As a mom of four, I’ve learned to streamline everything. Between school drop-offs, sports practices, and last-minute snack runs, there’s just no time left for mall trips or trying on outfits under fluorescent lights while a toddler tugs at my leg. That’s why personal styling services have been a lifesaver. I’ve tried both Wantable and Stitch Fix, and while both claim to simplify shopping, only one truly delivers for my everyday life.
Here’s how they stack up so you can decide which one’s worth your closet space.
If you want a quiz that actually understands your style... Wantable
The style quiz is the first impression, and Wantable nailed it. It asked thoughtful questions about fit, comfort, lifestyle, and even how I like clothes to feel. It made me feel like a real person, not just a checkbox.
I could tell my stylist actually read my answers. My first Edit felt handpicked by someone who understood my style goals. With Stitch Fix, the quiz felt a little more basic, and so did the selections. Some hits, but a lot of misses.
If you want more to choose from in each box... Wantable
Wantable gives you 9 pieces in every Edit. Stitch Fix? You’ll get anywhere from 5 to 8, usually 5 in my experience.
Nine pieces may not sound like a big difference, but it gives you way more flexibility. I love that I can try different styles, fits, and even colors I wouldn’t normally pick up at the store without feeling locked into anything. More variety = more chances to find something I love.
If you want a real connection with your stylist... Wantable
Wantable uses real human stylists who actually get to know you over time. I can leave detailed notes before each Edit, and I’ve seen my stylist make changes based on my feedback, like cutting back on crop tops and adding more comfy-chic layering pieces.
With Stitch Fix, it felt like I was starting from scratch with every box. There was less of that ongoing relationship and more of a “hope this works” vibe. I don’t have time for that kind of guesswork.
If you need more time to try things on... Wantable
Wantable gives you 5 full days to try everything on at home. That means I can test how things fit, get feedback from my 9-year-old style advisor, and mix pieces with things I already own without feeling rushed.
Stitch Fix’s default try-on window is only 3 days. Sure, you can request an extension, but who wants to jump through extra hoops when your life is already packed? Wantable’s generous window makes the whole process feel relaxed and doable.
If you're shopping for the whole family... Stitch Fix
This is the one category where I’ll give Stitch Fix the edge. Both Wantable and Stitch Fix offer men’s styling (which my husband has tried and liked!), but only Stitch Fix offers a kids' option. So if you’re looking to outfit your entire crew from one place, including the little ones, Stitch Fix has you covered.
If you love curated, themed Edits... Wantable
Wantable’s Themed Edits are a total highlight. Whether it’s a Fall Forecast, Country Girl, or How to Denim Edit, these boxes feel like little seasonal wardrobe upgrades. It takes the pressure off trying to stay on trend. I just pick a theme and let my stylist take it from there.
Stitch Fix doesn’t offer themed boxes, which makes their selections feel more generic. I’ve come to love the surprise of seeing what my Wantable stylist curated around a fun, timely vibe.
Final Verdict: Wantable fits my lifestyle best 👏
Wantable isn’t just another clothing box; it’s felt more personal than anything else I’ve tried. With 9 items per Edit, a smarter quiz, real stylists who listen, and a generous try-on window, getting dressed has genuinely become easier and more enjoyable.
If you're looking to refresh your closet and feel more confident in your clothes, Wantable has been the best fit for me, and it might be for you too.
