MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

FanMail Subscription Box Review + Coupon – October 2017

fanmail witch please box for october 2017

FanMail is a bi-monthly subscription box full of fandom goodies for women! They also feature at least one small business run by women in each box!

fanmail witch please info card for october 2017

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

fanmail witch please box items

The Subscription Box: FanMail

The Cost: $21.99 a box + shipping

COUPON: Use code SUBADDICT to save $2 off your first month!

The Products: FanMail boxes contain a variety of memorabilia and collectibles, some old, some new, some handmade, some fanmade. Among the items, you may find are exclusive comics and t-shirts, jewelry, stationery, books, autographs, photos and much more. And each month, you’ll get a handy pop-culture newsletter that will tell you what movies are coming out, what’s up for streaming and bingeing, and what conventions or events are out there that you may want to attend.

Ships to: U.S. and Worldwide!

Check out all of our FanMail Box reviews and the Geek Subscription Box List for all the geeky boxes!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your wish list or subscription list!

fanmail witch please info card for october 2017 fanmail witch please info card for october 2017 fanmail witch please info card for october 2017 fanmail witch please info card for october 2017 fanmail witch please info card for october 2017 fanmail witch please info card for october 2017 fanmail witch please info card for october 2017

October’s theme is “Witch Please” and focuses on all your favorite witches!

bookmark bookmark bookmark bookmark

There are also some promotional bookmarks advertising some great books!

comic comic poster

Bonus Comic Book

In addition to the main items in the box, this Halloween box contains a few extra treats. The first is this comic book. I love the scratchy, doodle-like art in this Lunch Witch comic!

zombie poetry magnets zombie poetry magnets zombie poetry magnets zombie poetry magnets

Bonus Zombie Magnet Poetry

The second bonus item is this hilarious set of zombie magnetic poetry. We’ve all seen these kinds of magnet sets, which usually feature all kinds of words to organize in creative ways. But zombies aren’t as, uh… eloquent… as typical poets. Hence the hilarious sounds on these magnets.

kikis delivery service keychain kikis delivery service keychain kikis delivery service keychain

Kiki’s Delivery Service Jiji Plush Keychain

I couldn’t find a price for this cutie on a reliable site online, but this sweet Jiji head is soft, squishy, and looks adorable hanging off of my backpack! I’m a big Miyazaki fan, so this keychain is a win for me!

broom pen broom penbroom pen

Exclusive Broomstick Pen – Estimated Value $1.00

What witch box would be complete without a broom? This broom has the rustic vibe of an old-timey witch broom, but it also has the functional perk of being a pen! Fanmail Box made this pen especially for the box. It’s a little more exciting than some of the promotional pens that wind up in some subscription boxes.


Exclusive Harry Potter Quote T-Shirt 

This is another FanMail exclusive. You’ve gotta love a Harry Potter shirt! This one features a quote from Ginny that should be inspiring to all the witches out there. Most of my closet is black, so I appreciate the color palette here. It’s a comfy, super soft fabric, too. Form and function!

print print

Black Cat Witch Holographic Print by Jen Bartel 

While this print is maybe a little too busy for me to display as decor in my apartment, the twinkling, undulating colors and powerful image are totally awesome—I’m hanging on to this small print for sure, if just for some artistic inspiration! Holograms always remind me of middle school Trapper Keepers, too, so that was a fun throwback feature!

apron apron

Exclusive Sabrina the Teenage Witch Apron

Oh my goodness, I FORGOT about the pancake madness episode of this classic show (which I was obsessed with as a tween)!!! Nobody loves pancakes like the Spellmans. This apron is a clever way of bringing that reference back. And I love that Salem gets a little cameo on top of the stack of pancakes. This apron isn’t the most sturdy, but it’s good enough for an amateur cook like me. I’ll have to wear this around the kitchen while I help on Thanksgiving!

The Verdict: FanMail is a fun subscription, and I’m a big fan of this month’s witchy theme. They really do try to cater to a bunch of different fandoms, from TV to books, and beyond. I love that they include a bunch of pop culture recommendations in their info booklet, too—it really helps reinforce the idea that the curators of this box are one with their geeky customers! I will say that these weren’t the fanciest items, but they sure are cute, fun, and unique.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No, but past boxes do occasionally go on sale here. Sign up now to nab the December box!

Coupon – Use coupon code SUBADDICT you can save $2 off your first box!

Value Breakdown: This box cost $21.99 + $6.98 in shipping (to Pittsburgh, PA). Most of the items in the box were exclusives, or else they were tricky to find from a reliable source online. So to give an idea of value, I recommend looking at the average cost of each item. This box cost me $28.97 and included 5 featured items, meaning each one is worth about $5.79. Add in the two bonus goodies, and that average price drops to $4.14. I think that’s pretty fair for what I got!

What did you like most in the October FanMail subscription box?


How do subscribers rate FanMail?

Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Deal Alert!
Click Here to save $2 off your first month!
per delivery
Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about FanMail!

Enable notifications () to get the latest FanMail spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Anna Reilly

Anna Reilly

Anna loves collecting little treasures, be they pop-culture finds, handmade mementos, or new potions to put in her makeup bag. Beauty boxes got her interested in the subscription world, but now she’s swooning for all things kawaii!

Posted in FanMail Reviews, Geek Subscription Boxes, International Subscription Box Reviews, Nerd Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women, UK Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: FanMail | 1 comment

Comment (1)

  1. OMG Where can I get the pancake madness apron? That is actually one of my favorite episodes! It must be pretty exclusive because a quick google turned up nothing.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.


Two Days Only: Create Your Own Tarte Beauty Box!
7 Full-Size Products, Just $63