Posted by on in Subscription Box News, Subscription Box Questions | Tags: | 94 comments

Subscriber Survey: What Box is at the Top of Your Wishlist?

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Sunday Subscriber Survey time! This week’s subscription box question is:

What subscription box is #1 on your wishlist? 

For me, it’s the Hasbro Gaming Crate.

It’s not available yet, but as soon as it launches this summer, I’m signing up!

What subscription box is at the top of your wishlist? 

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Mine would be Happy Rebel.

    • I would love to try out Beauty Fix as well!

  2. Saucefly is the one I lust over & WISH I could get! Looks AMAZING!!!!

    Also would love to get lip monthly & the new thinkgeek box. Plus, anything having to do with Harry Potter!

    • Saucefly looks AH-MAZING! It is now tied for first with Robb Vices for the #1 spot on my wishlist.

  3. Thinkgeek is starting a box and that is going to be very very VERY difficult to resist.

    Other than that, Robb Vices.

    • THINK GEEK IS STARTING A BOX?! Oh man….BRB, gotta research this stat!

      Thanks for the tip, Shawna!! <3

  4. I would love golden tote and some k-beauty boxes like memebox.

    • Memebox is a store now, they do kit boxes but not many options but the store is fantastic.

  5. Luxor, Avenue A and Oui Please!

  6. Morphe Me from Liveglam — makeup brushes!

  7. Rob Vices and FFF.

  8. Le Metier de Beaute…. why oh why can’t they do a 3- or 6-month sub????

  9. The Net-a-Porter and Addidas boxes 😘

  10. Rob Vices, Adidas A, and Luxor.

  11. I have two that I’d love to get every time a limited edition box comes up and that’s Luxor box and 5th Avenue Style. I wish I could get every LE box from both of those companies❤️

  12. That new one from Think Geek!

  13. I need LUSH to do a box. That would make me super happy but I want to get on the Erin Condren season box list too

  14. eric, you really should be jealous of Wesley…as you wish

  15. Mmmm..Robb Vices for sure. A hundo every month on just 1 box alone is too rich for my blood. Id have to cancel all my other monthly subs for this one. Not ready for that yet. 😉

  16. BOS, Causebox, Rockets of Awesome

  17. Box of Style, Happy Rebel, Blue Apron, and a bunch of the Korean beauty boxes. <3 🙂

  18. 5th avenue style for that Mutsaers bag! I have Luxor but oh how I wish I could afford the Black Box they just came out with too!

  19. Robb Vices and Rachael Zoe and The Nordstrom clothing one.

    • What nordstrom clothing one??

      • It’s Trunk Club a Nordstrom owned company.

  20. If I had to pick one maybe Rachel Zoe. But also luxor, happy rebel, oui please, modcloth, any lux sub… the list goes on

  21. BOS, FFF and PSMH….wish I could afford them all !

  22. Breo box! I’m really intrigued by that, but need to wait until our house sells before i take the plunge. Also curious about Stylogic or Natalie Attired. But definitely Breo Box.

    Oh, and pb&jealous if they start taking new subscribers again. It sold out quickly!

  23. Look incredible! It’s on my try next list 🙂

    • It’s worth every penny.

  24. Luxor

  25. None, I’ve subscribed to everything I’ve wanted. I have no self control. 🙁

    • Me either!

    • Haha! Me too! 🙂

      • Me too! But now I’m down to 7 which is better than the 16 I did have.

  26. ADIDAS A 😊

    • Second that

  27. iPen box

  28. Happy Rebel for sure!!

  29. Rachel Zoe Box of Style – I dream about it at night sometimes. I am hoping for a coupon for the summer box before I take the plunge!

  30. Rob Vices, that box looks amazing! Unfortunately It’s not in my budget right now 😕

    • Sameeee ^^

  31. I want beauty fix so badly 🙁

  32. Pusheen summer box. After being mostly disappointed with the spring box, I just don’t know if I can justify another $50… but last summer’s was soooo good and I wish I’d gotten it. I might eat only ramen for a couple weeks so I can afford it.

  33. Studio calico documentar

  34. The lit-cube Harry Potter box! I bought one for my kids to share, but I wish I could afford one each! 🙂 Oh well, it teaches them that there are limits, and they have to negotiate to see who gets what. Those are both good life skills!

    • I bought one! It was sooooo worth it!

  35. Probably Yummy Bazaar or something like Trunk Club

    • Hi Randi,

      Thanks for mentioning us! Private message us at [email protected] and we will send you a free June Box to try 😉


  36. Stitch Fix and Luxor for sure. And the higher dollar skincare boxes like Boxwalla and Pearlesque.

  37. Luxor…until I read terms and’s a bit scary to commit. Avenue A for sure!

  38. Adidas Ave A

  39. Luxor!

  40. Robb Vices and Luxor

  41. Clean Beauty by Art of Organics always looks stunning.

  42. I recently subscribed to the box I had on my wishlist for a year, Robb Vices. I just received my second box and couldn’t e happier. Now, I’m just not sure I have one I’m lusting after. Maybe one of the French boxes? I’m open to suggestions if anyone has any nice boxes you are consistently blown away by.

  43. Look Incredicle from the UK and So Susan.

    • I just got the Look Incredible box for May, and I’m so thrilled with it. I know it’s in the higher price range for a sub box, but they have two different levels of sub boxes (a smaller one, and a deluxe version), so hopefully you’ll be able to treat yourself to at least a month or two sometime this year. 🙂 I may be thinking of Mintd (for some reason, I always get the two mixed up in my head), but I believe you can also opt for a bi-monthly sub as well.

  44. Mine is probably the happy rebel, too far outside of my price range, and I feel like a few items are really marked up. But I really love the style

  45. I really want the Droids Smuggler’s Bounty box!

  46. My top three are Mapleblume, Organic Bunny Box and Willie Wags.

    • I really want to try Mapleblume as well!!

    • I love Mapleblume!!!! I’ve been subbed since February, and It quickly went to the top of the list of my favorite beauty subs. I’ve also been subbed to Organic Bunny box for the past few months, and I really like the sort of “random” feel to the curation of the box. I feel like it’s a great discovery box, as they include a nice variety of types of products, size of products (deluxe samples to full-sized), as well as very well-known brands to brands that most people have never heard of before.

  47. I have so many! Lol. Would love to sub to PopSugar, get the PS limited editions, the Rachel Zoe box, UpperCase or another book box. I wish I had all the $$$!!

  48. I don’t need new clothes yet, but the (ladies’) Trunk Club would be nice when I do.

  49. 7th Avenue Style or Luxor – but cannot afford either

  50. I want to get Litcube or another book box, just can’t afford it now. I did get the Litcube grab box. Can’t wait

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!