I’ve always been the kind of dog mom who reads every ingredient label and double-checks every “healthy” claim before feeding my pup. For years, I thought kibble with “premium” stamped on the bag was enough—until my dog started dealing with constant paw licking, messy poop, and a dull coat. That’s when I started learning about raw feeding and how a minimally processed, species-appropriate diet could make a huge difference in my dog’s health.
When I decided to make the switch, two brands kept coming up: We Feed Raw and Maev. Both are fresh raw food subscriptions, both promise human-grade ingredients, and both ship straight to your door. But after testing them side by side, the differences became pretty clear.
Why Choose Raw?
Before we get into results, here's the key distinction:
Raw dog food is made from uncooked meat, bones, and organs. It’s minimally processed and preserves all the natural nutrients, enzymes, and amino acids that dogs need to thrive.
Cooked dog food is cooked at low temperatures. While it’s cleaner than kibble, heat breaks down many of the raw benefits. You’re left with something that’s convenient – but not optimal.
Ingredients & Processing: We Feed Raw Is the Cleanest Option
Both We Feed Raw and Maev are raw, which means no heat is used in processing, and nutrients are preserved naturally. But when I dug into the ingredients, We Feed Raw pulled ahead.
We Feed Raw uses USDA-certified human-grade meat, organs, and bone, with nothing extra. They also use cold-pressure technology to eliminate pathogens without heat, so the food is safe while still keeping all the natural enzymes intact. It’s essentially the closest thing to what dogs would eat in the wild.
Maev, on the other hand, looked good on paper but included extras that felt unnecessary. While they market it as functional (with supplements built in), my dog didn’t seem to respond to it the same way—almost like it was more about presentation than results. In theory, those extras should help, but in practice, I didn’t see the same measurable benefits.
Health Benefits: We Feed Raw Showed the Biggest Improvements
This was the biggest difference.
Within just one week of feeding We Feed Raw, my dog’s digestion totally changed—firmer, smaller poop (a dog mom dream), fresher breath, and no more constant paw chewing. By week four, I noticed a shinier coat, consistent energy, and even an improved mood. It felt like I had a whole new dog.
Maev unfortunately caused some digestive upset early on. I stuck with it to see if things would even out, but my pup never seemed fully comfortable on it. While not terrible, it just didn’t deliver the dramatic improvements I was hoping for. With raw feeding, you want noticeable changes—and We Feed Raw made those obvious.
Convenience: Tie.
Both brands ship frozen food to your door and offer custom meal plans based on a quick online quiz.
We Feed Raw’s perfectly portioned packs were the easiest for me—just thaw and serve. Maev uses scoopable frozen pellets, which can be a little messier but still workable. If you like flexibility in serving sizes, pellets may appeal to you. But if you’re like me and want no measuring, no fuss, pre-portioned packs are the way to go.
Both also offer subscription management online, so pausing or adjusting shipments is simple. That kind of flexibility makes sticking to raw feeding way more sustainable long term.
Price: We Feed Raw Is the Best Value
Here’s what I paid:
- We Feed Raw: $3.51/meal
- Maev: $5.88/meal
Not only is We Feed Raw more affordable, but it also actually worked. Considering I’m saving money on supplements and fewer vet visits, the value was a no-brainer. Feeding my pup something that keeps him healthier now feels like an investment in avoiding problems down the road.
Taste & Protein Variety: We Feed Raw Is a Crowd Favorite
While I obviously didn’t taste the food myself (lol), my dog absolutely did – and his excitement for We Feed Raw was on another level. He devoured every meal, licked the bowl clean, and even started sitting by the fridge at dinnertime.
I also loved that We Feed Raw offers a variety of proteins like beef, chicken, turkey, lamb, and duck. I started with beef and turkey and plan to rotate for variety. It’s an easy way to keep meals interesting and avoid ingredient fatigue.
Maev has a smaller protein lineup, and none of them got the same tail-wagging enthusiasm I saw with We Feed Raw.
Final Verdict: We Feed Raw Wins
Both We Feed Raw and Maev are better than kibble or traditional cooked dog food—but in my experience, We Feed Raw was the clear winner. The clean ingredients, visible health improvements, affordability, and ease of use all made it the brand I stuck with.
If you’re deciding between the two top raw options, my advice is simple: go with We Feed Raw. Your pup’s digestion, skin, coat, and overall health will thank you. And honestly? Seeing your dog thrive and knowing you’re doing the best for them feels amazing as a pet parent.
