Posted by on in Boxycharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 44 comments

BoxyCharm December 2017 CONFIRMED SPOILER #1!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.


We have the first December 2017 Boxycharm spoiler thanks to Yosef on Boxycharm Beauties!

The December box will include:

Tarte Tarteist Lash Paint Mascara – Value $23

What do you think of the first Boxycharm spoiler?

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more. (And sign up asap if you want November’s box – there’s a waitlist!)

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. It’s Christmas Boxy Charm give us some awesome stuff, however I’m exited about the mascara, but not sure about the blush.

  2. Spoiler #2 for this box is a Real Her blush palette.

  3. I love this mascara! I have 3 favorites, and this is one of them!

  4. For all of you raving about this mascara, y’all seriously need to try some others! The doulce and Channel are amazing.

    I love tarte, but I am not a fan of their mascaras at all. They don’t add length or curl. I get like 2 a month in sub boxes.

    • Yes!!! Le rouge de Chanel changed my life lol. Has been my go to for years.. this one will be going up for swap;)

      • Oops “le volume de Chanel”

    • The doucce mascara didn’t work for me at all ☹️ But I’m so happy it worked for others.

      Chanel yesssssss. Their mascaras are divine when I have a little extra $$ to splurge.

    • I have to agree 100% non of their mascaras have done anything for my lashes the only mascara that I truly enjoy that works really well is Benefits Roller Lash I have yet to find a dupe for it though.

  5. This is one of my very favorite mascaras, though the wand is pretty prickly, it adds layers really well without clumps or spider lashes. I’m knee deep in mascara but happy to get this still!

  6. I’m happy to try the Tarte mascara, although the wand reminds me of the Benefit mascaras. For some reason, these type of brushes poke my eyeballs every time I use them. 😅

  7. I got my boxy charm yesterday.
    Cover FX illuminating spray, eye shadow palette, brushes, lip masks and lipstick.

    • I love it! Did you like?

  8. So excited for this. I was disappointed last month that the tartiest in glossy was brow gel. I feel like we never get mascara and that’s something I always need. Got a doucce one in boxy last September and loved it

  9. I’ve read so many good reviews of this mascara with most of those reviews mentioning this being the person’s #1 mascara. I need to know what all the hype is about. For me, I’m happy with this spoiler.

    I turned down the LE box. I was at checkout, but then removed it from my cart. I may regret it, but I’m concentrating on Christmas sets and gifting right now. I don’t understand why there are people angry over missing out on the LE box. LE means Limited Edition. Limited. That means limited in quantity too, not merely the bundle itself. Everyone should have expected it would sell out quickly. I was surprised it wasn’t sold out when I looked at it.

  10. I love this mascara 😊 now I’m just hoping they release a spoiler or two for the LE box that took me 4 hours to purchase!

    • Same exact words about the LE box!!! LOL

  11. This is my all time favorite mascara! I’m due for another tube soon anyway, so I’m thrilled to be getting this!!!

  12. Not an exciting spoiler as others have said, but I’m happy. It’s definitely something I will use.

    I’d much rather a nice mascara than fake lashes or something else that will sit in makeup drawer gathering dust.

  13. The whole Limited Edition Box was a blur. Being a subscribed member for a while now, I was a little disappointed that I didn’t get an email, text, notification, or anything. By the time I heard it on a beauty page I follow on FB the Boxycharm website had crashed and it was sold out. I follow Boxy on all social media sites and thought I was keeping up, but I guess not, lol. Interested in seeing what the hype is all about. We shall see if it’s as good as they promised.

    • Me too, it was kinda a joke. I get that the website was on overload but it was not fair for members. I tried forever and page wouldn’t load then went to bed to wake up to out of stock. Was not fair at all.

  14. I’m excited and have been waiting to try this since the spoilers first came out!

  15. Very excited to try. Holding off on “better than sex” mascara…. I’ve got a couple travel sizes I can use until I get the box mid month

  16. Does anyone know if it can add a gift subscription to my account without having to create a new account?

    • You can’t, I’ve tried but you just need to create a separate account and go on the waitlist.

      • Thanks for the info!

  17. So excited to try this! Is this gonna be full size?

    • Yes! It will be full size!

  18. My favorite Tarte mascara for sure!

  19. My 2nd favorite mascara of all time and I’m about out so perfect timing Boxy charm!

  20. Why aren’t they releasing LE spoilers like they said they would?

    Not releasing spoilers and being surprised it sold out are making me think that the box is not that great and they are stalling a second wave of anger.

    • In really worried about that too

    • When I watched the FB live video, I wondered if he meant he’d release more regular sub spoilers not from the LE box. At this point it seems like releasing LE box spoilers might only fuel the fire or add insult to injury for those still upset they missed out…unless the spoilers aren’t that great. Lol.

      • I assumed he meant December spoilers…not the LE box.

  21. Does Boxy ever have Black Friday deals or any kind of deal?

    • Last year they had some lip product as a gift with sub purchase.

  22. boxycharm is all, “bah, humbug!” towards me with this first spoiler for Dec box+ special edition box that was completely unavail. tarte mascara doesn’t do it for me. 🙁

    • My thoughts exactly! I’m so mad at Boxycharm.

    • Im with you on this one , ugh. Fingers crossed the rest of the box will be bomb!

      • Not to be Debbie downer (apologies if your name is Debbie, no insult intended) but mascara for December? Not excited for this spoiler. Hopefully, the rest will be worth it. Not to sound irritated, but I am expecting more especially when you finally get off wait list and it is December’s box. I am with the others above, bah humbug and ugh. After the crazy go back and forth link for the special limited edition box, boxycharm is losing its charm to me.

  23. Woo to the hoo!!!

  24. I usually use Tarte’s Lights, Camera, Lashes….it will be nice to try this one!!! I’m quite fond of Tarte as a whole!

    • I agree Regina! I use their Lights Camera Lashes mascara too 😉 it’s my favorite & I’d love to try this one from them too, could be a little more “glam” & would be a good “date night” mascara to make my “baby blues” as my fiance calls them, really stand out 😉😊😊😊

  25. My absolute favorite mascara!!

    • Mine too!!!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!