MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Pusheen Box Fall 2016 Subscription Box Review


Pusheen Box is a quarterly subscription box full of cute Pusheen things! Every Pusheen Box will have a curated assortment of mystery items with a total retail value of over $100. Most of the items inside are exclusive to the box and can’t be found anywhere else. The boxes may also include rare first edition items before they are released in stores!


This box was sent to us for review purposes. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)


The box itself is always amazing. (It’s sent with an outer plastic wrap so that it arrives in pristine cute condition!)


The Subscription Box: Pusheen Box

The Cost: $43.95 + $6 US Shipping

The Products: a mystery selection of Pusheen clothing, accessories, electronics, toys, stationery and more!

Ships to: Worldwide (shipping varies based on country)

Check out all our Pusheen Box reviews and the Kawaii Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wish list!


Each box includes an info card that lists the contents:


Now, onto all the adorableness!


Bat Pusheen Vinyl Figure

Each Pusheen box comes with an exclusive Pusheen figure, and for the fall box, we get a Halloween Bat Pusheen!


This pink, purple and orange figure has an 8-inch wingspan! (One head’s up – the rounded base makes this little cat difficult to stand on its own, so you may want to help it stay steady with a piece of paper or tac.)


Pusheen Pumpkin Scented Air Freshener


What a cute little air freshener! (I’m doing my best not to use the word cute in every sentence for this review, but it’s a struggle.)

The scent is classic fall – it has a pumpkin spice and apple pie vibe!


Pusheen Holographic Notebook

This notebook has a holographic design to make it look like the leaves are falling on Pusheen!


It’s lined, with a pink back cover:


And there’s a perfect accessory to go with it:


Pusheen Pen

This pen has a removable Pusheen charm that can also double as a zipper pull or cell phone charm, too!


Pusheen Tea Cup Set

It’s almost impossible to pick the cutest item in this box, but this tea cup set definitely gets high marks!

The cup is Pusheen surrounded by apples, and then the saucer has the pie crust:


(FYI – this set is hand wash only.)


Pusheen Coaster Set

This set is similar to the coaster set in the Summer Nick Box. The material is a flexible vinyl, and each one has a raised edge to prevent spilling:


These each measure about 5 inches in length (the purple one is a little longer).



(I think the orange one is my favorite!)


Pusheen Sticky Notes


Cutest. Post-Its. Ever!


I want to use these all the time, but I also never want to use them so that I always have them. What adorable little sticky notes!


Pusheen Ears & Tail Costume Set

I love that they included a Halloween costume! This set has two plush ears (they are attached with hair barrettes) and a clip-on tail!


Pusheen Sweatshirt

This crew-neck sweatshirt is 60% Cotton, 40% Poly and has a medium weight. I was sent an XL, which is a little big on me, but considering this is my new at-home cozy sweatshirt, oversized is totally fine!

Here it is on with the Pusheen cat ears (and the Pusheen sunglasses from the Summer Box):


Verdict: I feel confident in saying that Pusheen Box is the cutest subscription box that ever existed. Every single item in this box always makes me happy, and it’s a hit with anyone I ever show it to (whether or not they’ve heard of Pusheen before!)  It’s tough to put a retail value on this box since everything is exclusive, but if you just look at the cost per item for subscribers ($5.55) I think the value is incredible. 

What is your favorite item from the Fall 2016 Pusheen Box?

Pusheen Box

How do subscribers rate Pusheen Box?

per quarter
Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about Pusheen Box!

Enable notifications () to get the latest Pusheen Box spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Pusheen Box Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Kids, Subscription Boxes for Women, UK Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: Pusheen Box | 58 comments

Comments (58)

  1. Liz , you look as cute as pusheen! I love this box and this subscription. I always feel like I am getting my money’s worth and well I do hoard the cuteness. LOL
    I didn’t get a card either so that is interesting. For the summer box, I am actually planning on taking the glasses and getting my prescription in them so I can wear them next summer.
    I am really surprised by the lack of customer service I am hearing. I had a billing issue, and they were very quick to respond and very nice to deal with. I hope you all get your replacement items!

  2. The cup I got has QUALITY ISSUE, I emailed [email protected], but was told they have no extra cups for exchange and they wouldn’t do anything for this.

    • How long did it take them to reply to you? I emailed a week ago, but I have received no reply. I’m seeing several posts that they don’t have stock to send replacements, so I’m going to proceed through Paypal, but I wish I could have worked it out in a less official way.

      • About 2 days.
        Though I like other stuff in the box, but their customer service is way too bad…Thinking about if more quality issue in follow box…….

  3. Hi Pusheen fans 🙂

    Does anyone have a contact number for the Pusheen Customer Service? I emailed them a few days ago about my defective saucer from the mug and saucer set and have yet to hear back from them. Thanks!

    • Same here!!!!!!
      They actually replied me, told me they have nothing to do with it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

      • They said they aren’t responsible for sending out defective and damaged merchandise?

      • WOW!! This is very disappointing to read. This is not a cheap box and the fact that they will not take ownership of defective items, well where does that leave us?! Also, the fact that they do not have a customer service number is unprofessional in my opinion.

        **UPDATE – As I wrote the above I received a FB reply saying that they are making replacements and I am on the list to receive a replacement saucer. It will be a few weeks.

      • That’s good to hear. I have several defective items, and I still haven’t received a response.

      • Lisa, can you confirm that you are getting a replacement? I was told that any claims about replacements being given to anyone are false! Have you received official confirmation that you are getting a replacement?

  4. Your review is spot on. I too want to use the post it notes for everything and also nothing so they can be everywhere but so that I can have them forever. I can’t even handle the cuteness!!

    • Haha this box is cuteness-overload! 🙂

  5. It arrived today and am so thrilled – the shirt fits with room to spare! Everything is in pristine condition and, for the first time, I’ll use it all. I know some are disappointed with the box this quarter but I’m in Pusheen heaven!

  6. My tea cup have a scratch mark on the apple when I open it X(

    • Me too, mine has several black spots. I emailed them and they said they wouldn’t do anything for it.

  7. This is their best box yet, and that’s saying a lot! Liz you look sooo cute!

    • Haha, thanks Anna! 🙂 (And agree – I think this is the best box ever!)

  8. This is seriously my favorite box I’m getting right now! Everything in it is so cute and I feel like it’s really worth the money!

    • Yay! So glad you love it, too! I’m so impressed with all the value they pack into this box!

  9. This is, hands down, my favorite Pusheen box so far. I am in total obsession with every single item! So excited for mine to come in the mail today! On pins and needles for the mailman to get here!

    And I am VERY excited to now have a Halloween costume! Lol! I actually have a Pusheen hoodie that I can wear with the ears & tail!

    • OMG that Pusheen hoodie sounds awesome!!

      • It IS awesome! It has a hood with ears & a pusheen face. The rest of the hoodie is her “body”. It’s a zipper hoodie & super soft. It even had a little tail (which I had to remove, sadly, b/c it pressed into the bad part of my back when I sat down…). My husband got it for me for Christmas last year! I’ll definitely be wearing it with the ears/tail. I wish I could post a pic here for everyone!

  10. I just got mine and everything is so cute! I love everything but my coasters and teacup are damaged. The teacup and plate have places on it where it looks like the design wore off and my coasters were stuck together so the stamp on the back of the coasters actually imprinted onto the front. And the stamp is orange so there’s orange writing all over Pusheens body. I’m pretty disappointed in that.

    • Same. I emailed them, but I haven’t heard back. I hope they can replace the damaged/defective items.

      • Hi, have you heard back from them yet? I emailed about my defective mug and saucer but have not heard back. Does anyone have a contact number? Thanks!

      • No, I haven’t. I checked my mug after reading comments here, and it is also messed up. So is the notebook (pages are cut wrong). I ended up sending a message through Paypal today. I’ll escalate it if they don’t reply by Monday.

      • oh PayPal, good idea! Didn’t think of that 🙂 Thanks (:

      • No problem. I hope they can resolve this b/c these were supposed to be gifts. Sadly, I won’t be subbing to this box again.

      • I hear you, the Tea Cup Set was a gift for my niece. For now I will keep the subscription because I love the other items and was able to make some money back on the sweatshirt that didn’t fit me. I’m concerned with the lack of Customer Service and hopefully this doesn’t become an issue.

    • SAME!!
      They replied me said they have nothing to do.
      I am also trying to dispute this through paypal.

      • I’ve sent them three emails and a social media message, but they haven’t replied to me at all. I was asking for replacements, but I guess I’ll just have to escalate the Paypal claim. Super bummed.

    • I received my teacup replacement out of the blue today!

  11. Got my box today! It’s my first subscription box ever. I didn’t get the info card with the contents… is the card for reviewers only?
    VERY happy with my sweatshirt. I’m so happy they offered 3XL

    • Does it run small? I got an XL but now I’m wondering should I have gotten a 2XL :/ I’ll be so sad if I can’t wear mine

      • I find the shirt runs a little big. I’m a women’s 12 top with broad shoulders and received a medium top. It fits great with room to spare and I can comfortably wear a tee beneath it.

      • Unfortunately my sweatshirt was too snug, it fit but I like my clothes a bit more loose. I’m sad but at the same time I live in Miami and won’t get many chances to wear it. I’ve listed my 3XL sweatshirt on eBay, if anyone is looking for one. I typically wear 4X but some places like Torrid I wear a 3X.
        Also, my saucer came damaged. Hope they can replace it, since this was going to be a gift.
        Still super happy that I purchased the box and will keep subscribing.

    • That card is for all subscribers, it must have missed your box in packing. Sorry! 🙁

      Glad you are happy with the sweatshirt – what a fab first subscription box!

      • Hi, No biggie but I didn’t get the card either.

      • Yeah I didn’t get the card either, the box was damaged, and my teacup was scratched in multiple places and the saucer has a weird black smudge I can’t remove. :/ I had the worst luck time!

  12. SQUEEEEEEEEEE!!!! ‘Nuff said!

  13. Adorable box!!!

    (Off topic, the forum is not working for me today—it says “non-existent domain” when I’m supposed to be on the forum.) 🙁

  14. I have serious FOMO – everything is so cute but most of it is also useful! I need some Pusheen office supplies in my life pronto!

    • The fact that you can actually use most everything is definitely what caused me to finally break down and get the subscription. I’ve seen so many boxes where I just wasn’t sure what I’d do with half the items, but none of the Pusheen boxes have been that way- at least for me.

  15. Seriously having fomo. Liz tou look so darn Cute!

  16. “I want to use these all the time, but I also never want to use them so that I always have them.”
    best quote ever !!

    • OMG, this is how I feel about so many things, especially this Pusheen stuff! This is what scares me as a new subscriber… I will have to fight the urge to hoard everything and not use it because it’s “too cute!”

      • I kind of want to put it all in a basket, so I can just look at it and enjoy the cuteness every day. Lol. I want to use every item, but don’t want to, b/c running out of those Post Its would make me so darn sad. Ugh! The dilemma & struggle is real, people!

  17. Awesome hair day Liz! My box arrives Monday and I can’t wait to see it all in person.

    • 🙂 Thanks, Kristin!

  18. I mean, seriously. So. Frigging. CUTE. 😀

    • Haha YES! The amount of cuteness they fit into one box is outstanding! 🙂

  19. Well if that’s what an xl looks like on you, a large is neeeeeever going to for me. whoops

    • I am an adidas size m, Elizabeth and clarke size 10 and got the medium. It is big. Sleeves are long. I rather have it big than small, I am sure it will shrink in the dryer. This is my third box and all the items are just too cute.

    • Haha, I had the same thought! I ordered an XL and I am considerably more….Pusheen-shaped than Liz. 😉 Fingers crossed it fits, because that’s my favorite thing! 🙂

      • LOL. I love the sweatshirt SO MUCH. I am so sad that my daughter ordered a small and it is for her and not me! 🙂

      • LOL @ Pusheen shaped!!! I’m a size 18 and the XL is really baggy on me, so hopefully it fits you as well!

      • The sweatshirt is definitely more of a unisex sizing than women’s. I freaked a bit when I got mine b/c I wear a medium in unisex sizes & that’s what I ordered, but I thought this might be women’s sizes, & a medium definitely would NOT have fit me. The unisex medium fits peffect, however, so I’m very happy AND relieved.

  20. OMG I can’t wait to get mine!! I love every single thing in this box!!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.