Posted by on in Subscription Box News | 30 comments

Fancy Box Mystery Boxes Available Now!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Fancy Mystery Box

Thanks to readers Jaclin and Katelyn for alerting us to this box! Fancy is offering Mystery Boxes for only $10 (plus shipping). Each box will have a value of $30+, and you can pick the men’s or women’s box. (Use coupon code FOLLOWUP10 to save 10%!)

This box sold out I think yesterday and was just restocked, so I’m not sure how long it will be available for. Are you going to grab one?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Liz, Did you see where they’re offering more boxes in medium and large? I loved my first women’s box. Contemplating getting one of the larger sized ones.

    • Thanks for letting me know! I may have to try all the sizes now! 🙂

  2. Are these all supposed to be different things across boxes, or the same thing in each box?

    • I really hope they are different, based on another girl’s review. Whatever she received would turn me off to Fancy forever.

      • I just did a quick search and found two reviews/unboxings. Someone else posted that they got the same thing as KatyL (YUCK!), and someone else posted something totally different, which was actually cool stuff…

        My FedEx shipping lists my box as 1.5 lbs and tentative arrival date as tomorrow…

        • Mine should get here today – I’m so curious about this box! 🙂

          • I can’t remember what came in which (I got a men’s and a woman’s) but this is what I got: nail polish, head massager, 2 wall decals, card case, aqua pouch and a shave balm sample and 2 notebooks. I think they should have made them different. Maybe they are just trying to get rid of overstock. Oh well. Even though this was a little bit of a bust, I’m still keeping all my Fancy boxes as I do love them!

  3. That was THE fastest delivery of any box I’ve ever gotten! I got a text message that it had been sent, but when I opened the front door, it was already there!

    Unfortunately, the lightning quick delivery was the best thing about the box (which was huge and stuffed with interesting filler paper.)

    I got a vinyl sticker for the wall that says something like “Worker Harder and Be Humble”; a really pretty box that looked it’d have something interesting in it, which turned out to be a bright orange plastic credit card holder; two brown notebooks, one emblazoned with “Plan to Take Over the World”; and last, but not least, a China Glaze nailpolish in what looks to be a stainless steel color.

    Not bad for $10, I guess, but when you figure in the shipping, it doen’t feel like much of a bargain at all – esp. since you could’ve put this stuff in a box half the size and had room left over for something GOOD.

    I hope other folks got better stuff!

  4. IMO, Fancy is hit or miss. Hopefully this offer is a hit. I’m so glad the box was still available!

  5. I just bought one of the mens and one of the womens boxes. This is my first Fancy purchase so I’m hoping it’s good otherwise I won’t be returning. I did 2 Jewelmint surprise boxes a month or two ago and they were awful, thus I’ll never buy from them again.

  6. Well, couldn’t resist the coupon code! This will be my first Fancy box, hope they’re gentle with me.

  7. I’m hoping this 6.95 for shipping was worth it! !!

  8. I was really excited to hear about these but the shipping to the UK is $19.95, and thats per box!! I notice they also make a point of saying it is non-refundable. For a total of $29.95 for $30 I’ll definately pass. Look forward to seeing what those that did order receive though.

  9. The $8 shipping fee killed this for me too. I hope I don’t regret not getting it!

  10. This will be fun for those of us who’ve had to cancel Fancy subscriptions for budget reasons. I miss Fancy. I was a little bummed about the rip-off shipping cost, but thank you for the coupon code!

  11. I grabbed two! 🙂 One of each because I’ve never ordered from Fancy before and I thought this would be a nice way to try them out.

  12. I just ordered the women’s box. Thanks for the promo code!

  13. I absolutely LOVE all my Fancy boxes! Since my hubby is so sweet about me having a dozen or so boxes, I got him one too! I can’t wait!!

  14. I got two women’s fancy boxes, I hope they are different, these will be my first fancy boxes I’am so excited!!

  15. Thank you, Rena!! The 10% coupon worked for me as well 🙂

    • YW – every little bit helps!

  16. I don’t know if its worth $17.00 or not… maybe I should take the chance? 🙂

    • Alright, I went for it. Hope its a good one!

    • I wondered the same thing, but considering the box is supposed to be worth $30+ and there’s a little coupon code, I figured it was a good time to try it. My husband and I will enjoy opening our own mystery boxes together one evening after dinner or something so I feel like I’m kind of getting a little something out of the fact that this will be a nice little surprise even if we dislike some of the items. Perhaps the leftovers can go in the “gifting pile” heh. I left a note that this was my first time and let them know that I’m checking them out to see if I should subscribe. I hope they’ll make the extra effort!

      • Thats a fun idea! I didn’t order one for my husband- he’d rather me let him buy video games. ha

        I should have made a note in my order too.. oh well, I’m sure it will be fun regardless of what I get. 🙂

  17. Shipping is $8!!! That’s enough to keep me from buying.

    • I completely agree with you. $18 for $30 isn’t a very good deal when you have no idea what you are getting!

      • Me too… I was ready to buy for $10 but another $8 in shipping seems ridiculous.

  18. This is an awesome deal for someone who likes these kind of boxes! I’m particular about my interests though – only want beauty, baby, and food pretty much – and not random items, so this is probably not for me. 🙂

  19. I bought 1 women’s and 1 men’s box, I was able to use the 10% off code on them as well: FOLLOWUP10

    This will be our first try with Fancy Box.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!