As someone who lives for freshening up my wardrobe, the start of a new year feels like the perfect time to lean into layering cozy, chic pieces. I’ve tried a few personal styling services to help me achieve that polished-yet-comfortable winter look, and two of the big names—Wantable and Stitch Fix—stood out.
While both offer curated clothing delivered straight to your door, there’s definitely a clear winner when I compare them side by side.
If you want more pieces to choose from… Wantable
One major perk of Wantable that stood out to me is the sheer number of items you receive. Each Edit includes 7 pieces to try on at home, while Stitch Fix only sends 5. As someone who loves options, I really appreciated this extra variety. It gave me more to work with and made the experience feel more indulgent.
When my first Edit from Wantable arrived, I was blown away. It felt like my stylist had been lurking in my Pinterest boards (in the best way). Every piece matched my style, from perfectly oversized flannels to joggers that work for errands or lounging.
Stitchfix, on the other hand… let’s just say I wasn’t too impressed.
If you need more time to decide… Wantable
Both services offer free shipping and include a prepaid return label, but Wantable edges ahead with its hassle-free process. From the packaging to the instructions, returning items I didn’t love (a rare occurrence!) was straightforward. Knowing I had 5 days to decide also made the process feel less rushed.
Stitch Fix’s system worked fine, but the shorter return window (3 days) added unnecessary stress. Wantable’s customer-first approach truly elevated the experience.
If you need help defining your style… Both
Both Wantable and Stitch Fix start with a style quiz designed to get a sense of what you love to wear. I appreciated that each quiz asked thoughtful questions about my body type, budget, and personal preferences. The quizzes felt personalized and helped me reflect on my style—do I lean preppy? Edgy? Casual?
The Wantable quiz stood out slightly for its expert curation. The way the questions flowed made me feel like I was working with someone who truly “got” my fashion personality. Still, Stitch Fix’s quiz wasn’t far behind.
If you love getting a deal… Wantable
Let’s talk about pricing. With Wantable, if you decide to keep 5 or more items from your box, you’ll get a 20% discount on your total. This felt generous and encouraged me to consider keeping more pieces—especially since I loved almost everything!
Stitch Fix only offers a discount if you keep all 5 items. In my experience, it’s rare to love every single piece in a box, so I often ended up missing out on the discount entirely. Wantable’s policy felt more flexible and rewarding.
If you want to have a human-touch… Wantable
One thing I’ve learned: human stylists + algorithms = the most personalization. Wantable takes the edge here because real human stylists curate every Edit based on your quiz responses, special requests, and feedback with a little help from algorithms. My stylist seemed to understand my need for versatile winter pieces—sweaters perfect for layering, cozy flannels, and even a jacket that transitioned seamlessly from errands to evenings out. The selections felt thoughtful, like my stylist had taken the time to choose each piece for me specifically.
Stitch Fix uses a mix of stylists and algorithms as well, but it seems like they’re missing the mark. While my box included a few cute pieces, the overall vibe felt generic. It didn’t quite capture the aesthetic I was hoping for. Wantable’s human touch made all the difference, and it showed in the clothes I received.
Final Verdict: Wantable is the perfect addition to my closet
While Stitch Fix has its merits, my experience with Wantable was simply better. From the thoughtful selections by real stylists to the flexible return policy and better discounts, Wantable clearly prioritized my needs as a customer. Plus, getting to try 7 items instead of 5 gave me more chances to find pieces I truly loved.
If you’re ready to refresh your wardrobe and want a personal styling service that feels, well, personal, Wantable is the way to go. With cozy, curated styles and a process that puts your preferences first, it’s a no-brainer for anyone looking to elevate their look this season.
