Posted by My Subscription Addiction on in Play! By Sephora Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 44 comments

Play! By Sephora December 2017 Box #585 FULL SPOILERS!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

We have the full spoilers for the December Play! By Sephora box #585 thanks to TeeyaG!

Play! by Sephora December 2017 Box #585 will include:

Play! by Sephora December 2017 Box #601 will include:

Play! by Sephora December 2017 Box #577 will include:

Here’s a look at all the products that may be in your December box:


Sephora has let us know that every box this month will include 3 makeup items!

What do you think of the spoilers?

To find out which box you’re receiving at the beginning of each month, follow these instructions:

If you log in through a browser, not the app, and go to my account > account details > online orders and open the play! Order Details (it was dated 11/1 for me), you can see the “item number” next to the image.

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

Written by My Subscription Addiction

My Subscription Addiction

My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I got my box today . I was so excited because I wanted to try most of the items that were in the sneak peek. HOWEVER, I literally got EVERYTHING I DIDNT WANT . I wish could trade them in 🙁

    • Ah, yes So many awful, worthless products. Now you know why Sephora doesn’t send out their newest products; they send out high-rated winners and subscribers declare them worthless…

      This is why we can’t have nice things.

      I typically have 2-4 products from each box that hit it way out of the park, but I don’t realize it until several weeks down the line. That Bobbi Brown eye-opening mascara from July? I just looked to re-purchase, and it costs even more than Diorshow.

      I’ll give you a few days to re-consider, but is everything truly awful? And what are you comparing these products against? Whats the better moisturizer, mascara, and why?

    • Same here! I’m so mad. This may be my last play box.

  2. None of my play boxes have ever included a liquid liner. I always get mascara, and I already have the better than sex one which sucks. Now I have box 585. Just my luck. STOP Sending me mascara Sephora!! I wish I would have gotten box 577. Also I haven’t received my box yet, and status still says pending. I’m in NYC and I usually get my box way early. This month has just been weird.

  3. It’s not a bad box so to speak if I didn’t have everything in here already except for the hair product which is not for me , I have the thickest hair out there plus I don’t use hairspray but ok. At least the lip product isn’t bright pink

  4. Box 577! While I wanted a liquid eyeliner, I’m beyond happy with the items coming!! Woooohoo!!!

    • The best box in my opinion

  5. #585 is my box and so glad the lipstick is not RED! Yippee!

  6. Any one have 059 box spoilers?

  7. I’m box #593. Haven’t seen anything about that yet.

  8. I just found this…….Play box 627
    I emailed them and asked them for the items that will be included in my box this month.
    -Caudalie Vine[Activ] Energizing and Smoothing Eye Cream
    -Make Up For Ever Artist Rouge c-207
    -Laura Mercier Caviar Eye Stick (Au Natural)
    -Drybar Triple Sec
    -Stella McCartney EDP
    -Clinique Easy Liquid Liner

    • @Lindsay Smith — Thanks for posting the contents of box #627. That’s the box I’ll be receiving. Not looking forward to the products, but I appreciate knowing what the box will include! Thanks for posting.

  9. Interesting, apparently there are more boxes. My number is 201635.

    • That’s interesting ’cause my number is 2010635…but ours could be the same!

  10. Yay! This is me! I was specifically hoping for this cream (I’e loved everything IT Cosmetics so far) and one of the lipsticks so I’m happy. Otherwise, I think I got good stuff as well. I’m a huge mascara person, like floral perfume, would be more likely to use hairspray than the other thing, and been getting a little more into eyeshadow. Great box for me personally.

  11. Has anyone tried the 24K gold cream?

  12. Im getting a Sephora Play box for the first time ever this month – how do you tell which number you are and which box? Thanks! 🙂

    • raspberry – if you scroll to the bottom of Liz’ post below all the images, you will see the instructions on how to find your box number. It will be the last 3 digits of the item number. I hope you get a great Play box!

  13. I’ll trade 601 for 585 straight across the board! I’m on swap!

    • How can we swap?! I have 585 literally have 1000 mascaras!

    • That’s right! I’ve always been so happy with all my boxes (been getting them since June). I am box #601 and I am STRAIGHT UP ANGRY about it!! I even emailed customer service asking if they could switch me boxes but of course they said no! I do not wear dark lip colors, I said in my beauty profile I like florals, definitely NOT citrusy scents, and those smashbox eyecolors are hideous! It’s really super disappointing too because I would LOVE to have any of those other great products – fresh rose toner! Caudalie serum! IT moisturizer! Miss Dior perfume! (or any OTHER of the available scents!) Laura Mercier products!
      Ugh I’m pretty mad about it. I guess good thing it’s Christmas so I can find someone who might enjoy these as gifts.

    • Im in for this and getting 585, just got ship notifications, still looking for someone to trade?

      • @Haley – Yes girl please! I have #601, would be so so so happy to trade!

    • Haleymchaney @ gmail . Com

  14. yeahhhhhh didn’t get eyeliner. I’m just so happy about that lol. I got 577 I like this months bag for once. All except the perfume. I want to try the miss Dior but I’m not complaining. One for play Dec

  15. I’m getting box #585 and I’m really happy. Based on yesterday’s Sephora’s December boxing video, I would be happy anything except another black eyeliner. I do enjoy trying a new mascara every 2 months, though.

    As much as I love YSL’s Mon Paris, I’m curious to try the new Miss Dior. I know they reformulated some time ago, and that and Diorrisimo were favorites of mine back in the 80s when they were VERY unpopular.

    Interesting that #601 got 6 beauty products instead of 5 + fragrance. Maybe the ubiquitous black eyeliner is in lieu of fragrance. I did just try the green tiger stuff instore that’s in that box. Nice stuff.

    • ATELIER COLOGNE Clémentine California Cologne Absolue Pure Perfume is fragrance. 😉

    • Maybe I’m miscounting, but I count 6 items total, not 6 beauty items plus a fragrance?

      • You are right, Melissa B! I didn’t notice the Atalier perfume in there. I’m glad we are all getting fragrance this month. Enjoy your box!

  16. 593, medium skin, wavy hair, dry aging skin. I hope to get the eye cream and Peter Roth cream 😝

    • Hmmm. I swear that’s my box number this month too and I’m fair/light skin, straight oily hair, oily aging skin. I seriously wonder if the profiles matter at all unless they do a month with concealer or foundation….

    • I’m pretty sure we only get 1 skin care item per box. All the skincare items look pretty great this month; I would love to purchase a special play! box of just those skincare items.

  17. I’m 601 and I have just about everything in that box. Not very excited about it now, lol

  18. Mostly pleased with this box. Excited about the Smashbox duo and IT cream. And I’m glad I’m not getting the CoverFX drops which I just got a couple boxes ago.

  19. Well… looks like I’m gonna throw this whole play bag in my mom’s stocking and subtract 10 years from my sephora profile age.

    • Right! Glad mom will like it! #601 is garbage! Maybeee the skin cream will be okay. Never been this upset about it.

  20. Aw this is exactly what I was hoping for! My number is 2010627, so which of those numbers will they use in the spoilers here? 201,627? etc… I usually just wait and have it be a surprise but it’s taking so much longer this month! I usually have it by now and it hasn’t even shipped yet!

    • 627, I have the same box !

    • 627. It’s always the last three digits.

  21. Yay!! So happy this is my box.

  22. This is an OK box for me. I love the IT cream! I don’t need another Too Faced Mascara or that smashbox palette which I got from Macy’s BB but the rest is OK. I have a feeling the lipstick will be too light though.

  23. Yay! This is my box too. You’re going love that IT Confidence in a Cream. It is fantastic for dry skin.

    • Good to know…. Ugh winter dry skin

  24. Yay! I’m 585 this month. Not a bad box at all. I will rather enjoy all of my items. Miss Dior I have wanted to try, I love trying new fragrances. The smasbox duo I have gotten previously but will easily slip into my daughters stocking. Toofaced better than sex. I own already but will go into a stocking as well.. I haven’t tried the It Cosmetics, confidence in a cream yet, looking forward to it.. The makeup forever lipstick I do not own one so I can try the formula whether the shade is spot on or not. And the bumble and bumble thickening hairspray will be fine too. I haven’t tried it either. So I may make a few discoveries this month. I always am on the market for anything better. Over all I am very pleased as always because what I can’t use the lady veterans can. Thank you for the sneak peek! Merry Christmas to all of our MSA reviewers….m and thanks for all the research and hard work.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!