MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

It’s here! I never got a shipping confirmation email, so I was thrilled to find the POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have box at my doorstep this morning!

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

It’s a much heavier and larger box than any other limited edition box (which is a good thing considering it cost $250).

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

A first look inside.

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

The Box:Β Neiman Marcus POPSUGAR Must Have BoxΒ (This box is no longer available. Sign up for the daily newsletter to make sure you don’t miss the next limited edition box!)

The Cost: $250

The Products:Β The box will include a cozy chevron throw and undisclosed products from eight high-end brands including items from designer Jonathan Adler and a custom Le Metier De Beaute item, designed by Ken and Lisa exclusively. (The box will have a value of over $600).

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

This box came with a fold-out card detailing every item included.

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

Chevron Patterned Throw – Value $195

There were five different color options you could get of this throw, and I think this navy and cream combo is my favorite – I lucked out! I was thinking I might gift this, but now that I have it, I’ll be keeping it for our home!

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

Jonathan Adler Zebra Stacking Dish – Value $24

This is going straight to my nightstand to keep my lip balms from rolling around!

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

Shy by Sydney Evan Love Necklace – Value $125

I normally don’t like jewelry with words, but this necklace is so dainty I love it. Plus the tiny diamond doesn’t hurt!

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

Slim & Sage Dinner Plates – Value $99

These plates are beautiful and I’m so happy that they are microwave and dishwasher safe. I didn’t even realize they were portion control plates until I read the note from POPSUGAR. From Slim & Sage’s site:

Dazzling geometric patterns set within luxe 9-inch plates hide the proportions you need to build a sensible diet: one-quarter of the plate is for lean protein, one-quarter for whole grains, and one-half is for vegetables.

Just switching from a 12 inch plate to a 9 inch plate is supposed to drastically cut the calories you eat at a meal. (Check out their science page for more info).

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

Le Metier De Beauty Pretty in Punk Eye Shadow Palette – Value $95

This palette was made exclusively for POPSUGAR – I love little perks like that in subscription boxes!

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

(A better look at the lower two colors).

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

Nest Candle in Birchwood Pine – Value $34

This is officially the best holiday candle I’ve come across this year – it smells just like a pine tree!

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

Neiman Marcus Twist White Fudge Covered Corn Snacks – Value $19

This is quite the indulgent holiday treat! It’s going straight to the gift-pile!

POPSUGAR Neiman Marcus Must Have Box Review

Oribe Dry Texturizing Spray – Value $39

I have this spray and I only use it for special occasions because it’s so pricey – I’m thrilled to have a backup!

Verdict: I paid $250 for this box and received $630 worth of high-quality luxury items. This box was so much fun to open and definitely an amazing box to gift to myself! When I bought this box a few weeks ago I assumed I’d be gifting a lot of the items for the holidays, but I think I’m going to end up keep most of these items for myself! I love getting luxury products at a deep discount!

What do you think of the Neiman Marcus POPSUGAR Must Have Box?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in POPSUGAR Must Have Box Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| 33 comments

Comments (33)

  1. I love most of this box! The throw looks so cozy and the plates are awesome. I love eating healthy so they would be perfect for me. I was disappointed w/the beauty item and I’m always into beauty products, but pink eye shadow is just not practical. you really have to have the right skin tone to pull that off. I would rather they include a luxurious skincare item. They have access to the best brands and why not indulge for the box?!? I would love to buy this years, but we will see if I can afford it. I hope I can! It would be a real treat. πŸ™‚

  2. Those chocolate corn snacks are super good! Who knew you could cover a Bugle in white chocolate!?! I might have to try to make some myself after my NM snacks are gone.

    Also, did anyone have any trouble with the plates? I got the red set. Three of four of my plates had this weird bubbling all over the surface in the glaze. One of them had the bubbling and a raised piece of black gunk (that’s under the glaze, so you can’t get it off) – stands out like a sore thumb. So, three of four plates look really bad. I feel that over time, that bubbling will start to peel/scrape and my plates will be trash.

    I emailed Popsugar about this and here’s their response: “Thanks for reaching out and we apologize that you received a damaged set of Slim & Sage plates! We’re currently looking into a resolution for this issue and will let you know as soon as one is reached. We hope you’re you’re enjoying the rest of your Neiman Marcus box!”

    Makes me wonder if this is a widespread problem with the plates? Anyone else have this issue?

  3. Have the grey/white throw if anyone wants to swap – would prefer navy, but I don’t know what the other color combos are – hit me up at [email protected] if you’re interested. πŸ™‚

    • I have the navy if you still want to trade!

  4. I got mine today as well; Friday November 15th! πŸ™‚ I love how you got navy in the throw, plates and candy dish! I got permisson in the throw; love it! I thought everyone’s plates were red but evidently they are not and I just decided to buy some white bowls and small plates a little while back to go with our red dishes and I am thrilled I got 4 gorgeous dinner plates by Slim and Sage! I got a pretty baby blue in the candy dish; thanks for the great idea to use it as a lib balms/elastics dish on my night table! LOVE my box! Glad I ordered it! πŸ™‚

  5. I bought this box with plans on giving friends and family some really nice gifts for a great value, but I think I’ll be keeping most of it! (As I write, I am wearing the necklace and munching on decadent bugles…)

    The only thing I am disappointed about receiving is the navy throw (I was hoping for any color but navy). It’s a bit preppy for me. But, since I just bought a house and have an un-decorated guest room–I guess I have my theme, navy and chevron!

  6. Funny, but I just got the email that the box was on it’s way and to my surprise, they delivered it today!

    I received the same color, navy, for the throw, plates and zebra dish. The plates are beautiful and very heavy. All the items are really nice. Truthfully, would I buy these items myself, no, but it’s a really nice splurge for me.

  7. Confession: I’m a college student who spends a lot on subscription boxes; some students will spend as much as I do on purses, but I prefer to be surprised. That being said, I bought this box. Haven’t received it yet, but I’m kind of disappointed. :/ The box is centered towards women ages 18-40 and the only thing I can see that would appeal to the younger demographic (I’m 20) is the makeup and the food (what student doesn’t want tasty food?! πŸ™‚ ) and Nov’s box included a wine tote. O.o

    I wish the NM box would’ve included more things younger women would like (maybe I’m in the minority though since most college students haven’t discovered subscription boxes yet). :/ Plus, we can’t have candles in our dorms, so some scent alternative like a diffuser would have been amazeballs. πŸ™‚

    • I’m 23, almost 24 and I would have loved this box. Truthfully, while you won’t have much use for those items in college, a couple years down the road you’ll be glad you purchased it. Time flies quickly and life after college changes drastically. I’ve gone to a ton of weddings in the last 12 months and one of my college friends already bought his first house. It’s only been a few years since we graduated, but it feels like ages. You’ll be part of the older demographic before you know it….enjoy college while you can and store this box in your closet until you need it. πŸ™‚

      • I hope so. :/ I really wish Yuzen Box came out with a box like this – I would definitely be enthralled. πŸ™‚

        However, I like that PS gives you things you can reuse, while Yuzen Box mostly contains things that you’ll run out of eventually (although I love their spa and skincare items). πŸ™‚

  8. I love the box. Love it. I was expecting more for $250 but I am satisfied that it was just higher value but same amount. I quite like everything. I got all the same colors except my zebra tray is in mustard. I would have preferred navy by far but it’s still a cute dish. The necklace is darling but extremely short – it looks more like a choker when worn. That is kind of annoying. I wish one of these sub boxes would ever include a longer dainty necklace. (Not bellybutton length – just cleavage or above length.) That said the plates are awesome – I’d actually thought about them months ago when I’d seen them online or in a magazine but the price was really offputting. So glad to get this box for my birthday!

  9. I got my box yesterday and also never received a confirmation email, so it was a very pleasant early holiday surprise! Buying such a high price box was a gamble for me, but I love almost everything! The one item I’m bummed about is the necklace- I don’t like dainty necklaces so I’m not sure if I will wear this one. But the throw is amazing, the candle smells divine and the chocolate drizzled corn chips are delicious! Even without the necklace, I am so glad I bought this box!

  10. I tried SO HARD to get this box. When I went on Popsugar’s site the night it went on sale, I didn’t realize I wasn’t signed into my account so I had to reenter all of my info and by time I got through all of it and hit Order Now it took me back to the homepage where it said the NM box was SOLD OUT. I was so crushed I even emailed them to see if there were any extras, but no. So I bought their Holiday Box and Nina Garcia’s box to feel better, hahaa!

    • Oh, and I happen to think this box is lovely! I hope all of you who were fortunate enough to snag one enjoy πŸ™‚

  11. I can’t wait to see what colors I get. I already have the November Must Have box (awesome) but now I want this box ASAP!

  12. I can’t wait to get mine now that you have yours. It says it hasn’t mailed, but checked the reference # with Fed Ex and it sitting in Utah since Sunday! Wish it would get a move on!!! LOL until then I will enjoy your pics!!!! : ). Thanks, Liz

  13. Great looking items but the box was just too expensive for me to buy.

  14. Love it all! I’m ok that I passed on the box (just seemed too expensive for a bunch of unknowns!) but I will live vicariously through you + everyone else who posts reviews πŸ˜‰

  15. I am ridiculously envious but I just couldn’t afford it. I actually like the color-coordinating (in my case, the multitude of navy would have been perfect!). Maybe next time…

  16. I got my box today and I love it. Your right that candle smells amazing. I got the nay throw as well. My zebra dish came in green and my dishes came in red. I was wondering does the necklace fit you. Mine is like a choker and doesn’t even lay right on my neck. Is anyone else having this problem? I did email PopSugar about this and about maybe them sending an extender or something. Still waiting to hear back.

  17. So jealous of this box, but I simply couldn’t afford it!

  18. I got the exact same colored items. I was a little frustated that the plates, dish and throw were all navy. I emailed Popsugar to see if there was any chance I could exchange for different colors and they pretty much said “nope”. Oh well…it was worth a try!

    • I have not recieived my box yet but, I would be willing to trade anything if i get different colors

    • I’d trade someone my yellow dish for navy or black if in San Diego. πŸ™‚

    • I have the grey/white throw if you’d want to swap! I think my dish is green.

      • I have the navy throw if you want to trade!

    • I have the orange/white chevron throw and the turquoise zebra dish if anyone wants to trade.

      • Possibly interested in swapping my grey/white throw for an orange/white throw and my navy zebra dish for a turquoise zebra dish if you’re interested – waiting to hear back from another subscriber.

        Please e-mail me at [email protected] if you are – thanks!

      • Are you still interested in trading throws? I have the navy!

      • I have the navy throw if you want to trade!

      • Cassandra, did you want the orange/white throw? Mine is still in the bag and I am willing to trade.

      • Hi Dawn, yes! I would love to trade. My navy is still in the bag too. Email me: [email protected]

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.