Posted by on in Featured Review of the Week, POPSUGAR Must Have Box News, Subscription Box News | Tags: | 132 comments

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box – Available Now!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

MH16_MysteryBox_560x_Email (3) (1)

Yay! For the first time ever, POPSUGAR is having a mystery box sale! These boxes are available now through the 6th – or while supplies last. (AKA – they might sell out sooner).

The Box: POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery BoxΒ 

The Cost: $19.95

The Products:Β For a limited time, you can treat yourself to $100+ worth of mysterious favorites from past Must Have boxes for only $19.95! Each All-Star Mystery Box contains at least 6 products.

Are you grabbing a box? (Or more than one?) Check out my POPSUGAR Must Have Box reviews to see the types of items that might be included.


Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. This came at the perfect time!! I wanted the boxycharm box but I only wanted one thing…. I had got popsugar in the past and their boxes are amazing. So I am super excited that it was only $20 for $100 worth of stuff!!!!

  2. Ordered 2 – 1 for me and the other for my daughter as a Christmas gift. Yes, I’m that crazy person who stashes presents throughout the house all year long. Hoping there is variety between the two boxes! Not a regular subscriber so all these items will be new to us.

    • I’m totally that crazy person too!

    • I do the same thing! I save all of the stuff I don’t want from sub boxes in my closet for Christmas. I also buy things for family throughout the year when there are awesome deals (like during these long holiday weekends), then hide it in “The North Pole” (i.e. the top of my closet). Then, I save all of my points from sub boxes & stores until Black Friday, then spoil myself by taking advantage of awesome deals for “free”. πŸ™‚

    • Me, too! It allows me to give more/better gifts, and not be at the mercy of what happens to be in stores in and around December! ?

  3. Got one. I’m telling myself it’s a good way to check them out for less money.

  4. Do you know if products from limited edition boxes will be included as well?

  5. lol I ordered two. I only have June as my past box so anything but June should be a win for me.

    • June was the worst box I’ve received in 3 years almost. The rest of the year has been great, excluding half of March’s items and a couple from May…other wise you’re definitely going to get something you’ll like.

  6. I bit. I don’t sub to the mini box, so any of those items would be nice. I’m hoping for more of the items I’ve used up, like the foot peel or the spongelle. Or snacks! But I wouldn’t turn down an extra Pehr bin.

  7. Do I need this. .. nope. Did I buy one…yep! Something had to fill the target box hole in my heart today.

    • Lol yes! *That’s* the empty feeling I had-lack of Target box! It’s ok, PSMH is there to take my money πŸ™‚

      • I actually set an alarm thinking if I slept in I’d miss the Target box. Around 11 am I realized they weren’t having one, at least not today.

  8. Someone please hold me back. With my luck I would get all perfume, games and tassles.

    • If I get another game or anything tassled I will scream.

      • I know I envision my box having a bingo game, who am I game, salt and pepper shakers, tassel bracelet and necklace, cayenne drink. Lol. I am going to try to stay positive though ?

    • LOL…oh my. I didn’t think about that. I just ordered one because I’ve never wanted to fork over the $ before, but for $20 I figured it was worth a try. I wish for both of us to have a non-smelling, non-gaming tassle free box! πŸ™‚

  9. Not a PS subscriber so this will be all new stuff for me. Hopefully it will be all nice things and not a box full of tassel bracelets and yoga mat spray.

    • Not a subscriber either so I’m excited to see what I’ll get. If the items aren’t my thing I’ll just gift them.

  10. I hope it’s good. Not tassel necklaces and 2016 planners. πŸ˜‰ Guess we’ll find out. Thanks for sharing Liz. Excited!

    • Fingers crossed no tassels!

  11. Couldn’t help it..bought 2…????

  12. Liz- Are items going to be the same in every box?

    • Nevermind, just read the fine print!

  13. Omg I couldn’t resist!! I subbed TO PS from March-May. So I’m hoping it’s none of those lol fingers crossed it’s February’s box!!! Omg that would be so freaking awesomeeee

  14. Bought one for me! I’m glad I didn’t re-subscribe to Boxycharm. That Zpallete was tempting but don’t need it πŸ™‚ So this was a GOOD substitute! I’m not a PopSugar subscriber so this is a good opportunity to try their stuff! ❀️❀️❀️

    • I was thinking the exact same thing! I was going to sub boxycharm for July but wasn’t excited by the full spoilers. I’ve found PopSugar interesting but I don’t want to commit to $40/month.

      • Yay for you too! I didn’t really like anything this month from boxy! And yeah, I don’t want to commit to a $40 a month sub either. Any sub boxes $24 and up, I won’t do! Try to keep them at the $21 max.. πŸ™‚

  15. Argh…I couldn’t resist, ordered one! Hoping it’s not entirely repeats of stuff I already got, but that’s the risk you take. πŸ™‚

  16. Getting 4…1 for me, and the rest will be perfect girlfriend bday gifts!!

    • I did the same! 4 for a happy fourth!!

      • ??????

  17. Just being cautious… Why has Popsugar not posted about this on their Facebook page or sent out an email about this? I also can’t find this box on their website (I can only find it through clicking on the above link).

    • Mine is pending in my bank account and has the same “popsugar must have” info that shows up for my monthly psmh and mini. Not worried.

    • They are sharing this mystery box offer with MSA readers exclusively!! πŸ™‚

      • That’s so awesome… Thanks, Liz!

      • I just saw it advertised on a beauty gwp blog I follow. I wonder if they know it’s only for MSA readers and they shouldn’t be posting it ?

        • Is it stated somewhere that the link may not be shared or that non-MSA readers can’t purchase? Because I don’t see that.

          • You can pass it along as technically anyone could read this page today by random occurrence, Liz just gets the exclusive link to pass on to us! I’ve directed a few people over.

          • No, I don’t see it anywhere either. I just saw Liz say they’re sharing the offer exclusively with MSA readers. I used the link on here so I’m not sure if it works for others too.

        • Ya, I’ve seen a lot blogs advertising this. The honest thing would have been to say they got it from MSA.

      • Yay! MSA rules!

  18. Ordered One!! Does anyone know when these will ship?

    • July 15 was the date that appeared when I placed the order.

      • Ok thanks so much! I was so excited to place the order but I forgot to look when they shipped. I did get my Confirmation Email. Thanks Gloria!

    • It said somewhere along the purchasing process … the 15th I think if I recall correctly

      • Thank You πŸ™‚

  19. I’m not a Popsugar subscriber (I try to stick to beauty-only subs), but this seems like a good opportunity to try it out! The lifestyle items do seem cute, but I like to stick to “consumable” goods that I know will get used up (food items don’t count, since I stay away from those in subs too), so I’m hoping at least 4 or 5/6 items in my box are beauty products!

    • I think they will follow their usual pattern and it will be a mix of products from the boxes and you’ll still get the item from each section, just a mystery which. However, Popsugar’s items tend to swap well so you can always use it for past beauty item swaps or things you’ve been following.

  20. Popsugar gets me! Love this price! Love that it’s mystery items from past boxes!
    Trying to not order more for family members, I know if I do they’ll be hooked too!

    Have they ever done a sale like this before?

    • I reread the post! Lol! First time ever! I guess I just read popsugar, sale, $20. Sold!!! ?

  21. Got two…I haven’t had a sub for almost a year (wow!) so it should mostly be new to me. I figure between two I’ll at least get a few items I like…right? =/

  22. There doesn’t seem to be a Target box so far this month… So funds for this! That’s my story and I’m sticking to it!!?

    • Me too, until Target comes out!!!!

  23. These comments are so funny ! I grabbed one… I haven’t been subbed since February but i am hoping for something good, $20 for 6 items seems like a good deal.

    • Averages out to $3.33 per item, can’t beat that even if you dislike all of it..can be gifted or swapped. PS items tend to swap well (most of them anyhow!).

  24. Thanks for the heads up, hope I get all the stuff I love from the popsugar box. This doesn’t roll into a subscription does it?

    • Nope. One time purchase.

  25. AWESOME Blossom! I’m not a PS subscriber but commonly trade for their stuff. This is a great one time fling to surely grab some neat stuff!

    • AND anything you dislike someone else will likely have on their trade lists since they are popular swap items usually.

      • True that! πŸ™‚ Plus GIFT ALL THE THINGS!
        The one thing I don’t like about FFF is when the logo label their colaborations, but to my knowledge PS doesn’t do that right?

  26. I have only subscribed for a few months. I loved almost everything I’ve received and am so happy to be able to gift at this price. Hoping for items from older boxes that I don’t have for myself! Snagged two.

  27. This a no-brainer in my book at that price!

  28. Snagged 2… Oh jeez… Hope no more surprises today… Seriously considering buying 1 more… Must. Resist. ?

  29. I have every PSMH box plus duplicates of a couple, and I ordered two of these. WHAT IS WRONG WITH ME? I justified it as good gifts. I need help. Sub rehab.

    • Me too! Just spent the last hour reading old reviews to remember what I might get again. I’m ready now!

  30. Couldn’t resist buying one. I figure I can always use the items as gifts.

  31. I can’t bring myself to do it. I hated May and was happy I wasn’t a part of the June box. I don’t want any of that stuff. I had November through May already, so I don’t need more of that stuff, either!

    • I agree…i am thinking a lot of May box stuff

      • I think the worst for me would be extra June except the deodorant wipes from Pacifica! I’m still grabbing two and I’ve been a member since Nov 2013 Lololol.

  32. For $20… I couldn’t resist. It’s probably things I already have (almost for sure) but…

  33. Excited about this!! I bought one. My first popsugar anything so far! I figured you can’t wrong for $20. Fingers crossed we all get amazing boxes! Happy 4th everyone!

  34. No no no. I have shown so much self control this weekend. I am so proud of myself.

  35. Geez, I have no willpower. Darn you Popsugar! πŸ™‚

  36. So much for my lane attempt at No Buy July! Just ordered 3….?

    • Haha ! I tried doing a no buy and I think it lasted about a week ?. I broke it on the customizable Sephora favorites, and now I just grabbed one of these.

    • *lame

  37. Getting one! I don’t subscribe to PS so all of it will be new to me!

  38. Thanks Liz!
    Ended up buying 2… hopefully no duplicates

  39. My practical side says this will all be stuff from unpopular boxes. My mystery loving side says buy 2…I think you know which side won. Also, you can STILL get the CFDA box??

    • Lol my practical side, AKA tight budget, tells me this is PopSugar’s clever way to get rid of their surplus unpopular stock.

  40. Got it πŸ™‚ I don’t sub anymore so I have missed the last year so hopefully this is some of the good stuff I missed!

  41. That took about 10 seconds from clicking on the posting to submitting my credit card number. I’m getting a little too good at spending money on theses boxes.

  42. What to do, what to do…..I wasn’t too fond of either May or June & those are the only boxes I have received from them so far. I’m pushing the button & hoping for something from a different box. Crossing my fingers….

  43. I snagged one but fingers crosed it’s not another may box

  44. done! ordered ! love MSA !

  45. Well that was the easiest decision of the day! Purchased!! Happy July 4th to me ???

  46. I ordered one, sounds like a good fit for me since I canceled my monthly sub in December and I have been getting the special edition boxes only.

  47. Aaaand…. bought.

  48. I also grabbed 2.

  49. Huh.

  50. Thank you ! Today is my birthday so feeling lucky and bought 2.

    • Happy Birthday Connie! How neat to be born on the fourth of July. Have a wonderful fun day. I hope you get awesome items in your boxes ! πŸ™‚

      • Thank you!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!