Posted by on in Clothing Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women, Wantable Fitness Reviews | Tags: | 17 comments

Wantable Fitness Subscription Box Review – February 2018

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

wantable box

Wantable Fitness is a fitness styling subscription service similar to Stitch Fix. You fill out an in-depth survey about your fitness clothing preferences, and your stylist picks out items for you.

details on the wantable fitness edit box

The fee for this service is $20 a month, and that fee goes toward whichever items you choose to keep. If you keep 3 or 4 items you also get a 20% discount, and if you keep all 5 items you get a 30% discount.

how the wantable fitness edit box is packaged

Wantable sent me this box for review purposes. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

all items in the february wantable fitness edit box

About Wantable Fitness

The Subscription Box: Wantable Fitness

The Cost: You’ll pay a $20.oo non-refundable styling fee to start. You only pay for what pieces you decide to keep, and the $20 styling fee goes towards the cost of what you purchase!

The Products: 5 pieces of workout or athleisure clothing curated to match the preferences you set when you sign up. Keep 3 or more pieces to save 20%. Keep all 5, and save 30%!

Ships to: Ships free to the U.S. (Currently ships to the U.S. only.)

Wantable Fitness February 2018 Review

wantable fitness edit info booklet for february 2018

note from stylist for wantable fitness edit for february 2018

wantable product list for february order

The box comes with a booklet that contains a list of the pieces inside as well as a note from my stylist. In my experience, you get a new stylist for each order, rather than keeping the same one. This month, I got Natalia, who left a quick note about her favorite pieces in the box, as well as a reminder about the discount for keeping three or more items.

store credit card

back of wantable order booklet

informational strip in wantable fitness edit

details on the information strip in the wantable fitness edit

There were also some promotional papers in the box. Wantable’s revamped a lot of things for 2018!

In the style quiz I took when signing up, I noted the types of things I like, love, and dislike wearing, as well as the price range I’d be most comfortable spending on different pieces (like tops, bottoms, and tertiary styles like jackets, etc.). To get a feeling for the prices and quality I should expect with this subscription, I picked the mid-range price bracket. It looks like the items I got in this box run from $39.00-$72.00.

return bag

They also include a pre-paid shipping envelope to use with whatever you decide to return. Note that the return window is limited, so you’ll want to try on your pieces and make your picks as soon as you can after getting your package. I like that Wantable sends a bunch of notification emails during my return period to make sure I don’t miss my deadline. I had to extend my deadline this month, which I easily did with a quick email to Wantable. They let me know that there’s also a way to extend your deadline from within your account using a new tool called the Plan Manager. Awesome!

Just for reference, I usually wear a 10 in jeans, a medium (like a 6 or an 8) in tops and t-shirts, and I’m a 36B. I’m also just 5′ 3″. In short, I’m short. And a little curvy.

superdry burgundy pullover

Here’s my first full outfit!

pocketed superdry pullover

details of superdry pullover pockets

superdry sport logo on sweatshirt

Superdry Sport Gymtech Luxe Funnel Sweatshirt in Deep Berry, Size Medium – Cost to Keep $49.00

This pullover rulesssss! I love how the thick (polyester 66%, Viscose 28%, elastane 6%) fabric is because it gives the sweatshirt a lot of flattering structure. But wow is it ever comfortable, nonetheless. The fabric is smooth and hefty, but really soft and stretchy in a way that makes it feel cozy and hugging, rather than flimsy. I’m also wild about the color. I had some berry hues in last month’s order, and I’m so stoked to see that carried over into this month’s selections. And while I’m usually so-so about logos, these ones seem crisp and modern and sporty. Wearing this pullover makes me feel like some kind of cool snowboarder or something, hehe.

burgundy leggings with white and black panels

details on burgundy leggings

Mono B Colorblock Panel Leggings in Magenta, Size Large – Cost to Keep $59.00

More beautiful berry colors! Not to brag, but I feel like this color looks awesome on me, ha! It might read a bit fall, but I’m eager to wear it well into the spring and summer just because I like it so much! The panels streaking across the thighs look cool and seem to be placed in a way that’s flattering and sporty. The leggings are 88% polyester and 12% spandex. They feel like thick knit leggings, but they’re super sleek, cool to the touch, and have enough oomph to make me feel like all my curves are secure, snuggly hugged in. The tippy top of these high-waisted leggings seems to nip in just a bit, so that they stay sitting high on my hips. (I hate when high-waisted leggings shimmy down through the day, or worse, in the first five minutes of a fitness class…) I’m super happy with these leggings. And I love how well they match the pullover!

burgundy and gray sports bra

black mesh back of burgundy sports bra

Mono B Colorblock Bra in Black and Gray, Size Medium – Cost to Keep $39.00

More matchy-matchy styles! This bra is pretty cool. It’s 85% polyester and 15% spandex, moisture-wicking, and complete with removable cups. But I think I would’ve gotten it in a size larger. Not because it’s uncomfortable on—it actually lays across my wider shoulders nicely. It’s just that pulling it on is tricky because of how stiff it is. It doesn’t have as much give (that goes double for the mesh back straps) as I thought it might, so I feel like I’m really pushing its limits when I try to wriggle it on.

black sweatshirt

Next look! Props to Natalia for picking pieces that really do coordinate well together!

black sweatshirt with tight sleeves

cutout hem of black sweatshirt

MPG Sport Esme Knit Sweatshirt in Black, Size Medium – Cost to Keep $72.00

This sweatshirt was a real surprise for me. The material is 88% Polyester and 12% Spandex, which makes it feel like a thick, super-smooth version of a classic cotton sweatshirt. It has a good weight to it, too, so it feels warmer and (this might sound weird, but) more soothing than a cotton sweatshirt I’d swing on. It’s the kind of thing that’d I’d love to have hugging my body during a just-out-of-bed yoga practice. Speaking of hugging, the sleeves had a surprising narrowness about them—the majority of the sleeve feels normal, but the wrists get really narrow so that you feel like your hands and wrists are getting a comfy little squeeze.

black and white striped leggings

black and white striped leggings close up

Glyder Vital 7/8 Legging in Black and White Pin Stripe, Size Large – Cost to Keep $72.00

I’m not a huge fan of cropped leggings, but these 7/8 leggings give my ankles a little breathing room while still being flatteringly long. I looooooove this pattern. I know, it’s so super simple, but it’s also super me. I like the versatility (they’re sort of a next-level version of black leggings that go with anything), and something about the thinness of the white lines feels really modern, minimalist, and cool to me. The fabric feels awesome, too. It’s a lot like a thicker stretch cotton, despite it being 88% nylon and 12% spandex. The high waist has that same nipped-in top line as the Mono B leggings, so they stay put, too.

midi bra with black and white stripes

striped midi bra

Glyder Vintage Vinyasa Bra Black and White Pin Stripe, Size Medium – Cost to Keep $54.00

I. Love. This. Top! The longer line is so flattering and wildly comfortable. It feels really fresh, style-wise, too. The neckline is different from most other bras I’ve tried, and I’m so pleased with how secure I feel in it, despite the little plunge. And again, it’s black and white, which is super me. It’s the same fabric as the leggings, which is comfy and cottony, if thick. I feel so cool in this set!

oversized free people gray hoodie

gray zipper detail on pullover

oversized free people gray pullover with hood up

Free People Movement Think Future Hoodie in Gray, Size Medium – Cost to Keep $68.00

This order was full of great pullovers. This one wasn’t my favorite, style-wise, but I’ve got to say, it SURE was comfortable! It feels a lot like a vintage 80s sweatshirt. It’s a cotton-blend top with sort of slouchy shoulders and a big kangaroo pocket. I think the way it all sits on me isn’t the most flattering, but again, I would love to snuggle into this big, soft sweatshirt after a hard class!

The Verdict: I was so excited to see the color palette in this month’s box. The burgundy colors felt really flattering, and of course, I swoon for anything black and white. I was also really pleased with the way these pieces fit. The high-waisted leggings were both designed in a way that they stayed put. And my curves felt supported, rather than crammed into/about to fall out of the looks.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Wantable curates its boxes based on each individual’s preferences as well as what’s available. What you get might not be the same as what I got, but you also might get something that fits your style and body even better than the looks above! Sign up and see what they choose for you!

Value Breakdown: This box cost $20.00 with free shipping. The total retail value of the items inside was $413.00. If I keep 5 or more items, I’ll get 20% off of that amount. Oh, and remember that my $20.00 styling fee goes towards whatever I buy. In short, if I kept everything, I would spend $310.40.

Check out all of our Wantable Fitness reviews and more fitness subscription boxes in our Women’s Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of the Wantable Fitness styling subscription service?

Written by Anna Reilly

Anna Reilly

Anna loves collecting little treasures, be they pop-culture finds, handmade mementos, or new potions to put in her makeup bag. Beauty boxes got her interested in the subscription world, but now she’s swooning for all things kawaii!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I’m a little confused, at the beginning you mentioned a 30% discount if you keep 5+ pieces but at the end you only mentioned a 20% if you were to keep them all?

    Thank you for the review! Everything looks great on you! Some of the pieces are a little pricey than what I expected and I still think Calvin Klein’s performance line has much better price points and their stuff is super cute too!
    I think I’ll skip subscribing for now and check upcoming reviews, see if they get rid of the stylist fee and lower their prices.

  2. Anna – you must keep it ALL! Please tell me you didn’t send anything back! You are gorgeous in everything! Best Fitness Edit ever!

  3. What did you keep?

  4. I don’t normally comment, but that first outfit caught my eye. Take lots of pictures in it-it looks great on you. If I were you I would put it on and go get a new drivers license, passport photo, work ID, etc…..

    • That is such a great idea to get license and passport pictures in these clothes. I would keep it all. Like the others I would love to know what you kept.

  5. Wow I like everything in this box. I am wondering what you kept out of the box in the end. It all looked great on you. I tried getting one of those back in January and the stuff they sent me wasn’t as nice as what you got. I am wondering now if I should give it a second try. Thanks for the review! Joyce

  6. Details on the sneakers, please!!!

    • Seconded!!

  7. Anna, you look great in all this stuff! I love this box so much!!!

    • Yay! Thank you Krista (and to everyone commenting with such kind compliments)! I was soooo happy with this one. I am LIVING for that striped set!!!

      Thank you all so much for reading!

  8. That first outfit looks especially great on you!

  9. The striped bra honestly looks like you could wear it out for date night. You look great in everything!

  10. Not to sound creepy or anything but I hope you kept those berry pants. They made your butt look great! hahaha. Seriously tho, this whole box was great on you! Did you keep it all?

  11. Best batch of coordinates I’ve ever seen. But your sneakers are the real winners.

  12. You look fantastic in everything! 😊

  13. I got the same burgundy colorblocked mono b leggings in my fitness edit last month! I agree with your assessment of them, surprisingly flattering placement of the stripes, nice thick fabric, and a comfortable high waist! I think I like wantable’s fitness edit better than the style/regular clothing edit. They seem to have really unique fitness pieces, especially when it comes to leggings and sports bras!

    • Awesome, Christianne! I’m so glad you liked those Mono B leggings, too! I’m going to have to keep an eye out for that brand outside of this subscription, too. Even if Wantable doesn’t hit it out of the park with EVERY box they send me, I’m always impressed by the variety of brands, colors, patterns, and styles they find. I wouldn’t even know where to start to find these kinds of cool pieces!

      Thank you so much for sharing your take, Christianne 🙂

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!