Posted by on in POPSUGAR Must Have Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 69 comments

POPSUGAR Must Have September 2015 Spoiler + Coupon

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

POPSUGAR April Boxes Have Sold Out!

We finally have a spoiler for the September 2015 POPSUGAR Must Have box! (Thanks, Lisa, KC, Candace, Sara, Judy, Wendy, Laquisha, Brittany, Ilka, Jessica and Marissa for the head’s up!)

Each box will include:

Too Faced Cosmetics Spoiler


Too Faced Cosmetics Brow Envy Brow Shaping and Defining Kit ($39 Value).

What do you think of the first spoiler? FYI – they August box has sold out, but the September box is still currently available. If you haven’t signed up yet, use coupon code MUSTHAVE5 to save $5 off your first box.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Finally decided to order the September box and I was too late! Anybody have any thoughts on how likely one would be to get a box if you check waitlist? I’m guessing there’s really no way to tell.

  2. If anyone who got the August box and didn’t like it is still looking to sell it, please email me with your price: [email protected].

    I don’t think anyone is still checking the posts on the August review, and I’ve emailed a couple people who posted there saying they were looking to sell but got delivery failures back, so PLEASE just email me if you have a complete AUGUST box… I’ve subscribed starting in September, but I really want the August box too 🙂 THANK YOU!

    • I don’t have whole box but still have;
      AMERICAN COLORS Mediterranean Plaid Scarf
      ROYAL APOTHIC Tea Balm Firming Eye Treatment
      HAPPY JACKSON Yay Lunch! Lunch Box
      MYYOGAWORKS 3–Month Trial
      FOLGERS ICED CAFÉ ™ Caramel Macchiato Flavored Coffee Drink Concentrate

      So missing mug, napkins and pancake/waffle mix

      Any interest?

  3. So, I was debating whether it not to cancel. I think these boxes are fun but I don’t love them (think maybe I should just stick to book, card and geek subscriptions 🙂 ). I never look at spoilers but did for August to determine if I should cancel. I won’t use the brow stuff but I was holding out for another spoiler. Well, I finally looked up their cancellation policy. It gas to be done by 23rd (since I’ve been billed on the 1st I thought I had until then). D’oh!
    OK September PopSugar box; make me love you or you’re getting cancelled and I am using those dollars for another book or geek box.

  4. I currently use benefit brow zings but I’m excited for this because it comes with a highlighter which brow zings doesn’t have. This will be my first popsugar box (bday gift from the hubby) and I’m beyond excited. I hope more spoilers come out because I’m curious about what I’ll be receiving. I’ve gone through the pretty much all the former popsugar reviews on this website and there isn’t a single box I couldn’t find a use for. I do hope that it’s less food items and more housewares though (I just bought a house).

  5. I use Anastasia and am happy with it so this is not pushing me to subscribe. Hope they put up another spoiler. I liked the 2013 box (review) but not the 2014 box (review) so I’m hesitant.

  6. I decided to cancel my Sept. box because I really don’t need any eyebrow anything…and it was really bumming me out (I’m actually surprised so many people seem happy). But I sprung for the fall SE box, so I’ll be looking forward to that!

    • I’m in the same boat! Had no idea so many people use and love brow products. I had a 6 month sub that ran out in August and was about to resub but unless there’s another spoiler that I just have to have I’ll skip this month and use the saved $ as justification to buy the Fall LE! …which I’m sure I would have done anyway. Ah, addiction! 😀

  7. Not thrilled with the sales tax added in! I’m in PA and even with the -$5, my total was $37.10. As much as I love Too Faced, i may have to pass. Torture! I don’t need it, but want it! Grr!

  8. Liz – Popsugar sent out an e-mail about an hour ago about changes to their referral program and referrals resetting to 0 when they implement the change, (September 10) not sure if you want to make a post about that or not.

    • I never received an email about a change of the referral program. Can you give any more details?

  9. I’m frustrated with Pop Sugar who insists on charging sales tax for a state that does not collect tax from internet companies. Pop Sugar companies do not have an office/outlet in our state. Our Secretary of State said they should not be collecting taxes and our state is not receiving any tax money from Pop Sugar. Yet, Pop Sugar writes that since our state is on their tax “list” they must collect.
    So…makes one wonder who is getting all this collected tax money….

    • What state? Just curious. The taxable nexus for states also applies to warehouses…

    • I love popsugar- but that should be reported to the IRS.

  10. This sub is getting dangerous for me. I usually try to stick with less expensive or quarterly subs but I got sucked in to July with the Henri Bendel Dopp kit, bought it as a gift subscription to myself. And I love Royal Apothic so got myself another ‘gift’ for August. Then I just threw in the towel and got myself a 3 month gift sub for September-November before any spoilers were even released since I loved the August box full spoilers so much (even though I haven’t yet received it)! Seriously my favorite mug had just broken (my dog knocked it over) and I went through a major scarf purge last spring and was missing my scarves, Birthday cake flavored anything is my favorite, I love Royal Apothic, and I have been wanting to get back into yoga. Perfection! I’m a brow product junkie and really don’t need this but am excited to try it and am thrilled to see this as the first September spoiler! My Birthday is in Seltember, so surely that makes my sub spending acceptable, right? Right?! 🙂

    • *September… Apparently I can’t spell my own month of birth. I blame my phone.

  11. At first I was like…….oh no more eye shadow or contour …..but will keep an open mind. I’ve read some great reviews and looking forward to try something new. I’ve never used powder before. so far so good for Sept.

  12. I just canceled after August! That box just completely blew it for me… Now here I go again but this time on a month-to-month basis. At least I got to get five dollars off and free shipping LOL. I love two-faced and I am looking forward to this! Now I just have to figure out how to cancel beauty fix! I just am always scared as soon as I cancel they’re going to have a good box. Last month was good but, it still seems like they’re sending stuff that they can’t sell.

  13. Okay. I finally couldn’t pass this up and longer!

  14. I just want this box only …can I sign up as a gift purchase for myself so that it doesn’t auto renew??

    • Yep! Just select the monthly subscription & check the box indicating that it is a gift

  15. Just when I had my boxes down to just one , this is a great deal so yes I got it!!

  16. Yay! Thanks for the mention above. I ordered before I shared the sneak peek thanks to Amber B. I cannot wait to get this box! What a great treat for an early birthday gift to myself!!!!

  17. I have this kit and love it. I recently swapped for the it cosmetic universal pencil and really like it better than this kit. I will probably swap this. I think this is great beauty item! I’m hoping they include the necklace from last months spoiler. This box looks like it’s going to be a major hit! Can’t wait for September and the fall special box!

  18. Awesome!! I love this and it’s not something I already have 😀 Love to dress up my brows and this is perfect. Thanks bunches POPSUGAR! I’m a happy girl!

  19. So excited! I have been wanting this for a while. I was actually going to buy this. They come through again. Love my PopSugar!

  20. I’m intrigued by the brow kit. I’m thinking about buying the box.

  21. I’m so excited! This is a wonderful spoiler.

  22. I have so far resisted the PSMH boxes by living vicariously through Liz’s reviews. After seeing this spoiler, I might have to give in. I first tried Too Faced cosmetics back in 2001 & have loved everything I’ve tried. My brows are pretty plain on a regular. However, I can tell a big difference when I do pay some attention to them, especially in photos. I think this kit will compliment my Too Faced BOUDOIR EYES shadow collection.

    Ok…I think I will go for broke (figuratively) & sign up for the box.

  23. I caved and resubscribed on a month to month…hoping for a deal on Black Friday 🙂 That would be sweet!

  24. This is so exciting!!!! I am so stoked we are getting this!!

  25. Just signed up for 3 months instead of the Fall LE since I very much disliked the last one…. Now I can relax until the thanksgiving coupon shows up (hopefully!)

  26. WOOOHOOOO!!!! A beauty product I don’t have, I do want, and from a company I love!! I’m so happy I gave PS a 2nd chance after unsubbing after the Dec. debacle. They haven’t let me down!

  27. WANT.

  28. Nope nope nope. Don’t need it, don’t want it. Will definitely be swapping or selling this one.

    • Yes, same here…… Booorrrriiinnngggg. I really want a home item- a cookbook or something like that. These beauty items are so not for me! This will be up on the swap!

  29. I’ve fallen in love with Too Faced ever since the summer box of style. I also have been wanting to learn eyebrows since I have had them done once and really liked the outcome. I ordered. I knew I shouldn’t have looked at the spoiler. I was thinking about picking the birch box eye pencil because of this but now I will pick something else!

    • Same here. The Box of Style turned me on to Too Faced and I can’t stop ordering it. The La Creme lipstick is honestly my favorite lip product ever. I’m on board for the Sept box!

      • I’m addicted to the lipstick from the Rachel Zoe box too!

      • It is the best lipstick! Definitely will order more when it runs out! I love the bronzer too. Just need a better brush and to put it on lightly.

  30. It seems like all the sub boxes are including brow kits…and I wax my brows. I have no need for these. I wish I did, because I would have enough to last a decade. lol Not excited about Sept just yet….

  31. My first thought was, “meh, I never use products for my brows” but then I realized that putting a product like this in a box could really encourage people to try it and see what they think. Especially since this kit includes everything you’d need to spruce up your brows. Isn’t that the point of subscription boxes anyway? I know that I wouldn’t go out and get brow wax, powders, or a spoolie brush, but this kit is handy if you’d never take the initiative yourself.

    • Compared to some of the other brow products that have been sent out lately, this kit is really good! Unfortunately, I already have my brow routine down pat so I’m not looking to venture into new products for them at the moment…

    • I 100% agree. I often see really negative comments on the boxes but I think that people lose sight of what the purpose of a subscription box is for. I like that I get things that I would never buy so that I can give it a shot and try it, or the brand out.

  32. I’m putting it off, but I’ve been thinking of cancelling this sub and this product is really solidifying that thought… but I want the jewelry item that was a possible spoiler awhile ago for this box so I’m torn!

  33. I LOVE this! I was so meh about July, then like Yeah! for August, now for September I’m like YEAH! (It just keeps getting better for me!) And I got a shout-out on the MSA blog – coolness!

    • 🙂

  34. I am kind of meh about this personally.

  35. Ohhhh, they got me! I LOVE eyebrow stuff! And Too Faced!?!?! Signed up ASAP, everything else in the box will just be extra!

    • Yes!!! Me too. The rest of the box is a giant GWP 🙂

      Almost makes up for this months suckage. Scarf I’ll never wear with a plastic box and mug I’ll never use.

      • I’ll swap with you if you are interested for the mug or box. My kids love them and I’m glad I bought fun extra box as the each have one but would love an extra 🙂

        • Glad I bought “one” extra box. Autocorrect =1/ me = 0

  36. I’m not real excited about this spoiler since I don’t use any brow stuff. Hopefully the rest of the box is great. I finally got my August box today… haven’t had a chance to really look at everything yet, but I’m not overly excited about it (really wish the lunch box thing was dishwasher safe!) so hoping September will be great!

  37. Very stoked. I never get tired of trying to perfect my brows! Love that this kit is somewhat unique. Looking forward to this box, the rest will be gravy after this!

    • Couldn’t agree more. Love the opportunity to try out this kit. I’m a brow girl. If my brows look great, I feel great!

  38. Meh. I don’t need or want this. I hope there are other goodies that justify the price. Maybe their will be someone willing to swap. Fingers crossed.

    • Ooops! I know I used the wrong “there”!

      • No, you used the correct “there” in your case. 🙂

  39. I am going to try to stay positive, but I don’t use things on my brows. I will hope for other fantastical stuff in the box. My first box ever was the August box, which I LOVED (and just got last Saturday).

  40. I love it when pop sugar adds the too faced palettes to our boxes! That alone is worth the price of the box itself, so it’s like everything else is just a bonus! tee hee Not to mention they’re always amazing palettes! So glad I didn’t buy this yet!

  41. Sigh…,yet another product that WOC can’t use.

    • I noticed a few WOC on the Sephora website who had uploaded images of themselves after using this product. Maybe all is not lost! The shaping tools and wax look pretty handy! =)

  42. I’m really excited to try this!

  43. Lovveeee two faced but was hoping for a palette instead of brows. Still amazed though!

    • I was hoping for a palette too, I love the Too Faced Naturals palette from last time.

      • Agreed! I use mine very often! I would love more!

  44. Yasssssssss! I can’t wait!!!!!!!! I currently use a Bodyography trio, the Benefit Instant Brow pencil, Benefit’s Gimme Brow or Anastasia’s Dip Brow pomade. I’d like to try this one out so I am so glad we are getting it!!! <3

    • I use the bodyography trio too! I can’t wait to try this one – I’m guessing the September boxes will sell out quickly with this spoiler!

  45. So much yessss!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!