Ipsy September 2013 Review

I was really disappointed, I received a terrible pinky/taupe chalk looking lipstick, the eyeliner, a charcoal eyeshadow, under eye gels and mascara, well I have way enough mascara and eyeliner. It would’ve been nice to receive the lipgloss (which was a much better color) than the awful lipstick and the nail lacquer. You really can’t go wrong with nail polish. I finally decided to cancel since I found (for just $2.00 more) another subscription that caters better to my profile and I have been able to use everything from that box.

I got
~ NYX in “Beauty Queen” which are browns…love
~ the mascara…love
~ Jesses Girl black liquid liner…not sure yet
~Cailyn full size lip balm…love
~ a “J. Cats” full size lipstick in honey crisp …adore!

I got everything you did except the Butter London (I got paper face masks). I have been working my way up to red lipstick and wore the Cailyn stuff today and really liked it!

My bag came in yesterday. I got the Poppy color in the eye shadow. Meh, it’s ok, but would rather get the other colors mentioned. I do like the color of he Pop crayon, Rose Romance, and will be using that. Black eye liner pencil that I won’t use (I use liquid.) I can’t wait to try these eye gel pads. I think the best part of this box, is the too cute blue bag!

We got completely identical bags except I got a different eye shadow. I LOVE the nail polish, it was the only thing I was really excited for. I love Ipsy but I’ve been really iffy the past couple bags. The actual bag is definitely my favorite part.

http://fromonejourneytothenext.blogspot.com/2013/09/ipsy-september-2013-classic-beauty.html

GRRRRR – please for the love of God, no more shampoo, black eyeliners or mascara, Ipsy!

Sooooo bummed that – AS ALWAYS – I didn’t get Cailyn. I love that brand and I’ve been dying to try that lipgloss. I didn’t get Butter nail polish either. My bag had shampoo and conditioner, sparkly white eyeshadow (sigh), black eyeliner (for the 9 millionth time) and mascara (for the 9 millionth time).

It’s still an awesome bag considering it was only $10, though. I’ll give them that.

Meh…I just received my bag today. For the first time, I’m honestly disappointed. Ipsy has sent me eyeliner AND mascara in every bag since I subscribed (like 7 months) – and the thing is, I don’t wear eye makeup, and my profile reflects that. All I do have in my profile is lip stick, lip gloss nail polish, yet this month I received Eyeliner, Mascara, Eyeshadow, a nude colored lipstick, and 3 face masks. If it weren’t for the awesome little bags, I would cancel. I’m not sure what else to do to fix what they send me – I even retook the quiz…Man I would have loved that nail polish and lip balm.

I’m so annoyed I didn’t get the Butter London, because I keep getting eyeliner every month. And every time it is black. If it was different neat and experimental colors, I wouldn’t mind so much. But I love my black liquid liner and don’t care for black eyeliners sent to me month after month. I got the shampoo/conditioner bottles, bright white NYX shadow, the liner, and mascara.

You got lucky with a Butter London! I haven’t got mine yet, but I’m pretty happy with what I see in my glam room. Looks like a good month.

No Butter mini for me. 🙁

This was my first month and I am disappointed. I will be receiving the John Frieda Shampoo and Conditioner which count as 2 items. I won’t use either and it took up an additional spot of another brand I would have loved to try. these were the only two items I was not interested in at all and I got stuck with them. My other variation item was the Starlooks Eye Pencil. I will stick out for a few months and hope it gets better, but not off on a good start.

I got lip pop crayon that I already got in something else and a highlighter pencil instead of the nail polish and lip tint. This was my first bag. I had to wait 5 weeks or so seemed like forever

I got the nyx eye shadow in this awesome shimmery white as well as 3 face masks instead of the nail polish! PLUS i got an em cosmetics life palette sample. did you not get that in yours???

Seeing everyone else’s wait times is helpful. I have been sitting on the wait list for 5 weeks now. 🙁 It only took me four hours with Birhbox (plus like 8 days before my first box shipped). Even with Goodie, it was only like a 2-3 week wait.

I can’t wait to start getting Ipsy though! The bags looks much better than my last two BB.

I received an eyebrow pencil rather than the Butter London, may have to go buy some. My NYX eye shadow is called Velvet Suede, it’s very pretty. By the way I love your site and check it out several times a day, thanks.

I don’t have my bag yet, but I am NOT getting Butter London, which I have to admit makes me mad since I didn’t get the Urban Decay last month! I did go to Ulta today to get my 2 Butter London’s for $10 each.

I was debating if I was going to cancel or keep ipsy. This month helped me decide to keep it.
http://50thingsbeforeiturn50.com/2013/09/14/my-september-ipsy-glam-bag/

Still waiting and I love that bag!

I got the eyeliner and mascara too. As well as a pop lip crayon in romantic rose, a chella ivory lace highlighter crayon, some light NYX shadow and a sample of life palette makeup. First bag! Very happy – counting down the days to next month!!

Ipsy is going to be my next subscription box, based on your reviews.

PS – I love your site!!!

Eek! I want this but I’m on the waitlist. 🙁
Anyone know how long you usually sit there?

I also received eyeliner and mascara. I cannot have enough black eyeliner (especially with fall and winter coming up). The eyeshadow that I received was a yellow (golden poppy) and broken. They are sending a replacement. The email ststed that they cannot guarantee what color I would receive, so I’m hoping for a different color.  I also received the eye firming pads (2 pkgs) and the Pop crayon in Romantic Rose. The Pop crayon is way too light for me. The polish looks like a great color for Fall. I wished I received a bottle. Even though there were items I couldn’t use, the eyeliner was worth the $10 that I spent for the bag (so everything else is a bonus).

This is only my second bag and so far I’m impressed. Thanks for sharing all your reviews!!