Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Hi,
I noticed that many people who purchased products from the Popup sale received many damaged items.I had similar issues and 5 pallettes were broken and 3 of the foundation outer boxes were crushed.
They were supposed to be for birthday gifts, but they are totally unsuitable for gifts now.
I sent emails with photos of the damaged pallets and the foundations several times.However the customer service reps keep asking for photos of the damaged products and have not made any effort to take care of this.I hope that this issue can be resolved without getting my credit card company involved.
Would love to find out if any similar problems were resolved and if so,the steps they took to get a replacement or a refund.
Thank you in advance for any pertinent advice.
Reply
Margo
I barely received my order on Thursday and had 3 items completely missing and 1 of the items wasn’t cheap. In addition to that, I received a ceramic face succulent broken into several pieces!!!! I’m not happy at all. I emailed them and sent a picture that day and they just replied today stating they’re unable to replace my broken item and my other items are out of stock therefore they issued me a refund. Haven’t received it yet but assuming it takes a couple of days or so.
Reply
Jacki
I feel really bad for Traci. My replies appear in the wrong place when I use my phone
I spent $200 and my box arrived with 3 bottles of Keratherapy spilled all over the box. The pumps are completely separated from the metal tubes. Nothing can be used for the gifts they were intended to be. Most aren’t usable. I took a photo with the label on one flap looking into the pile of goop. I then emailed pictures of goop soaked items. Boxycharm has the complete list of what I ordered. I’m not happy they haven’t gotten back to me yet. Hopefully they will make this right without involving my credit card co. I’ve shared a single photo on social media already. I will have to post more. I want people to make informed decisions when they order. It’s very troubling that boxy didn’t learn from their mistakes and place the conditioners in plastic bags.
Reply
Traci Randazzo
I ordered $85 worth of products. Great deals but was packaged horribly. 14 items stuffed in a bubble envelope. There was a Keratin Fix 20-in-1 hair treatment that the top popped completely off. The entire bottle of product dumped all over everything else in the package. I carefully took pictures and sent them all to Customer Service, but because I did not take a pic of the label next to each damaged item they are refusing to replace. I’m truly unhappy, as I don’t usually spend that much and I was really looking forward to getting the package. I was less than charmed with the whole experience. I was really disappointed.
Reply
Suzanne
I received my order today and it was missing over half of the items. Plus there was an item I did not order in there. Very concerned about this. Boxycharm how are you going to fix this? I know you read this website!
Reply
Sam
I ordered 3 items the first day of the pop up and they have yet to ship.. anyone else?
Reply
Angie
I ordered stuff on the 12th and on the 18th. When I check on the status they both still say ordered. Did you get your order yet? It seems like it’s taking forever for them to ship!!
Reply
Kim S
I placed two orders on May 12. The first one arrived quickly, missing one item that has also now arrived. The second order has not shipped AND my email about it has gone unanswered. I will give them until June 10 then I guess I’ll have to contact my credit card issuer. I’m thinking it’s time for me and Boxy to part ways…
Reply
Tiffany Schmidt
I also ordered 3 items within 5 minutes of pop up going live and none have shipped yet for me either
Reply
Sam
My order status still says ordered.. I ordered my stuff on the 12th! Insane
Jen
Me too. A few things I ordered are for some upcoming b-day gifts. I am really hoping they ship soon. This is my first pop up order. Does anyone know how long it usually takes to ship out? Thanks!
Tina Ames
Does anyone know when the popup sale ends?
Reply
Pita
Be careful with what you ordered. I ordered the Elemis oxygenating night cream at 50 ml. I received it today and it was a 30 ml one.
Reply
Kate of Spades
Your order already got delivered?
Reply
Samantha
I placed 2 orders on the 11th. Only one has come in the other I received no shipping info on.
Flora
Well, they gave me a code for $10 off but you still need to spend $25 after discounts to get free shipping. And a lot of is now sold out (everything that I wanted actually lol). So don’t get suckered in with the email code you got today.
Reply
Jessie Dye
I really wanted the two faced face Palette but it was sold out 😭 if anyone has a new one for sale let me know
Reply
Lori
I practiced restraint as I just spent $400 in FFF add ons. I got:
-Kaja Heart Lip stuff (great reviews and too cute, always need balm/stains this time of year) x2
–Perricone MD Instant Blur (HG product, great deal!) x 2
–Ella and Mila nail polish (only $2!)
Around $35 w tax. Woohoo!
Reply
Sara
I got
2- glamgLOW – Glow Essentials Mask + Moisture Set
1- dr-brandt-pores-no-morer-luminizer-primer
The GlamGlow will make great gifts, should I decide NOT to keep them (prob will keep though) and I want to try the primer.
For under $30, I’m happy!
Reply
Page
I bought the Dr. Brandt primer at the last Pop Up and I really like it.
Reply
Page
I finally got the choice link to work in time to choose the Tula balm then I went in to Pop Up with a list of 3 items I really wanted. The Tula toner, the Angie perfume and the Elemis scalp mask. (It would be nice to hold back even a handful of every item for the base box subscribers or even limit items to 2 each of things on the first day.) JMHO None of the items on my list were available.
I did purchase:
MAC lipstick in Pretty Boy
BECCA glowgloss in Camelia
Skinfix resurfacing glycolic scrub
Perricone MD Vitamin C + citrus brightening cleanser
Cuccio yogurt milk bath
Rosie Jane perfume Rosie
Akar Skin soothing face oil.
I think I spent $75.00 today. Retail on everything came to $283.
I hope the rest of you got the things you wanted.
Reply
Flora
Is everything sold out yet? I’m curious to see if there’s anything I’d be interested in but I’ve skipped the past few months.
Reply
Lcbourgeois
They still have A LOT. I just checked for you. I knew they probably couldn’t run out of stuff because there was SO MUCH. Some things are gone, but 1/2 of what I ordered (or still want to order) is still available.
Reply
Flora
Thank you so much! I guess they were tired of running out in the first 30 minutes and people being so mad about it. I’m glad there’s a good supply this time around, finally wised up!
Christina
Does anyone know if they add more items tomorrow? I believe in the past they added more things the day it opened for all access but I’m not 100% sure.
Reply
Lcbourgeois
I just saw one new thing, but only one. I may have missed some, but most of what I see was available yesterday.
Reply
Marion
Maybe! Last time they raised the prices on some things, though. The theory on Reddit is that the prices went up (to at least $6 an item) because the bonus item for new subscribers was a $6 shop credit.
Reply
Marion
Flora, they did give out some new codes got $25 credit to people whose Premium boxes did not meet the promised value.
Flora
That code isn’t working anymore, maybe they won’t raise prices!
Lcbourgeois
Oh man I am having fun in popup today. I had to come see if everyone is as excited as I am. I think this has been the best popup yet. Boxy is killing it. I love seeing what everyone grabbed!!! I think I might have to go back in a fourth time. I am amazed!!!
Reply
Mary GT
Lol, I just went back a 4th time. 1st order was Elemis Dynamic Resurfacing Cream (will go with the Elemis pads I’m getting in my base box), 2nd order was the Two Faced Diamond Light eye palette and OSEA Ocean Cleansing Mudd. 3rd order was the ban.do Universal Power Bank (phone charger) and some hand sanitizer. And just now I added the Kate Somerville Bio-Mimicking Peptides Serum. The bottle I got as an add-on is gone and I love it!
Seems like items are selling out much quicker this time! Definitely placed 2 orders all ready. One quick one to make sure I scooped up at least most of my wish list. Hopefully they’ll restock some things for tomorrow all access!
Reply
Mika
This is a great sale with many options!!!
I got the:
Kopari deodorant
Kopari coconut lip glossy
Skinfix clay cleanser & glycolic renewing scrub
Rosie Jane: Angie
Hum: Hair & skin glow
Six Tony Moly sheet masks &
Adesse New York liquid lipstick ( I absolutely love this one, wish they had more shades)
All for $60.36
This was my second popup sale and can’t wait for more.
Reply
Jenn
I spent around $100 on 2 separate orders. The first order was the stuff I really wanted and wanted to grab before it sold out. The other was smaller less important items. I got a Zoeva Plaisor 2 box, the VV Best Life 2 pallete, the only Ace Beauty palette I dont have in the collection yet, the Classical Paradise, some sheet masks, some more Kypris, Avant primer (only because it was $6 and said it retails for over $100 so I want to try it.), Winky Luxe Matcha balm, nail polish remover, a pair of socks, Billion Dollar Brows Microblade pen, VV lippie and some Spongelles. That’s alot for under $100, I would pay that just for 2 of the palettes and I got 5 plus all the other stuff.
Reply
Lcbourgeois
I’m not sure if you’ve tried the Kypris, but I wanted to let you know I LOVE it!!! & I also love ace beaute!!! Their eyeshadows are phenomenal!!!!
Reply
Jenn
I have tried the Kypris which is why I was so happy to see it so cheap on the sale. Boxy got me into Ace Beaute palettes from the Grandiose palette they sent awhile back. Since then, I’ve been able to get pretty much all of their palettes through Boxy. Either through the box or add ons or pop up sales. I love them also.
Vi
Has anyone received the items that they ordered around April 13 from the last pop up sale? I have not received several of my items that I ordered on April 13. I sent an email and I’m waiting for a response. I also ordered something else after the 13th and received that one weeks ago. I hope the order that I placed today comes in a timely manner.
Reply
Liz H
Yeppers I just got my stuff last Saturday
Reply
Marion
Boxycharm does sometimes take a while to ship, & right now shipping is delayed for most companies. I’d allow an even larger cushion for the shipping window than usual before you start to get nervous.
Reply
Christa H.
Yes, I received my Hourglass blush last Thursday. It took forever
Reply
Crystal
I have received none of my items.
Reply
Samantha
I scored some pretty good deals, I wasn’t feeling any make up this time around. So I got skin care.
1. Sunday Riley Tidal
2. A ton of Tony Moly Face masks
3. Saturday Skin Water cream
4. Perrcone face was
5. It Cosmetics Moisturizer.
All for like 42 bucks !!! Amazing deal !!
Reply
Kate of Spades
I’ve upgraded to premium. I really wanted that teeth whitening device and blowout brush…and it saved me like 400$ (at least if you believe the retail prices)…and now that I’ve secured that I am going to shop make up!
Reply
Heidi
I got in no problem. This is the 1st time I’ve purchased on pop-up. I saw the Kypris for $5 and mine is half gone so I had to buy another.
I also got the Purlisse Watermelon & Marshmallow peel off mask, Ace Beaute Blossom Passion palette, & Georgette Klinger makeup remover.
Not bad for $27.63
Reply
Lena
I got 13 items (3 being eyeshadow palettes) for just under $100. Really nice selection this time around, I think this is the most I’ve ever spent on popup.
Reply
Tiffany Schmidt
I got the three things I wanted as soon as Pop Up opened. I got:
•Uptech True Wireless Skypods in Black (for my husband)
I’m really glad I was able to get what I wanted!
Reply
Lori
Ooooh, I’m envious of the Kaja Bento! Looked so cute, but both were sold out by the time I looked. Hope you love it!
Reply
Marion
I spent over $100. I’ve never spent that much on a pop-op/ad-ons/edit sale before. I think the FOMO of items potentially selling out before I could checkout prompted me to rush through & not carefully consider my purchases. 😆
Overall, I’m pretty pleased — I got what will be my first Viseart palette, plus the Hank & Henry palette I wanted, & a bunch of smaller stuff.
I loled at the DLS umbrella brand products being $1. I wonder if the KVD products will sell — the Boxy prices seemed like the same/similar to what they’ve been in the Sephora clearance section for a few months.
Reply
Marion
Oh, yeah, the other big ticket item I bought was the Ellis Brooklyn fragrance 4-piece Novellas set. That brand is $$$, so I’ve only ever gotten samples with my Sephora purchases. I was surprised & delighted to see the brand in this pop-up.
Reply
Marion
Yeah, By Rosie Jane perfume! Those were good deals, too, but I don’t tend to blind-buy full size perfumes any more.
Luna
I got that perfume set too! I’m so excited about it 🙂 I also got both bottles from another perfume brand I’ve been lusting after… but I can’t remember the name of the brand right now, lol! By Jane? I think it has the name Jane it. 😀
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.