My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

The 5 Best Fishing Subscription Boxes in 2021

Anna Reilly
ByAnna ReillyJul 22, 2021 | 1 comment

Fishing is a relaxing, fulfilling pastime — but the goal is to actually catch something, and without the right equipment, you’ll waste a lot of hours waiting for a bite. The right fishing subscription box can help you spend your time more effectively.

On this list, you’ll find a variety of fishing subscriptions to delight anglers of all ages and skill levels. We’ve included promo links and coupon codes wherever possible, along with detailed information about the benefits (and in some cases, drawbacks) of each option.

If we missed one of your favorite subscriptions, let us know in the comments. We also have a full list of outdoor subscription boxes for more great subscriptions.

1. Mystery Tackle Box - Our Favorite Fishing Subscription Box Overall

Cost: Plans start at $16.99 per month. Subscribe here!

Why we love it: Fun and affordable, Mystery Tackle Box is a great way to try new gear and sharpen your fishing expertise.

Choose your preferred fish species and budget, and you’ll receive a selection of lures, tackles, and baits. Mystery Tackle Box offers options for bass, inshore saltwater, walleye, panfish, catfish, trout, and ice fishing, and you can change to a different box at any time.

The items in this fishing subscription box are hand-selected by real fishing professionals, and it frequently features state-of-the-art lures to help you make the most of every trip. Subscribers also receive access to how-to videos, and each box includes helpful tips from experts.

Mystery Tackle Box earns our top recommendation for their low pricing and expert curation. Ideal for gifting, this service helps subscribers explore new brands, and they ship over 2 million baits each year. The boxes deliver a great value — the $16.99 box has a retail value of about $25, while the larger boxes deliver additional savings. Subscriptions can be cancelled or modified at any time.

Check out our Mystery Tackle Box reviews and details for more information on subscribing. Ships to the US.

2. Lucky Tackle Box - A Fishing Subscription for Baits, Lures, and More

Cost: Starts at $16.99 a month. Subscribe here!

About This Fishing Subscription Box: Lucky Tackle Box also features multiple subscription options based on your level of expertise and your preferred fishing style. Options include bass, crappie, panfish, trout, ice fishing, inshore salt, multi-species, walleye, and fly fishing.

Lucky Tackle Box includes up to 6 items in each box, along with a link to online videos with tips and techniques for each included fishing product. This subscription is similar to Mystery Tackle Box, right down to the pricing — some reviewers note that Lucky Tackle Box offers a slightly better overall value per box on average, but since the selection changes from month to month, that’s not guaranteed. If you’re buying for yourself, we’d recommend checking our past boxes from Lucky Tackle Box and Mystery Tackle Box, then choosing the option that’s most aligned with your fishing style. Either way, you’ll find useful products for landing that legendary catch.

Check out our Lucky Tackle Box reviews and details page for more information on subscribing. Ships to the US and Canada for free.

3. Postfly Box - A Fishing Subscription Box for Premium Flies


Cost: Starts at $16.50 per month. Subscribe here!

ACTIVE DEAL: Save 10% off!

About This Fishing Subscription Box: Looking for premium flies? This box is stocked with top picks for trout, bass, and saltwater fly fishing. In addition to 12-15 trout flies or 4-6 bass/warm water or saltwater flies, you’ll get a monthly custom sticker and tips from the Postfly team. This fishing subscription box also includes tying kits and other gear, but the premium flies are the real selling point.

As we’ve discussed, Postfly is specifically for fly fishing. If you’re buying this box as a gift, make sure the recipient is familiar with fly fishing (as opposed to bait fishing, spinning, or trolling). If you’re buying for yourself, you already know whether this is the fishing subscription box for you — happy angling!

Check out our Postfly reviews and details page for more information on subscribing. Ships worldwide.

4. Red Tuna Shirt Club - Fun T-Shirts for Celebrating Your Love of Fishing

Cost: $22.00 per month. Subscribe here!

ACTIVE DEAL: Save 10% off!

About This Fishing Subscription Box: Fishing isn’t just a hobby, it’s a lifestyle. If you’ve already filled your tacklebox with lures and baits, Red Tuna Shirt Club offers something different: Each month, this service delivers a new shirt from a different fishing charter. There are options for long-sleeved shirts, pocket tees, and 2X-5x shirts.

The quality of the apparel is consistently high, and this makes a great gift for the fisher who has (almost) everything. You’ll find prepaid options, so if you’re giving this box to a friend or family member, you won’t have to worry about cancelling the subscription.

Find out more on our Red Tuna Shirt Club reviews and details page. Ships to US only.

5. The Sportsman's Box - A Hunting & Fishing Subscription Box for Outdoor Living

best fishing subscription box

Cost: Starts at $40 a month. Subscribe here!

About This Fishing Subscription Box: The Sportsman’s Box caters to people who love the outdoors, and many of its selections focus on hunting — there’s a lot of overlap between anglers and hunters, but if you’re not interested in field sprays, you’re better off with a fishing-specific box.

With that said, everything in the Sportsman’s Box has been field tested, and the company’s curators put a lot of time into each selection. You’ll get tools, baits, tackles, apparel, and a variety of accessories. Choose from three options: The Starter (2-3 items), The Original (3-5 items), or The Denali (4-6 premium items). The Denali includes game cameras, solar lanterns, and other high-end gadgets, but all subscription levels include some fishing supplies.

Sportsman’s Box isn’t for everyone, but if you love spending time outdoors, this subscription will give you an excuse to start planning your next trip. Members also get discounts on products from top brands. If you’re giving this hunting & fishing subscription box to someone else, you can send a gift card via email with no additional processing fees.

Find out more on our Sportsman's Box reviews and details page. Ships to the US and Canada.


Which box has reeled you in? Let us know in the comments!

Anna Reilly
Anna Reilly
Anna loves collecting little treasures, be they pop-culture finds, handmade mementos, or new potions to put in her makeup bag. Beauty boxes got her interested in the subscription world, but now she's swooning for all things kawaii!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

1 comment


Tried buying a Lucky Tackle Box subscription but the discount code didn’t work (SAVE5)

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike