MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

My First Reading Club Review + Coupon – September 2017

My First Reading Club September 2017

My First Reading Club is a monthly subscription box that delivers three age-appropriate books specifically for you and your child!

My First Reading Club September 2017

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

This is a review of the Just Starting Out, $9.99 a month, box for kids under 2 years old.

My First Reading Club September 2017

The Subscription Box: My First Reading Club 

The Cost: $9.99/month for pay-per-month subscription, $9.33/month for 3 months, $8.33/month for 6 months, or $7.92/month for a 12 month subscription. Shipping is a flat rate of $5 for the U.S. and $10 for Canada.

COUPON: Use code NEWREADERS to save $5 off your first box!

The Products: Three age-appropriate books curated specifically for you and your child. Sometimes, a free surprise is also included in addition to the book. 

Ships to: Contiguous U.S. and Canada 

Check out all of our Baby + Parent Subscription Box Reviews!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

No information cards were included.

My First Reading Club September 2017 My First Reading Club September 2017

My First Words: Animals – Value $3.00? (based on similar books)

My husband and I are huge animals lovers, so I know that teaching our son about all the creatures of the world will be important to us. This book is a fantastic way to do that, and it’s super informational! I love that the sturdy cardboard pages include a mix of illustration and images clipped directly from photos. This means that all of the animals are super realistically depicted. They are also fairly to scale with one another. For example, an orca is the largest animal on the Water page followed by the medium-sized alligator, and the otter and jellyfish are much smaller than both. You can definitely use these images to teach a lesson on animals’ size, how they interact, or how they behave. Each page is devoted to a different type of animal from Desert, Cold, Farm, Jungle, Water, Forest, Pets, and Bugs. There are also 8-10 clearly labeled animals on each page, so it’s not only a fantastic way to learn animal names, but a nice way to understand the spelling of each word (later down the line, of course). I could see this book really growing with my little one, and I can’t wait for him to identify his favorite animals!

My First Reading Club September 2017 My First Reading Club September 2017

Be Patient, Pandora! (Mini Myths) – Value $6.93

This short book is based on the original Greek myth of Pandora’s box, a summary of which is included at the very end. From the author’s official description: When Pandora is warned by her mother not to open a box, her spirited curiosity trumps her obedience. Pandora harmlessly touches the box, innocently leans on the box, and eventually, albeit accidentally, bursts the box open! The cupcakes that were hidden inside are ruined, except for one last vestige, which Pandora presents in the hope that her mother still loves her. The underlying message about impatience is really valuable, and I love that Pandora received reassurance from her mother after making a mistake. It’s a really terrific way to teach forgiveness. The illustrations are also vibrant, silly, and adorable! They do a wonderful job of depicting Pandora’s range of emotions as well as many of the action words used in the story (touching, leaning, standing, bouncing, etc.). Most of all, this book is a great way to introduce your child to Greek Mythology, and I’m excited to explore other titles from Mini Myths like ‘Make a Wish, Midas!

My First Reading Club September 2017 My First Reading Club September 2017

Sockheadz: Shapes –  Value $5.00

This very visual board book explores basic shapes ranging from triangle, circle, rectangle, diamond, heart, oval, square, and star. Each double-page spread features a different sockhead animal and scene. The sockheadz are all very cute and illustrated with a sort of patchwork-y drawing style. Their environments reflect the same style, making this book super colorful and visually engaging! Shapes are hidden in objects as well as patterns. Because the shapes range from obvious to subtle, as a parent, you are able to prompt lots of questions relating to more difficult-to-find shapes. For example, “Do you see any rectangles on the window? What about outside?” or “What about on Heart Cow? What are his spots shaped like?” This is another book that can grow with your child as they begin to develop more understanding of shapes and general visual awareness.

My First Reading Club September 2017

Joseph Abboud Body Lotion – Value $1.25

Honestly, I was so thrown off to see this lotion sample in my box. I knew that My First Reading Club sometimes includes free gifts in their boxes, but I never expected to find toiletry products. Seems a bit odd as it’s not exactly a child-friendly item. The lotion is fine, but nothing special, and the size and style of the package is like what you’d see in a hotel room. Free samples are always appreciated, but, all things considered, I found this addition to be a little confusing.

My First Reading Club September 2017

Joseph Abboud Vegetable Soap – Value $1.67

Again, a little surprised to see soap in my children’s book-themed reading box, but I did enjoy this more than the lotion. It had a creamy texture and light linen scent, and it lathered well. I am glad to have been given the opportunity to try this brand via a free gift.

Verdict: This is my first box from My First Reading Club, and I really enjoyed it! All three books included this month made amazing additions to my very sparse nursery library, and I’m thrilled to be able to build up a bit of a collection before the arrival of our little one. I was also excited to find such a variety in quality book selections. 

The value of this box comes in at $17.85. With a subscription cost of $9.99 + $5 shipping, the value is slightly higher. I suppose that you pay for the convenience of having three curated selections arrive at your door, and, to me, that does end up being worth it. However, instead of soap and lotion samples, I would have much rather received an additional book or toy to increase the value.

What My First Reading Club book was your favorite this month?

My First Reading Club

How do subscribers rate My First Reading Club?

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about My First Reading Club!

Enable notifications () to get the latest My First Reading Club spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Jess Cole Payne

Jess Cole Payne

Jess’s love for subscription boxes began with a makeup and skincare fixation. She’s looking forward to broadening her horizons in discovering new products within the lifestyle and food world of subscription boxes.

Posted in Book Subscription Boxes, My First Reading Club Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Babies, Subscription Boxes for Kids| Tags: my first reading club | 3 comments

Comments (3)

  1. Yes, moms work hard, they deserve a little treat in the box. It’s a very popular feature.

  2. They always include a mommy gift! Those are what the toiletries are. I have been getting these boxes 4 months now.

    • Yep. They always include the mommy gift. The website actually mentions just one, but I’ve been subscribed for four months too and I think I’ve always received two. Added bonus. And while they aren’t large in size, they are good quality. I’ve really enjoyed this box and would recommend it

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.