This is the last day to grab a POPSUGAR mystery box!
The Box: POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box
The Cost: $24.95
The Products: For a limited time, you can treat yourself to $125+ worth of mysterious favorites from past Must Have boxes. Each All-Star Mystery Box contains 7 products.
Are you grabbing a box? (Or more than one?) Check out my POPSUGAR Must Have Box reviews to see the types of items that might be included.
223 comments
Connie
So disappointed, I ordered 2 mystery boxes which were delivered today. They are identical. What a waste of money.
ReplyJenny
Anybody get theirs today and care to post the contents?
ReplyKat
I hated my box I thought it was supposed to be “must haves” I was sooooo disapointed- a crap scarf from Michael stars- if that thing cost a dollar to make I would be shocked 48 dollars online I don’t think anyone would buy this! A boring charger- who has not already got two or three, online it was in rose old which would have made it more interesting. But at 30.00 I don’t think so. a book I already bought on Amazon so that was a waste of 11.00. Some pretzels- small bag- I could get those at the grocery store… Some Christian lacroix sticky notes- really guys that’s not even trying here!!! A heart beat necklace in rose gold-who’s heartbeat is that anyways. And some little bathsoap. I’m sooo bummed I was reAlly looking forward to something cool. I feel like I wasted my money I will not buy from them again!
ReplyCaligirl
I got mine today! Happy dance.
Chalkboard candle smells amazing
Powergloss universal charger
Cheers bottle opener
Skinny scarf
Swing design jewelry box
Spongology milk & honey
Dream pretzels
Love love
ReplyCMB
Hey! I haven’t gotten mine yet (not till Thursday, booo), but there’s a whole thread with spoilers and people commenting on what they received!
https://www.mysubscriptionaddiction.com/2016/10/popsugar-must-have-all-star-mystery-box-reveals-giveaway.html
ReplyMarie
Ordered two, coming from NY. Will be delivered today (Central Florida). Both started at 6.2 lbs, one has now dropped to 4.9. Most likely the two variations that have been discussed. I will post if anything changes. Sorry to those who are receiving tons of duplicates 🙁
ReplyTeresa k
I am in Central Florida also, 2 boxes coming from NY, but mine won’t be delivered until tomorrow. This morning I saw the adjustment of delivery date and weight (originally both boxes showed 6.2 lbs and Saturday delivery). Fingers crossed that we aren’t getting duplicate boxes.
ReplyColleen
Good morning everyone! Has anyone else reached out to Popsugar to express frustration over their failure to honor their advertised word? If no one communiques to them, they can’t correct their issues. Like so many, I ordered multiple boxes, I knew it was possible I’d get dups, but didn’t think it would be the whole box. I’d be ok if I got a duplicate box if I was alone, but ALL of us being sent duplicate boxes?!!! They succeeded last time, so what happened?
I’ve emailed them my concerns and requested they consider how they can remedy this mess. I encourage others to do the same, they need to hear from all of us.
ReplyErinne
Do you have a direct email for them or just through support on the website? I will certainly write them if my 2 boxes are identical
ReplyColleen
Hi! I just submitted mine to the email link at the very bottom of their page. I chose ‘other’ as my reason for contact. If I should send it somewhere else as well, please let me know.
Thanks!
Cat
Why haven’t we all just donated the Bingo games to assisted living facilities/nursing homes etc by now? I’m getting two 6.2 pound boxes out of New York so now I will have 4 Bingo games if all proves right prediction wise. I’m just going to donate them all to one of the smaller places around here if that’s what I end up with. The cards have huge numbers if I recall from box? I never opened.
ReplyWendy
I bought 3 at the same time (as I read that Popsugar said they would vary the boxes). All 3 are coming from Gilroy CA and as of Sunday night have left Sacramento. They are due on Thursday. Also, all 3 have the same shipping weights and dimensions:
Weight 3.5 lbs / 1.59 kgs
Dimensions 11x11x11 in.
As I’m likely getting 3 identical boxes, I’m dying to find out any spoilers! Also – I’m never buying more than 1 mystery box again.
Replysher_w
Likewise. I ordered three boxes, two look like duplicates, don’t think I’ll order more than 1 again.
ReplyLiz
ditto really frustrated even at a discount
I can’t gift the exact same items to multiple people at some point that gets very tacky
Ann
I ordered 5 boxes, and every. single. one. is 2.1 pounds with 11x8x4 dimension. Never again, Popsugar. Very unhappy.
ReplyErinne
Both of mine are being delivered tomorrow. Both out of NY. 6.2 & 6.3 pounds. Both 14x10x5. I’ll let you know what the contents are when I receive them. Wish they are different but not hopeful.
ReplyJen
Mine is also 6.3lbs and has the same dimensions, I’m excited to see what you get !
ReplyStacey
I have two coming from NY. Started at 6.2 lbs, now at 2 lbs. I’m guessing they are the same and if so, I would love to trade. Arriving tomorrow. Excited!
ReplyTS
Mine says 3.5 lbs and doesn’t say from where or the dimensions. I hope it’s good!
ReplyKarly
I ordered two boxes, one on the the 6th, the second on the 14th. I live in California and my first box is coming from gilroy, ca at 3.5 lbs, the second from NY at 6.2 lbs. I hope that’s a good indicator it’s two different boxes. Fingers crossed!
ReplyMisti
Both my boxes are 3.5lbs. Please don’t be the same box!!!!
ReplyDinielle Nunez
I just got my email today, but my tracking said it shipped friday 10/14! So hoping it gets here fast! Coming from Gilroy, Ca and i am also in Ca.
3.5 lbs! I’ll report back when I get it 🙂 So excited!!
ReplyColleen
I can see the swap site going crazy really soon. Popsugar is going to have much more of a challenge offloading these next time. I doubt we’ll be ordering 2-6 boxes again! Super thankful I didn’t order more than my 2. I was really hoping the candle (that melted during summer) was going to be in there again. I love the box it was in. Guess I’m headed to look for one available to swap.
ReplyErinne
I had gotten the melted candle last time. The box is cute but my candle was a mess. They sent me out a 2nd mystery box (no candle) to make up for the melted candle fiasco. That was nice of them. I hope I don’t get a candle this time.
ReplyAndrea
Has anyone received a box that originated in California? The suspense is killing me!
ReplyGabriela
My box coming from CA has 11x11x11 listed as dimensions. No idea what to expect.
ReplyBostKim
Well, my 2 boxes showed up as expected… aaaand… they’re identical 🙁 super disappointed.
they both had:
michael stars skinny scarf (now I have 3. yay)
candle (at least they’re two different scents)
cargo blush
gluten free bites
powergloss charger
lacroix post it notes
texturizing spray.
I would have been happy with all of this if I had only 1 of everything.
ReplyTS
This sounds like a good box, I’d be happy to get this one! What was the weight of yours?
ReplyBostKim
Oh, and the weight started out as 6.something and then dropped to 2.1 along the way…
BostKim
Yeah I was disappointed at first but then I realized if I had to get double stuff, this is probably a good box to get… 🙂
Kerri
That’s what I expected as well. Mine will be here by Friday. 🙁
Replychillybeans
Im surprised-last time they did a good job of sending different boxes to the people who had ordered more than one it seemed?
ReplyZo
This is interesting – I ordered 3 boxes (coming from NY). All were showing 6.2 but then two of them changed to 6.3 with one still at 6.2. However, all 3 are showing different size boxes.
Box 1 is 6.3 = 14x9x5
Box 2 is 6.2 = 13x10x5
Box 3 is 6.3 = 13x9x5
Hmm, perhaps I am getting 3 different boxes after all. will be here Thursday but I’m hoping before then as they are in a post office maybe 15 miles away.
ReplyJenny
How do you find the box measurements?
ReplyMichelle
I ordered 3 boxes at the same time. It looks like all 3 boxes are 2.1 pounds respectively and are coming from NY. The interesting thing is that one box is scheduled for delivery tomorrow and two won’t be here until Friday (even though all 3 were ordered at the same time). Fingers crossed that the boxes are different. Can’t wait to see pictures of what people have already received.
ReplyAli
Mine updated to Wednesday delivery (was Saturday), three boxes are 6.2 and 13x13x13
One box is 4.8 and 12x12x12, not sure how accurate the measurements are. I am thankful at least one box is different or fingers crossed it is!
ReplyKerri
I have 2 boxes coming from NY. I’m in Mass, they are in CT. right now. They were supposed to be here Friday.
How do you check the sizes of the boxes? Mine are still at 6.2
ReplyCMB
It should be right below the weight – here’s a paste of one of mine (not including ref#):
Service FedEx SmartPost
Reference
Weight 2.1 lbs / 0.95 kgs
Dimensions 12x7x4 in.
Total pieces 1
CMB
I refuse to get my hopes up about dimensions being slightly different, lol.
Good call checking measurements! I just checked and both of mine are 2.1lb boxes, but one is 12x7x4, the other is 11x7x4 🙂
I’m thinking it’s just a mistake by fedex, that way I won’t be disappointed if/when they’re the same! I think I’d be fine with 2 candles, 2 post-it pads, 2 chargers…most of the items are giftable if I don’t keep them!
ReplyErinne
So I have 2 boxes that started at 6.2 pounds each. Now one has changed to 6.3 pounds. Both are 14x10x5. My thought is that I got duplicate boxes and the scale at FedEx was wrong. I’m sad. I don’t want doubles.
ReplyDeb
Mine just updated and both say 4.8 lbs(Were 6.2 coming from NY) and will be here on the 20th instead of the 24!…Gee…I hope that it’s a good sign!!
ReplyJoanne
Mine should show up today when I get home from work. Tracking says 2.2pounds…. don’t know if that is a good thing or not…. (no bingo no bingo!)
Replychillybeans
You can tell from the size of the box too-under dimensions. Mine is 12x8x4-no bingo!
glenda
Ha! Mine just went from 6.2 to 2.2 and being delivered this Wednesday (instead of Friday).
ReplyAli
I’m now curious if anyone, that ordered more than one box, got different boxes. Or all the same…I’m a little disappointed considering last time I did have different boxes, and it was great! Deal or not, chance or not, I was holding this go around to the last ones.
Don’t think I’ll be ordering 4 if they do it again.
ReplyClaudia
Mine just showed up and I can’t find the weight. Skinny scarf, Oribe dry spray,. Charger, Christian LaCroix post its, cargo blush, candle, skinny scarf and gluten free bites. I’m happy!
ReplyDeb
I’d be good with that!
ReplyCMB
You find it by clicking on the tracking number that they emailed to you ….it will be at the bottom of the FedEx page.
ReplyBostKim
I love seeing the box content updates starting! My two boxes are supposed to be delivered today. From what I’ve seen so far, my wish list includes:
Homestead candle
Universal Charger
I’d be ok with the LaCroix post it notes
Cargo blush
Fig & Grapefruit bubble bath
Can’t wait to see what others get!
ReplyJess
I got this too. This is my first experience with popsugar must have abs I have to say I am really disappointed. The only thing I find useful is the hair mask. I knew it was a risk but the $20 mystery boxes from the summer seemed pretty good. This box has five useless products- postcards, bingo, chips, post its and bottle opener. They are not even gift able. I also gifted a box and am worried that they are getting the same thing. I just wish there were two items I was happy with, not just one!
ReplyTat
Mine just got here. 6.2 from NY. I got
The Bingo
Gold plated church key
Universal charger
post cards
Lacroix post em
fig and grapefruit bubble bath
ReplyKelly
Tat,
Your box includes the items listed above and a bag of chips and the Briogeo hair mask? Sounds identical to Cindy’s below except you included a church key. What in the heck is a church key?
ReplyTat
A church key is an old fashioned slang term for beer bottle opener. The term is still used today, especially in the min-West. Sorry for the confusion…
Tat
…sigh. Also got a bag of Joe’s chips and the full sized hair mask…
ReplyDayan
Boxes showed up unexpectedly today… Unfortunately, I got 2 identical boxes… super bummed…
Same as Cindy and Tat. I really don’t need more bingo games…
Well, at least some of the small items are pretty good gifts actually (try to think positively after knowing I’ll get the least favorite sephora box and missed out on target baby box…)
BostKim
I hope I get the charger…
ReplyCindy
My postman just pulled up and my boxes should be in today’s mail!
ReplyJen
Cindy- did you also receive a bottle opener ? It looks someone else had the same box plus a bottle opener and chips. Thank you for sharing what you got ! I think I am getting same and I am happy with it (aside from the bingo). I think post it’s are really cute, I only have one portable charger now so another will br great to have, I’ve tried the bubble bath and hair mask and like both. For only $25 I think this is great deal.
ReplyCindy
Darn! They are both the same (6.2 lbs). And now I own FOUR bingo games…..the one thing I was really hoping was not in this box.
ReplyErinne
What’s so bad about the bingo? I’m not a regular subscriber, only buy the mystery boxes
Teresa K
Did yours come from NY?
I ordered 2 boxes, each on different days, but both shipped out of NY Friday and both showing 6.2 lbs. set to be delivered on Saturday.
I don’t subscribe, so all will be new to me, but was hoping they would be different boxes like the last time. I ordered 2 the last time on different days and they were both different, only overlap was a magnetic picture frame which I really liked. At least I don’t already have the bingo.
Cindy
The other items in the box:
Christian Lacroix post it notes
Gramr postcard pack
Powergloss Universal charger
Briogeo hair repair mask (full size)
Bubble Elixer Fig and Grapefruit (full size I think)
Anyone exited? Disappointed?
Jen
What else did you get ?!?!?!?!!
Megan
Ahhh! The bingo. Sorry to hear that. I also already have it, and am getting the 6.2 box.
What else was in your box?!
BostKim
Boxes are on their way to local post office… which means if they don’t get there in time for the mail person to deliver them, I can at least pick them up after work. Yay 🙂
Reply
Grow your brand with authentic customer reviews.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.