Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I really want the Naked highlighter, if someone wants to trade, please let me know. My box is 0.8, so I am guessing I am getting the Ofra.
Reply
Lexi
Based on the weight/dimensions of my box, it looks like I’m getting the Z Palette. I’ve never gotten a chance to try any unique colored highlighters, and I don’t wear much blush. The only 2 things I wanted were the lip scrub and the highlighter and I get the one box that has neither. So disappointed. Does anyone want to trade, or does anyone know where I can go to do a trade??
Reply
Melissa Stephens
I really want that highlighter palette i checked my fedex it said 0.8 lbs / 0.36 kgs i’m gonna guess that means i get the orfa 🙁 still have hope though
Reply
Tammy
Me too…I wanted to try the Naked Cosmetics Highlighter Palette. I don’t need a pop-up palette as I already own a Z-Palette. *keeping fingers & toes crossed*
Reply
Lauren
My box was .6 and I got the highlighter palette.
Reply
Courtney
Yes! Thank you! Mine should be here tomorrow and it is .6. I really want the highlighter palette!
Reply
Carrie
Mine is .8 z pallet is probably what I am receiving 😒
Reply
Monica
I love boxycharm but this is a very odd variant. I mean a Z palette vs a highlight palette?!
I would prefer the Z palette but I really want to that lip scrub that comes with the highlight palette. I despise lip plumpers. Still pretty excited about this box.
Reply
lily
Boxycharm has become rather hit or miss for me lately. Can’t win them all I suppose but if this is my box the only thing i’ll be excited for is the covre fx. Way too many eyeliners and i hate lip plumping things
Reply
Katy
I wanted to cancel this month’s box but didn’t get to it in time so I was hoping the rest of the spoilers would be good since I didn’t want the Ofra palette or the highlighting palette and so far it’s a disappointment for me. I want an eyeliner and limp plumper even less than the palettes. Lol. I hope the other variations are better suited for me and I get one of them. It’s not a total loss at least. I do love those brushes and I have a good friend who is just starting to build her makeup collection and would be super excited to receive the lip plumper, eyeliner and either of those palettes.
Reply
Emily
I’m interested in the ofra pallet – let me know if you’re open to swaps!
Reply
Tammy
I’d swap the Ofra Palette for the Naked Cosmetics Highlighter Palette too. 🙂
Alyssa
Based on box weight I think I will be getting this variation, I’d love to swap for the highlighter!
Merlisha
Hope that the sugar lemon moisturizing lip buffer is a variant for the lip plumping exfoliant. Really not a fan of lip pumping products.
Reply
Dawnn
My box is the same weight, so hoping this box is mine, I need the Z palette in my life. I rarely use highlighter so fingers crossed this is my variant
Reply
Sarah
I will glady trade you if I get the Z palette! I would much rather prefer the highlighter palette, I use so much highlighters this would be perfect!
Reply
Angie
I think this variation knowing me will be mine. If I get this I’m definitely trading this palette for the naked cosmetics just because I personally have no pans and the only thing in my palette will be that one and only blush! That being said I’m never disappointed with boxycharm for this being my 3rd box they’re amazing! I just saw on gram their highlighter palette and this I need in my life 🤩
Reply
Toni
Hmm I thought since mine was already shipped I was getting the Ofra but mine only weighs 6 oz so if one of the other posters are correct I’m getting the highlighter
Reply
Nicole
The weight doesn’t really tell you what you’re getting.
Reply
Deonna
Very excited about this box! If I end up with variation #1 I am willing to trade the Ofra for the Naked palette.
Im just afraid everyone is going to want the Naked palette.
Reply
Sky
I will definitely swap you if I get the naked palette!
Reply
Deonna
Sounds good. Ill keep you updated. My box just shipped.
Deonna
Sounds good Ill keep you updated. My box just shipped.
Dana
My box already shipped, so I’m assuming this is my box. I don’t see what’s so “Glam Glow” about this box; really would have preferred the highlighter.
Reply
Savi
My box shipped too but it weighs different from this one so I’m not sure all the ones starting to go out now are the same. Either way, so excited!
Reply
Dana
Mine weighs .8 which is the same as this one. If you’re weighs .6 you probably got the highlighter.
Svetlana7e
My box is 0.8 lbs / 0.36 kgs and will be delivered Monday. I would be very happy if I get this variation. Dont care about ANOTHER black eyeliner, but happy with other items.
Reply
Jayden Andrews
I hope I don’t get the lip plumper exfoliant. I have too much lip scrubs and I barely use them as is and I don’t really like lip plumper a shirt I’ve never really seen any results and anything they ever do do is usually for a very short amount of time before going back to normal. I’d love to get a liquid lip or something. Not sure if I’d rather have the ofra palette or the highlighter palette. I guess it depends on if the highlighters look good on me or not. It’d be cool if the ofra kit came with like magnets that you could put on your makeup or something so you could make out some stuff in the pop up palette you normally couldn’t? Idk, the value difference kinda sucks though
Reply
@skincareplusmore
Just a heads up. If you get a chance buy a Ulta palette. They come with nice little magnets. A good amount. I think you can buy some on eBay as well.
Reply
MzBev
You can buy magnets at the hobby store, use a hot glue gun and attached them to the bottom of anything really and put it in there. I’ve done it to several items!
Reply
Tomi
I didn’t know that you get same version all the time! I got 1st version at last time, I gonna get 1st version at this time too!? Thank you for new knowledge! I really want OFRA one. I’m so exciting! I love highlighter. but… I don’t think it is good on me like that colorful one. I love more basic and classic, or modern but not flashy. so…. yay!
Reply
Sarah
I will gladly trade you if I get the Z palette! I use highlighters like this every day and would be willing to trade if you wanted.
Reply
Candace
That’s generally how it has worked for me, though I’ve gotten 1 twice, In Sept. when everyone got the same box and Dec. I got the concealer palette, which was 1. Every other time I have been 2. So it’s not a definite method but generally reliable.
Reply
Selina
I know what u mean, I have a monthly sub and always get box 1, only once in the entire year of 2017 did I ever get box 2!! Really wish Boxy will have 1 box for all subs, I was on the Tarte site today and was very tempted to buy a highlight
palette on sale 😀Have a feeling that long time subs will get Ofra item. Just have a suspicion about this item.
Toni
My box has shipped already so I guess that means I’m getting variation #1 . If so I guess I’ll be wanting to purchase the highlighter because it looks awesome
Reply
SpoilerAddict
The Instagram post states that the box size weight is 0.8.
Does anyone else have any other box weights?
Reply
Kimberly A King
Mine says
Dimension 6x5x2
and weight is 7.0 I havent seen anyone yet with a 7.0 clueless here
Reply
Carmen
Mine. Is .7 / 32 kgs hmmmm. The highlighter would be interesting to try. But I don’t think I would be too mad at the blush
Reply
Redhed36
How do you figure out the weight?
Reply
Candace
It’s in your shipping info.
Kelly
Mine is 0.6
Reply
Candace
Haven’t gotten my shipping info yet but from what I can tell we’ve got .8 and .6 (stated in another thread) box weights so far. Ofra is gonna be .8 and the Naked .6.
Reply
Shoppeaholik
so of course, i have .7…*sigh*
Julie
I hope there is lip scrub trend, I can never have too much.
Reply
Candace
Well usually I get variant 2 so hopefully that means the highlighter palette is coming my way.
Reply
Kellie Cole
Bummed. I always get box variation 1. I wanted the highlighter palette. I have no use for the Ofra.
Reply
Redhed36
How do you know what box variation you get?
Reply
Candace
Look at the bottom corner of your card. It’ll have the variant number on it. Ive gotten 1 twice and the rest of my cards are all 2.
Jennifer Rose Martino
I just want the amythest coverfx. I’ll buy it from someone. I don’t subscription yet
Reply
Darcie
Hi Jennifer, I’d be happy to send it your way. You can PM me here. My user name is dw85202.
Reply
jennifer
How much did you want for it?
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.