Play! By Sephora February 2018 Box Spoiler #2

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

We have a new spoiler for the February Play! By Sephora box! (Thanks, Tammy, for the heads up!)

The theme is Feel the Love. And here are the first two product spoilers:

Each box will have TWO lip products, but we’re only spilling one of them. Will it be Sephora Collection Rouge Matte in Rebel Chic or Sephora Collection Ultra Shine in Perfect Nude? We can’t wait to share the love.

What do you think of the spoilers? Which lippie do you want?

To find out which box you’re receiving at the beginning of each month, follow these instructions:

If you log in through a browser, not the app, and go to my account > account details > online orders and open the play! Order Details (it was dated 11/1 for me), you can see the “item number” next to the image.

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

Posted in Play! By Sephora Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: play by sephora | 53 comments


  1. I can’t seem to find any spoilers for box #406, any ideas where I might be able to find some?

  2. I don’t know how I feel about get a Sephora brand product. But I do really like some of their makeup some I guess I’ll just have to see. But I would definitely prefer the red. Hopefully the brand of the other lipstick is nicer and I hope I don’t get both of them. I have been wearing glosses more than I used to but I’m not really someone who loves glosses. So hopefully the other lip product isn’t a gloss

    • Everyone gets 2…one for you and one to share it says

  3. SPOILER! Posted on reddit by u/cuckoococopebbles for box #177:

    I’ve had a awful Monday so I caved and emailed Sephora to see if I could find out what my Play box will contain. Usually I love the suspense of waiting for spoilers but I needed something to get me through the day! Hopefully it brings a smile to anyone else having the worst case of the Monday’s.

    Belief moisturizing eye bomb

    Viktor & Rolf flowerbomb

    Sephora cream lip stain (color unavailable)

    Sephora Rouge Matte

    Lancôme drama liquid pencil

    First Aid Beauty ginger tumeric mask

  4. Lol I have enough lip products to supply my whole county with. I only wear on special occasions. Please double up this month and send me 2 more. I don’t know about yalls Valentine but if I come anywhere within 2 feet of him with painted lips he freaks out. J/S

  5. They should send full size since there on sale for 7$… just saying and agree with sending the red lipstick to those who got that lip gloss recently.

    • I’m new to play by Sephora I’m not happy with the infant size things the send I believe I will return to Ipsy they have adult makeup

      • Ipsy always sent me more skin care and maybe 1 full size of something but Sephora sends the brands I’m interested in that’s why I stay. Sometimes it’s full size but usually the eyeliner

      • Ipsy always sends cheap brands. Hakari, Bella Pierre, etc. Sephora sends higher end and you get 60 points per month. The value is definitely there and the quality is so much better. I’d rather have 5 high end deluxe samples

  6. Red red red please red lol. I can never have enough red lipsticks!

    • So agree!

  7. Nudes look godawful on me and I hate lip glosses and they all go straight in the trash, so Sephora and I are done if I get that nude gloss.

  8. I would honestly not wear either. I MAYBE would wear the rogue lipstick once a year.
    As in two lip products, I was hoping for a lip scrub, lip balm or lip plumper.

    Definitely didn’t want any color.
    Not so sure about my first Play! sub…

  9. Yeahhhh I told myself that if I don’t get some good stuff this month that I’d have to cancel and it looks like pretty sure I’m canceling. I got the same nude gloss a few months ago and I don’t use it because it looks dumb on my dark skin. I have received MAYBE 3 things that I’ve half assedly used since I started the subscription 5-6 months ago. It’s a waste of money at this point. They never send anything for my hair type or skin color and, since I put that I have oily skin, I’m forever getting a charcoal scrub or mask. We do use other things!

    I’m so annoyed with Sephora at this point. I might as well spend a bit more in another box and get something that would match my skin tone and hair type for sure.

  10. WHAT? I just got sent this! And I’m really sick of getting reds and brights colors but never nudes! Most people prefer “everyday” colors not bold shades, so why is that like 90% of the lip products they send out… This gloss is the only nude color I have ever received from them and now I’m gunna get the same thing.. wow.

    • I read the comments here a lot and people complain when sub boxes do brights “I want nudes!” And then they do nudes and people complain “ugh I want something more interesting, how about some brights!?”

      It never ends.

    • All I get are pinks/nudes even though I’ve indicated I like red.

      • How do u indicate that?

  11. I actually don’t really want either of these lol…. I’ll try them but I’m usually not a lipgloss person or a dark red person. At least it isn’t another bright red though. Hopefully since the first lippie will be Sephora brand the second one will be a higher end brand or nicer product!

  12. For some reason I have a feeling that both of these products will be included in everyone’s boxes. I guess we will find out later this month.
    I’m not a fan of Sephora brand so I don’t care for any of this items but I guess if I had to choose I’d go with red lipstick.

  13. I received the exact same lip gloss in my November box!! Going to be so annoyed if I get it again. They could have at least chosen a different color. Where’s the variety???

  14. Definitely got the gloss a few boxes ago!! It’s really nice but I’m looking for variety when it comes to subscription boxes. The red lipstick is ok, but I doubt I’ll wear it often. Hope the other products redeem the spoilers!

  15. Unlike most of the comments here, I would absolutely love a different red lipstick every month! It’s my everyday color. Bring on the red!

    • Me too. I love red lipsticks, it’s my fave color.

    • Me too. I love red for every day. It just makes me feel polished.

  16. I already know I like the formula for both the lipstick and the gloss. I just really don’t care for the colors of either. I think I’ve only ever received one lippy from any box (Boxycharm, Sephora, Allure) that I like. I’m pretty sure it’s me and not them.

  17. Please let it be the nude gloss in #227. I can’t do red!

  18. Please no more red Sephora lipstick. Can’t give that stuff away any more.

  19. I’m all about red lipstick, bring it on!

  20. I honestly love love that lip gloss and would not mind another!

  21. Almost no one here wants that red lipstick. (Me included) I want the gloss as well. Being sephora brand, the other brand should be an awesome one lol

    • I love red lipsticks, and will gladly take them off everyone’s plate 🙂

  22. My box # is 201.

    It seems to me that almost all sub boxes go the cheap way in both December and February with bright red lipstick.
    Like we all look great in red lipstick just because it’s ” the holiday for it”.

  23. No!!!!! Not unless it’s a Matte Neutral or Brown!! Please no more glosses or reds!

    • I agree! Red looks terrible on me!

  24. Meh.

  25. I’m probably canceling after this month bc this is the same lipstick I got before!! I seriously have always received lipsticks which isn’t my thing but was optimistic, but after 4 months of just lipsticks never any lip gloss I’m sick of it. Plus this Sephora collection is the same one I have already got in my box 2 months ago!

    • I haven’t been happy with any box from sephora and I’ve waiting 4 months just to be safe. There’s always 1 thing i sorta like. I’m going with ipsy since I can try and get what I like. 1 month of ipsy and I like 2 things I got already. I’ll just be sad I won’t receive basically free 50 points from sephora now.

  26. Oh goodness… I hope NOT another Sephora lipstick or gloss! They keep sending the same things!!!! I hope they don’t send both or they lose a lot of subscribers!

  27. Seriously NO more red lipsticks!! I get one in every other box and from other sub boxes as well.

    • Indeed.

    • I agree

  28. Ugh I want neither. I got that exact gloss in a Play box a few months ago and I don’t look good in red lipstick…

  29. Didn’t we just get that same lip shine a couple of months back?

    • Yes! I think it was November or December. Out of the hundreds of different lippies they have you would think we wouldn’t be getting repeats this close together!

    • Hopefully they are at least conscientious enough to send the lipstick to the people who already received the gloss 🤔

  30. Either looks nice, as long as it’s not a orange red I’m good to go

    • I think we get it every month…

  31. I can’t take another red or matte lipstick either.

  32. If I get another red lipstick, I’m cancelling.

    • Same. I didn’t think I would ever cancel this one, but I’m just…bored, I guess? It’s probably just time for a break.

  33. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE be the lip shine! I’m so tired of matte lipsticks!

    • I am with you there!!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!