Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I got the bellapierre mascara. it smells AWFUL and made my eyes burn. and the hot pink blush, which is a totally unwearable color, especially on my fair skin. really a disappointing month and it’s only my second box.
Reply
Michelle Butler
The Bellepierre Mascara made my eyes burn too! Almost immediately. It sucks anyway. If it hadn’t changed the color of my lashes, i would not have known i had any mascara on. No lengthening or any volume at all. I can’t believe anyone would buy it.
Reply
Cynthia
I received box variation #1 and it had the Hush Blush and Double Decker in it. So happy! 0.9 lbs
Reply
justmissjamey
Since its showing all 4 boxes…does this mean all of us will be getting the hot pink?!?! I don’t see a box with the other color in it…
Reply
Brianna
I got Box #1 and it had the Hush Blush in it, not the hot pink color.
Reply
Alexia
I’m interested in the answer to that as well. I’ve seen some unboxings with the other blush variant, so I’m thinking either there’s an error with the variations on MSA, or there’s a 5th variation.
Reply
Alexia
Definitely loving all the variants this month, with the exception of the bellepierre mascara. Does anybody have the weight spoilers yet?? Mine’s .9lbs
Reply
justmissjamey
I agree , I got the funky craft like bellepierre glitter last month…,hope I get one of the butter London this time….mine says it’s .9 as well. I usually tend to get box number 4 often
Reply
Carissa
so far I’ve gathered that .9 should include the double decker mascara and the more nude blush, and the 1 lb will include the bella pierre mascara and the hot pink blush. IF blush color goes along with weight, that is.
Alexia
My fingers are crossed for us both girl! My variation # doesn’t seem consistent, but I’ve read that most people’s are. And since I don’t care which blush I get, if I get the Bellepierre I’ll trade it and the blush together just for one of the Butter London’s.
Misty
Wow.!!! It is so nice to read these comments and not see much complaining like the usual.. hopefully all the negative people have moved on.!
Reply
Marta Kuil
well, I just guess this whole box is much better than the previous 2. that”s why people seem satisfied
Reply
Jilli
People are going to have issues always, and that’s ok. Us as the consumers explaining our issues is how companies get better. 🙂
Reply
Rhenn Rainbow
I’m very happy to see the variations cut down. Variants should be just like this… everyone gets the same item ( mascara,blush) but the exact one or color variable. And no variant on the palette! Bravo! I already got the palette from pur, ( they sent me it instead of the trolls eye palette I bought, didn’t offer, just sent a completely different palette) and I actually love it! So i’m Kind of glad to have two of it. I might be in the minority here, but I really love that they give us an eye palette most months.
Reply
Rhenn Rainbow
Though I do wish they would cut back on Bella Pierre. IMHO, it’s overpriced and very poor quality. That’s really the only thing I don’t want this month, the Bella Pierre mascara..
Reply
justmissjamey
Agreed.
Christy
Yes, I agree about bellapierre. I loathe seeing it in any subscription box. Horrible quality and something I can’t even give away.
Betsy Wetsy
Can’t wait to get this box! Only thing I really hope I get is the Barbie Pink colored blush. That color is gorgeous! Just got my shipping notification but it’s still going to be days before I receive my box. Great box this month! Super excited! <3
Reply
SunnyT
This month I honestly don’t care which variation I receive. Last month I was lucky enough to get the highlight pallet and seraphine lip scrub. This month my box weighs .8, and I’m looking to the Pur pallet and really don’t care which mascara I get. I love the Tarte one we got a few months back, and I’m still using it! Plus, just received a smaller Tarte mascara in last months Allure.
Reply
Amanda
What box did you happen to get? Mine weights .8 as well.
Reply
Christine
I really like how they have cut back on the variations this month. And I already have a HG mascara so I don’t really care which mascara I end up receiving.
Reply
Wendy
I will be happy with any mascara that has a fluffy brush. I don’t like the hard plastic brushes at all, don’t work well at all for me.
Reply
Nicole
Glad they seem to listen to their customers and cut out most of the variations. Obviously the Bella Pierre is the only dud but looks like an awesome box! Hoping for the more wearable blush color but I feel like people are so creative in showing you how to make products wearable no matter the shade (with the exception of those greige/brown lippies for us pale gals)! Kinda hoping the spoilers for next month are not my jam bc I’m on serious overload!
Reply
ADRIENNE
I agree! The Greige/brown lippies look absolutely atrocious on us brown girls too. Those colors aren’t made for humans in general lol.
Reply
Ks
I love greige lips though. Haha.
Redhed36
I don’t care which mascara I recieve as I am unfamiliar with all of them. I am hoping I don’t receive that bright pink blush. Hoping they stick with the two color variants they shown previously. Excited for my box
Reply
magoosmom
Same–any mascara works, and I’m really hoping for a useable color for the blush but otherwise this looks good to me.
Reply
Candace
I already have Double Decker and have been wanting to try Iconclast so I’m good with either of these.
Still haven’t found anything that beats out Maybeline Great Lash for me. I’ve used that since middle school and I can’t believe it’s still around! I have yet to find any other mascara that does what that one does for me. The search continues….😁
Sydney Smalls Beauty stated that she got a Bellapierre mascara this month so there’s another possible variant to be aware of.
Reply
Grace J Mock
As for mascara, I have tried a bunch but my holy grail is Urban Decay Perversion. I use it with the Subversion lash primer and everyone asks me what kind of false lashes I am wearing!!! I don’ wear falsies. The combo works better than anything I have tried. I have 2 tubes as a backup, most other mascaras if I try and don’t like i give to a friend that can’t afford to buy her own makeup. Nothing else I have tried holds a candle to that stuff!!!!
Reply
NikitaMarie
I agree 100%! Perversion is the absolute best mascara on the market, imo!!
Sarah
Glad I canceled. Great value – yet the palette every month is annoying, palettes are great for teenagers who like to play with makeup . That color of blue is awful – great to for halloween though. Mascara is nice though, yet mascara is in a ton of boxes – Boxycharm needs a complete change. No more paletes! If they decided to paletes in PLEASE make them more adult like, no teenage blue colors, no more awful color lipsticks and makeup that dont go with peoples skin tones. Every box I’ve gotten from them the makeup colors are meant for a different skin. tone. Boxycharm needs to improve on customizing boxes for peoples skin tones, also the fact you can not skip a box and have to cancel a box if you have to many products is ridiculous. I used to get the box because there was always one nice skincare item in the box that is the value of the box so i could careless about the rest of the items, yet now it looks like skincare has been replaced by brushes. How many brushes does someone really want or need?
Reply
sheridan
I’ve purchased the Butter London Iconoclast mascara a few times. It’s one of my top three favorite mascaras! I’d be really happy to receive that or any of the items in this month’s box. I canceled all my beauty box subscriptions early this month because I’m on makeup overload–I only have one face after all–but now I am regretting canceling BC. It’s really the best!
Reply
Robin Lackey
I am hoping for the lighter color blush and one of the Butter London mascaras. But truthfully, any will be fine with me. 😃
Reply
Kellie Cole
I’m hoping for one of the Butter London mascara to try and the softer blush.
Reply
Mayra
Glad there’s not a big difference in the variations. I was so disappointed last month. I only kept one item from my 2 Boxy subscriptions.
Reply
Lucy
Yeah… I don’t know what happened last month but Boxycharm totally missed the mark. No wonder people got so mad!
Reply
Susan
I 100 agree with you Lucy!
No doubt why Boxy Charm is off the wait!
It doesn’t take a genius to understand what fair means and last month,not to mention other months where variation products didn’t come close in comparison,not to mention in price either….made a lot of people,already fed up,cancel their subscriptions!
March’s box is an excellent example of a fair variation,so thank you Boxy Charm!
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.