Posted by on in Boxycharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 30 comments

BoxyCharm October 2015 Full Spoilers!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Boxycharm October 2015 Spoiler

Spoiler alert! Boxycharm is emailing all subscribers with the box variations they will be receiving this month. Here are a few variations from Instagram:

What are you getting from Boxycharm this month?

It looks like all boxes will include:

Palmetto Derma‘s Rejuvenating Antioxidant Mask ($64 Value)

Bellapierre Cheek and Lip Stain ($20 Value)

Lord and Berry Line Shade Eyeliner ($18 Value)

Cult Cosmetics Nail Polish ($12 Value)

And subscribers will receive one of the following as their 5th item:

Vincent Longo Trio Shadow

Cargo Cosmetics Blush 

Beauty For Real Lip Creme

Doucce Punk Volumizing Mascara

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Hey has anyone with a darker complexion tried the lip/cheek stain? I received the coral color and contemplating passing it on if there’s only a small amount of pigmentation. I didn’t want to swatch it if it doesn’t show up on darker skin.

  2. I’m not a fan of the cheek and lip stain, I already got one a few months back in Glossybox I think it was. I never use it. Hopefully this is a different color. But I’m still super happy with Boxy, I cancelled my Glossybox last month and am happy with my choice 😀

  3. Received my Boxycharm yesterday, really impressed with all the full size items for the cost of this box, don’t know how they do it but glad I’m a subscriber and used the mask last night, super happy.

  4. yay, I am getting the eyeshadow trio

  5. Getting the mascara! Liked the box so much, talked my mom into subbing too. 🙂

  6. I saw a bunch of Bellapierre makeup being sold at TJMaxx. Does anybody else find it odd that all of the sub boxes constantly have the following brands: Ofra, ModelCo, Bellapierre?

    • I have been thinking the same thing! It’s the same stuff a lot, and with some of the colors it almost seems we get what isn’t selling….which would fall in line if you’re seeing it at TJMaxx.

      • Plus I find it odd these random brands that are extremely expensive are always included. I understand these are supposed to be “discovery” boxes so of course there will be new brands but Ofra, ModelCo, and Bellepierre seem to be over-priced unknowns, which would be fine if the quality is good but they WAY overuse them.

    • Agree! I had to cancel Ipsy and a couple others because I was sick of getting bella pierre in every box. I didn’t know anyone even liked them…I’ve seen them trying to sell their makeup in the mall and no one ever seems interested.

  7. I got the mascara, which I wanted. The Bellepierre has 2 colors on the site, I’m hoping coral is in the box, but it will probably be the pink.

  8. Im getting the mascara! I must say this is my second Boxycharm and I’m really impressed. I sub to 6 boxes and Boxycharm by far is my favorite and always a high dollar value for the $21 monthly price. Have a few on the cutting block, but this box will not be one of them.

  9. Ugh, i hate that cheek and lip stain. Impossible to get out, ugly pale pink color, feels cheap, and was sent out in bb5 last spring. Other then that though i dig the box. Assuming the eyeliner isnt black (id really like something funky and witchy) and the nail polish is the color shown, I’m happy.

  10. I really want the face scrub, but I had to cancel all my sub boxes this month? I had to make the tough financial decisions that Noone wants to. Hope everyone enjoys their boxes. Maybe here soon I’ll be able to re-sub

  11. Decent box but I’m happy I didn’t sub Boxy this month. Disappointed because I was hoping it would be more witchy/Halloween-related but happy because “yay for saving” lol!

  12. I’m getting the mascara box in the middle.

  13. Based on those pictures, it looks like possibly the nail polish is the same color throughout all the boxes. Does anyone know what the color is though?

    • It looks to me like it might be Cult’s holographic top coat that makes any base nail polish look really cool and shiny. I could be wrong, though.

    • Boneyard.

      • Me too I think it’s Boneyard.

  14. I’m getting the middle box with the mascara. Not my favorite but I wanted the mask so I subscribed! I wish I got that blush though.

  15. Firstly, I want to say how happy I am I discovered this page!!
    This is the 1st subscription I decided on subscribing too after some research. Still, I got the bug & subscribed to many more with lots of 1/2 & gift promos. I plan to pare down to about 3 & I must say Boxycharm is my fave so far & definitely a keeper!
    This is my 2nd boxycharm, but I haven’t received my 1st Glossybox yet. I thought Beautyfix would be my fave bc I love skincare but there September box was underwhelming to me.

  16. Nevermind. I reread Liz’ post and checked my email. I’m getting the eyeshadow. I’m happy with this since I have tons of unopened mascara and don’t care for lip gloss

  17. I was wondering how you guys know what you are getting?

    • They sent us all emails Carmen. Check your junk mail.

  18. I am getting the box with the mascara, I hoped for either it or the Cargo blush. I wonder if there are color variations in the polish, cheek/lip stain, liner?

  19. I got the lipgloss one which I was a little sad about simply because I never wear lipgloss and red’s never look good on my skin because I have such pink undertones. I was really hoping for the eyeshadow because I am in love with the colors in the trio.

  20. I keep thinking I should sub. Seems like such great values

  21. I’m receiving the box with the mascara. I wanted that mascara, lol. I’ve been a subscriber to Boxycharm for about a year and a half. This is my favorite subscription box. The value and brands are always amazing!

  22. im really tempted. boxycharm is doing great things lately

  23. This is my first month w/boxycharm. Apparently, I am getting the box with the mascara. I’m happy as I wanted anything but the lip gloss. Seems like a really good value.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!