Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
How about a high end foundation ? So far Boxy is just about eyes I love eye stuff just wish they would mix thing up a bit
Reply
Dana
High end foundation would be tough, considering they don’t customize this based on a style sheet or anything. I’d personally rather get products that work for a range of people, rather than something where it’s a huge risk I won’t get the right shade, especially since it’d be a whole bottle.
Reply
Jamie
How would they match our skin tones? It’s not an option right now.
Reply
Candi
They could include a voucher/ gift certificate that you could redeem online at the brand’s website for a specific product.
Laura
I just signed up for boxycharm recently, and so far I’m loving everything I get for the price that they charge me. I mean where else can we get high costly make-up for just 21.00 a month? NO WHERE!!! And it be full size. Ipsy gives out travel size. And I really enjoy all the brushes too. I really do wish ppl would just stop complaining about BOXYCHARM. But that’s just me. But the only thing that I’m not going to use will be the false eyelashes, but big deal. I will give them away to someone. BUT TO ME BOXYCHARM RULES!!!!!
Reply
Michelle
I am betting it is a lip product since we are already getting a palette.
Reply
Jackie
This brand spoiler will be for a future box, not the June box 🙂
Reply
satomi
Hank & Henry Beauty? I’m so exciting! I saw this at famous youtuber! I hope it is eyeshadow! Green one please!
Reply
Amanda
He said last night on his live that it isn’t something he has on his site now. It will be something new.
Reply
Jamie
Yes girl yes! I’m with you! I want the green too! Excited!!!
Reply
StaceStace
El Jefe 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Reply
satomi
El Jefe or The Kings Queen!
Reply
Brittany Bailey
So are we getting all 3 luxie brushes? Or just a random one?
Reply
Sweets
All three I believe.
Reply
Sweets
Trois!!!
Reply
Jamie
We are getting all 3. Some ppl are wishing that we were only getting 1 so that the SDJ product could still possibly be a more expensive one, but it’s not happening that way. The box value is between $130 and $139 with $62 of it being the 3 brushes, $28 being the palette and $26 being the lashes. That leaves $14 to $23 for the SDJ item and the last item combined. Ppl were hoping that getting just 1 or 2 brushes meant getting a higher dollar SDJ item or more than 1 SDJ item instead of one that’s just $10-$15. It’s not like that though. We are getting all 3 brushes.
Reply
anna
Honestly, I wouldn’t be surprised if we get the foot scrubbing tool. It’s cheap, fits easy, and it summery. That or the rain forest relief. I know the hand cream is technically in range, but it doesn’t seem the most summer beach theme appropriate to me.
Sherry Ledford
I thought all 3 brushes were counting as 1 item? Thats what i saw on YouTube
Lily
That’s if you count the brushes individually. Luxie sells sets for cheaper (more like $45) so the value of that could be different.
Mo
Oh fiddle 🙈– was in FFF box. MY BAD! So sorry!!!! 🙄
Reply
Mo
Wait! What happened to the BumBum????
Reply
Mo
Well I sure as he$$ hope it’s not another set of false eyelashes (Come onnnnnn Boxycharm, really?????) or another PALETTE!!!!*
*long-time subscriber ready to ditch Boxy over these godawful “palettes”
Reply
Jackie
I’m a long time subscriber (over 3 years now) and I keep this subscription BECAUSE we get so many palettes. I’m a hoarder and I love that if I need a last minute gift for a birthday or holiday or just want to give a friend a little pick me up, I always have a stash of makeup to give. Most people subscribe to this box because of the palettes. There are plenty of other subs that don’t give out palettes, so if you’re over the palettes, maybe you would want to sub to a box that is less “palette heavy”. There’s so many sub boxes out there, you should spend your money on something you actually look forward to.
Reply
Whitney Earl
I’m with you girl. I too am a bit of a high end palette hoarder!!! I actually love everything we get. Boxy is my FAV sub box of all the 8 subs that i get ( that are all make up, lol). I haven’t ever been able to make lashes stay, so ill get some practice with the ones coming. I’m super excited for whatever we get. Usually the pk of 3 brushes is usually considered 1 item since they are packaged together. <3 Have a lovely day!!
AmyM
I don’t mean to be a jerk, but influencer brands don’t do much for me. I’d rather see brands I know and trust.
Reply
annalily5
I’d super love to try their eyeshadow box, those always looked marvelous, but from the sounds of it it’ll be something new, so I’m hoping it’ll be equally cool!
Reply
Heather G
I considered canceling boxy for a few months until I found out Hank & Henry will be in one of the boxes!! Henry is as funny as he is talented and love his makeup!
Reply
Kathie
It will be fun to find out what the Hank & Henry product will be. It’s going to be a Never before released item…as in Brand New 🙂 That’s Awesome!
This is what they posted on Instagram:
*** THE SECRET IS OUT!!!!! We are beyond excited at @hankandhenrybeauty to announce that we will be in an upcoming @boxycharm box, AND the item in the box is a new item we have not released!!! Where are all my #boxycharm lovers at!?!? BoxyCharm will be announcing what month we will be in very very soon. We are so excited and just love their team so much. #hankandhenrybeauty
Reply
Kelly G
I’m really not feeling this box, but I don’t know if I want to cancel or not. Would I be able to sign back up and use the charms I have saved up, or would they disappear?
I don’t use false lashes, and I feel like I already have all of the eyshadow shades (even though I LOVE eyeshadows), so I’m not sure yet…still on the fence!
I am curious about the two brand spoilers we’ve gotten though, since I’ve never tried anything from either.
Reply
Rawda
I had been a boxycharm subscriber for two years, i cancelled in 2017 and just signed up again in February 2018 and still had my charms in my account and was able to use them.
Reply
Jamie
Your charms will stay and as long as the waitlist is gone you’ll be able to sign right back up, but if they reinstate the waitlist it could take weeks or even months to get subbed again. When I first signed on I tried to get the December box, but couldn’t. My 1st box came in February bc of the waitlist and that one came mid-month. Then 2 weeks later I got my March box. Even if I didn’t like most of the box I wouldn’t drop it just bc of the waitlist potential. Besides, the palette, the lashes and each of the brushes are worth kust about or more than what the box costs so you can always put the entire box up for sale on whatever site you prefer for around $50 and someone will surely buy it no problem.
Kiersten
I havent heard of this brand before but looking at the website im super excited to try this brand!! ❤️BOXYCHARM!!
Reply
Anieke
Hank&Henry said on their Instagram that this is gonna be the item that they haven’t released yet.
Reply
Marie
I’m so excited!!! Really hoping it’s eyeshadow. For those who don’t know who Hank & Henry is search for him on Facebook. I am sure you will love everything about him and his products. I’ve never tried his products but I’ve heard nothing but good things. He is such a beautiful person inside and out. He has such a good heart and knows his makeup. I can’t wait!!! I was honestly thinking about canceling Boxy but this news has changed my mind.
Reply
Courtney
I have never heard of him and just looked him up! The small eyeshadow palettes look amazing! I hope it is one of them! I really like the pretty in pink one!
Reply
Jamie
I hope the Hank & Henry item is the little shadow kit/box thing & I hope I get the green one! I’ve been lusting after it for weeks but it’s out of my normal price range. Maybe I’ll get lucky!
Reply
Amanda Patenaude
The item from them that’s going is the box is a brand new one. Something not on their site. I’d LOVE one of the eyeshadow kits to!!
Reply
Jamie
Awww. Oh well. I hope it’s as good, as fun and as colorful as the eyeshadow box was. If I get a black liner or a mascara I’ll be heartbroken.
Gina
I’ve never heard of them either. Only a couple of the eye color cubes look appealing to me. I hope it’s a lip product.
Reply
Jillian
Never heard of them. 🤷🏻♀️
Reply
Jenna
I thought the Lashes were the Hank & Henry item.
Reply
Jackie
I think the lashes are from Battington or something like that. Hank & Henry is going to be in a future box.
Reply
Jamie
You’re correct Jackie. Hank & Henry is coming in July or after that. Battington lashes will be in the June box.
Stephanie
I think it’s going to be one of the eyeshadow box trios. Gabby used one awhile back in an IG video and was raving about the pigment & packaging. I had never heard of the brand before that though.
Reply
Marie
I’ve never tried his eyeshadows but I hear amazing things and I’ve watched his videos. His line is fairly new so he doesn’t have a huge line but he’s growing quickly. He deserves it though, he is a good hearted person and so unique. Look him up and watch a few of his videos. I really hope we are getting the eye shadow. It’s $37 but comes with 3 shades.
Reply
Sweets
Really? I remember only seeing two. I must look again.
Sweets
Do the charms add up on their own – w/o my doing anything? I am on my 3rd box & finally decided I am keeping BC. Of course I signed up for spoilers ectera.
Heather K
Also, if we always get the sold out items, (I have never checked that out so I do not know) then theoretically we may get the sol de janeiro brazilian golden body veil as our June SDJ item. It has been sold out everywhere since just a little while before the brand spoiler came out.
Reply
Mel
Brand spoilers are not exciting. I do like the little eyeshadow cubes, though. Having a loose pigment to compliment the duo is pretty neat. I wouldn’t be upset to receive one, if that is the product we receive from them.
As long as it isn’t anything matte for the lips. So over that.
Reply
Phyllis
Their stuff is adorable! So excited to try it out..😊
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.