Posted by on in Play! By Sephora Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 62 comments

Play! By Sephora April 2017 Spoiler #3!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

We have a new spoiler for the April 2017 Play! By Sephora box! The theme is “Step it Up!”

Screen Shot 2017-03-18 at 11.46.22 AM

And each box will include an item from the brand:

Screen Shot 2017-03-18 at 11.46.47 AM

And now we have an item reveal from Make Up For Ever. (Thanks, Chrissy, for the heads up!)

Screen Shot 2017-04-10 at 8.13.57 AM

Make Up For Ever Aqua XL Waterproof Eyeliner

(FYI – all subscribers will receive a Make Up For Ever item in their April box, but not all subscribers necessarily will receive this item.)

And in case you missed the earlier spoilers:

We have another EXCLUSIVE spoiler just for MSA readers! Each subscriber will receive one of the following skincare items in their box:


What do you think of the latest Play! by Sephora spoilers? Which item are you hoping to get in your box?

If you haven’t signed up for a Play! by Sephora subscription yet, the waitlist is currently open! If you sign up now, your first box will be the April box.

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Yay for Peter Thomas Roth I love everything from this company,so I hope I get that .As far as the eyeliner I’d be happy to try it since it would be a new brand of eyeliner .I use eyeliner every time I wear makeup ,most of the time colored but chances are I will add black to my waterline

  2. I am not looking forward to getting a eyeliner.
    I don’t need another one.
    It’s a waste of an Makeup Forever product 🙁

    • I need one. Hope I get one!

    • I agree. I was so excited for makeup forever then really sad when I found out its a liner, and a pencil liner at that.

  3. Can someone explain how the swap works? Do we have to pay for shipping or just put it in a envolope?

    • It comes in a drawstring bag that is then placed in a box. No envelope involved.

    • You pay to ship your own items to the person you are swapping with and they pay to ship their items to you.

      • Thanks for the reply. I figured that much, but what do you do if the other person doesn’t send their item even though you sent yours after you both agree on the swap? Is there a list of bad swappers to avoid headaches?

        • Oh basically if they don’t send there’s nothing that can be done about it. I’ve never had it happen and if someone has a bad rating you can choose not to swap with them. If someone has less than 100% rating I read their negative reviews. If they have someone saying they never received their items I won’t swap with them. Also, after a few they do get banned from the swap site.

          • I’m glad there’s a way to leave feedback for bad swappers. I’ll have to give it a try one of these days. Thanks again for the info.

    • Thank u for all of the info ladies 🙂

  4. I hope there’s some fun colors. Even if it is black, though, I’d still be happy to try it to figure out if I want to buy one of the fun colors.

  5. I’m getting Sephora Play item #1926583. Hope it’s a good variation this month! I don’t need any more eye liners! I just gave a bunch of eyeliners to my sister and niece, and I still have plenty! The other spoilers sound good to me. Anyone else getting the same # as me?

    • I’m getting 591!

      • I’m new to this subscription box. How do you find out what play item you’ll be receiving?

        • Go into your account and find your orders. Click on this month’s Play order (probably your most recent order, unless you’re like me and have a serious Sephora addiction), then you’ll get a screen that has the item number and that will be the variation you get. 591 are the last three digits of my item number for this month’s play.

          • Found it! It shows# 1926583. Sooo.. I feel silly asking, but what do these #s mean? Like there’s X # of April boxes, & I’m getting this version?

          • Not everyone gets the same box, there are variations each month. You’ll get the same box as everyone else who is a 583. So when the full spoilers come up, that’s the number you’re looking for.

        • Oh, and you won’t know your items until you get your bag. Eventually they’ll be in your account online under Play! subscription.

          • Well, you do actually get to see what’s in your bag before you get it…that’s the point of the box spoilers.

      • I keep checking to see the peeks for each number!

        So far, nothing up! I am getting 591 too!

      • I am getting 591 and I got a sneak peek of the Make Up For Ever Aqua XLT eyeliner. It was a notification from the Sephora app so eyeliner for sure for box 591.

    • I’m getting #583, too – hope it’s a good one….

      • I’m also getting 583… keeping my fingers crossed for anything but eyeliner…

    • I am getting the same one as you, it was in my inbox on the app that showed the Makeup Forever eyeliner. I definitely don’t need anymore black eyeliners, so hopefully it’s a different color!

    • I’m getting 583 too!

  6. Please share the swap site being mention on this thread. Would like to check it out for swapping purposes.

    • I found the link for swaps. Could someone please explain how this site works? How do you tell bad swapers from good ones etc.

      • Swappers are rated after the swap is complete. So you can read their reviews. If you are a new swapper you are required to send your items first. Once they receive they send to you. After you have 5 positive swaps you can both send out at the same time.

        • Thanks so very much for the info Tara.

  7. Don’t want! I only use liquid eyeliner yet I have like 3 black ones like this. Hopefully I get something else but I would take this if it meant I got the fresh mask 😅

  8. The only thing I want is the truth serum. I’ve been dying to try it.

    • LOVE the truth serum!!

  9. This is the only pencil eyeliner I’ve ever tried that stays put on my super oily lids AND is comfortable to put on! I love this product! The down side for me is that I already have quite a few of them.

  10. Pls, no exfolikate and eyeliner for me 😣

  11. I love eyeliner super excited for this! Would also love Kate Somerville: ExfoliKate Intensive Exfoliating Treatment. I love ipsy, sephora I canceled as soon as I did loved the next box, last month was pretty good, so far this month is a keeper!

  12. I only have seven sub boxes, I recently cut back on two, so it’s been a while since I got an eyeliner, un less the ahadow stick counts. I just don’t want black.

    • I love how you say “only” 7 lol. I wish I had 7. I have 2 (Ipsy and Sephora) and I usually buy the Target ones. Oh and I subscribe to Walmart’s. I keep getting primers!

  13. Yay. More eyeliner.

  14. I don’t wear eyeliner so I hope I get a different variation. I know a lot of people were like we better not get the primer again but I actually really liked the primer and would love to get it again.

    But either way its only $10 if i don’t like one thing I’ll pass it along to a friend.

  15. Am I missing something or this only 2 spoilers?

    • The third spoiler is the theme…

  16. Black eyeliner is one of the only products I won’t use since I use gel liner! But that’s why I love the swap site!

    • what swap site?

      • I’m new and would like to know too.

        • If you go to the top of this site their is a label “swap” you can sign up for. There’s usually a wait list but it didn’t take long to get off.

          • How long does it take to get off? I’ve been on the wait list over a week.

  17. I literally have black eyeliners in my cart, I’ve been trying to decide between them!
    I’m hoping for the truth serum or the vitamin mask.

  18. meh – this doesn’t excite me much

    • I agree!! I almost cancelled after last month, maybe it will be this month I cancel, we shall see 😉

  19. I don’t use black liners or mascara so I’m hoping for another variation. Hoping for Fresh or Peter Thomas Roth since those are new to me.

  20. Excited to try this eyeliner for the summer months since it’s warm waterproof! I’m hoping to get the Exfoliating treatment for this time of year! Can’t wait to get this box and see all the other fun products!

  21. I don’t really like black eyeliner, so I hope I get something different. If not, it’ll be up for swaps. Looks like a good product though.

    • is swap a site ?

  22. I’d love to snag that waterproof eyeliner for our trip to Jamaica. And I’d be happy with any of the skincare products.. they’re my favorite beauty box item!

  23. *subscribes to Play!*
    Oh no, too much make-up
    *sees spoilers for next month*
    Dang it!
    *check into Sephora Addicts anonymous*

    • LMAO!!!

  24. That girl from Gossip Girl and the band The Pretty Reckless should subscribe to a bunch of beauty boxes. She’ll never run out of black eyeliner!!!

    • little j? all hail queen blair in this household.

      • I’m not sure, never seen the show. Whichever one wears an entire black eye pencil around her eyes when she’s performing in her band 🙂 I think her name is Taylor Momsen?

      • Lol I loved gossip girl !

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!