BoxyCharm Premium April 2021 Full Product List

I chose: Natasha Denona concealer + Wander night treatment.

I was worried bc my shipping info said my box was only 0.9 lbs! I really like my variation though:
– Inc Rollerball Duo
– Makeup Remover pads
– Marc Jacobs liquid eyeshadow in Shimmy Dip (pale gold)
– Dose of Colors eyeliner in Unbox (a medium warm brown)

So happy to get the liquid eyeshadow instead of a primer! And of the 3 shades they sent, this is the one I wanted most.

I also think it will be fun to try the Dose of Colors eyeliner — not the shade I would’ve chosen for myself, but at least that means it’s not a dupe of anything I already have!

Mine came a couple of days ago. I opted for the ND palette and the wander beauty retinol. I also got: murad spray toner, dose of colors (don’t know whether it’s a lip or eye pencil as I’m not home), inc.redible roller ball glosses, and the fenty primer. I don’t much care about the roller glosses, but the rest of the box I’ll use.

Hello, I get all 3 boxes, and I too, don’t have to shop for to much more. Hair products I still have to buy. Anyways, it’s my understanding, because I just asked them, cause I thought about canceling the regular box. They said if I do that I can’t get the luxe box. I like getting the premium box, and I don’t want to get rid of luxe, so I had to stay getting the base box. Also a lot of you are talking about the prices. Last year sometime my base box went up to 27.15 a month, every month, premium is 38.01 every month. Has this not happened to anyone else? This was all with no notice either. I just wondered if anyone knew why this happened. Thank you.

For anyone thinking of signing up because of the ND palettes. I can confirm that all of the shades in the Jubilee are from previous palettes, and at least 3 of the shades in the Ayana palette are repeats from other palettes too. I can’t find the names actually listed, but watching try-ons and tutorials I got 8 of the 10 shade names.

I’m glad I figured it out, Boxy almost had me sub this month, but the palette I liked Jubilee repeats 4 shades I already have (from the Tropic & Love palettes).

Received both my base and premium. Both boxes had 2 great items and the rest were duds.
Farmacy Honey Grail
Touch in Sol – primer
Wander – night cream
Nars blush

The duds
*liquid eyeshadow in both boxes that was roughly the same color and neither of which are wearable shades for me. 🤨
* I also received a burgundy eyeliner 😱
*rollerball lipgloss duo by Nails Inc 🥱
*Froze body scrub ( which has been blessed by Buddhist monks !?) 🤯
* Tweezers 🤬
* Lavendar color correcter 😒…

I like Boxy but I wish there were more usable items in the boxes. Most of my friends/family are not interested in these filler products either so they are just being thrown away 🥲

Question – I am currently getting all 3 boxes and would like to drop down to only 1 for financial reasons. Would it be better to get the base or premium if you had to choose between the two ?

Wow, a lot of variant items for Premium! This could actually be a good thing if only they customized our boxes to our quiz answers, instead of using the quiz to determine interest level in general.

I remember back in the early days of premium when we all got close to the same items. Now it feels like they give you one or two “hero” items and then fill out with stuff they had left over from previous boxes, and it’s annoying. I’ve probably now gotten 40+ of those 111Skin sheet masks, and at one point in add-ons they were two for the price of one.

Wow so many repeats again!

Couple months ago there was a shipping problem and I never got my Premium box. They sent a replacement box but I didn’t get the Laura Mercier stick which was my Choice because, as they always say, they ran out. I wrote and complained, hoping they could just send one in any shade, but no response. Now I see it’s a possible box item and that’s so annoying.

Boxycharm confuses me. Do you have to subscribe to the base box before you can get premium? And can you only upgrade to Luxe from a base box?