Facebook PixelThe Pumpkin BatchSubscription Box Review - January 2016 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The Pumpkin Batch Subscription Box Review – January 2016

Bekki Menzies
ByBekki MenziesJan 24, 2016 | 12 comments


3.1 overall rating
7 Ratings | 2 Reviews

The Pumpkin Batch subscription is a subscription for those ardent pumpkin lovers that wish they could get their fall goodies all year round!


This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

The Subscription Box: The Pumpkin Batch

The Price:  $29.99 per month, with discounts available for longer subscriptions

The Products: Hand-crafted pumpkin and pumpkin spice everything, with the added bonus of a featured goodie (FOOD! Yay!) every month.

COUPON:  From now until 2/14/2016, you can subscribe to The Pumpkin Batch for 15% off.   This coupon applies to your first monthly or quarterly subscription.  Use the code: pumpkinlovers15.


The illustrations on the shipping box are seriously adorable.  I really love it when companies put thought into their packaging as well as into the curation of the box!

I am always a huge fan of information cards in boxes, so I was excited to see one in this box particularly.  Since the box is comprised of items from individual artisans, I loved seeing the information that Serena included on the information card.  Most of the artisans are from all over the West Coast, with one thrown in from Texas.  I live on the West Coast and am a huge proponent of individuals starting their dream business, so I love seeing them supported and represented in the sub box world.


Ticket Chocolate Pumpkin Spice Hot Chocolate - $9.00

I've always thought these individual serving hot chocolate spoons were a great idea.  I think these would be fun to put out on a hot chocolate bar for a party - if you have a variety, everyone would be able to make their dream hot chocolate!  I stirred one of these into my morning coffee and am sipping it as I write this review - it is delicious It's not overly sweet, the pumpkin spice flavor comes through just the right amount to balance with the chocolate, and it dissolved quickly and fully.  I think this was a great addition to a January box, especially when so much of the country is buried under a snow storm - hot chocolate is the perfect way to chase away the January blues.


Scrumptious Brownies - Pumpkin Brownies - $5.00

Since I'm drinking my pumpkin spice hot chocolate, I had to eat my brownies with it.  There is no better, more nutritious breakfast than brownies and hot chocolate, right?  Who is with me?!  These brownies are gluten free and delicious.  They're quite moist, soft, chewy, and the pumpkin flavor sneaks up on you.  My first bite was "Hm, this is good" but my last bite had me wondering why there weren't more in the bag!

Madyson's Marshmallows - Snowflake Marshmallow Melt - $0.56

These are so fun and the perfect addition to a box with hot chocolate in it!  as they melt, the design of the marshmallow stays (somewhat) on the top of your drink, and you get the creamy-marshmallow flavor throughout your sips.  If you really like marshmallows, you should poke around Madyson's site - they even have marshmallow donuts!


Our Pretty Lil' Things - Pumpkin Cozy - $9.00

A company with the tagline "We make pants for your drink" immediately wins points in my mind.  This is a very nicely crocheted drink cozy that fits one of my favorite mugs perfectly!  This neatly solves the problem of handleless mugs that get too hot to drink.  I love the pumpkin design on the front, and I received the tan color.  What a fun way to keep pumpkin season with you all year round.

Violet Serpentine Pumpkin Spice Organic Lip Balm - $6.00

This lip balm is made from various oils, beeswax, tangerine mica, ground herbs, and essential oils.  It is very smooth to apply and smells great!  Lip balms in tins are never my first choice, but this one is very nice, and I have no doubts that it will get used!

Verdict:  I really enjoyed my first shipment of The Pumpkin Batch!  First of all, I love the clever name, secondly I love pumpkin, and thirdly, this was a nicely curated box.  The value of the box comes up to about $29.56 - the values on the information card are slightly higher than what I came up with, so they may include shipping - adding those up, I come up with $31. Either way, the value of the box is right at what you would pay for it monthly, which is great for an independently owned subscription box.

What did you think of The Pumpkin Batch?

Starting at $21.25
Active Deal
Save 15% off your first box
Use Coupon Code TAKE15
Subscribe Now

Treats is a subscription box that helps you explore the world through tasty treats. Expect candy, crackers, cookies, chips, and everything in between.

Treats offers two subscription levels to pick from. The Standard Pack ($13.95 per month) includes 5+ typical snacks from a new country eac... read more.

Bekki Menzies
Bekki Menzies
Bekki first discovered subscription boxes in 2014 and they quickly took over her life! (Not quite, but pretty close.) She started with POPSUGAR Must Have, then moved to Little Lace Box, Birchbox, Hamptons Lane...the rest was history. Her favorite product find is Beekman 1802 Fudge (so, so good) and her favorite boxes are Birchbox and Hamptons Lane...but she's always looking for a new subscription to try!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



I ordered the January box as a single purchase based on this review. I had some trouble getting the website to work, but I emailed and got a super fast response. Their shipping was very quick, and best of all, I love the box! Awesome items and I highly recommend Pumpkin Batch.

Reply ButtonReply


I love pumpkin everything too. I was lucky enough to swap for the pumpkin pants Snuggie now I need to track down some of the other items that look delicious

Reply ButtonReply


Sounds fun and I may try this! I absolutly loveee pumpkin! I’m upset when Starbucks doesn’t have it?

Reply ButtonReply


While I think it’s a new idea, I’m not sure that pumpkin all year round, at that price, would be worth it.

Reply ButtonReply


I’m so glad to see this review on here! This box really peaked my interest.

Reply ButtonReply


Oh my! This box is so tempting!! I love pumpkin spice everything.

Reply ButtonReply


Oh my goodness! Pumpkin all year round? Yes please! Am so subscribing to this box!

Reply ButtonReply


I love all things pumpkin! This is so tempting!!

Reply ButtonReply


Enjoyed your review and this box looks interesting. Love my pumpkin and appreciate the breakfast ideas.

Reply ButtonReply


“…Since I’m drinking my pumpkin spice hot chocolate, I had to eat my brownies with it. There is no better, more nutritious breakfast than brownies and hot chocolate, right? Who is with me?! ”
Yes, total fist-bump in solidarity from me! I 😀

Reply ButtonReply


Same!! XD

Reply ButtonReply


OMG I love this! I love pumpkin and how it was used in all of the products! I can’t wait to see what other items will be included in the future 🙂

Reply ButtonReply