My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

BoxyCharm Premium September 2020 Choice Time!

ByMSAAug 13, 2020 | 46 comments

Boxycharm Premium

BoxyCharm Premium
5 overall rating
1 Ratings | 1 Reviews

We have spoilers for the September 2020 BoxyCharm Premium box!

Choose between:

Ole Henriksen Phat Glow Facial Mask

Marc Jacobs Youthquake Hydra-full Retexturizing Gel Crème Moisturizer

Marc Jacobs Dew Drops Coconut Gel Highlighter in Dew You

Marc Jacobs Dew Drops Coconut Gel Highlighter in Tantalize

What do you think of the spoilers? Which item are you going to pick?

Here’s everything you need to know about BoxyCharm Premium:

  • It’s $35 a month
  • 6-7 beauty items a box
  • $175+ Value
  • You get to pick one of the items
  • The items will be different from BoxyCharm/BoxyLuxe – you can subscribe to both with no product overlap.

Check out our reviews of Boxycharm boxes, and our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more about this subscription.

BoxyCharm Premium is a full-size beauty and makeup subscription box BoxyCharm Premium sends you 6-7 beauty items that include nail care, skincare, makeup, haircare, fragrance, and more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



Actually let me tell you something. I got in the minute they send the notification and the cream and the light highlighter were never available because they decided to sell the cream in the boxy pop up and they didn’t let us to choose it. I was outraged by the situation and how they play with us.


I am getting a little nervous about this month as we still have not seen more spoiler for premium… T.T


Same…. both of the other boxes have spoilers out. We should have at least know a few by now. Sometimes I know 3 or more items by now that will be in my box.


Same experience here: I logged in within half an hour of receiving the email and was stuck with choosing something I did not want. I loved the box for the first few months-I used to check the calendar daily until I got it-but it’s inconsistent since I upgraded to the BoxyLuxe. I am still signed up for all three versions, am getting charged monthly for the premium and the regular, but have only received the premium this month. To put it nicely, I would have skipped it if there was a complete reveal ahead of renewal time. The eyeshadow collection, while expensive, had unattractive colors that didn’t match and mostly shiny eyeshadows which aren’t appropriate on aging skin. There really wasn’t anything in the box I would ever use, I fared better with spending more than $100 on add-ons. I am subscribed also to Ipsy, which also seems to be struggling, Beauty TestTube, Allure and Fashionsta; Fashionsta consistently has become the best although they don’t ever carry Sunday Riley, which is what is keeping me with the others.

Whitney Earl

I’ve been a subscriber to Ipsy for over 7 years. I thought when they added $2 to the price that it would have a bit more value/newer brands. However when I got my August bag, i was not impressed with the sizes. I had Birchbox for about 4 years but canceled bc of the sizes and repeats. Both of my Aug Ipsy bags were disappointing specifically due to the sizes. I chose the Glamglow bright eyes and i think i might be able to use it 4 times SPARINGLY. I also got a TEENIE eye shadow, can’t remember the brand, but the pan was the size of my thumbnail, i also got an IT COSMETICS mask and it was in a very very tiny jar. I tried it last night and didn’t get to apply it to my whole face before running out. So, your comment about Ipsy , is dead on. I’m LOVING the Sept Boxyluxe spoilers. I have Regular and Premium. Thinking about canceling reg Boxy and subbing to Premium for Sept.


What size was your glamglow eye cream? Mine was 3ml, which is not uncommon for eye creams, and lasts a couple of weeks easily..


I also have been a subscriber for about 7 years, and it seems to me that I never get the “hyped up” items. My last box was full of random things and brands I have never heard of, and while sometimes that’s ok. It has been a long long long time since my box matched one of the boxes they send out to the influencers… I feel like even though I have been loyal to them, they have no loyalty to me.


For those wondering, yes they added our moisturizer and highlighter options to boxypop up like a whole HOUR before they let us do choice. The highlighter and the moisturizer didn’t last 5min in choice when they finally did let us choose. Yet they still had them in popup even after they became *sold out* for choice. I wish they would let us do premium choice at 10am pst like the other choices, yet they haven’t been opening choice as of late until like 1pm pst for premium. aside from the mask, our options were in Pop up at 12pm pst.
Since I have cancelled, especially after that fiasco, I hope I still get my pop up orders. On the side, I thought it said somewhere that you have access to things like pop-up as long as your got that months box, yet the second I cancelled, I no longer am able to order from pop-up despite having the august box. Oh well.


Is choice time for premium officially 1pm pst? I’ve been trying to figure out what time it’s supposed to be.


So I got an email from Boxy being shocked choice went so quickly yesterday. If they can sell them in pop-up why can’t they have enough for choice?! Anyway, they offered me $10 to spend at pop-up. Unfortunately the one thing I wanted, Youthquake, is gone. I would have ordered it on Monday if it had been an option. I spent $100 as it is and now you give me a discount?! Oh, and the $25 minimum for free shipping still applies, so it does not equal a free item as Boxy states in their email. I think it’s time to let go of a bad relationship.


Anyone else get a email about being selected to be a boxy influenster for a day? Apparently I’m getting a new mascara sent to review before it’s launched?


I think its messed up that they were all out of choice items yesterday, but when I went to the pop up shop, there they are! A bit shady imo


i agree


My premium box waws shipped before choice even opened. Fed Ex shows that it was shipped on 8/10 but choice was for 8/13. :s


Same here…what’s up with that. Plus I did add on’s


The 8-13 choice is for the September box. I hope you were able to choose still.


Hi, Does anyone else have problems making choices? I have been a member since May and never have been able to choose, nor have I ever received any notification that choice is open. (I am a member for regular, premium, and luxe boxes). Every month I have to write to them to tell them that choice did not open for me for premium. Yesterday, they opened it for me, but only 3 hours before choice ended and since I was at work, I could not log in within those 3 hours and it was too late to choose. Anyone else having this issue and if so, were you able to get it resolved?


The only way I ever know about it is when MSA post reminding me

April JK

Yes, I’ve never once been able to choose.


Why, yes, I surely do. I think I was only able to choose once. Pretty frustrating, and resulting in disappointing boxes…


Sorry, not just me, I just read all of your posts.


They dont send out emails for choice anymore….also, you have to set a reminder on your phone and log in right away because choices disappear in less then 2 minutes often.


Tell me please is it possible to skip a month like in Ipsy subs?


No, they make you cancel and then resub. Losing any points you may have accumulated.

Emily hawes

Hey Zo just thought you would like to know, i have cancelled three times this year and my points were always still there when I reavitavied my account so I don’t believe your points go anywhere. I had like 35000 and they were still there when I resubscribed. I got to use them in the charm room.


I have a couple friends that have cancelled and subbed a year later and both still had all their points…


Thank you! That is not good.


Only th Ole Henriksen Phat Glow Facial Mask was left when I went on. I saw that Marc Jacobs Youthquake was being offered in pop up so I just grabbed one from there


I ended up sending an email to BoxyCharm because I went to select a choice everything was already gone besides the ole henrickson product. I got
On there right as choice opened too!! But then you go to the pop up shop and they have all the Marc Jacobs products for sale in the popup!!! If they enough products t list in popup then they should have enough for us to be able to choose those products!!


They added our choice items except for that mask, to boxypopup a whole hour before they opened our choice. Then when choice was finally opened, of course it was all gone. It’s ridiculous! I guess they feel if they sell most the stock at popup, they get extra money because people will still pay $35 for the premium box, even if they don’t get the choices they wanted…


Please let us know if they respond with anything besides too bad so sad. All the choices were gone except the 0H by the time I checked but they never really seem to give a crap so I just said choose for me and hope I don’t get that one.

Kathy S.

Such BS Choice was apparently not open long and closed already? So Shady of Boxy and Ipsy is not any better these days. Seems as if they all have went to hell in a handbag. I’m so tired of all the excuses blaming Covid for everything. The worst of subscriptions I have is Glossybox and they seem to be the only ones delivering on time with no excuses.


Hi! I just went to make my choice for Premium and it said choice is over. I’m mad they said Thursday so wth? I tried at 11am and NOTHING now this?? How can they do this? That’s false advertising!


I feel your pain. They never have the choice at the same time. It’s so annoying! Then they try to make you check their IG CONSTANTLY looking for updates. Very disorganized.


The Marc Jacobs Youthquake moisturizer has been spotted at TJ Maxx for $6.


I am not surprised. I see most things at TJ MAXX that this company features in their boxes. Marc Jacobs Beauty is also having a big sale and all these items are in it.


Choice is apparently closed doh!


By the time I got on two options were gone, but I didn’t really care about any of the options anyway, so I chose “choose for me.” Hoping the rest of the box is good.

tammy g.

i got the marc jacobs…youthquake..i haven’t tried this yet..


I totally forgot about today’s choice and when I looked around 12.30 PST, the Dew Drops Coconut Gel Highlighter in Dew You was no longer available.
Not sure why this one is so hot? I was debating between the MJ Youthquake and Ole Henriksen mask and chose MJ.


Only Ole Henriksen Phat Glow Facial Mask left!


That’s what I had to get because I was late to the party. The two Marc Jacobs products featured in choice were also available for sale in Boxy Pop Up for $18 – which I think is wrong – if they had more product it should have remained available for choice. The same thing Ipsy did with the Luna oil.


Same here even though the other choices are being sold on pop up. Glad I’m canceling my premium box


I’m canceling my premium box too. Im so tired of getting the exact opposite of things I want. They don’t listen our quizzes or reviews at all. Im just waiting for my September luxybox and im canceling the base and Luxy too, not to mention they are shady af.


BC is so shady.


I wasn’t even that late to pick and already two options were unavailable. Neither were the one I wanted but still, that was fast lol

You Might Also Like

GQ Best Stuff Box Fall 2021 Subscription Review
GQ Best Stuff Box Fall 2021 Subscription Review
September 7, 2021
Stitch Fix Plus Size End of Summer Dresses and Jumpsuits Review
Stitch Fix Plus Size End of Summer Dresses and Jumpsuits Review
September 11, 2021
BoxyCharm October 2021 – Choice and Add-Ons Open NOW!
BoxyCharm October 2021 – Choice and Add-Ons Open NOW!
September 13, 2021
Glossier: Want $500 in Glossier credits?
Glossier: Want $500 in Glossier credits?
September 8, 2021
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.