Posted by on in Featured Review of the Week, Subscription Box News | Tags: | 62 comments

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box – Sale Extended!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

MH16_MysteryBox_560x_Email (3) (1)

Good news – since the POPSUGAR mystery box sale has been such a hit so far, this exclusive deal has been extended to Friday!

The Box: POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box 

The Cost: $19.95

The Products: For a limited time, you can treat yourself to $100+ worth of mysterious favorites from past Must Have boxes for only $19.95! Each All-Star Mystery Box contains at least 6 products.

Are you grabbing a box? (Or more than one?) Check out my POPSUGAR Must Have Box reviews to see the types of items that might be included.


Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I was wondering how do I order more….my friend would like one…As the offer it expired?

    • This was a limited time offer. They may have another sale in the future but you’ll have to wait and see. It would likely include different items though.

  2. Oh, I held out for three whole days … and caved tonight! Haven’t ever gotten a Popsugar box, so should be fun. 🙂

  3. I had to, I just had to. I don’t subscribe to popsugar and tried to resist because I just signed up for the serendipity by LLB but I feel like I just might like this surprise too. Now to stay away from a second one…

  4. Does anyone know the answer to this question: If I order 2 boxes will I receive 2 of the same box or 2 different mystery boxes. I have been trying to reach out to PopSugar but have not been able to get an answer and I would like to purchase the box but want to be sure before I order more than one.

    • If you order two, they may or may not be different. (POPSUGAR isn’t guaranteeing no duplicates if you buy multiple boxes.) Hope that helps!

  5. I ordered one of these the other day and then just ordered another one because apparently I have zero self control and am insane! I was thrilled that the LaRitzy mystery box was sold out and then saw that it came back and thought wouldn’t you rather pay another $5 and get another pop sugar that has more variety and value. What a sucker!

  6. I was totally not going to get in on this and I’m not a POPsugar subscriber, But I am (a Brand new) subscription box addict AND I just came off the swap group waiting list so I figure what can it hurt? I hear the items have a good swap value 😉

    All I needed was a good reason to justify this to myself 😛

  7. I love the idea of this. I know that I love most of the past boxes but it is a complete surprise opening the box. No spoiler to tempt me!!

    • This will be my first time getting a box from Popsugar. I couldn’t resist after the terrible Target boxes this month and since I cancelled my only 2 subscriptions a few months ago ( little bottles were taking over my house lol) I ordered a second box this morning, I’m just hoping they will have different items in them, I would hate to get 2 boxes exactly the same. It seems no one knows for sure? I’m with you Erika, no spoiler needed for me, after reading reviews I’m so excited!

  8. Is anyone else having a hard time ordering this box? I keep trying but when I select Place Order the site starts processing but then it goes back to where i select Place Order and nothing happens. I have checked my banking to make sure they aren’t going through and they aren’t.. I have even tried using a different internet browser to see if that was the problem and no luck… Help!!! lol

    • I haven’t been able to order either! I have tried two different days with different cards and it keeps coming up Technical Error.

    • I was kinda having problems for awhile last night on my phone from home (but I have really bad service there so thought that might be it). But I ordered 2 from home on Monday with no problem, so last night I went back to Liz’s original post about the Mystery Box sale and clicked on the picture there and was able to order with no problems.

    • I had the same issue but then realized I had my cookies disabled. The site didn’t tell me to enable them. Once I did I was able to place the order.

  9. Thanks for posting. Popsugar didn’t email me and I would have been upset to miss this! #FOMO

  10. Sometimes I wish I hadn’t found this site! Actually my husband wishes I hadn’t!
    I ordered one box. I don’t subscribe to popsugar so everything will be new to me.
    I just cancelled birchbox and I’m going to cancel my sephora, so I think I deserve a treat for cancelling. That’s how it works, right?!?

    • Best logic I have heard…I’m teetering between a silver bangle and this box…arrrghhh….

  11. I wish the boxes were labeled a, b, c etc… that way we would be guaranteed a variety. I want to purchase more than one, but I have no idea how each box will vary. Do I just take a risk??? Decisions….decisions. ..

    • That’s why I ordered 2 on Monday and I’m going to order 2 more today or tomorrow. Bc that almost guarantees that I’ll get a little variety right?!? (that’s what I’m telling myself anyways – gotta justify it somehow 😉 )

  12. Shoot….I’m trying to avoid doing this but I know I won’t make it.

    I am hoping if I order 2 they won’t be totally identical. I am also figuring I’ll be getting some sort of water/fruit infuser thing since they still seem to push that a a gift with purchase after about 2 years…LOL.

  13. I keep trying to get one but it comes up ‘Technical Error’ and won’t go through. Tried yesterday and today with two different cards. Guess I am not destined to get one.

  14. Could I just request an entire box of those lemon tea towels?? God, I’m in love with mine. And my mom stole it on the 4th of July, and I’m sure it’s never coming back. I wonder if they are going to include any of the Mini products??

    For real though, lots of gift opportunities. Big wins from the last year:
    Anything BeautyCounter.
    Tea Towel
    That cookbook from Chrissy. It’s hilarious and I could give one to everyone for Christmas.
    Foot peels!
    GAMES! Bingo and that guess the celeb one were great.
    Royal Apothic- Great gifts!
    Those durn goodie girl cookies. ADDICTED.
    The collapsible basket from January

    Actual reality of what I will receive in the two boxes I purchased:
    Salt and pepper shakers
    Arrow ring/Baubble bar.
    Planners that are for 2016
    Anything with the word “trio”
    Wine glass writers/Wine bottle bags
    17 different gift cards to Hello Fresh.
    All packed in loose tassels.

    • I love that cookbook and everything I’ve made from it so far as been delicious. Love the tea towel too.

    • LOL! But I bet you’re right!!

    • I haven’t made anything from the cookbook but I read through the entire thing bc the little stories with each recipe were hilarious! I loved it just for the stories alone 🙂

    • I’m with you for those tea towels! I purchased two boxes hoping to split them up as Christmas gifts.
      My wish list is for the entire April 2015 box, any of the Royal Apothic products, anything from the December 2014 box, books, and that avocado Lauren Conrad bag.

  15. Ugh! I kept waiting to see these are sold out – then the deal gets extended! The struggle!! I don’t get this sub so it would be all new to me and the price looks great. Do I? Don’t I? Lol

    • Only $3.33 per item.

      • LoL! You’re an enabler! 🙂 I went ahead and bought one!

  16. I bought 3 and I’ve had PSMH sub for years. I’m thinking I’ll keep the things I’d like replaced like spongelle, etc. I figure I can divy up the rest for birthday gifts/Christmas. I’m thinking they’ll definitely make great teacher gifts!

  17. I went ahead and got one. I figure it’s a good way for me to try them out without spending $35 for the first month.

  18. Do we know when these ship?

    • The website says they will ship out July 15 via FedEx

  19. I snagged two, but my fear is that I’m going to get an entire box full of tassels….

    • Hahaha !

    • Me too! I’m hoping for variety but know they love their tassels.

  20. I bought one. I want to buy more, because they will probably vary, but If I bought more than one, I would probably have to answer for it to DH. I haven’t subscribed to Popsugar for over a year, but I did subscribe for a couple of years before that.

    Kendra Scott
    Paddywax candle
    Yoga Hand Towel
    Anything from Turkish Towel
    Swell Bottle
    Reed Diffuser
    Picture frames
    Hallmark Cards

    Thinks I am hoping NOT to get:
    a few things I traded for, like scarves, though they would make nice gifts, so I guess that is ok.
    Some things specific and horific
    Eyeshadow, lipgloss and mascara
    Books (because I mostly have them all or don’t want them)
    Hats (have several from past boxes)
    Sunglasses (wear Rx)

    • The first list is my wishlist

  21. This is a great idea – esp. if you’re not a regular subscriber. I’m not getting one, I have gotten every box for the past few years, so I don’t really need duplicates. But if that weren’t the case, I’d be all over this! 🙂

  22. I ordered one and hope that there isn’t that planner and Mari Kondo book from the January box. I have a planner and it’s July and I have my own organizing system that works well for me

    • Hopefully they wouldn’t send a planner with it now being halfway through the year!

    • Surely they wouldn’t send those at this point but I guess if they do I can use it as a meal planner (not go by dates but by weeks) I need to start back doing that.

  23. I will be soooo not happy if the items are mostly from the June box. We shall see

    • The June box was SUCH a dud!!!

      • Agreed. I use the sarong just because I have it. But it’s flimsy and just meh.

  24. Yep, had to buy another one, just because. Ugh!! I’m trying to cut back. I really am!! The struggle…

  25. Thanks so much for posting, didn’t get any email from popsugar regarding this, happy to snag one up.

  26. Ugh I already bought one, but now I feel compelled to order a second one. The struggle is real.

  27. I saw the first part of the title in the email and I got so excited I thought we had spoilers already! I want to know what I got in this box!!!

  28. Liz – when are you going to partner with Popsugar for a PSMH/MSA box?!?!
    That’s what I’m hoping for! I’d probably buy like 10 of those!

    Until then, I guess I’ll probably end up buying a couple more of these – I thought I could resist more until maybe Wednesday, but no way am I going to be able to resist until Friday!
    Thanks for all the awesome deals!

    • That would be so great! I am still enjoying my gray blanket from MSA#002. It’s just beautiful.

      • Me too! One of my favorite subscription box items ever.

        • Oh I loved that but it was before my time!!! Before I found this glorious site! Liz, do you plan on doing another collaboration box for us poor folk who weren’t able to get your earlier MSA boxes? That would be a dream! Those boxes were like no other ones I’ve seen yet! Perfect!

  29. I grabbed one! My first PopSugar box was the limited edition Summer box, so I can’t wait to see what I’ll get! ^_^ Now to decide if I *need* a 2nd one. 😉

  30. Oh man I already bought one now this is making me want to think about buying another one

  31. Liz, must you make so many boxes sound so wonderful!!!!!! Dang woman, now I want this one! Lol. I will decide Friday by seems like good treat!!!!

  32. Dang it I couldn’t resist! I bought another one. The struggle…

  33. Are these past monthly boxes, or just random items from past boxes being combined into a box? Because I bought a couple but I am hesitant to buy more for fear of duplicate boxes.

    • My understanding is that these are new boxes made with items from various past POPSUGAR items. Hope that helps! 🙂

      • Thanks so much!

      • To put it simply. They’re trying to rid their old and remainder inventory. I cancelled my PSMH, stuff is way over priced and can locate many of the items from various other sources at discount.

      • Liz what an encouragement and a great collaboration! I snagged one today!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!