Posted by on in Galentines Day 2017, Mystery Boxes, POPSUGAR Must Have Box Coupon, Subscription Boxes & Coupons | Tags: , , | 114 comments

Galentine’s Day Deal – New POPSUGAR Must Have Mystery Boxes!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.


POPSUGAR Must Have has created two exclusive Mystery Boxes for the MSA Galentine’s Day Party!

Screen Shot 2017-02-13 at 11.18.02 AM

The Box: Girls Night In Box

The Cost: $24.95

The Products: A cozy night in with your besties can be the perfect cure for the cold-weather blues. Luxuriate in self-care at home with our Girls’ Night In box, which features our Must Have products from past boxes. Each box includes $200+ worth of products. Staying in has never been more fun!

*Orders will ship within 7 to 10 business days via FedEx SmartPost. All Girls’ Night In boxes contain the same assortment of products.

Screen Shot 2017-02-13 at 11.18.06 AM


The Box: Girls Night Out Box

The Cost: $24.95

The Products: Kicking off an evening out on the town by getting glam with the gals beforehand? Ladies, we’ve got you covered. Our Girls’ Night Out box is the kit you need to sparkle from head to toe. It features our previous Must Have hits worth over $200, so you can look your best all night long.

*Orders will ship within 7 to 10 business days via FedEx SmartPost. All Girls’ Night Out boxes contain the same assortment of products.


Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Whooo, sold out! So glad I hesitated, since I’ve been kinda-sorta disappointed in previous mystery boxes.

    • So glad I resisted too – was hoping for a subscription deal because I cancelled after my deal ran out.

  2. Wow, these both sold out quickly. Good thing I was resisting!

    • YES Jackie! Me too! I just saved $50! lol 😀

  3. No way am I going to do this – not this time. I kicked myself last time and no matter how appealing they make these boxes look I refuse to cave.

  4. Really hoping for no makeup so I got the girls stay in. Didn’t realize it could be packed with bingo and other games I can’t seem to swap away. Hoping for the best. The candles smelled great.

  5. Popsugar you sneaky devils, you sure are tempting with your mystery boxes!!! Very hard to resist a mystery box! I already got the night in and keep thinking about adding a night out box too. I have been very happy with the last few months boxes😀

  6. Girls night in is sold out 😢

  7. Yep, one of each. Hope they’re good! 🙂

    • The Night Out is awesome! I have only subscribed to Jan and Feb 2017, so i had none of the night out products! I love it!

  8. Just ordered the Girl’s Night In box! My first PopSugar ever! So excited!!!

  9. Will the boxes be reviewed on MSA after they are issued? I’d love to see what was in them?

  10. I got one of each. I love me some Popsugar and most of it trades fairly well if I don’t like/use it. All except that Bingo game, that I just gifted to my game loving and very creative s-in-law 😊

  11. Omg! Omg! I am so excited PopSugar is part of the Galentine’s Day! I ordered one of each. I don’t subscribe to their monthly boxes so I splurged. Happy VDay to me! Yay! Can hardly wait! Thank you, MSA!

    • My first PopSugar too!!!! YAY!!

  12. I really enjoyed the first two mystery boxes – I sat on the sidelines for the Black Friday ones and regretted not picking up the one I wanted (for the home) and seeing as it’s tax return season I think I’m going to pick one of these up!

    I appreciate that they’re not putting a far out date for shipping these too like they’ve done in the past. Makes my impatient self much happier.

    • Your reminder that tax refunds are upon us, might tilt me towards buying one. I haven’t been disappointed with a mystery box yet, but I’m also not a subscriber

  13. I grabbed girls night in! I think of candles and bubble bath and face masks and treats and I’m so excited!

    • I’m going for both haha. Hopefully it’s some good stuff! I wouldn’t mind getting duplicates of some things, but not the Who am I game, my husband and I already played all the cards hahaha. Now we have to give it away lol. *crossing fingers*

    • That’s exactly what I’m hoping for! Given me all the candles, sweets and masks you can and I’ll be happy!!! Hoping the vanill oil and bubble bath are for sure in this!

  14. I stopped subbing ages ago but I always get the mystery boxes. For the most part they’re great for in the pinch gifts. I have boxes in my closet with, jewelry trays, mini lip kits, bubble bath, etc lol I can tell you, a good bit appeals to teenagers lol

  15. Ok, I got the night in! I couldn’t help myself and I don’t have the bingo game, I do have the “Who am I?” though so I hope I don’t get that one.

  16. I bought them both. I cant resist the mystery boxes especially since I’m not a subscriber. I think these are a great alternative to their $40 a month subscription. I got the home mystery box last time and loved every piece. I’m hoping I have the same luck with these boxes!

  17. Tempting… Still, Im passing this one. Im pretty sure this will be filled with the items previously featured in the boutique with the 75% percent discount.

    3 of the items of the night out should be: power charger, stowaway palette and the lint roller :-/

  18. Interesting. In the Night in photo, one of the girls is wearing the Illesteva sunnies and the other is wearing what looks like some quay Australia sunnies… Hmmm… I bought one of each box, lol

  19. Hi Liz!
    I have been trying to contact you regarding a certain swap/swapper.
    How can I get in touch with you, please?

    • If I remembered correctly, MSA doesn’t take responsibility and response for swap/swapper issues. Liz claimed at the beginning.

      • Just emailed you, Rosemary. Apologies for the delay in getting back to you!

        • You are the best, Liz!
          I got your email and am keeping you up to date with what’s going on.
          As always, thanks for all that you do for we addicts (OK…I am addicted to these dang boxes).

      • I am not blaming Liz for anything, nor holding her or this site responsible for a damn thing. Out of courtesy, I would like to inform her of something, and if I remembered correctly, we are asked to contact MSA in certain circumstances. This is all that I am doing.

  20. I am having serious FOMO about this but at this point in time I am going to pass. The first round of Mystery boxes last summer were AWESOME. The second round they had in the fall were less than stellar. Not only did they have repeat stuff from the summer mystery boxes but then they also gave out duplicate boxes to those that ordered more than one. I feel like they have had so many amazing products over the years that they could have made the curation so much better on those…maybe they learned and these one’s will be awesome and I will cry I did not get them.

  21. What are the chances that the Girls Night In box will have a bingo board in it? Hmm.

    • rotflol that is exactly what I was thinking!

      • LOL!
        Let’s have a girl’s night out!!!
        Bingo game $20
        Blow-up swan $28
        Winky Lux Lipstick $14 (although I think Bunny is a great color)
        Cargo Cosmetics Powder Blush $26
        Stowaway Cosmetics Dawn To Dusk Palette $25
        Snowfall necklace $28
        Mane Message Date Night Bobby Pins $10
        Michael Stars Porcelain Skinny Scarf $26
        Wine Glass Writers $9.95
        MakeUp Eraser $12
        Power Your Happy by Lisa Sugar $25

    • NOOO I certainly hope not lolol 🤣

  22. I got the night in box. I figured I can always use duplicates of products like candles, lotions, chocolate, tea, spa products, etc. If not, they are always giftable!!!

  23. I’m tempted but doesn’t the limited edition box come out really soon too? I feel like it’s BF all over again and my CC hasn’t even recovered yet 😑

  24. I got $10 that the girls night in has the brown sugar body wash stuff lol

    • I LOVE that stuff!

    • I hope so!

  25. Going to take a chance on the night out box. The in prob has cocoa, candles, etc. Things I don’t need.

  26. I got the girls night in!! Super excited I just started Pop Sugar so I won’t have anything already if the items are from past boxes. They should offer both past boxes for newbies and boxes with all new products for their loyal subscibers.

  27. I think I’ll get one of the night in boxes since I haven’t purchased a mystery box since last summer and I really liked the contents.

  28. So excited!!! I bought the girls night in. I’m hoping they put items from the limited addition boxes.

    • If the last mystery boxes are any indication they will be filled with leftover items. I doubt from any limited edition boxes. The last LE boxes sold out and I imagine they got rid of the extras from earlier boxes that weren’t hits with the mystery boxes from last year. The mystery boxes with LE items in them were set at a higher price than these boxes.

  29. Based on their description “features our Must Have products from past boxes” looks like these boxes will be staffed with left over items. I am little bit hesitant to jump into this offer, because based on the swap site looks like all popsugar items available in hundreds, meaning that too many people dislike the product and want desperately to swap it. I am going to pass.

    • I almost think many people just buy popsugar to build a “swap stash” bc of the silly rsv and all the “hype” it gets.
      without even intending to enjoy the sub itself 😕

      You can find popsugar items on ebay at disproportionately high prices ( 1 item alone selling for $20, when thats the cost of the whole box) or people selling the entire box for $50 before they even get it…. surely they paid $20 for it.
      I even am at fault for having things that i “hold onto/ store”, like the clutch, kendra scot bracelet, and pher bin NOT because i dont like them, but because i think maybe one day ill want to swap and someone will like them more than i do. Its ridiculus.

  30. Wow, I’m actually passing on both. For girls night in I was imagining the hair towel, candles, peppermint tea or maybe the hot cocoa, mani-pedi kit. All of which I already have.

    • Wow! My thoughts exactly! Plus the mug. And all of the items that did not sell at 75% off like the eye shadow palette, makeup eraser, lip pill etc will be in the go out box.

      • And the book!

        • GAHHHHH not the book. I already have two. 🙁 And it’s not like it’s something I’ll run out of… Is anyone else refreshing the Galentine’s page every time it gets within five minutes of the 30 min marks??

    • Or the peel from January. Mine is untouched in my closet. I’m afraid to use it.

      • Kelly, I’ll swap with ya if I have something you want!

      • I have SUPER sensitive skin (I have skin disease), and that Goldfaden MD peel has not bothered me one little bit. It feels like water when it’s on. No tingling or anything on my skin. You should do a little patch test and give it a try.

      • The only reason I bought the Night In was fingers crossed for more of the peel. Love it.

    • Yes your so right. I can’t believe I may pass. This last mystery boxes were not a big hit with me at all. I wish they had mostly new sale stuff inside them or at least most. They would sell out of them in a few hours. Crap I am sorta sad. Oh well….

    • I am imagining that too but that is exactly what I want!

  31. This is a one time purchase, correct? I won’t be subscribed to PSMH if I buy one of the aforementioned boxes, right?

    • Right – just a one-time deal, CiCi. 🙂

  32. Are mystery boxes always “leftovers” from previous boxes, or are they ever stuff that’s not been in boxes? & if so, how far back in the previous boxes do they go? I’ve been subscribing since September, and I’d pretty much love more of anything from December-February… Or I can never have enough Lalicious body wash… but I would HATE more stuff from Sept-Nov otherwise…. 🙁

    • Ditto. It seemed like they had a ton of extras from those boxes, and the Lalicious and hot cocoa are the only items I wouldn’t mind receiving again from those months (and maybe the Flint lint roller, but I may be alone on that one, lol. I gave mine to my boyfriend and don’t have one).

      • No Samantha – you’re not alone on that! I somehow ended up with THREE Flints, and I still wouldn’t mind more LOL the refills are relatively cheap, but the shipping isn’t. We have two dogs, and my fiance is a lint-roller junkie. I can think of plenty of people who would love any I have left over too. 😉

        • Hey Cornflake, you may have already seen this, but the refills are available on Amazon as well. Some qualify for Prime shipping (mostly the bigger/multi-packs, but if you’ll use them, it might be worth it 🙂 )

          • Nope – when I looked, they didn’t have any under Prime. Thanks, Kristen G.!

        • Lol, glad I’m not alone! : ) But I wonder if they give that out, if it will be for the Girls’ Night Out, since most people don’t do lint-rolling for a night in, lol. I only bought the night in box.

  33. I SEE A CANDLE IN THE GIRLS’ NIGHT IN BOX! Please be Holiday Magic!!! : D

    • Got too excited, I mean in the PHOTO for the night in box. Look on the right hand nightstand!

    • That candle is awesome. I received 3 of them in the last mystery box triplicate. It lasts a long time and really keeps its scent even to the very end. I still have one left.

    • I see a stack of books 😂

      • Who doesn’t like having a girls’ night in reading books and not talking to each other? LOL. I wish they would include some Govino items for the night in box. Cause wine. Wine is what I want during girls’ night in. : )

  34. Grabbed the Girl’s Night In box – so excited! (Oh, please don’t let it be a bingo box. Please please please, no bingo box)

    Thanks so much for posting, happy Galentine’s Day, MSA! 🙂

    • Happy Galentine’s Day, Beth!! 🙂

    • Hahaha, I agree on the Bingo comment, Beth! I currently have three that I’m going to put out at my next yard sale! I also have three of the Who Am I? game so finger’s crossed it more of a spa-themed box with bubble bath and hair wraps than a game night! 🙂

      • LOL Clutterbee – I’m at work next to my “Who Am I?” game. I thought I would never use it, but I’ve been posting daily trivia on our internal website with it haha

        • What a great idea, Cornflake! That’s super fun!

      • When the stomach virus was going around during the holidays and all one could do is lay down in between, you know, I would read the questions to whoever was sick. It really helped pass the time and was something that you could do for 2 minutes, 10 minutes or longer. Now we’ve put it in the car and the passenger will read questions to the driver to pass the time on a longer car ride. We don’t go by rules, just use it for questions. Best $3 I spent (got it during the 75% off sale).

        • Car game – love it! We take a 12 hr (one way – ouch) drive every December, and I’m about tired of the “letters” game – this one would be good!

  35. I want them, but I don’t want or need any repeats. I am trying to think of what I didn’t get in the last mystery boxes. These are very tempting!

    • Any guesses on what could be in these boxes? I am sort of new to Popsugar so I can’t imagine past the last mystery boxes.

      • There are reviews for two versions of a July Mystery Box up with the rest of Popsugar reviews. I looked at several reviews and decided on both boxes. The only PS box I’ve bought so far is January’s. I’m thankful for the swap part of MSA so if there are items I don’t like, I can try to swap them away. Or just give them to my favorite Humane Society thrift store and make someone else really happy at such a great find 😀

  36. I bought both ! I love popsugar 😍😍😍 yayyy 🎉🎉🎉

  37. Wish there was a spoiler or two on it. Looks like maybe the girls night out may have the 3 pack lip set from a while ago.

  38. That happened quickly! Got the night in box!

    • Same! I have so much makeup so I hope to get more use out of the night in box. Even if it’s repeats of some of their spa-like products, like the Lalicious shower oil or Spongelle, I’d be happy to get more. Not much makeup I’ve seen in their boxes that I want that I don’t already have.

      • Agree!! I figure it’ll be lotion, the shower oil, candle, maybe head wrap, and then some chocolate to cookies. All things I will happily take duplicates of!

        • Ooo, I’m loving your selections Shakira! A box filled with these items would be a home run in my book!

        • Yeah I would get this in a heartbeat if it had more of December’s cookie mix in it LOL

        • That sounds so good. I love the shower oil and I didn’t care for the makeup either!

  39. Will these boxes only be available today? My payday isn’t until the 15th! 🙁 And I love me some PSMH!

    Thanks so much, ladies!

  40. Gosh the mysteryboxes get me everytime but i ended up buying a home box for myself last time and made sure I said it and I still ended up with another mysterybox that was picked threw. I can’t take another umbrella or stars or wire baskets or games.

  41. I’m pacing myself, so I just ordered the Girl’s Night In. I don’t want to blow all my money right away. Just in case. Lol.

  42. Why am I thinking about ordering one of each? I am sorry to be a misery-guts, but after the last mystery box shambles, I believe that PopSugar hates me but loves my money. On the bright side, I just talked myself out of these boxes.
    I really, really hope that I totally regret this decision, and that everyone LOVES their boxes. I also hope they don’t include one of those Baublebar snowfall necklaces (if you want one…I’ll throw it into a swap for free).

    • I know it! I’m in the same boat. I want to be happy for this deal, but honestly with the BTBF deals, the monthly boxes break down to less than this, and at least then we know it will be different stuff. I’m always burned by mystery boxes, but ughhhh if they had another Goldfaden peel or Tribe Alive clutch, I would be bummed if I missed out…

      • Yes and no…some of PopSugar’s stuff is lovely (like the Vanilla body oil). The necklace…not so much (but I don’t want to totally dis it because I know that some people will totally rock it, but not me).
        If you are new to PS, it wouldn’t be a total stretch to get both boxes. I have a couple of discount subs to PS, plus I had a terrible experience with their last mystery box, so I won’t be getting these.
        You never know…PS might have put some effort into these boxes to try and make up for the last mystery box debacle.

    • I agree but I did get the night in box! I’m hoping and praying for no bingo game!!

      • I have to laugh when people mention the bingo game…I absolutely love bingo. However, none of my friends do, so I would be playing by myself.

  43. This is going to be a very expensive day.

    Not complaining.

  44. Yay! Got one of each – such an addict!!

    Thanks for putting this all together, btw!

  45. Ordered a girls night in, but debating about grabbing the other as well. But there’s more offers from other boxes coming soon! So excited!!!!
    Thanks Liz and My Subscription Addiction!!!! You guys rock! 😍

  46. I really want the girls night in box, but not sure it’ll be things I’ll use….I’ll wait til tonight, and if they’re still available, I might bite.

  47. I miss so excited! I ordered one of each!!!

    • So excited I can’t spell “I’m”. Lol

    • Me too. I am so excited!

  48. Grabbed one of each….really hoping for some of the newer products and not only the crap that was in the 75% off sale….

  49. Ooh, girls night in sounds fun!

  50. Thank you! Ordered one of each! So excited!

    • YAY!! 🎉

    • Me too! These sound like fun. I debated on getting two of the night-in boxes because that’s more my speed, but decided adding a little sparkle might be nice 🙂

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!