If there’s one thing I’ve learned as a dog parent, it’s this: not all dog food is created equal.
I used to think kibble was just the norm—like it was the only way to feed a dog. But then I noticed my dog turning up his nose, getting bored with the same old meals, and dealing with random tummy troubles. That’s when I started paying way more attention to what’s actually in his food.
On one side, you’ve got classic kibble like Blue Buffalo. On the other? Sundays for Dogs—a fresh, air-dried alternative. I put them both to the test and after watching my pup’s reaction (and checking those ingredient lists), I found that one brand was the clear winner.
Let’s break it down to see which truly delivers the best for your dog.
If you want fresh food with real, human-grade ingredients, go for Sundays.
Sundays for Dogs completely outshines Blue Buffalo in ingredient quality. Sundays is fresh food made with 100% real meat and superfoods. I’m talking human-grade beef, chicken, turkey, and healthy add-ins like pumpkin, blueberries, and ginger.
While better than many grocery-store brands, Blue Buffalo still relies on meat meals and by-products in some of its formulas. Sure, they avoid artificial preservatives and fillers, but when you compare it side by side with Sundays’ air-dried whole meat pieces, it’s not even close.
If you want a meal that your pup will love, go for Sundays.
If you’ve got a picky eater, you know the struggle. I’ve watched my dog turn up his nose at plenty of kibbles (even ones labeled "chicken & rice"), but Sundays? Gone in seconds.
Sundays has a jerky-like texture that actually looks and smells like real food. It’s gently air-dried, which locks in flavor and makes it way more appetizing than kibble.
Blue Buffalo? It’s classic kibble, dry, crunchy, and coated in flavoring. Some dogs love it, but if yours has a more refined palate (ahem my dog), they might not be as excited.
If you want effortless feeding, it’s a tie!
When it comes to convenience, both Sundays and Blue Buffalo are equally easy to serve.
With Sundays, you scoop and serve straight from the bag—no prep, mixing, or refrigeration required. The air-dried pieces are ready to eat, and since they’re dry but still have some moisture, you don’t have to add water. With Blue Buffalo, you also scoop and serve.
At the end of the day, both options are just as simple.
If you want maximum nutrition, go for Sundays.
Sundays is crafted by a vet and nutritionist team, ensuring that every bite is packed with essential nutrients, vitamins, and high-quality protein. Unlike the high-heat extrusion used for kibble, the air-drying process preserves these nutrients.
To its credit, Blue Buffalo offers grain-free and limited-ingredient formulas, but their processing methods still strip away some of the natural benefits of whole foods. Plus, they have had a few recall scares in the past—something to keep in mind.
My Pick: Sundays for Dogs Wins (And It’s Not Even Close)
After testing both, I can confidently say Sundays for Dogs is the better choice. The human-grade ingredients, air-dried nutrition, and treat-like taste make a noticeable difference—both in my pup’s excitement at mealtime and how good I feel about what I’m feeding him.
Blue Buffalo is a solid option if you want a budget-friendly, widely available kibble, but when it comes to quality, digestion, and overall enjoyment, Sundays pulls ahead. It’s fresh food that is easy to store and serve.
And honestly, seeing my dog run to his bowl every time I opened Sundays bag made the decision easy.
