My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm Premium October 2021 – Full Spoilers!

BoxyCharm Premium October 2020 Full Product List!

ByMSAOct 8, 2020 | 36 comments

Boxycharm Premium

BoxyCharm Premium
5 overall rating
1 Ratings | 1 Reviews

Here is the full product list for the October 2020 BoxyCharm Premium box:

  • Laura Geller – Fifty Kisses Lip Locking Liquid Color
  • Kosas – Kosasport Lipfuel – baseline
  • MAC Cosmetics – 70 Lash

  • MAC Cosmetics – 43 Lash
  • Go to Skincare – Exfoliating Swipeys
  • FENTY Beauty – Brow MVP Ultra Fine Brow Pencil & Styler
  • Clarins – Instant Smooth Perfecting Touch – 0.50 oz

  • Bodyography – Eye Pencil Duo – OnyxBlack Walnut
  • Jouer – Essential Lip Enhancer
  • Murad – Hydrating Toner

  • Kosas – Color & Light: Crème Cream Blush & Highlighter Duo
  • Kosas – Tinted Face Oil Foundation
  • Kosas – Color & Light Palette: Powder Blush & Highlighter Duo

What do you think of the spoilers? 

Here’s everything you need to know about BoxyCharm Premium:

  • It’s $35 a month
  • 6-7 beauty items a box
  • $175+ Value
  • You get to pick one of the items
  • The items will be different from BoxyCharm/BoxyLuxe – you can subscribe to both with no product overlap.

Check out our reviews of Boxycharm boxes, and our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more about this subscription.

BoxyCharm Premium is a full-size beauty and makeup subscription box BoxyCharm Premium sends you 6-7 beauty items that include nail care, skincare, makeup, haircare, fragrance, and more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



My premium box was amazing.

I was actually thinking of purchasing the Murad hydrating toner and the Kosas skin tint so when I saw that I got these in my box I was excited.

I live in Vancouver Canada and I feel like We are the last to get our boxes and honestly I was really disappointed in last months box. Omg my fabfitfun fall box was terrible as well.

Everyone is right it’s super hit and miss but I manage to sell a lot of my stuff on Poshmark so I’m okay with it.


Just received my October box wow I’m so freaking impressed I love everything in it it’s the first time and about a year I love the beauty bakery breakfast and bed eyeshadow palette I loved the Wunderlist set of brushes oh my God The dose of colors meet your concealer perfect the Ace beauty draw a li p liner duo magnificent The lip color I’m in love… Way to go boxycharm for once


I’m feeling pretty salty that most of the Premium products are available in add-ons for super cheap prices. Why should I keep my subscription if I can just get Base and buy only the items I want in add-ons? I can’t think of a good reason…


I just did the math on how much my box would have cost if I had purchased it through add-ons, and it would have been $37 without the palette (which I am not even going to open), which still makes it slightly cheaper to have the subscription. FWIW, I received the eyebrow pencil, lip liners, Murad spray, creme blush/highlighter duo in the mauve shade, and swipeys, and I really enjoy using everything I received. I usually have good luck with products from Fenty, Murad, and Kosas, so I wasn’t surprised about enjoying those, but I was really pleasantly surprised by how well the lip liners work for me. I’m in it for the discovery (and early access to sales), and there are certainly months when I have been less thrilled by the items in my premium box than I was this month, so I hear you, but I got lucky with this month.

Stephanie W

I was very disappointed in my box this month. I’m not even going to open the palette. I heard enough reviews and saw people testing it so I know it won’t show up nicely on my deeper skintone. I’ll keep it in its shrink-wrap. The Laura Gellar lipstick shade that I received is probably the worst possible one for my complexion (baby pastel pink). I am happy with the Kosas foundation and will use the swipes. I got a pair of MAC lashes which I will never use and are not on my beauty quiz. I wish they would pay attention to the quizzes.

BTW, there is a new hair quiz on there now.

Miss Love

Hey I’m with you on this , we got the same box. I got a red and my colors are marked as pink or nudes. They keep sending me red 🙄

If you’d like to trade let me know


Got mine today. Variation 8, 1.9 lbs. Was worried that I’d get lashes because my box was lighter than others’, but I’m pleasantly surprised.

Kosas tinted face oil
Illuminati x is a palette (please stop with the cheap palettes that no one wants, boxy)
Clarins Instant Smooth
Go To exfoliating swipeys
Kosas base line lip fuel
Laura Geller fifty kisses in beige bite

Out of all the options, I’m pleased with my box.


Base Box
Variation 66 WEIGHT 1.5 lbs / 0.68 kgs DIMENSIONS 9x7x3 in.
Pretty Vulgar Palette
Rodial soft focus glow drops
Murad Cleanser
Sol De Janeiro lip butter
Lavaa Lashes
171.99 Value


Got mine today, Friday the 9th. 🙂
It;s box #7, weighed 2.2 lbs.

The palette- Up for swap, not for me….
Murad toner- for swaps, not sure I need the extra moisture on my oiley skin lol
Kosas FOundation- pickeds the closest shad left that day to pick from, prob wont work 🙁
The swipeys- just used one and they made my face soooo soft! Win! lol
Kosas lip balm- Im a balm fanatic so win!
Eyeliners in black and brown- more swap fodder

Ended up liking 2 products so it covers the box cost barely….
My base box shipped yesterday so hopefully there will be more wins in that one.

Overall not pissy about the contents, it could have been ALOT worse for me anyways. lol


I got the swipeys and had actually wanted the Murad toner. I would be willing to swap with you if you would like to. I thought the swipeys sounded interesting, but my skin has not been liking any kind of chemical exfoliation lately. The Murad line tends to work well for me and I’ve been trying to find a toner that works for me.


Are you on swaps? I have it listed, the toner that is. lol Hmm, it’s not letting me link my swap page anymore, just noticed that. But I have most of the Boxy items I listed in the comments here posted already and my name is the same here as over there. 🙂

Joy-Not the Other One

I just received mine. It is the strangest thing though because not only did I not receive a shipping email, but when I go to my account online there is no tracking number and it still says “Shipping” instead of “Shipped” Oh well, it’s no big deal, just odd.

Mine was Version 11

Fenty Brow MVP Ultra-fine Pencil & Styler in Medium Brown
Illuminati Palette
Murad Hydrating Toner
Kosas Cream Blush & Highlighter
Go-To Exfoliating Swipeys
Laura Geller lip in Makeout Merlot (very pretty deep mauve)


My box was delivered today. I got variation 10
illuminati X Isa Eyeshadow Palette
Clarins Instant Smooth Perfecting Touch
Kosas Powder Blush in Papaya 1972 (my choice)
Go-To Skincare Exfoliating Swipeys
Mac 70 Lash
Laura Geller Fifty Kisses Lip Locking Liquid Color in pink pucker (a hot pink color)

Not loving this month’s products overall, but out of everything offered I would have picked these except the lashes I have tons never use them ever.


It came today. I want to talk about the terrible $12 palette we all got before listing the rest. Idk how it is for the rest of y’all, hopefully the quality varies. I gave this palette to my 4 year old. It’s bad, like really really bad. The shade Izzy is dried up and no glitter goes on my fingers. Purple Dream doesn’t swatch at all. The rest are patchy and basically the same quality as play makeup.

Also got:

Clarins (yay, rather have this over the toner) $9
Exfoliating wipes $6
Kosas chapstick $4
Kosas foundation oil (choice) $42
Cheapo $4 LG liquid lipstick (does not dry)

So the box is worth $77. $42 of that is just the foundation. So the rest of the box is worth $35, so it’s filler and equals the price of the box. It all has to do with what the products are worth to the individual though, we all have different taste. To me, the foundation is not worth $42 because I’ll never be able to wear it. I imagined something else. The foundation is messy af.


The items with slashed prices will be appearing in add-ons!

I got Variation #78 (11x10x4, 2.2 lbs) :
– Illuminati palette
– Murad toner spray
– Kosas Tinted Oil Foundation (Tone 02)
– Go-To exfoliating swioes
– Jouer lip enhancer
– Laura Gellar 50 Kisses liquid lipstick (Ruby Romance)

I resubbed hoping to get the Kosas face oil, which I’ve never tried. I guessed what shade would work for me & put it in the Boxy foundation quiz. I’m also really happy with the Murad toner & Go-To wipes. I’m calling this box a win, even with the filler eye palette (which has lots of PET glitter in it).

I’ll admit to having a few private-labeled cosmetics from sub boxes that I enjoy, so in all fairness, I decided to give the Illuminati palette a try (not the shades with PET though). I noticed when I swatched the colors yesterday that they have a weird, slightly creamy consistency that made the swatches slightly water resistant when I splashed them with water to wash them off, but the swatches removed easily with soap. Today, I wore the light green, blue, & lavender colors to work. After 8 hours, they are almost completely faded and gone in a way that has never happened to me with any other eye shadow ever. If you like the color scheme of this palette, I’d recommend investing in the Nomad Cosmetics Harajuku palette, which has some very pretty pastels & some transformative shimmer shades.


My box weighs the same and I picked the foundation in the lightest shade so I wonder if our boxes will be alike 🤔

I hope so. I’d be happy with this curation especially since there is no lashes.

What do you think of the lip enhancer and the lipstick? Worth trying? Or better to leave unopened for a gift? They would both be new products and brands for me so I’m tempted to open but idk…


I remember back in the day a lot of the MSA forum people liked the Jouer lip enhancer, & it was a hot commodity on the swap site. Personally, I have never tried it because it has a rose scent, & that is just not my thing.


Does anyone know what day Boxycharm charges? Premium is a joke and I’m ready to be done.


Boxy charges around midnight the last day of the month so this month it will be the 31st going into the 1st at a little after midnight.


Wow. No FOMO here. So glad I canceled after seeing the pathetic spoilers late last month. It’s sad how quickly premium has gone downhill.


I’m going to list what I hope I get according to what my profile says on Boxy. They never take those into consideration which is annoying. This is probably the worst premium box I have ever seen since it started.

Kosas oil foundation-chose this
MAC lashes
Fenty brow pencil
Mourad Toner

The palettes they send now are cheap and basically useless except for beginners who don’t have much yet. And even that is a stretch because the palettes are still bad. That’s probably why we get them because the company could not sell their crumby palette and boxycharm bought them in bulk for cheap. We all probably have more cheap eyeliners than we know what to do with. Watch me get those though. The “lip enhancer” is a fancy term for overpriced lip gloss. Laura Geller is $4, enough said. Cheap filler, ugly color. Even after all these years, it still annoys me how some people get a $4, filler while others get an $18 product. If they are not going to take profiles into account, we should all get the same thing. I’ve been on the verge of canceling for a long time but fear of missing out has kept me on. Sometimes they have great boxes but this one is just meh, even if I get my ideal box. This stuff is not premium worthy. I understand that they buy companies leftovers, stuff that couldn’t sell, at bulk discount prices like what’s at marshalls/TJMaxx but they can definitely do better. With the economy and the pandemic, I doubt beauty products are selling well right now. The whole box feels like filler.


You said it very well and I have been feeling the same. All of last months box is just sitting out untouched. I should cancel today!


I read Megan’s Boxy Luxe review after this one and her write up and swatches on the HipDot palette swayed me to open mine and swatch it. I ended up being really impressed with them. I haven’t used it yet but I am going to now. I did find the pigments to be quality and the shades pretty.

This month’s palette in Premium has a lot of pretty shades. I’m more interested in seeing the quality of them now than I was.

I cancelled my base box for now after an underwhelming Luxe month experience but I have no plans to cancel my Premium soon. The skincare is too good, they are finally sending out the types of products I need regularly and the brands have become more interesting to me.

I feel like Boxy has listened over the last 4 years. How many of us wailed on and on for more brow products, more foundations and powders, more primers and toners and setting sprays and more skincare and less nail polish and less hair care and as little red lipstick as possible!!?? Lol.


I think it’s all hot or miss on makeup and always has been with Boxy since I initially subbed in June of 2016.

What is impressing me enough to cancel all my other beauty boxes and keeping premium is the skincare, both brands and product types. Boxy has tremendously stepped up their skincare to many quality, interesting to me brands and product. Finally, toners and setting sprays! Foundations and setting powders. Face oils and serums! Those are the things I go through the most and need regularly. I feel like I have enough of everything else piled up for a decade or more, especially my makeup. And I am impressed with their bonus member only sales. The $6 and $9 range of products has been very nice in my opinion.

In perspective over the 4 years, Boxy has shown growth that I personally like. The Premium box seems to be where it’s at for me the most and I am interested in seeing how well they do customizing my boxes the next couple of months.


It’s either Clarins or Murad, so you can’t get both, & unfortunately, you WILL get the filler eyeshadow palette.


This box is boring. I could build a better box in the sale with my $35. If I get lashes, I’m out.

Lauren Vavala

I feel like the base box products were way more “premium” than these…not really excited for anything really.


Yeah, I’ve seen some base boxes with all brand-name item this month & no weird “sub box” brands!


You are right on the money. Other than the Kosas product I received, this box is cheap filler. I couldn’t agree more with regard to the cheap eyeshadow palettes we’ve been getting. The two I received last month in luxe and premium were both subpar. This months Iluminati Pallette looks like something you could by for 6.00 at a discount store. I also received the Laura Geller $4 lip crap. The color isn’t usable (no surprise)..Also received some exfoliating wipes (boo) and Mac eyelashes (big thumbs down). The thing that I enjoy and has kept me from canceling are the add on and pop up sales. I have gotten some great items. I really have no fomo about the boxes..I wish we had more control over what we received in the actual boxes. I’m thinking of dropping down to base box only.


Everything looks great except for the lashes!! I am super excited to get my box. It should be here on Monday.

Being that there are two set of lashes, does anyone know if there is a good likelihood that everyone will receive one or the other??


Most boxes I’m seeing on Insta do not have lashes. My box also did not.


I got the Mac 70s, which I will never use. I never like it when lashes are in the mix but I’ve been lucky until now. This is the first time I’ve received lashes. I’ve seen quite a few variations that don’t have any lashes, so hopefully you will get one of those.

tammy g.

yes, this looks boring…and if i get those stupid eye lashes i’m going to scream..boxycharm ..and i have begged them to quit sending me eyeshadows…


Well… I got the stupid eyelashes today in my box and I’m screaming !!! I absolutely hate false eyelashes and personally do not like the way they look on anybody. This is got to be another loss leader type of product and why we continue to see these in subscription boxes. Other than one tattoo artist friend (who looks amazing in everything) I know absolutely no one else that uses false eyelashes. Maybe I can off load them on Ebay. I pray I don’t receive another set in base box because they are offering them to in a different brand.


This feels very boring to me.


I kind of agree. I cancelled back in June due to financial reasons. That has worked itself out and I was thinking of resubbing for October but now I think I’ll wait until November…although I think I could find 5 things I’d like to receive here. Brows, foundation, maybe the palette, the toner and either the blushes or the lipgloss.

You Might Also Like

Trendmood Volume 13 Box: Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4
Trendmood Volume 13 Box: Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4
October 23, 2021
FabFitFun Winter 2021 Box Spoilers: Fantastical Finishes
FabFitFun Winter 2021 Box Spoilers: Fantastical Finishes
October 21, 2021
Allure Beauty Box November 2021 – Spoiler #3
Allure Beauty Box November 2021 – Spoiler #3
October 27, 2021
Birchbox October 2021 Review + 50% Off Coupon
Birchbox October 2021 Review + 50% Off Coupon
October 20, 2021
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.