Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I can’t request my Colourpop palette preference, can I? There’s only one I want but with my luck I’d get any other one. lol! If I could, I’d join.
Reply
Jackie
No, unfortunately you can’t request, but the good thing is everyone wants a different palette so if you don’t get the one you want, there’s a good chance to swap for the one you do want. I don’t own any ColourPop palettes so if someone wants the one I get, I’ll happily swap.
Reply
Kiersten
So excited for colour pop to be in the future boxes. This brand is great quality. I already own several things from them so im pumped! 😊
Reply
Misti
I’ll take 1 of each Please LOL Love them all now just got to figure out if I need to get my daughter her own box to keep her hands off mine.
Reply
Regina
I have 62 palettes including the new Life’s a festival too faced one ( so giddy over it) I am 48 years old very active. I do most anything from going dancing to riding Harleys , nothing stops me. Especially not my age. I love all colors, shades, ranges, or whatever strikes me at the moment. I am missing a palette from colourpop I will gladly except any of these into my collection. I know, I know, how can I have 62 palettes and none from colourpop. I buy mostly urban decay, too faced, tarte, Kat von d, have the occasional few mixed palettes of different brands boxy has sent out in the last year. Bring it on boxycharm, I like your style. ( kissy kissy )
P.S. Of course there is no way I can use all these palettes!! I’m realistic! But!! It if I want a specific shade of shadow, likelihood is that I have it. We all get to choose what we spend our own money on. Mine is palettes ( kissy kissy )
Reply
amy
so happy with this! i would love ANY of these
Reply
JB
I don’t have any of these, so would be happy to get whatever they send. But can anyone tell me, how on earth does everybody get decent use out of all these palettes? I still have a few unopened, due to previous Boxy palettes and the ones I’ve purchased on my own…I only have two eyes and do my makeup once a day! And don’t tell me to unsubscribe cuz I won’t.
Reply
MzBev
I rarely buy palettes anymore BECAUSE of getting them from Boxy! I have gifted a few of the neutral ones since I have plenty of those colors already. Very happy to get new colors for my collection!
Reply
steppamy
lol! i feel the same way! but i love eyeshadow so much! i use a different palette everyday so mine are getting used very slowly.. no complaining here 🙂
Reply
Nyesha
I only use Colourpop super shock shadows because they are AMAZING!! However, I do want to try 1 of their palettes so any of these will be great. Come on with it Boxycharm!!
Reply
Jules
Has anyone tried the golden state of mind pallet and liked it? I tried it from Sephora and ended up returning it because I couldn’t get any color payoff. If you have any tips let me know. The other pallets look fun though!
Reply
Kiersten
I already bought the golden state of mind a few months back and i reallh enjoy it. I love all the shimmer. I personally use an eyeshadow primer and it lasts all day for me and the colors really stand out. Im obsessed with colour pop products right now. Lol i cant wait for aprils box. Hoping i get any of the other pallets since i already have golden state of mind
Reply
Grace J
If you do not get any good color payoff with a brush you can try 2 things. Wet your brush with some setting spray before dipping into the palette and foil the shadow it will make it last longer and will make the color pop, or apply with a finger and tap onto lids. Works best with metallic or shadows with sparkle and shine. Hope that helps.
Reply
Stephanie S
For GSM and the Semi-Precious Metals palettes, the makeup artists usually use a wet brush to apply for better color payoff. I don’t have any of these palettes but love my Yes Please palette and single shadows that I have. I’d like any but the MLP or EoS palettes, mostly because I have similar shades elsewhere. Love Colourpop though!
Reply
Jackie
Yayyyyyy saw this on Yosefs IG stories yesterday! Hoping its true! At least if there’s variations, there’s a chance we can all get what we want thru swapping! Im so excited!
Reply
Lucy
Can I choose which one I want? Pretty please Boxycharm!?? I want the You Had Me At Hello palette! I love the colors. I’m 48. Please DON’T send me the Little Ponny palette!
Reply
Jan
This is not boxycharm. And you dont get to choose your products. Boxy is not tailored to our individual wants, its just curated boxes, and being 48 has nothing to do with makeup, I really wish people would stop using their age as an excuse for personal preferences. Im 53 and I love bright colors and glitter and my age has nothing to do with what I like and your age shouldn’t affect your preferences either.
Marie
I’m 47 and I love the My Littke Pony palette. LOL.
Rhenn
Please don’t let these be variations! I want them all, especially the gold one and the purple one
!
Reply
disneyjoy1970
I do enjoy receiving eye shadow palettes in my Boxy, so this is not a complaint. It’s a suggestion… I wish they would mix it up some. I get tired of receiving eye shadow palettes, so often. Perhaps include an entire face palette (that has blush, highlighter, pressed powder, eye shadow and a bronzer). Maybe a lip palette of some sort, some good quality skincare items- like a good overnight moisturizing mask or some “Saturday Skin” skincare items, hair care items. I do love Boxy, just wish they’d branch out a bit more.
Reply
Selina
I totally agree, a face palette, lip kit or skincare mix would be nice!💖💖💖
Reply
Sara
I love ColourPop palettes!! They’re so beautiful and highly affordable. I have 4 already. You Had Me At Hello looks gorgeous!!
Reply
Jess C
I wish we could tell them if we already own one haha. I have Element of Surprise. 1/5 chance of getting it isn’t too terrible…
Reply
Marie
I have all of them except Element of Surprise, so I hope I get that one.
Reply
Lenya
I have all of them except for semi-precious, so I’m in a similar boat!
Nicole
I’m down for the golden one please! That my little pony one looks similar to the Winky lux cat palette that I did not end up liking.
Reply
laura elliott
I own the pony pallette and it is nothing like the winkie lux pallette. I love both but they are very different.
Reply
LeddyFM
I was thinking the same thing! I gave that Winky Luxe palette to my younger cousin, and I had no interest in those My Little Pony collab, from anywhere. I love Pur Cosmetics palettes, but theTrolls, & MY Little Pony collection were a hard pass.
I’m excited about the prospect of a Colourpop palette in a box, though! Their palettes are just as good, if not better, than higher end brands.
Reply
Karenkk
OMG I already have all the pallets except the little pony one which I don’t like 🙁
Reply
Rashma
It say future box spoiler,does that means April???
Reply
justmissjamey
P.s.i wanted the color pop one from sephora but it was sold out..the photos of looks people did with it looks amazing too.
Reply
justmissjamey
Oh yes ma’mm!!!! Please, I’ll take all the pallettes shown throughout this year and won’t complain…haha excited for the other items mentioned as well!!
Reply
Heather K
Looking through the comments it is reading like the My Little Pony pallette is colorpop. I thought it was Pur. Almost positive. Are they owned by the same company? Or am I missing something else?
Reply
laura elliott
They both have a my Little pony pallette. I personally prefer the colour pop one.
Reply
Victoria
Hooper this is not PUR it’s the color pop one. I’ve been wanting th PUR my littl pony one badly!!
Reply
Candace
I have that palette and I just love it.
I don’t think they’re going to do anymore restocks on it so if you really want it you might want to snag it. They’re trying to clear out the collection, it was all on sale about a week ago.
Victoria
Ooo wow it was meant to say “Nope”not Hooper lol
Candace
Pur has one too. I have it and it’s great. Pur’s has a galaxy looking unicarton and the palette is white
Reply
Cheyenne Skaggs
Could this be 5 months in a row!? OMG Never canceling my BC!
Reply
Candace
I have the My Little Pony palette in my cart right now. Haven’t pulled the trigger yet and now I don’t know what to do. Do I buy it? Do I wait?
Reply
Chandra
Wait,if you don’t receive it in Boxycharm, it will go on sale. Granted I bought mine Black Friday but I get sale emails all the time.
Reply
Meow
Please let me get MLP!!🦄
Reply
Toni
Bring on the colourpop Boxycharm , I love getting my Boxycharm each month . I keep some I give some but I’m always happy with what I get.
Reply
JuJu
Lol, I already have all of those palettes. 😊
Well, not all, I have the left three on the pic.
Reply
Jazzy
Same here! I’m a big time ColourPop beauty junkie and have All of these palettes!
Reply
Mayra
We should get 2 since they’re not pricey. 🙂
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.