MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Sock It To Me Women’s Subscription Review – February 2018

Sock It To Me box

Sock It To Me is a sock subscription for men and women that sends out 2 pairs of exclusively created socks.

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

This is a review of the Women’s, $22.00 per month, box. 

contents of Sock It To Me Women's February 2018

About Sock It To Me

The Subscription Box: Sock It To Me

The Price: $22 a month + shipping

The Products: 2 pairs of quirky, super fun socks

Ships to: US only

Sock It To Me Women’s February 2018 Review

open Sock It To Me box

When you first open your Sock It To Me box, you’ll notice a big ol’ “SURPRISE!” on the inside of the lid, almost like you just walked into your own surprise party. Two pairs of shiny new socks are also revealed.

Box reuse ideas at bottom of box

Once you take them out, you’ll see they’ve urged you to recycle the box and have given you a bunch of (questionable) ideas on how to do so.

Sock It To Me Magnet featuring a pig with balloons

I also received a cute little magnet that has a piggie being lifted into the sky with a bunch of colorful balloons.

Sock It To Me info card

Next, the info card. It states their promise to you, each month: to make you smile with their kooky socks!

other side of Sock It To Me info card with a heart cutout

Since it’s February, the other side has a Valentine cutout of a cute heart.

Heart cutout with fingers

I tried to make mine do a little dance, for your enjoyment.

Unicorn Fair Isle Women's Crew Socks other side of Unicorn Fair Isle Women's Crew Socks close up of Unicorn Fair Isle Women's Crew Socks

Women’s Unicorn Fair Isle Crew Socks – Estimated Value $11.00

The socks that come with the subscription are exclusive and aren’t sold on their site, or anywhere else. They’re sometimes a sock that will eventually become available, but not until later, so they’re essentially a “sneak peek”. Based on other crew socks though, I was able to estimate these to have a value of $11.00. The first of the two pairs I received are of the “crew” variety and feature what I can only describe as a whimsical design of pastel unicorns, rainbows, and stars. They’re a blend of 52% cotton, 46% polyester, and 2% spandex, so they are breathable and fit my size 6 feet snuggly but with plenty of room to stretch for larger feet. Although not terribly thick, they are comfy and have a pretty detailed design. These are super bright and fun and come about halfway up my shin.

Horse head Nebula Women's Knee Socks other side of Horse head Nebula Women's Knee Socks close up of Horse head Nebula Women's Knee Socks

Women’s Horse Head Nebula Knee Socks – Estimated Retail Value $12.00

Like the first pair, I estimated the $12.00 value based on other women’s knee socks, but these are nowhere to be found on their site. As promised, these fantastical horse head nebula socks go all the way up to my knees, and have a left and right, meaning that it’s not just the same sock duplicated in the pair. The horse head appears on the outside side of the sock on each one. I really like the colors used: the black, fuchsia, blue, purple, white, and turquoise all look great together and make a lovely space scene. This pair has a slightly different composition as the crew socks and is made of 54% polyester, 43% cotton, and 3% spandex. I think that extra spandex was definitely needed to get the sock around my ample calf. 😉

Verdict: My first Sock It To Me delivery was fun and full of horses. I like that the pairs they send are exclusive, so it makes the box a little more special than just buying what you want from their shop. At $22.00 with free shipping for two pairs of socks, this subscription is a bit higher than others but came with a lil magnet. It looks like I saved $1.00 compared to if I would have bought a pair of each (although they currently are having a 15% off sale) but I would have had to pay $4.50 shipping, so I’m still coming out ahead here.

To Wrap Up: 

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? The socks are a total surprise – so you might not get the same items as you see here.

Value Breakdown: At $22.00, you’re paying $11.00 per pair of socks.

Check out all of our Sock It To Me Reviews to get more information on this subscription. Check out all of our Sock Subscription Boxes in the Subscription Box List. Rate, review, and follow this subscription on the Sock It To Me profile page.

Do you subscribe to Sock It To Me?

Written by Marne Orenich

Marne Orenich

Marne is a lipstick connoisseur, record collector, and twice over cat mom. She loves discovering new clean beauty brands and has quite the collection of beautifully packaged serums and moisturizers.

Posted in Sock It To Me Reviews, Sock Subscription, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| Tags: sock it to me monthly | 4 comments

Comments (4)

  1. Thank you for the giggle with the bonus (and absolutely adorable) dancing entertainment in your review! It was very much appreciated.

    I have a question about this sock subscription and any other sock subscriptions. This is for Marne and anyone else that could PLEASE, PLEASE answer. I need some fun socks as I recover from a terrible accident involving a dislocated ankle, compound fractures, etc. I need socks that aren’t tight, especially at the top. Of all the FUN socks, which one is the most comfortable that would be best for someone with circulation problems or swelling or injury recovery? Sorry, in advance, for TMI, but felt it was needed to explain why I really need the more forgiving top border and general fit, while not giving up the giggle factor.

    • Hmmm- I asked around and we agree that none of them offer particularly loose fitting options (although there are some no-show options that don’t go above the ankle at all). If only there was a legwarmer subscription!!
      Hope you heal quickly!

      • Thank you for asking around. The intarsia patterns are usually tighter for some reason. If there’s ever an island discovered that they name Intarsia, I’ll never visit it, because I refuse to wear tight clothes. 😀

  2. I love both of these sock designs!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.