Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I just send an email to unsubscribe. Will I receive a March box? If they reply me late, then I will still receive a March box?
Reply
Jackie
They usually reply fairly quickly for cancellation. You should be good.
Reply
Patty
go ahead and remove your credit card information from their website, so they can’t charge if you are wanting to totally cancel.
I just sent them an email informing them that their lack of customer service and communication is the reason I want to be removed from the wait list. I can handle a wait, I waited a LONG time for Sephora, but I will not give money to a company that has no respect for the customers.
It is heart-wrenching because Boxycharm is one of the best products in the sub game, but I won’t reward their actions with my hard earned money, maybe if enough people cancel they’ll get their act together.
Joan
I like the colors, but can’t stand all that shimmer and glitter. I live in a small, rural town, and would look absolutely ridiculous wearing that here.
Reply
Jackie
Pretty sure this is a guaranteed item. Just saw gabby using it in a Snapchat on someone and dupethat said it would be in Marchs box!! So excited and cannot wait for more spoilersss!!! I’ve been stalking this page multiple times a day waiting lol!
Reply
L
Not excited about these colors… too bad its not purples or blues or even pinks or golds or silvers…
Reply
Brit
This is a $45 palette on pre-sale for 30 bucks. I’m ecstatic that we’really getting an item that is BRAND new, instead of something being discontinued.
This is my 5th month with boxy…and I have zero excuse for having the same eyeshadow on everyday. I’m glad it’s different colors than a typical subscription would send out, because I know I wouldn’t have the balls to spend 30 or 45 on these colors.
Reply
Amy
Does anyone have a preference for Boxycharm over Glossybox? I’ve read about these two subs but wanted to know if anyone could weigh in. They both look good.
Reply
Jackie
I glossybox for about 3 months before I cancelled. I prefer boxycharm over glossy box anyday. Now I only have ipsy and boxycharm but it’s all a matter of preference.
Reply
Jackie
Dang where’s some more spoilers? This time last month we had like 3 and we only have 1 “possible” one so far lol. I’m stoked for this eye shadow trio!
Reply
Gina
I know right. I’ve been coming back everyday for a week to see what else.
Urrrrrrg.
Reply
ML
Yes I can’t wait either 🙂
Reply
Siren
I love the look of those colors but in reality I never wear anything with sparkle or shimmer. I’d need a glitter glue for starters, and it has been on my wishlist for a while so maybe I’ll try something new when this box arrives? Who knows? 🙂 If not, my niece will love it.
Reply
Lolo2182
Hey! These are my pressed pigments. No need for glitter glue of any sort. A good eyeshadow primer and you’ll be all set just like with any eyeshadow! 🙂
Reply
Paula
YAY!!!! Love that green and gold! I wear a lot of camo where I live and this is so much prettier than brown!
Reply
Brittny
Dupe that confirmed this is one of the items c ok ming in march!
Reply
Brittny
**coming
Reply
Aimee
BoxyCharm has to please a whole melting pot of beautiful ladies of every wonderful race, hair color, texture & same with skin needs. You pay $21 dollars give or take the plan your on and receive at least 5X your investment. I get things that are simply not made for my hair, skin or nail preference. There is someone in your life you can share the love with by passing it on. Life’s way too short to complain. <3
Reply
Tania Williams
Yes!! Exactly what I think. It’s not just about us as INDIVIDUALS, BoxyCharm has to think about a diverse community of women and men and their different likes, needs and expectations. They cannot possibly please every single one of us. Its pretty simple if a subscriber does not like an item they have two options: simply give it away there are plenty of people that will want it or Cancel the subs. There is Zero need to complain.
Reply
Jackie
Well said. I’ve been trying to come up with a comment that says what you just said only everything I was going to write sounded rude and I knew id get hate for it because my thoughts every time I see someone complaining is “why complain? You pay $21 for a box that retails for at least 5 times the price you pay. BoxyCharm can’t please everybody so either quit complaining and give the item to someone who would like it, or unsubscribe so you have nothing to complain about. Simple as that”. But you said it much nicer lol!
Nicole
I think this is the best and most well put comment ever!
These three shades are perfect accent shades. Do a more neutral smokey eye and then pop the purple on the outer edge, a halo eye look with matte plums or browns and put that bronze on the center lid, or the green just on the bottom lash line. I am excited to get these beauties!! 🙂
Reply
Karen
Aimee — excellent commentary. The cost of $21 is what the agreement is, and one or two of the products combined always cover the cost of the box. It is an adventure of learning new brands and products and getting some we know at a bargain price. I appreciate the adventure — and when I don’t, I can cancel. It’s always lovely to hear people voice enjoyment and appreciation. Those who earnestly feel their complaints are justified can be lucky enough to cancel.
Reply
Marie
Love! I think they’re pretty.
Reply
Jennifer
This is only one product. What if all the others products in the March box blow the doors off of these shadows? It’s hard to judge the whole box just because of one thing. There could be way more fabulous things included as well..
I love all the variations. That’s what makes Boxycharm so exciting to everyone 💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻
Reply
Mel
I’m so excited! The colors are so pretty and pigmented.
Reply
Sheila
Just a suggestion for those that say they dont and wont use the colors in the naked palett, if u go and watch some of these you tubers apply eye shadows u wouldn’t believe how they can take a color u wouldn’t normally wear and make it look so pretty. I watch shaexoxo, Kathleen Lights and few others. It’s just an idea, but I’ve learned from watching these ladies.
Reply
Michelle
Gorgeous!! So glad its not neutral sick of neutrals. I get that many like that but here’s something for us girls who want some color. I’m 56 and if I want sparkle I wear sparkle. There are no rules and if there are I’m up for breaking them. Thank goodness we don’t all look a like.
Reply
Nancy
Okay..here goes…I am on the waitlist since 2/5. Hopefully will be off soon, as I love the February box. Wondering if there are any other ladies out there who like me loves make up but being older cannot wear the glitters and shimmers that seem to be everywhere. Would love to find a beauty box with make up and skincare even haircare for us mature gals…just sayin…
Reply
Toni
I’m 54 ,but I love sparkles and shimmers there is a way to wear them tastefully .Watch some videos that are out there on u-tube you will be amazed at what you can learn from these ladies.
Toni
We could be besties I feel the same way about my sparkle .Who made these rules anyway? But I’ve never been one to follow the rules
Reply
Julie B.
I agree with Michelle! I was so boring when I was younger wearing the same old makeup shades, so now I enjoy trying lots of different looks. Sure I couldn’t pull off the purple lipstick, and lots of blush makes me look ridiculous but eyeshadows are fun. Even as a crease accent or undereye pop of color. Can’t wait!
Reply
Toni
I love purple lipstick ,always have always will!.Now there have been some shades I just Rock around the house in
Jex
Man I can’t wait to get off the wait list. I’d be happy to try these out.
Reply
lindsey
I’ve been with boxy for about 2 years…. people always complain when we get palettes full of neutrals and want boxy to try something “more fun”. Then they do and people complain…. Guys its one spoiler for one month. There will never be a subscription full of everything you love every month. Personally, I love that it pushes us out of our comfort zone! If you don’t like it, pass it along to someone who will. We know the rest of the contents will have more value than the $21 cost 🙂
Reply
Toni
Those colors are beautiful so different than anything I have .I hope we get them I’d love to use them.I guess it’s true different strokes for different folks!
Reply
Rachel
I subscribed for the Jan. box. I was so hoping to get it and then the Feb. box too, but I am still waitlisted. That shadow is far too shimmery for my 40 yr old eyelids! Maybe one of my nieces will want it though…
Reply
Rebecca
Aww! I’m 40 and I’m up for it! I’m not one to go all wild now, but hey, these are great colors and can be used with all the neutrals if you want. I know you can pull these off and look great doing it. These look shimmery not glittery to me but that’s just me. A brush stroke is different than a finger swatch tho😉
Reply
Paula
Whaaaaa????? I’m 47 and loving this. I don’t do shimmer or sparkle from eyebrow to lash line but matte transition and crease with a pop of shimmer or sparkle on the center of the movable lid is soooooo pretty!!!
Reply
Cassie
For those who do not like the colors, remember that finger swatches are always more opaque than using a brush and applying to your eyes. These might actually look better and/or more flattering when applied to the eyes and well blended. Just trying to be positive! 🙂
Reply
Deanne
Great comment 🙂
Reply
wendy
I understand for those who like different and colors, but this box is sent to a variety of people, so for that reason I appreciate neutrals. It’s something everyone can wear. I am not a fan of these colors at all personally. They look very cheap to me and clownish. I will be cancelling unless something else shows up as a spoiler.
Reply
Lala00
They should seriously block people that unsubscribe for a pre-set time period, due to one product they don’t like the look of only to resubscribe in two months again.
Reply
Toni
I personally signed up for subscription boxes to try new things and learn new tricks .I love different color’s besides Browns all the time .These color’s are sparkly abd beautiful .And even if I didn’t like them someone I know would love to have them
Jillian
I’m not in love with these shadows. It’s partially the colors and partially the extreme shimmer. It’s overwhelming. There’s glitter everywhere. I hope it’s just the lighting.
I’m worried that this product is going the same route as the Ofra lipstick from a few months ago. Love Ofra, but that color was insanely unflattering on me. Great product, but a really difficult to wear color.
Reply
Jackie
Those shadow swatches did not make all that glitter on her hand. If you saw her Snapchat when this was done, she had been swatching other shadows and that’s where all the glitter came from.
Reply
June
I can see myself trying these colors as accents. I would use a neutral base and then line or accent my eyes with one of these bold and beautiful colors! Looks like fun to me!
Reply
viola
cant wait!!!! have been waitlisted since January and they said in an email that my subscription starts march!!!
Reply
Candy
thats awesome, i was waitlisted in january as well. so i am crossing my fingers for march. i havent received an email yet though? of course since january and february’s boxes were so good. guaranteed my first box is sure to be a dud.
Reply
April W
I actually like these colors. Don’t see anything wrong with them. I would love to try them out! Very excited. I love Boxycharm!!!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.