Facebook PixelEarFleek Earring Subscription Review - September 2017 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

EarFleek Young at Heart Earring Subscription Review + 50% Off Coupon – September 2017

Anna Reilly
ByAnna ReillySep 25, 2017 | 13 comments

Check out the earrings in my Young at Heart Earfleek earring subscription for September 2017!

EarFleek
3.8 overall rating
58 Ratings | 14 Reviews

EarFleek is a monthly earring subscription that delivers a new pair of earrings each month to your door. Choose from three different subscription styles: "Boho Babe", "Young at Heart", "Minimalist, but Groovy", or let them decide for you!

The earrings come bubble wrapped in an envelope.

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

This is a review of the Young at Heart, $3.49 a month, box.

Check out the earrings in my Young at Heart Earfleek earring subscription for September 2017!
Check out the earrings in my Young at Heart Earfleek earring subscription for September 2017!

The Subscription Box: EarFleek

The Cost: $3.49 + free US shipping

The Products: “Every month EarFleek will personally style cute and trendy earrings and deliver them to your home! You’ll receive the ultimate accessory that can pair with your outfit or perhaps you can show off to your friends! Shipping is FREE! and if you are not thrilled you can always return them!” 100% nickel-free.

Ships to: Worldwide

Check out all of our EarFleek reviews and more jewelry subscription boxes in the Women's Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add EarFleek to your subscription list or wishlist!

Check out the earrings in my Young at Heart Earfleek earring subscription for September 2017!

They include an info card from your stylist. Mine is Rachel S. You can share your new look with the hashtag #earfleek, or use the email they include to cover any questions you might have.

Check out the earrings in my Young at Heart Earfleek earring subscription for September 2017!

Each pair of earrings also comes with a temporary tattoo. My tattoos are two butterflies. They're not my current aesthetic, but I like how they remind me of things I'd wear back in middle school. If I do a throwback look for Halloween (or if I have any friends who do so), these will come in handy!

I thought it was interesting how these stud earrings were packaged. Rather than having their posts punched through a card, they're squished into either end of a tiny soft plastic tube, then tucked into a bag. I imagine this prevents the posts from getting unintentionally squished or flattened during shipping.

Check out the earrings in my Young at Heart Earfleek earring subscription for September 2017! Check out the earrings in my Young at Heart Earfleek earring subscription for September 2017! Check out the earrings in my Young at Heart Earfleek earring subscription for September 2017!

Hot Pink Owl Earrings

This month, I got these little owl-shaped studs. I was impressed by how much detail they packed into these teensy, nickel-free earrings! Each owl has tiny toes that grip a small branch, they have little rhinestone eyes, and there are drops of strawberry pinkish-red enamel in each owl's tummy. They're not perfect—the enamel overflows over its setting in some spaces, the rhinestones are slightly too big (they look a bit overwhelming on these bitty owls), and personally, I would've preferred a cooler tone of enamel, rather than this bright, lipstick red. However! They cost so little per month (and even less with our MSA50 50% off code) that it's worth it to me! Welcome to my earring drawer, little owls!

Verdict: EarFleek is great because of how affordable it is. For $3.49 per month (or only $1.75 if you use our MSA50 50% off code!), you get a surprising new pair of earrings. That's super low risk, and the potential of a delightfully fun reward. I wasn't sure what to expect with the Young at Heart subscription, but I really like the vibe of this pair—they're playful, but not so juvenile that I couldn't tuck them into a professional outfit to give it a pop of personality.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today?: Since stylists choose the pair for you each month, it's hard to say that you would get these specific earrings if you ordered today. However, monthly shipments go out on the 15th of each month—if you're curious about this subscription, sign up soon to get October's earrings!

Value Breakdown: There's just one pair of earrings in each Earfleek monthly shipment, so these earrings are at least worth $1.75 (the cost of the subscription after our 50% off coupon).

Have you subscribed to EarFleek yet? What earrings have you gotten so far?

Starting at $3.49
Active Deal
Get your first box for $1.75!
Use Coupon Code MSA50
Subscribe Now

Receive fun and stylish earrings every month! Every month EarFleek will personally style cute and trendy earrings and deliver them to your home! You'll receive the ultimate accessory that can pair with your outfit or perhaps you can show off to your friends! Shipping is FREE! and if you are not t... read more.

Anna Reilly
Anna Reilly
Anna loves collecting little treasures, be they pop-culture finds, handmade mementos, or new potions to put in her makeup bag. Beauty boxes got her interested in the subscription world, but now she's swooning for all things kawaii!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

13 comments

Earfleek

Both – the majority of our dangly styles are in Boho Babe at this time and some in Minimalist and a few in I don’t Give a hoot. :)_

Reply ButtonReply

justmissjamey

Do they have dangle and big sized earings, or are they mostly small like this?

Reply ButtonReply

Earfleek

Both – the majority of our dangly styles are in Boho Babe at this time and some in Minimalist and a few in I don’t Give a hoot. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Earfleek

Both – the majority of our dangly styles are in Boho Babe at this time and some in Minimalist and a few in I don’t Give a hoot. :)_

Reply ButtonReply

Kelly

I just received my first pair of Earfleek earrings today!
I chose minimalist and received a small pair of gold airplanes with black and white stripes covering most of the front.

They are fantastic quality actually. I’m super sensitive to cheap metals and I wore them for several hours and they were fine!

The shipping had taken slightly longer than I expected, so I had contacted customer service, and I must say that they’re fantastic as well. They did offer to replace the earrings if I hadn’t received them (luckily I was able to reply and let them know they had come in in time)

I really think this subscription is worth a shot. I mean, not much to lose if you don’t end up loving it, right?

Reply ButtonReply

Earfleek

Thanks so much for the support Kelly!

Reply ButtonReply

Kelly

No problem! I received my second pair not too long ago and I love them even more than the first pair!!! Once again, not cheap metal or fake. I’ve worn my newest pair every single day for work (8 hour days) for over a week now, and no discoloration yet again. Perfect!

The only think I do wish is that there was an option to choose how many pairs we wanted every month and be charged $3.50 × quantity. I’ve become so excited, wish I could look forward to more than 1 a month.

KimberlyB

Oh, and I got black bird/feather designs that I really like. I’m glad you mentioned them, Anna, because I wasn’t sure if they were tattoos or stickers.

Reply ButtonReply

KimberlyB

Is this Young At Heart (like it says in the review title) or Boho Babe (like it says in bold just over the second photo)?

I chose Boho Babe and I got a VERY tiny (less than a quarter inch across and very thin) circle with a heart in the middle as one piece hanging from a rhinestone post. Waaaay too tiny for a big person like me, so into the swap basket it goes.

I would guess that different people get different styles. If you buy in large assorted lots from places like China and Malaysia, a pair of tiny post earrings can be as little as ten cents.

Reply ButtonReply

Anna Reilly

Whoops! This one is Young at Heart – sorry for the typo, Kimberly! I’ll fix that now 🙂 I appreciate your eagle eye!

Reply ButtonReply

ichigoluvah

I got little gold and black cupcakes in my “young at heart”. Maybe they send something different to each person?

Reply ButtonReply

Rene f/Earfleek

Yes, we have lots of different styles 🙂

Reply ButtonReply