Macy’s Beauty Box December 2020 FULL SPOILERS!

Hm, it’s middle of January and I still have not received my December box yet- recieved the January one tho- did you receive yours?

January spoilers are up on Macy’s website, hair themed.

Ok… I actually never looked at the spoilers on here on purpose, because I was planning for a pretty miserable Christmas and intended to wrap any subs coming this month. I scrolled right to the comments. It turns out I am going somewhere for a few days soon, so I just unwrapped my Macy’s Box to get the travel bottles out. I figured I may as well see what they is were and how helpful they might be.

I too got the Oops! Card. I really don’t quite understand what goes on there, since you can’t exactly order/subscribe last minute. I got the GrandeLips Plumping Liquid Lipstick instead. I think the rest is the same as above. I haven’t tried anything yet. I just opened it. I haven’t formed an opinion yet.

Can someone please tell me how Macys ships there beauty boxes…is it USPS? Thank you..

I was really excited to try the lip liner and I knew as soon as I saw the oops card that the lip liner wouldn’t be there. I do like the replacement product, but with all the sparkle it’s not like an everyday lip product. Besides that, they sent that very same product in the same dark color in the past except that it was full sized the last time. I still have it. They also have had oops cards multiple times in the past. It’s really not a new thing for them.

I wrote a long review about how trash this box was, but then I lost it….

Short story: this box was trash. Macy’s should be ashamed at how skimpy these product sizes are, continuously sending boxes late, substitutions each month, the list goes on. Needless to say, I canceled.

A. Total. Mess.

I received my box today. Kiehl’s was Calendula Petal Infused Calming Mask vs. Calendula & Aloe Soothing Hydrating Mask which I am cool with the substitution, imagining they are similar in value. But I was looking for the full-size invisible lip liner and received travel size plumping liquid lipstick in dark metalic color. We receive bold lip colors in sub boxes and I am finally learning to use it, lol, as a stain and it will help the product to stay put. I recently received Lipstick Queen one as GWP from Birchbox, so I will try it out. But it is dissapointing that they substitute a full-size (at least from the picture) to a travel size. I am not sure the BareMinerals lipstick was supposed to be full size or travel size, but it was a travel size… I am locked in for another month, so let’s see if Macy’s can bring it back.

I got my box today. They substituted lip pencil to lip gloss . I think these two months substituted maybe because these box are between June, July. At that time they have this item, but at this time I’m speculating they don’t have these item can work with Macy’s box.

I just got my box, and I am actually pleased with this one (now regretting that I canceled). They substituted this lip pencil with a plumping lip gloss by the same brand in a crazy dark midnight purple color (had to Google it as the tube says nothing about it). But I am actually excited to check it out. The bare minerals lipstick is also very nice and neutral. Happy! I might think to re-subscribe for Jan. Keep it up, Macy’s!

Just got my first macy’s box, Oops card and no lip liner- of course that is what I wanted the most of the spoilers – I got the 10 gift card so went online and put the lip liner in my cart along with a benefit brow microblade pen and applied the card… 5.00 off… chatted with an online agent and was offered a 25% off my cart- applied that code- excludes cosmetics/ fragrances… along with a list as long as my arm so no discount with that code. Tried to get the agent to apply the 10 dollars as stated on the card… no go. Said that the items in my cart were excluded and I should put other things in my cart… freaking run around frustrated … NO SALE. 🙁

It looks like Macy’s might be trying to make up for their last box, which was horrific. I hope I actually get everything advertised. Last month 3 were missing, and replaced with 1 item. Big disappointment.

For those looking for uses for the travel stuff – put the SK-II Facial Treatment Essence (PITERA Essence) from last month into the spray bottle. It’ll last waaaaay longer.

I canceled Macy’s after we got the spoilers for December because everything after the Jo Malone box has been a disappointment, and I wanted to wait until this sub gets back on their feet again (if they do).

I thought I would still receive December though, but I was never charged!

Can’t believe the cancellation worked for the same month, but I am certainly happy that it did.

Just got my November box. Surprise, surprise, they are making substitutions again!

What is wrong with them? They JUST restarted this box, how is it possible they are sending out all the boxes with only half the advertised items?!

I got a different Kiehl’s product than the one that is listed, and I got some matte liquid lipstick mini (I have no use for liquid lipsticks and I already have a zillion of them) instead of the full size Grande lip liner, (which was the only thing in this box that I actually wanted.)

I also was disappointed w/November box! Poor substitution of SK-II and my box was missing the eyeliner & the Anthony No Sweat. I’ve yet to reach customer service. I used to really enjoy this box but they are going downhill badly. Maybe they will actually pay attention to us customers & make some changes. 🤞

As usual, they subbed out thr full size item for a sample size. I am so done with this box.

I really like the Macy’s box! I quit the allure beauty box, so when I learned Macy’s had a box, I jumped right in! What I love about the Macy’s box is the range of products you can get vs other boxes which are typically all makeup and/or skincare. Loved getting the panties to try last month (even if they didn’t turn out to be my favorite, I was curious about them so it was nice to get to try them!), I love getting fragrances which you don’t normally get with any other boxes, the containers this month, etc. I think it stays true to what I love about these lower priced “try me” boxes, which is getting to try a bunch of different things (and so far the samples haven’t been ridiculously small like birchbox–samples should be bigger than my pinky nail, thank you very much!). I haven’t received my box yet, but from the spoilers I know I will enjoy using everything (am secretly hoping for a different lip color tho, sometimes I feel like all the boxes just send out all the dark colors nobody will buy ). Still totally worth it for everything else! 🙂

I cancelled my box In November past the cutoff day… I thought I would receive the December box. I got the email that my box will be delayed. However, I have not been charged nor have I received a tracking number. I dont really want the box as I went crazy with the Birchbox sale and got super nice GWP and mistery samples packs. Although I didnt budgeted this sub for 2021 Im a sucker for the Macys beauty pouches, so I might re-suscribe if I see one I like.

I’ll be happy as long as I get all the items. I’ve tried the PTR mask and Shiseido before; they worked fine for me. Bareminerals consistently worked for me, though I prefer their blushes & powders to lips.

Lol at the travel container though. I’ll get use out of those in maybe … two-three years when the corona’s gone?

Anyone having a hard time cancelling the box? I’ve been cancelled since May and in October they started sending me a box. I’ve alerted them 4 times and they keep saying there is nothing they can do. Meanwhile, they are charging my card without my permission. I have no idea what to do next. They just don’t care.

Hi everyone, I just wanted to update and say that my box has shipped for this month, got the email tonight, about 8 hours after I was charged for the box.

Did anyone get charged today for the December box,I was charged today for the December box,

I don’t mind waiting a little bit, as long as I get everything that’s advertised here. The substitutions and lack of amount of items is what makes me sad. I love subscription boxes, I don’t want to cancel.

I feel like these boxes are getting more and more not what they used to be

I’m happy to see that there’s no “one size fits all” underwear this month.