reply
Sam
I’ve been wanting to try the Pretty Vulgar eyeliner for a while now and have even contemplated purchasing it a few times. I’m excited to have it in my box for this month!!! Everything except the contour and highlight palette looks BOMB!
Reply
Mommy
My box shipped already, anyone else? It’s 0.8lbs
Reply
lesli
mine was shipped so fast too! it’s nice
Reply
Detty
Mine also shipped and also is 0.8! Maybe no variations this month?
Reply
Maranda
Mine only weighs 0.4
Maranda
Mine weighs 0.4
Holly
How do u find out what the box weighs? I only get an email with tracking and the USPS site doesn’t say the weight
Reply
Alexia
Mine already shipped and also weighs in at 0.8lbs.
Reply
RoguesEn3D
The only thing I am interested in is the Pretty Vulgar pot. The brushes to use with the eyeliner will come in handy. I nearly cancelled this month, but that eyeliner pot costs more than the entire box. I really was hoping for something spectacular, given the anniversary. I hope the last two items are fabulous but, if not, I’ll still be happy to have that eyeliner.
Reply
L
IM IN LOVE WITH THIS BOX 😍😍😩😩
Reply
DocN
I don’t contour and I don’t feel a big black hole in my life for it. I also don’t use gel liner like this one, so this box looks like meh from here.
Reply
Julia
Yeah I’m not that excited about it either. It’s only my third month too. I like gel eyeliner, but I don’t want or need black. And I have a couple contour palettes and don’t really use them much. So it’s kind of a meh month for me.
Reply
melanie711
It’s so funny how different we all are which is what makes the world so interesting. What a boring place it would be if we all liked the same things.
I have complained non stop about their boxes recently. They have been all glitter and shine. I’m excited to get this box. It’s actually things I can use. A cover fx product that is matte. A matte contour palette. Some cool eyeliner to try and I can always use brushes especially some that are different than ones I normally get.
I personally was getting tired of the disco theme and it shows that the subs can’t win! They can’t make everyone happy! Lol.
Reply
Lizzie
Idk if it’s for everyone, but I just received an email saying there isn’t a wait list right now.
Reply
Luna
I just got one too. 🙂
Just thought I’d share my Boxy status in case it’s sent to certain people on their mailing list: I recently unsubbed, so I’m no longer a subscriber.
Reply
Lizzie
Yeah, I’m no longer subbed either so they may just be sending to former members?
Anya
I would think if it were their 5th anniversary, that they’d put better products in their birthday box
Reply
Candace
I cancelled and I’m not as sad about it as I thought I’d be. I’m saving that $21 a month to put towards Pat McGrath and Natasha Deanna palettes. We had a good run, Boxycharm.
Reply
Wendy
I had 3 subs, cancelled two after April’s box. Now considering cancelling the last sub. I kept it because it was the “Anniversary” box, I thought it might be epic. So far, I’m not impressed.
Reply
Jennifer Rose Martino
I cancelled after the last box. It was meh at best. Only good thing was the liquid highlighter. Rest was meh. Glad I’m no longer subscribed, this looks blah to me. Especially fir a 5 year anniversary
Reply
Candace
*Natasha Denona. Stupid autocorrect.
Reply
Regina
Looking forward to the primer, like the pretty vulgar packaging, not thrilled with the other two, but I will pass them on to someone that will appreciate them. Never disappointed with Boxy!
Reply
Christy
I want none of this. I cancelled several days ago, but they billed me anyway. Disenchanted.
Reply
Heather K
Interesting, none of these seem to be variations yet….
Reply
Ash_Kay
I agree, this is very interesting as not everyone will be able to work with the shades given. I will be disappointed if they do not have appropriate palettes for different skin tones.
Reply
Jm
I never need anything make-up but I can’t quit this box. I’m always excited to see what I get and appreciate how they put quality items for $21! Thank you 😍
Reply
Jacki
If this is a birthday bash, I think something colorful will be in the final two items!
Reply
delaina
i was thinking this exactly lets cross our fingers
Reply
Jennifer
Wow, awesome value, for only $21.00! Almost $200.00 and only 4 products so far, 2 more to go since we are getting 6 instead of 5 this month!! WOo HOo!
Reply
Christine G
I counted $137 so far, not close to $200. Did I miss something?
Reply
Cheryl
😂😂😂😂😂😂 #BestComment
Jacki
What we know is the total value is spoiled at $170+ and 6 items, two more items to come combined worth at least $33. Who knows what the final value will be.
Nicole
I’m on overload of everything but this is a great item and I’m thrilled with this box! Love that everyone seems to be getting the same items so far. I’m trying to cancel but they keep luring me back!
Reply
Jill
I sincerely don’t know how they do it.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.