Posted by on in Subscription Box Spoilers | 70 comments

POPSUGAR Must Have Box April 2014 FULL Spoilers

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

POPSUGAR Must Have Box April 2014

The first spoiler for the April POPSUGAR Must Have Box is out! And it’s this gorgeous T0o Faced Natural Eyes PaletteΒ ($36)! (Can you tell I’m excited?)

What do you think of the spoiler?

FYI – Use coupon code MUSTHAVE5 to save $5 off your first box. And thanks to a few readers letting me know about this little article, we have the whole list of items:

POPSUGAR Must Have April 2014 Items

Blue Avocado Shopper Tote Bag (Value $25)

T0o Faced Natural Eyes PaletteΒ (Value $36)

Caldrea Rosewater Driftwood Hand Soap (Value $10.50)

Graphic Image Pocket Notes (Value $25 -$40)

Fresh Pastry Stand Tea Towels (Value $9.95 – $25)

I officially can’t wait to get my hands on this box – and I think the April box looks like a great gift too! What do you think of all the POPSUGAR April spoilers?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Just got my pop sugar box this month. And I absolutley love it thanks for the spoilers.

  2. When do PopSugar boxes ship? Do they email tracking codes too? This is my first one and I’m so excited!

    • They have always emailed me with a tracking number and it usually goes out the night they send you the email. I received my notification April 5, but they ship at different times/days. i’m not sure what determines that. April is a good box.

  3. I think I like this better than the resort box! Wow!

  4. I had totally cancelled and then signed up again. Can’t beat $20! I’m also a sucker for neutral eyeshadow pallets.

    • What is the 50% promo code??

  5. Well good news bad news for me. I didn’t know you had to cancel and they auto renewed me for the april box of course for the full $39.95 grrrrrr. I have mixed feelings. In general it’s a good box but sooooo don’t want the eye shadow and that’s the biggest cost item of the box. I got so many brownish nude colors last year that I cant use …..I don’t even go out that much since I work from home so they are piling up not being used. Maybe I will swap. Anyway, hand soap….ahh I always use bath and body foam soap ……I do hope there is a good snack…….or fun extra. Well this box could have been A LOT WORSE! I am lucky in that regard.

  6. Ahhh I’ve been resisting the spoilers but once I got the email my box shipped I couldn’t resist! I’m so glad I peeked! I almost bought new eye shadow today but changed my mind last minute AND I need new hand soap, Perfect!

  7. Oh dear, I purchased four boxes for gifts, but someone said via Facebook that they were getting the March rather than the April box. I’m confused because it said subscriptions would start with the April box, but was I supposed to uncheck something??
    The March box was fine, but I really wanted the April box for gifts…

  8. The code isn’t working for me. Anyone else having trouble?

  9. I tried using the promo code and it did not work….it says it is invalid…do they deactivate them after they sell so many?

  10. I’m really excited. I can’t get enough of nude palettes! It looks like I’ll use everything this month.

  11. Oops, I posted comment in wrong place 1st time!! This box looks good overall. However, as a vegan, I’m very disappointed in a leather notebook!! Does anyone have anything from a box or stylish surprise sz med, they would like to swap for this notebook??

  12. Last month was my first month of Popsugar. I subscribed because I had to have the scarf. (Big scarf junkie!!) Meant to cancel but forgot. Sooo glad I did! This box looks great! So excited for the Too Faced palette. It will be my first! Thought this would make a great care package for my daughter in college and for $20?? It’s really a no-brainer! She is going to be excited to see this in her mail!

    • What is the 50% promo code??

      • Unfortunately it expired.

  13. I can’t wait to get this box! Yesterday I went to Sephora with my 15% off coupon to buy some Tarte waterproof mascara, this palette and a train cosmetic case. I picked this palette up twice and finally decided to get the mascara and a few other items. In line at the check out I almost changed my mind and went back for it a third time, but decided not to because I was in a hurry and thought I would pick it up next time. Also, two weeks ago I ordered several items from Blue Avocado and this bag is something that I took out of my cart with plans to purchase later. I am so happy I waited. Mom was wrong, sometimes it does pay to procrastinate. This is going to be the best Popsugar box yet!

    • It sounds like this box is made for you! πŸ™‚ (And I love Tarte mascara too!)

    • Wow I can’t believe how this worked out for you. At first i was disappointed in the eye shadow pallet because I have received so many nude/brown type colors last year in different boxes and brands, but this has gotten so many great reviews i think it is a higher quality and I will try it. I’ve never heard of Blue Avocado before this box and I am bag crazy so I can’t wait!

  14. It’s okay, I didn’t need that 20$ anyway.

  15. I feel like this box was curated just for me! I love everything in it. I bought a second one as a Mother’s Day gift.

    • I did the same!

  16. Do you know when the last day to order is?

    • I’m not sure – I think it depends on when they sell out of the April boxes.

  17. Thanks to the coupon I finally signed up for this box! So excited!!!

  18. Holy crap, I’m in love with this box already! I’m getting a little tired of neutral eye palettes in my sub boxes, but this one is so gorgeous and has such great reviews that I may ditch the Nyx and POP Beauty ones I’ve been using.

    I’m ridiculously excited to get this box. It’s perfect for spring!

  19. I hope that the pocket notes cover isn’t leather, I don’t buy any animal products – wonder if I could email them and ask for the non-leather ones?

    • I doubt it. Yeah, I’m a vegan & disappointed to see this too!! πŸ™

      • Hi! I feel the same way about not wanting anything that is made of real leather, and according to POPSUGAR’S website, they choose only animal-friendly products! So, I am guessing that means that it is not made out of real leather, which is awesome for a number of reasons, but mostly because I am really looking forward to getting this in my box now!! Blessed be!! πŸ™‚

    • Hi, this is what is on the website for the pocket note….if you click on the link Liz has in blue it says traditional leather then if you look at the description further: Traditional soft full-grain calfskin leather.

      This could be something different in the box but at first glance it appears to be the same. You can always check with pop sugar or just see what the description is when you get the box.

  20. I just cancelled this a couple of days ago because $40 a month was too expensive for me, but I signed up again today with the coupon. Thanks Liz! Too Faced eye shadows are gorgeous and have a well-pigmented formula. So excited!

  21. This box has a theme of Earth Day which is this month. Everything is eco friendly . πŸ™‚ love that

    • I absolutely do, as well!!! πŸ˜€

  22. Eeeeeekkk!!! I cannot wait to get this box! Everything looks fab! With the 50% off code I think I might gift one box too, what a great deal! Now I just need to know what surprises are in my PSMH Resort Box!

  23. I am so excited for this box! I have a slight addiction to neutral eye pallets, so I can’t wait to try the too faced! The grocery tote looks super cute!

  24. I already paid for April- if I cancel and sign up again without checking the wait list box, would that be the May box? I want to take advantage of the coupon.

    • Rats- I tried it, and it looks like I’m getting 2 boxes in April. I just wrote them- hopefully, they can move it to May.

  25. I am similarly surprised that the box does not contain a must have snack. Nevertheless, I like it! Plus, I was able to purchase a few boxes for my friend with this great 50% coupon. Thanks!

  26. I’m so sad! I bought it earlier with just the 5 dollar off coupon. πŸ™ I could have saved some more money. Anyone known if you can cancel and rebuy it?

    • I used the 50% off code and it worked for me, so I cancelled my full priced April box. Now to see if the money will be refunded lol.
      I’ve only ever bought the resort box, so I was a little irritated that I couldn’t use the $5 off of my first subscription from them. But all is well now because I got the box for $19.97 πŸ™‚

    • I just sent an email to customer support requesting a credit for the difference with the new code for the same reason. I’ve heard that their customer service is good, so this should be a good test!

      • Their customer service seriously sucks. I doubt they will do anything. I had a similar issue and they were stone cold about it.

      • I had this issue before and I had to say I was going to dispute the charges if they didn’t refund the money, that worked.

      • I’m really surprised that you heard their cs is good. I’ve dealt with them a handful of times and it’s like pulling teeth to get them to address issues. Unless it’s something super straightforward like a broken item or something (which they will replace after making you send a pic of the broken item.) If it is anything that requires a customized response or for them to bend the rules, they usually won’t be much help.

        • I also had a super great cs experience with them. They didn’t question me on the broken product (or require a picture) and immediately sent out a new item. I’m guessing it just depends on what kind of day the particular cs rep you happen to be in touch with is having?

          • I’ve also had good contact with their customer service. The month we got the jam, mine was broken and they sent one right away (no pics required), and one month my box didn’t have the mascara that was supposed to be included, so they sent me one on the side after I asked about it. No questions asked. I think it’s all about your attitude when you email them.

  27. I’am surprise there is no snack in the box.

    • I heard the snack was going to be a Naturebox snack “Popsugar mix”. Not as cool as that pipcorn, but should be okay.

  28. I feel like I won the lottery! Thank you so much for the code. I was on the fence, but that made it official. I can’t wait for it to come.

  29. For 50% off, I had to buy another as a gift! Such a great month. Thanks for the spoilers.

  30. Before I found your site, I hadn’t subscribed to a single box, nor was I planning on it. Now I have about 8 or 9 boxes… and this makes about 10! This 50% off coupon just pushed me over the edge on a difficult decision of whether I would subscribe to them or not.

  31. Thanks for the update and coupon. This makes up for the yucky mystery box I got from Fancy. Pop Sugar always brings some quality even when not everything is a fit for me. My daughter is going to fight me for this box!

  32. I totally bought it. I love those colors and I’ve always wanted this box anyways. Lol. Lord knows I don’t need this!

  33. This makes me so excited! This alone makes the April box better than any of the last 3 Popsugar boxes. Yay πŸ™‚

  34. Oh my so tempting. I will wait to see what else they have. I just got my first 2nd Blush box and am not thrilled with it. So hard to decide which box to keep subscribed too. I want them all! You have a great job Liz!

  35. Game! I almost bought that exact product today and was like… Hummm, lemme see what I get in my boxes this month. Yea!!

  36. Did they spell two wrong? Isn’t it “Too Faced” not “Two Faced”??

    • They did. The correct spelling of the brand is right there in the picture of the palette.

  37. Oh, I’m so excited! I was just thinking I need more eyeshadow palettes. Yay!

  38. I have several unopened eyeshadow palettes, but this one will move to the head of the line! Gorgeous!

  39. Well yay!!! Have u heard when the limited edition box is going to ship? I thought that it was supposed to have mailed out the last week in march :/

    • I received an email from popsugar stating that the resort box will ship out on April 7th.

      • mine was shipped out last week… so close to my house now I thought i’d get it today…..Monday for sure……so excited πŸ™‚

  40. I’m kind of bored of eyeshadow palettes in general, but I recently purchased my first Too Faced product (a nude lip stick) and LOVED it, so I’m sooo excited to get to try out another of their products, eyeshadow or otherwise!

  41. ughhh I had to cancel popsugar this month because i’m moving and had to do the whole security deposit + first month’s rent + move-in fee + pet fee + movers/truck song and dance. le sigh…I want that =(

  42. I am soooo glad that I subscribed this month. I actually gasped with joy over your post!

  43. Oh so pretty!
    I’m glad to FINALLY see a spoiler, I was stalking their facebook page and your blog.. LOL

  44. OMG I’m SO excited! That practically covers the price of the box!

  45. Very nice! I have the Too Faced Chocolate Bar but it will be nice to have a smaller one for everyday.

  46. Oh my!! I was going to buy that and hadn’t had the chance yet. Now I’m glad I didn’t as it is included, wonderful and lovely and awesome is all I can say! My Christmas present my husband brought me is just getting better and better as the year goes on! Thanks for sharing Liz!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!