Facebook PixelIpsy Glam Bag Ultimate May 2021 Choice Time! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Ipsy Glam Bag X May 2021 Choice Time!

MSA
ByMSAMay 3, 2021 | 215 comments

IPSY Glam Bag x
2.7 overall rating
21 Ratings | 23 Reviews

It’s time to pick some of the items for your May 2021 Ipsy Glam Bag X! Glam Bag X is a quarterly, limited edition upgrade to your monthly IPSY membership. Check out the full Glam Bag X announcement here.

Here’s what my May bag looks like for one of our accounts:

 

Which products are you picking?

And if you are new to the regular Ipsy, it is a $12 a month beauty and makeup subscription box. Check out all of our Ipsy reviews to see what’s been in past boxes. And check out our Ipsy Spoilers to see what’s coming up in future boxes! Ipsy Glam Bag Plus is $25 a month. Check out our Ipsy Glam Bag Plus reviews to see what you can expect each month. Ipsy Glam Bag X is $55 a month. It's an additional $43/shipment for Glam Bag members and $30/shipment for Glam Bag Plus members. 

Starting at $55.00
Subscribe Now
Ipsy Glam Bag X is a quarterly upgrade is available for Ipsy Glam Bag and Ipsy Glam Bag Plus subscribers. It’s an additional $43/shipment for Glam Bag members and $30/shipment for Glam Bag Plus members. The first Glam Bag X will be available in February 2021.
MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

215 comments

Kenley

There must have been quite a few people cancel. I just signed up for the August bag and it says I have secured my spot for August. I didn’t have to be put on a waitlist.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marjorie

Just received my Glam Bag X and it is missing three out of the seven products. How does that even happen? I’m done with Ipsy. There isn’t even an easy way to contact them.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Gwen Hill

you can also rech ipsy care through messenger and you should have a reply back with in the hour. my may glam bag x never arrived their sending out a replacement within 15 days so basically by July ill have mays…..ugh

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Dinah

Wow, that’s crazy that a lot have missing products. I haven’t even received mine yet. It’s been in limbo since the 10th.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

h

Mine hasn’t arrived yet, either. This is constantly happening…the response is to have to wait either 10 or 15 WORKING days, then contact them again to discover that everything you chose and expected is out of stock, but they will send you something awesome that they already sent you two times, so that now you can have 3 pieces of some unknown makeup company’s blush trio or tumeric mask…woo hoo!

Like This CommentLike

Connie

I had also had missing products. My box was actually opened and taped back up so I’m not so sure it was ipsy fault or not. However I contacted them they responded less then 24 hours my missing products are on there way. They were really good about it. I do understand the frustration I felt the same way. I’m happy with how fast they responded and the way they made it right

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Shiloe Tramp

I was missing two items as well… but you can contact them. I got a response via email within 24 hours and replacement products sent out with tracking code within 48 hours. Look on the website for IpsyCare and go through the process of getting in touch with them.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marjorie

Sorry you had missing items also. I contacted them immediately. I was told that they will ship the replacement products within 15 working days so it might be a full month before they arrive. I am kind of over it now. Just disappointing because I had been really excited to receive my first Glam Bag X box.

Like This CommentLike

Kenley

I really want the CT cream the most. I have been stalking EBay and Mercari hoping to grab one, but everyone is wanting to sell it for 60+ dollars 🙄 Already paid $60 for the bag and I’m not going to spend another $60 to get one product. Here’s to hoping August is better

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marion

Plot twist! Instead of what I was supposed to get:
– ABH brow in Blonde
– Ole Henriksen banana eye cream
– One/Size palette

I received:
– ABH brow in Ebony (still not the right shade lol)
– Rodial Cleansing Balm
– Charlotte Tilbury cream!

While my eyes got super big when I opened up the box & saw the CT cream (my family even commented on my expression) this does bring the number of usable products in my box down to a whopping 3. (Although we realized we don’t have a mirror in our classroom at work, so I may get more use out of the mirror than I thought). What’s weird is that I have heard about some people getting the incorrect Choice items this month, while all my Choice items were correct, & it was the Ipsy-picked items that were wrong. I’ve sent IpsyCare an email with a photo, so we’ll see how they respond.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marion

Received my 2 replacements today, 2 weeks later. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Dinah

Ooooh, that’s awesome! I hope I get a plot twist box too lol

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jennifer

That happened to my Feb X. They substituted *four* products on me (including swapping out the Huda Rose Gold palette for the Bell En Argent Plum Premonition from a Plus bag,) and partially refunded two. They claimed this was because they were “Sold out” – but the refunded items were currently still selling one item in shop bundles, and sold the lash serum in April as an add-on, so hardly sold out.

It looks like what they did is just swap most of the stuff with a different brand or semi-similar item, and refund anything that didn’t have a close enough replacement on hand.

In the end, I ony got *two* of my box items – the Patrick Ta brow wax and the Creme shop peach and argan oil face oil stuff.

I regret not insisting they send me a pre-paid shipping label to mail it back for a refund, as they can’t legally require you to accept substitutes.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marion

I’ve been told that I’ll be getting replacements for the ABH brow pen & the Ole Henriksen eye cream, but there are no more One/Size palettes, so I’ll get a partial refund of $10.77.

That puts me back at 4 usable items from the bag (IF the Blonde brow pen works for me… Soft Brown might be better), & the price down to $50 instead of $60. I probably wouldn’t buy a bundle of these items at that price if it were an Ipsy Offer, but, yeah, still a reasonable discount. I guess I’m just surprised that I’m a little disappointed by not getting a new palette to play with, considering I don’t have much interest in the One/Size brand.

Like This CommentLike

Leslie

I wasn’t able to pick my stuff and ended up with a box with mostly stuff I don’t like but I am pretty upset with the Olaplex! If you read the directions you have to buy the No 3 product and use it with the 0 and it cost 28 dollars! So I either have to spend another 30 bucks or one of my products is worthless. This is my first X and it will be my last.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Dinah

INFO ON OLAPLEX: According to their website, you can absolutely use #0 on it’s own. It will serve as a repair. So if you received this you can still use it if you’d like.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Veronica

I am happy about the 111. The face wash I am curious to try but like my other skin care friends out here other than that I didn’t get the mask or the CT lotion. I also was shocked I got the ONE eyeshadow when I marked no adventurous shades. I was hoping for Anastasia palette if I had to get one. I guess after seeing the Herbivore mask and then eye cream, banana products… I was hoping for any of those. I wanted the CBD but had to give it up for something else. Excited to try the collegen powder. I canceled. Just really wanted one of the hot skin care items. So jelly of the ladies that got both the cream and mask. Lucky you guys 😍

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Veronica

I just wanted to update wasn’t sure how to delete my old comment to make this one.
So I got my bag and for the people that weren’t sure about the face soap it was hard to get out but super nice on the skin and unique. I really like it.
The 111 smells yummy and I love it. Leaves a nice shimmer.
I got the setting spray as a choice and I know that will be good.
The mascara seems very high quality. Super heavy tube. The packaging is nice.
Although I didn’t want the OS palette it is also good quality. I will use it.
I still canceled since its such a gamble to get what each of us really wanted. So even if you don’t get the Herbivore or face lotion, I think the other items are nice. I can’t say I’ve ever had an ipsy bag I absolutely hated. One way or another I like them. Maybe we can buy Herbivore or face lotion later 🤷🏼‍♀️

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Kate

Not impressed, glad I canceled. Miiight re-join in August, because August is my birthday month, if spoilers are good. I did get the February box and liked it.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Kimberly Sifford

I really wanted the Herbivore, if anyone wants to trade, I would trade multiples! I still have the HUDA palette from last Glam X and Banana Bright Eye Cream ( Would love to try, but am on overload of eye creams!) OR Kosas Mascara (LOVE this Mascara…I am a Mascara addict..so I can part with one 🙂 haha)

I am happy with my Glam Bag X choices, I got several items I wanted..also several I had marked rarely..haha..but I the value outweighs so I will take it!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Autumn P

I’m NOT saying the value isn’t there. BUT…NO! I would be pis$ed about this one…

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Stephanie L.

Well said! I wish I didn’t fall for the bait and switch. And the people who got great boxes (CT, Herbivore, OH) are almost rubbing it in and making those of us who got a horrible selections feel even worse. The inequity in this box is awful, and that’s on Ipsy. So glad FFF is now 100% customization, so we can all be happy with what we got!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Rachel

My box is TERRIBLE. I didn’t get anything I wanted and I resubscribed just for this box. I really wanted herbivore or CT but would have settled for Kosas… Didn’t even get that.

Like This CommentLike

Sophia

I am ok but certainly not excited about the glam bag X and not sure if I will repeat it in august. I knew CR scrub would be a choice item, which I use already, and its $53 price tag would justify the bag and everything else would be extra. The extra is uninspiring. . .
111skin (uhh)
OS palette (not my color but already swapped in MSA)
RMS (interesting)
Rodial (some interest to try)
Tower 28 lip jelly (no)
CR scrub (my only real reason to get this)
Dr Brandt vacuum cleaner (i just finished this, it’s ok but not the best mask)
Route Beauty party peel (unexciting for me)

Having ipsy for a few years, I knew things like the CT, which was in basically every promo for the X bag, would only be sent to a handful of people. They always do this. I just wish that something that is $55 and only comes 4/x a year would leave me giddy or excited.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marion

” I just wish that something that is $55 and only comes 4/x a year would leave me giddy or excited.”

Well stated! Ipsy tried its best to generate buzz for this bag by posting about it ad nauseum, but the reality was not that exciting.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jessica

Im so happy with what I got. I got the Anastasia brow pen in blonde which is right, the magic cream, ole Hendrickson eye creme, color wow, kopari balm, tower 28 in the shade i wanted and of course the 111 skin. Its my first X box and im extremely pleased. I wish everyone loved theirs. Its the worst when u get a bunch of products u hate. Thats why I canceled boxycharm bcuz I always hated what they sent.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Dom

I got the Herbivore but wanted the CT the most.

I see that a lot of people here are curious about the CT cream and wanted to try it. I’ve used it before and I love it. It instantly made my skin feel so much softer, much faster than any other moisturizer I’ve tried. I loved the way it felt. With that being said, I do think it is overpriced and could never justify the full price of it. But CT does a lot of full size GWP which often includes the cream. They also sell smaller sizes and sometimes Sephora has deluxe sample size promo codes for it.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jessie

For the most part I’m usually really happy with ipsy plus. However, the only reason I didn’t cancel my ipsy X is because the way they were promoting it they were making it seem like it would be skincare heavy (and no I wasn’t putting all my hopes on just the CT). So I was disappointed to see that out of the 5 products chosen for me I only had the 111 skin that everyone else was also receiving. I was hoping that out of those 5 products I would get at least a couple of skin care items, especially since I rarely get makeup in my regular bags and they tend to be heavy on the skin care. Anyway, I’ll still use most of it but kind of a letdown.

Ipsy picked:
-111 skin serum (overloaded with serums, and don’t personally like this brand.)
-ABH brown pencil thingy (actually sending right shade, and even though I’m not excited about it, it’ll be used.
-MAC lipstick (just decluttered a bunch of Mac lipsticks, so I’m not sure how I feel about getting more).
-olé Henriksen primer (one of the worst primers I have ever tried).
-one/size palette (I assumed that everyone would get either this one or the other one, guess I was wrong, still out of the two this one is new to me, however, seeing as I never get eyeshadows from them you’d think they wouldn’t send me one now).

I picked:
-Christophe scalp scrub (have used this for 3-4 yrs now, and absolutely love this thing).
-Sunday Riley glow oil (again have used it and do quite enjoy it).
-train case (nothing good in this category, debated between the bag and the mirror, but I knew I would never use the mirror and was only considering it because other people were hyping it up, but the bag would be perfect for my summer vacation).

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Tavia

I’ve always been really happy with my Plus bags and since they did such a good job on curating the picks for it, I thought the X would be the same. I feel the same way about how X was promoted. I was hoping for either the CT or Prism mask, because they are two products/brands I haven’t tried before and at their price points I wanna try it before shelling out to buy it. Since my profile is set up for skincare I thought I’d have a chance for at least one of them. I did get the Rodial cleanser, but I just opened up the Go To Fancy Face Oil Cleanser and I found I’m just not into to the whole wipe off with a muslin cloth thing. I was surprised to see in one of my groups that a lot of people got both the CT and the Prism mask, so good on them.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jeanine

Just curious what did you want? I’m super happy with mine…love the mirror and the herbivore (I wanted those most)! Plus will enjoy the Kopari, brow pen, Mac lipstick and the scrub!!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Jessie Morales

I would have been happy with any skincare. I go through it like crazy, and depend on subscription boxes to replace it since it can get expensive. Wanted to give the the Rodial cleansing balm a go, because I tend to go through jars every month or two and that one sounded interesting. I would have preferred to have gotten the tower 28 lip gloss instead of the mac, but out of the two shades that they were offering I already own one of them, so in a way probably a good thing I didn’t get it (with my luck I would have gotten a repeat).

Like This CommentLike

CrazyCupCakes

To all of you gals out there that didn’t get the Charlotte Tilbury cream – don’t sweat it. 😉. I can tell you from experience that you are not missing out on anything. The cream is notjing more than overpriced Nivea. It’s thick and super heavy and definitely not a Moisturizer that you would use in the Spring and Summer months. And between you and me, it’s about as magical as my hind end 😁. A high end sunscreen would have been more appropriate this time of year. Also this cream is a free gift with purchase at Charlotte Tilbury right now. I personally feel CT is a tad overrated and overpriced. She has great marketing but the products aren’t all that. I’ve tried many of her things and the only thing she makes that I can’t live without is Pillow Talk lipstick. I’ve tried the foundation, primer, eyeshadow, magic cream, bronzer and blush and wasn’t blown away by any of it. I mean it was decent but my tried and true products were better.
My point is you are definitely better off if you received the makeup. I think you will get more bang for your buck that way.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

AIDA

Totally agree with you. I bought a butt load of CT products a couple of years ago when she had her yearly August sale and while I was pleased with my purchases I also had a few MEH moments as well. Bottom line is that I would buy again ON SALE but not full price.
One thing I truly loved was the EYES TO MESMERISE cream shadows. Completely worth full price and my only regret is that I didn’t buy the shade CLEOPATRA! It was a gorgeous teal and after repeated requests about restocking they finally told me it was discontinued!
The Magic Cream is very nice (got a sample) but I sure as hell ain’t paying 100.00 for it!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

h

Agreed! I have everything she has made. There are a couple eyeshadow quads that I really like and a couple blushes, and several lipsticks. I have liked the little pots of glimmery (made up the word) one-and-done eye creams. I’ve started buying more Tom Ford and I am totally in love with his quads! He’s my new makeup crush.
Just received my GBX today and while the postal lady looks like she took a peek since it was pulled open and barely put back together EVERYTHING was inside. So happy to not have to contact them.

Received a free month of Refreshments, with such a pretty silky bag, I realized that I didn’t get a bag for the GBX.

Do they not send bags with GBX?

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

h

Thank you for the information about “no bags”.

Hopefully your order will show up tomorrow and you will be excited about the contents.

Like This CommentLike

Dinah

I’m glad you received your GBX, mine is still in mail limbo. No, unfortunately we do not automatically get the bag. It’s a choice item.

Like This CommentLike

Smc

This is true. Search for it and the experts confirm. YouTube has some good comparisons.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Alice

Thank you for your first hand experience information!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Kenley

It would be really nice if Ipsy provided us a survey or a link a month before curation and get to select whether we want our upcoming bag to be makeup heavy, skincare heavy, or an equal mixture of both. Sometimes I’m looking for more makeup and other times skincare.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marion

You can change your beauty profile choices at any time.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Pudding

I did not get CT cream, which makes me feel so sad. What makes it worse is I cannot even buy one for the add-on. My favorite one is CT cream, then Herbivore peel, RMS cheek color. How “luckily” I do not even get one I like.

I received:
– 111skin booster (everyone gets it. I have one at home, not interested)
– anastrasia brow pen (I suppose everyone gets it, just different color)
– MAC lipstick
– olehenriksen eye creme (I have one at home)
– one/size eyeshadow palette (I do not like the eyeshadow palette, if I need to get one, I prefer anastrasia Renaissance, which has more natural colors)

Overall, I am really disappointed about this month’s glam X box. Ipsy does not follow my preference setup, I prefer skincare over makeup, see how much makeup included in this box. For makeup, I prefer natural colors other than pop colors. I am debating on if I will get glam X box in Aug, considering how disappointing I am.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Pudding

I am so sad I did not get CT facial cream. I have one bottle before, it works really great before makeup. I am so eager to get one this time. Even though I am not matching one CT cream, I hope I can purchase one in the add-on.

I really not a big fan of makeup. But what ironic is I get so much makeup in this bag, I get
– 111 skin booster (everyone gets it, I do not like it, I have one bottle at home)
– Anastasia brow pen (I suppose everyone gets it as well, just different color)
– MAC low me lipstick in bated breath
– olehenriksen eye cream
– ONE/SIZe eyeshadow (if I need to get one eyeshadow palette, I prefer Anastasia Renaissance palette, more natural choice)

Overall, I am really disappointed with this month’s glam X box. I am pretty sure ipsy does not follow my preference at all. I choose I prefer skincare other than makeup. For makeup choices, I prefer natural colors, not pop one. I am debating if I will keep Glam X box in Aug.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

h

I was surprised to get the email to Choose items for May’s Glam Bag X. I was told that there were no more waiting spots. I also received a free month of the Refreshments.
Included:

111SKIN Rose Gold Radiance Booster (already own and have never tried it)
ANASTASIA BEVERLY HILLS Brow Pen in Soft Brown (wrong shade)
M·A·C Love Me Lipstick in Bated Breath (meh, too warm)
HERBIVORE BOTANICALS Prism AHA + BHA Exfoliating Glow Facial (Yay!)
ONE/SIZE PATRICK STARRR Visionary Eyeshadow Palette (meh)

Didn’t have many choices that I really loved, but chose:

OLAPLEX No.0 Intensive Bond Building Treatment (Yay! I own the entire line, including this)
DR. BRANDT SKINCARE pores no more® VACUUM CLEANER (already own multiples)
LOLLIA Breathe Shea Butter Handcreme (original subscriber, so I own a lot of hand creams from ME)

Added On:

COMPLEX CULTURE Face Time Brush Trio ($25, but I like their brushes)
ORIGINS CLEAR IMPROVEMENT™ Active Charcoal Mask To Clear ($3 sample great for travel)

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Phoebe

Anyone interested in swapping their Glam Bag X train case for my Tower 28 Gloss in Coconut and Sugar Cosmetics Matte Lip Crayon in Miss Rosa? Was hoping to get the bag as an add-on but it wasn’t offered, and I have a ton of lipsticks/glosses in pretty much these exactly colors already.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

inkchick

After last month’s Plus, which was awful, I was hoping X would be outstanding and thankfully it is! I got the CT moisturizer and the cute mirror and the Olaplex. No, I’m not excited about the brow pen or the lip gloss (boring color), but other than that, everything seems great. I do feel badly for everyone who didn’t get the really good skincare or the mirror.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Subbox lover

What’s so great about the CT cream anyways? Besides the price tag??Truly, I want to know! I received the:
-OH eye primer (is it worth it’s claim?)
-ABH Palette (which I always wanted but was always opened and too grubby at TJ Maxx for me to purchase)
-RMS lip/cheek tint (meh..)
-Morphe continuous setting spray (which added literally no value to my $300 valued box but I know I already love it)
-gua sha stone
-collagen peptides (for my morning coffee)

*Not mad about the CT Cream…again, I’m still not seeing what’s so “magical” about it (someone please fill me in) but I have SOME good news if you’re a CT fan and planning on shopping on her site soon. I went on to purchase the new love collection and saw that she’s offering a full size magic cream for FREE until the 9th I believe with orders of $175 or more. So I thought that was a great deal so I added a lippie onto my order to bring the price limit up and am receiving a free cream. That’s why I asked what is so great about it. I’ve read all about it on her site after seeing i didn’t receive it in my choices yesterday but I have so many creams that claim the same promises…unless I’m missing something? Anyways, it is valued for $100 and would make a great mother’s day gift so I figured I’d put it out there if you’re that set on the cream and Planning on shopping her site regardless.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Marion

I think that’s why most of us were hoping to get the CT cream: to find out what’s so “Magic” about it…. and if it’s really worth the $$$

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Subbox lover

Makes sense. I’m curious as well. That’s why I asked. 🙂

Like This CommentLike

Morgan

My bag was actually 75% skincare. Well, 62.5% skincare. I know that’s boring for most people but I love skincare because it actually gets used and I have way too much makeup from Ipsy and GBP in the last.

-Charlotte Tilbury cream (I’m curious about this)
-111Skin serum (glad I got this, which puts me in the happiness minority)
-ABH pen in dark brown
-Herbivore peel (I really wanted this)
-Tower28 gloss in coconut (someone wants to trade shades with me, yay!)
-Route Beauty peel (choice)
-Christophe Robin scalp scrub (my choice to use in trades)
-Dr Brand Vacuum Cleaner (choice)

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Katy

I cancelled because I knew I didn’t want the 111 skin and that the CT and herbivore weren’t listed as choice items. I resigned up for August and am hoping that one has a better curation. It is a massive bummer that this bag didn’t turn out well for the majority of the people spending a decent amount of money on it, especially since I was completely pleased with the Patrick Ta curation from the first bag. This second round seems like an overall letdown.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Rachel

I knew when I saw so many different products being listed in the options and that neither palette, CT cream, Herbivore, etc were not choices and that the 111 Skin was going to be given to everyone (leaving 4 Ipsy selections left), there was a good chance I was not going to get the CT cream, the ABH palette and other items I wanted.

I am overall happy with my GBX and think the value is there, even if I didn’t get my ideal bag:

Ipsy curation:
– 111 Skin
– ABH brow pen
– One / size eyeshadow palette (initially not interested in this palette but am more interested in trying this out after further research)
– Herbivore
– MAC lipstick (not sure about the color but MAC lipsticks are great)
(Happy with most of the above…)
My choices:
– Christophe Robin (makes the bag worth it – I love everything I have tried from this brand so far)… I wanted the Olaplex and the Hair serum too but figured they would put all the hair choices in one selection pool)
– SR Glow Oil (Didn’t really care for any of the choices in this category and this SR product is not on my radar)
– Riki mirror (glad I selected early in the morning …didn’t know this would sell out)

Would I do GBX again? Maybe – it depends on the spoilers for August and knowing what I know now about how the curation and choice for X works.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Danelle

I guess I’m in the majority with the disappointment. I was thinking we would get the CT or the Herbavore. I didn’t get either of course. I got the ABH palette and already have it. 111 skin, the cashew lip gloss- I was praying for coconut as it looked perfect for my taste. The Rodial as everyone too. The wrong color ABH pen in onyx. I have micro bladed brows in a medium to med/do brown to that’s a no. My choices were meh just like everyone’s. I went with the train case as the mirror was gone, the SR because I haven’t tried it, and the Morphe spray because the others sucked that bad

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Annie S.

I agree. Life happens to all of us and sometimes announcements might not be posted in a timely manner. People who write for MSA don’t always get it right or post exactly before subscription boxes release their items. Companies like IPSY usually have a schedule when they allow you to make a choice and if you really want an item, the responsibility is on you to make sure that you check in with the company as early as possible on selection day.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Rachel

Agreed. Well stated.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike