Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

POPSUGAR Must Have Summer 2020 Box Full Spoilers!

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box FULL SPOILERS!

ByLiz CadmanMar 24, 2018 | 419 comments

MH16_MysteryBox_560x_Email (3) (1)

POPSUGAR Must Have

3.9 overall rating

530 Ratings | 71 Reviews

Thanks to chillybeans and Em1 in the forum, we have some spoilers for the POPSUGAR mystery box!

(FYI this box was $19.95 and no longer for sale.

The Box: POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box

From chillybeans:

Got my 5.4 box from NY today!!!!
It has…….
Ansel cook book -the secret recipes
wine glass writers
tarte eye shadow trio
terrapin ridge mustard
Deepa Gurnani headband
Mercury jewel box rain candle.

From Em1:

Screen Shot 2016-07-18 at 12.50.41 PM

Capri Blue candle
Barr Co Bubble Elixir
Set of 4 Govino glasses
Deepa Gurnani headband
Xoxo note cards
Terrapin Ridge Farm mustard

There may be other variations than these, but so far, both boxes look like a good value to me! What do you think of the spoilers?

Check out my POPSUGAR Must Have Box reviews to see the types of items that might be included.

Starting at $75.00

Active Deal

Get $20 off your first box!

Use Coupon Code MSA20

Subscribe Now

POPSUGAR Must Have

3.9 overall rating

530 Ratings | 71 Reviews

POPSUGAR Must Have is a quartely lifestyle subscription box curated by the editors at POPSUGAR. Each box features their "must have" products for beauty, fashion, home, food, fitness and more. Every box has a value of $250 +!

Read customer reviews >

Posted in POPSUGAR Must Have Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Read More By Liz Cadman >

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Notify me of follow-up comments by email

419 comments

Carmen

Hi Liz, I posted the contents of my box below and was wondering if you have any way finding out the value of them. My box didn’t come with an info card

CMB

Hi Carmen,
There have been a few reveal threads since this one… the most recent is:
https://www.mysubscriptionaddiction.com/2016/07/popsugar-must-have-all-star-mystery-box-unboxing-2-giveaway.html/comment-page-2

Yours looks like box #8!

Carmen

Thanks, I somehow missed that! 🙂

Carmen

This is my first receiving anything from popsugar. My box arrive today. The tracking said it was 3.2 lbs and I received a studio hall shore line bar of soap 8 0z, creme lipstick trio in cranberry, raspberry and muted plum, a gold/silver toned bracelet from LUV AJ, a soy candle from chalk board in the scent Mine 7 oz, a packet of gourmet gum in summer snow flavor, 12 pieces, and a very pretty jewelry box by Nova in blue mist. I was pleasantly surprised. I had visions of getting the pecan jelly – I have a severe allergy to pecans, or the stationary which I wouldn’t use, and I already have tons of eyeshadow.

Janet

Mine is 5/1 coming from NY. It’s supposed to arrive tomorrow but it hasn’t moved from PA since last Friday. I hope it didn’t get lost!!

Karen

WOAH! Popsugar sure had a lot of that mustard. Looks like EVERYONE got at least one. ??

Christy

Pecan honey mustard sounds delicious to me! I’d be happy with one! Watch me be the only one who doesn’t get it, haha

Karen

I hope you get it. So far, I think 4 of my boxes has it. I wish I loved mustard.

fangirl11

Gosh I was ecstatic to get my box today. I received the mustard, headband, candle box mentioned above. Well, I open it and there is mustard everywhere. I am so bummed 🙁

Melissa

Well, the lid off that horrible pecan honey mustard blew off the jar in transit. Seriously, mustard EVERYWHERE. I can still smell it two hours later, and I took the trash can down to the curb early just to get it as far away from the house as possible.

Why would you not bag up a huge, glass jar of mustard separately inside this box??? Greeting cards, soaked. Headband, INSIDE of protective bag, coated. Plastic glasses inside of box? Coated AND infused with mustard scent. Candle (in bubble wrap, nonetheless) filled, somehow, with mustard between the wicks and the soaked through with mustard up to wooden candle lid. Bubble bath? You guessed it, label soaked and unglued due to mustard intrusion.

Bonus? The mustard soaked box sat on my Florida front porch for five hours, fermenting, waiting for me to get home and gag upon lifting it. This was just disgusting.

I contacted PS via customer service email, we shall see what the fix is.

Sarah

I got the same box as em1 in the photo. It was the 5 pounds box from New York. The whole box is duplicates of everything I already have except the bubble bath and cards. I love the candle- so having two is fine. The first mustard is still sitting unopened…need to eat it…lol. my daughter is getting the second headband. Overall a great box of repeats and for only 20 bucks ya can’t go wrong!

Anna

I am seriously bummed that I talked myself out of ordering more than one! I am really pleased with what I got but darn!

Abby

I can’t find my original post, but I got the first box described (5.4lb with Ansel cookbook, Tarte quad, headband, candle, wine writers, mustard.. think that’s it..); I have the box listed– here is my swap profile url: https://swap.mysubscriptionaddiction.com/user/10380/profile

Shaun

Ugh, Now seeing what’s in the 5.4lb box I already have it all. 🙁 I desperately wanted a Pehr bin…so disappointing. If anyone wants to swap my entire box for their Pehr bin send me a message!

[email protected]

Just got the same box as Em1 and the mustard had come open in transit. The entire box was COATED on the inside. It was disgusting. The cards were soaked, the headband wad been coated inside the bag it was in, the candle was filled with mustard (and it was wrapped in bubble wrap) the paper label of the bubble bath was soaked and the box for the glasses was filled a bit with mustard and the glasses were coated. I had no idea that size jar of mustard could spread so much. And, in the Florida heat, it had really come into it’s own by the time I got home from work. Would it be so difficult to out the dang mustard in a sealed bag or something before shipping? Anyone know my options from here? I sent PS customer service an email with gross pics of the box attached? I swear, that smell is going to be with me for DAYS.

Heather

If I receive one in either of my boxes I’ll swap with you, I’ve already got 2.

Shaun

Does anyone want to swap their entire box for the 5.4lb box? Since I have everything in that one already, I’d be happy with any of the others b/c they have products I don’t already have!

Liz

I think I have the pehr bin coming and if so I will gladly trade you for the 5.4 lb box. I will keep you posted!!!!

Khaleesi

I got my 3.1 from CA and I love this box! I got the Pehr bin, straws, Tarte eyeshadow, Patchology masks, soap and frame. I love it and all for $20. I wish I had got more. I also like how PSMH made sure people got a variety of boxes so there would be no duplicates ( from the different warehouses).

Can’t wait for them to have this sale again!

co2

Ugh, I got the same as chillybean. I have gotten all of those items already and don’t use any of them. The book came water damaged and had mold on the cover and every page. I so was looking forward to this! I really wanted a bag, scarf, frame or storage item.

Chantel

My box hasn’t moved since Sunday :'( I am getting so anxious!!! I am imagining my entire box just sitting there melting in the hot sun!!!

gcc

I didn’t think about that until today when I saw multiple people were receiving boxes with melted candle and/or broken mustard jars… I think I have both in mine and the ‘real feel’ temp are 100 degrees here this week. Mine should arrive tomorrow.

Kay

My box arrived today, 5.1 lbs from NY and it is exactly the same as Em1 and I am very happy with the box! The wine glass and mustard is something I can share with my husband, so he will not be as upset with me getting another box, lol. Total value is $151 using Liz’s past reviews and the only bust item is the headband for me. I didn’t know the headband was on the expensive side and didn’t even come in a gift-able box. I gave the one from Birchbox a while ago to my sis-in-law and she loved it, so this one is going to her, but I need to find a box. Note cards are something I always have handy, bubble bath seems ingredient conscious, so I can use it for my son, and such pretty candle/jewelry box! I reuse pretty candle container for make up brushes and pens, etc. Overall, a win for me. And all of my July boxes are good this month.

CMB

Awesome! I have my fingers crossed for that one – 5.1 from NY also, but won’t arrive till Friday (sadface).
Did yours arrive intact (no melty candles, no broken things)? I’ve seen others with issues, but I’m desperately hoping that isn’t the case with all of them in this awful summer weather. Luckily it won’t be dropped on an outdoor porch at my place (it will be inside a building), but it will be sitting in a warm postal truck for over 100 miles between today and Friday 🙂

Kay

Yes, my items arrived intact, phew! Only the candle/jewelry case was wrapped in the bubble wrap, not the bubble bath or mustard. They all should be wrapped. My fingers crossed for you to be my box twin! Enjoy!

Jessica

Would love some more of the Govino glasses!

Erinne

I just opened the 4.6 pound box from Wappingers Falls, NY. I got:

Barr Co Fir & Grapefruit Bubble Bath – keep
Popsugar Tiny Prints XOXO Notecards – swap
Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard – gift
Rain scented Candle (melted in the heat)
Deepa Gurnani Headband – swap
Tarte Apple of my Eye eyeshadow – undecided.

This is my first experience with PopSugar. I’m not sure how I feel. I got a lot of things that I won’t use and a melted candle. So….I won’t be buying from them anytime soon. It is a great value for the price but not when I wont use the items.

Kara

I received the same box as Em1 – except the mustard jar was completely broken. So I have a sticky, gooey, smelly mess. The entire content of the jar spilled into every other item in the box. Not to mention there is also sharp glass throughout the box.

I took photos and emailed to customer service. Wish I had a number to talk to a representative in person. At this point – I just want a refund.

Wow. I just sent them an email because what I think was bubble bath exploded all over the box. Shards of glass everywhere. Pretty much everything ruined, minus the wine glasses. The mailman had to wrap it in a plastic bag because the box was soaked. Hoping they respond.

Kara

Update: customer service got back to me and said they would issue a full refund. Yay! I also discovered that the glass container holding the candle also broke during shipment. But really – the broken mustard jar – which wasn’t in any protective wrapping – is what caused the huge mess and ruined all of the other items. You cannot believe how sticky and crazy this box was! And then imagine broken glass throughout the entire box!

I’m relieved that customer service got back to me and issued the refund that I requested.

Kara

It’s terrible isn’t it?! Neither the bubble bath nor the mustard were packaged with protective wrap. It’s no wonder breakage would occur – and the liquid contents are super messy – so everything else becomes damaged.

I hope we get responses too. I’m worried as I haven’t heard back from customer services and I’ve specifically requested a refund. I could barely even open my box as the mustard had created such a sticky mess. Then there were also the glass pieces everywhere.

I’ve been stalking my email waiting circa response from Popsugar.

Sera

Ugh, mine came. I wanted those wine glasses so badly! I got the mustard, eye shadow, bubble bath, note card set and candle. Does this really equal a hundred?!? Would anyone want to swap anything for the glasses?

gcc

Didn’t you get a 6th item?

Sera

The headband, which was like an unintentional slap in the face since I just finished chemo!

gcc

sorry, I misread and assumed you didn’t get the glasses

Pamela

I am SO happy!! I just received the box and it contained:
Got my 5.4 box from NY today!!!!
It has…….
Tarte eye shadow trio
Terrapin Ridge pecan honey mustard
Deepa Gurnani headband
Mercury jewel box rain candle.
tiny prints xoxo notecards

I love them all, especially the rain candle and note cards.

meg

I’m pretty sure I’m getting the same box. Just curious…you only listed 5 items, shouldn’t there be 6 items? Thanks!

Pamela

Oh you’re right! I left out the Barr Co. Bubble Bath!

Janet

I got the 4.9 box from NY: xo thank you cards, giovino wine glasses, fir and grapefruit bubble bath, mustard, sparkly headband, and the silver candle. I wish they had mixed up the items from different boxes more (although I imagine this was a lot easier for them). I had really been hoping for some beauty products so this was disappointing. Still, I can give the wine glasses to my parents who picnic a lot and can probably find homes for the rest of the items. Still a great deal but I was really hoping I’d get a treat for me!

Chantel

I have a 4.9 box coming from NY I am hoping it is this box!

Jean

Im so sad i dont think im getting the mercury rain box candle 🙁 if anyone wants to swap please let me know. Im getting the 4.0lb box and the 3.1 lb box

Danelle

My weights had changed. I was doing the yay happy dance for glasses. Now I have no
Clue why it dropped by so much weight. I’m getting now the 2.8 and it was 5.2.

Danelle

5.3,2.8 coming Friday. From NY. 3.1 and 3.2 from CA coming next Tuesday. I was hoping for glasses in a box….

Kara

Does anyone have a phone number for customer service?

Jessica

My first of 3 boxes came!
Mustard, Deppa headband, wine glass writers, Tarte eyeshadow quad, Mercury glass candle with wooden lid and a tube of Simpatico hand lotion.

Carmen

I am really disappointing by the customer service. I placed two orders a couple hours apart and only received shipping information for my second order which will be delivered today. I reached out to customer service on Monday and still have no clue what with happened to my first ordered box.

Jayne

I got both of my boxes on the same day but had only received one shipping notice

Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box FULL SPOILERS!

Advertise With MSA

Information

Company