Facebook PixelModCloth Stylish Surprise is Available Now! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

ModCloth Stylish Surprise is Available Now!

MSA
ByMSAMar 6, 2017 | 82 comments

Screen Shot 2017-03-06 at 8.15.33 AM

ModCloth Stylish Surprise
4 overall rating
27 Ratings | 6 Reviews

ModCloth Stylish Surprise is available now!

UPDATE: Use coupon code TREAT20 to save 20% off orders of $100 or more! (Thanks, Suzanne!)

Stylish Surprise - Dresses, $20, available in sizes XS-4X

Stylish Surprise - Apparel, $15, available in sizes XS-4X

Stylish Surprise - Shoes, $10, available in sizes 5-11

Stylish Surprise - Apartment, $10 (SOLD OUT)

Stylish Surprise - Jewelry, $5

FYI - Shipping is free on orders of $75 or more!

If you aren't familiar with the Stylish Surprise, you can buy a mystery item (as many as you want) from any of the available categories - basically, it is a create-your-own-mystery-box!

Good to know: All Stylish Surprise items are Final Sale. These sell out VERY quickly - make sure to buy ASAP if you are interested!

Check out our Stylish Surprise reviews to learn more about this offer from Modcloth!

Starting at $10.00
Subscribe Now
ModCloth Stylish Surprise is a once-a-quarter mystery box. ModCloth offers their apparel, shoes, accessories and sometimes apartment items at a huge discount, but you don't know what you're going to get - you can only pick the size. This isn't a typical subscription, so if you want to make sure ... read more.
MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

82 comments

Kelly

I am sooooo disappointed in all of my clothing surprises. I ordered 3 shoes, 4 apparel, 2 dresses. The tops that I received are definitely not my style. Like, I can’t stand them. The two dresses that I received are not flattering at all, which is a bummer because they’re both pretty. The shoes aren’t bad but only my boots fit well.
So $130 converted to Canadian $$, plus shipping, plus the $23 I was charged at the post office… around $233 for a pair of $90 boots that I like. I’ll keep one of the tops for pj’s, and I’ve worn the pair of booties that I received, so they’re dirty and I’ll keep ’em. I don’t think I’ll be purchasing again. I also ordered a skirt, blouse, and shoes full price and will be returning the clothing items. Should be fun, doing an international return. Womp womp.
If anyone in Canada is a Plus size 2 clothes, or 8.5 shoe and would be interested in me posting these to Pinterest or somewhere, let me know! Just a general idea of what I got…

Tops –
mustard coloured blouse with tiny racoons on it (what even?!)
flowy sleeveless blouse in a splatter paint print
maroon tee shirt with crochet inset

Dresses-
Pink with lots of lace
satin and cream with flowers printed on the skirt

Shoes-
Red heels

My full priced items-
mid-length black skirt
dinosaur blouse 🙂

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

sharlie

Where do the majority of the Stylish Surprise swaps occur? I would be interested in checking out the thread and possibly putting some of my SS on there.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Kelly

Ditto!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Hillary

I got a tank which I love, really cute set of 3 stud earrings, a sweater that doesn’t connect in the front, but then a shirt that doesn’t fit, a shirt that kind of fits, and then one of my apparel items was a skirt, which sucks because I’m a different size on the top than I am on the bottom. And then I got a cute black dress.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Ks

I got roughly $250 retail value from $55. Granted, most of the value is from a bridal gown I received 😂 IDK if I’ll sell it or save it for a special occasion. It is quite beautiful. Got very cheap Qupid brand flats but they look really nice. And a PJ top by Honeydew which I wouldn’t have paid $15 for but it is super comfy to lounge in.

Overall, it’s been an okay SS. Everything fits so hey.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Anisha

I received someone else’s order. Modcloth put the correct shipping label on the outside but the wrong items and packing slip in the inside. I would love to get this box to the right person and hopefully whomever has my box would send it back to me as well.

If ERIN BRADLEY from Saint Paul, MN is in this group I have your box!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Anisha

I received someone else’s order. Modcloth put the correct shipping label on the outside but the wrong items and packing slip in the inside. I would love to get this box to the right person and hopefully whomever has my box would send it back to me as well.

If ERIN BRADLEY from Saint Paul, MN is in this group I have your box!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jonina

Pretty happy with my box! I got a rainbow stripe shirt that I’d ALMOST bought like four times but never actually ordered and I love it soooooo much. Also a pair of sandals that I will definitely wear all summer and a pair of earrings I love. I also got a hilariously weird pair of heels (hopefully someone somewhere will want them), and a set of earrings I already gifted to a friend. My other apparel item was nice but not my color. This was way better than my first Stylish Surprise, and I’m feeling way more enthused about doing it again in the future.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jena

This isn’t the best stylish suprise I’ve ever gotten (the 5th time for me). I got a grey/blue sweatshirt material short sleeve top with a lace trim. And grey fit and flare, cap sleeve dress that is so comfy and cute, a camel color pair of booties. An amazing, unique, colorful statement necklace that arrived damaged and already got refunded for, but I’m going to attempt to fix it, a pearl and beaded pink, and neutrals, multi strand necklace, and tribal looking gold, drop nexclace. And the weirdest item was a set of three pairs of gold dinosaur earrings including t-Rex, stegosaurus, and long neck Dino’s. These are not my style but might be fun when I want to be whimsical. Did I mention best SS ever? I can’t wait for the next one.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Zoe

Omg! I’d love to swap something for the dino earrings if you’re not into them.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Hillary

Would you be down to swap for the earrings?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jena

I might depending on what you have! Do you have a swap board or anything?

Like This CommentLike

Jena

****IS not isn’t! It IS the best SS ever!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Donna

I can’t even begin to express how happy I am with my order. I’m just now wishing I would’ve ordered a lot more!! I absolutely love it all. They forgot one of my jewelry pieces but I am still extremely happy and can’t wait for the next lol

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Donna

I loved mine so much that I bought more lol

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Kim

I got a hideous chunky metal feather necklace, a super cheap looking tee shirt material blouse with a giant bow at the neck, and some velcro, clunky geriatric heeled sandals. Lesson learned.I won’t be buying this surprise again.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Cortney

This was my second stylish surprise, and I was pleased with it! Cute navy/white sheath dress, cute cardigan, and a pair of sort-of stodgy heels that will actually be perfect for work. Last time ordering 1X was hit or miss (the dress fit, the apparel/skirt didn’t) so I’m glad this time the sizing worked out. I managed to find the items on other sites and they were all priced sliiiightly more than I paid for the SS, so overall I’m happy!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Elizabeth

This was my first surprise and it was, sadly, pretty much a bust. I got some very boring but comfortable shoes, two necklaces that are Chunky Monkey and going to swap, a dress that’s cute but too big (even though I picked apparel), and a tank that’s not my style and too big. My yoga teacher might like the tank, though, so I’ll offer it to her.

Ah well. Don’t gamble what you can’t afford to lose, right?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jessica

This is my second surprise. I got three shoes- a black bootie that I was excited about until i tried on (so uncomfortable), one blue summer type heel sandal – which actually matches a dress I got in my last surprise (win there) and cute retro type heels which are adorable, but most likely not good for lots of walking. I also got 2 necklaces – both are not my style, but one is better than the other. i got a dress, which fits but is not flattering and three tops – one i love, one is OK, and one is made for a small child even though its supposed to be a medium- so total loss there. would like to try to swap this as well as a few things i got last surprise that didn’t work. I am no longer on social media (i.e., facebook)- is there somewhere else to do swaps?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Christina Sanders

received my package of 2 apparel items. They ended up both being safe & I will wear…But I received 2 cotton tank tops. So, I’m disappointed. Not much value and was hoping for some nicer /fancier clothes. Something that seemed more “modcloth” style these are very casual and modern.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Julie B.

My apparel items are on the way. I always hope for a jacket or trench coat as I’ve seen some people get, but I haven’t been so lucky. Tank tops aren’t very exciting but at least they fit!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marianne

My order arrived yesterday! I was hoping for a pair of cool boots and a coat (wishful thinking!) so when a small box arrived I was immediately a little disappointed. I wound up getting a cute, lightweight, long sleeved hooded top in purple…fits well! In lieu of boots 😩, I got a pretty, low heeled pump in a camel color. Not what I had hoped for, but for a grand total of $25 I’m not gonna complain! Good luck to you all…so exciting to see what others are getting!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Maria

My order arrived TODAY. Wow, fast. I got 3 apparel, 1 shoe and 3 jewelry. The clothes were all wearable(one will probably go to swap just because it is a bit snug) The shoes, super cute but don’t fit my daughter like she would like(glad sandals) and jewelry is nice. I was rather happy this time and glad I gave them another chance. The 20% off and free ship was great. I got a top I really wanted and a grad prezzie too.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Julie B.

Got my tracking info already! Can’t wait. Instead of buyer’s remorse I’m actually sorry I didn’t buy more. Yesterday “in the moment” I was thinking realistically what are the odds these things will fit AND be things I like? But now: other people are going to get so many cute shoes and dresses!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Ks

Saaaaaame 🙁

After last SS with so many duplicates, I only got 1 of each clothing and shoe items. But now I wish I got like 5 of everything. Haha.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Vanessa

People are already getting tracking numbers?? I can’t even LOOK at my order from yesterday. NONE of my past orders are showing at all. *sigh* I do hate the waiting. Stylish Surprise is my FAVORITE and I’ve been waiting for it since the last one in September! I’d be tempted to put another order in if they had any more apparel in 4X. Oh well, back to the waiting.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Zali

Same here. I got the confirmation e-mail, so I hope that’s enough to indicate that it went through, but not having the fast shipping or order showing up is making me stress!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Karen

I got 2 apparel in xs, 1 dress in xs, 2 shoes in size 6 and 1 jewelry. I have always had good luck with the stylish surprise boxes. I have never had anything not fit. I don’t wear earrings but I do have pierced ears so I can wear then if I get earrings. I wear every other type of jewelry so fingers crossed for a ring,necklace,bracelet etc. For those asking I did once manage to get 2 apartments and I got a gorgeous teal vase and a pretty black and white marble looking paper weight that I still use at home to keep bills and other papers organized. Fingers crossed for more good stuff!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Zali

Sooooo sad I didn’t see this until after the shoes were already sold out! I’ve never seen mystery grab bag shoes before, that would have been awesome. But, that didn’t stop me from getting 3 dresses, 2 apparel and 2 jewelry. Never bought from Modcloth before, but I have always liked the dresses in the internet ads I see. Hopefully sizing one up will be enough…

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Beth

The jewelry is still up for sale because I just got one at 5:30am 3/7/17

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

JacLyn

Woo! I just got my tracking number. I’m kind of hoping jewelry will still be up after my package arrives, so if I like what I got, I can order more. XD

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Julie

These are so much fun. I got two apparels. Last time I got a nice top and a gorgeous pink dress worth about a hundred dollars. It’s a bit too big but I can’t bear to give it up. I’m always tempted to get a bunch of stuff to get free shipping, but it might be a waste of money and I like treating myself just for the fun surprise.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jena

I’ve been waiting for another one of these for months! It’s my favorite sale!

I got….
1 dress (I always have the best luck with this category)
1 apparel (not great luck with this one but I keep trying)
1 shoes (sometimes I love this one and sometimes it’s just ok)
4 jewelry (is this new????? I have to restrain myself from buying more lol)

A new planner that was on clearance and a kate spade travel mug. I think I have an addiction .

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

JenA

I got my tracking but they oversold dresses and apparel in size large and my orders for those got cancelled. I’m super sad because dresses are my favorite. I don’t understand how because I placed my order at 8:30 central time.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Victoria

I got the same message (M dress, M apparel, and jewelry oversold) but when I contacted customer support about it, they said that they’re having a bug where if the orders are shipped separately the system says they were oversold. You’re probably just gonna get two packages, one with the dresses and apparel and one with everything else you ordered.

Like This CommentLike

Ks

It took everything in my power not to go for free shipping but with last time’s duplicates in many orders, I couldn’t risk getting multiples. Got 1 dress, 1 apparel, and 1 pair of shoes. Last time, my dress got cancelled but the other pieces were awesome. Hoping for same luck this time around 🙂

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike