MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Ipsy Best of 2019 Mystery Bag – Available Now!

Ipsy has added a new mystery bag to their Shopper section!  (Thanks for the heads up, Heather!)

The Box: Limited Edition Best of 2019 Mystery Bag

The Cost: $14

The Products:

Try 5 surprise picks that got all the cheers from Ipsters this year, all in one super cute bag. Plus, every bag will receive a bonus keychain gift to help you ring in the New Year!

Want a hint? Your mystery bag may contain products from these Ipster-favorite brands:







• & more …

Limit: 3 bags per order

Are you going to grab a mystery bag? 

FYI – you must be a current or previous ipsy subscriber to buy through Ipsy Shopper. If you are new to Ipsy, it is a $12 a month beauty and makeup subscription box. Check out all of our Ipsy reviews to see what’s been in past boxes And check out our Ipsy Spoilers to see what’s coming up in future boxes!


How do subscribers rate Ipsy?

per month
Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about Ipsy!

Enable notifications () to get the latest Ipsy spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in Ipsy News, Subscription Box News| Tags: ipsy | 23 comments

Comments (23)

  1. I recieved:

    The First Aid Beauty Coconut Water Cream
    (Pretty excited for this)

    Kensie Free Spirit Perfume
    (Meh, smells good, just not exciting)

    Ofra Madison Miller lip gloss in Smiley for Ryleigh
    (Full size, pretty shade, but I rarely use lip gloss)

    The Balm Foiled Again Eye Shadow in Red-handed
    (Really pretty shimmer, pretty excited)

    Vital Vita 12 Jelly Cleanser from Tony Moly
    ( I have actually been to Korea and this was my favorite makeup store to go into there by far, so I’m pretty excited)

    Cute Champagne Bottle keychain

    Over all I was pretty satisfied with the bag. It’s a solid 4 out of 5. I really like the actual bag itself. It’s really cute and has a nice metallic shine.

    • I got this exact bag too.. I loved the coconut first aid beauty lotion SOOO much I was raving to my boyfriend about how I just had to have a full size bottle when all of a sudden a 2 year old tattoo covering my shoulder and part of chest had an allergic reaction! It was so bad! I’m so upset too because I loved it at first did you have adverse reactions?

  2. I received my bag today. I got:
    -a Madison Miller/Ofra lip gloss (smile for Ryleigh, I think it was)
    -one of the “foiled again” eyeshadows from theBalm
    -a Kensie perfume (free spirit)
    -tonymoly gel cleanser (whatever one was in the orange tube)
    -First Aid Beauty coconut water cream
    -champagne bottle charm.

    I’m happy with all of that but the perfume (because most of it gives me a headache) but my sister will probably be happy to have it.

    And the bag is reminscent of the one that says “and off she went to change the world.” I initially thought it was the same one, just without printing, but this bag isn’t as shiny– it’s kind of a matte metallic, which I like.

    • I also recieved the exact same items. I was happy with it overall. The lip gloss I was excited because it looks like it was a full size and it’s OFRA, but I very rarely use lip gloss so I may find someone else to give that to.

  3. Please please ipsy send me those repeats of my favorite items!!! Dont send me new items!!! I will take the pixi blush and the ciate lipgloss!!!!

  4. I love buying the Mystery Bags as gifts for friends/family that dont get Ipsy. For $14 they make a really nice gift and are always a hit. I picked up 2 of the skincare, 2 of the neutrals, and a September bag as Christmas gifts. I thought they were all good bags and everyone that got one from me seemed to really like them.

  5. I was tempted, & the bag is cute, but I noped out after I saw the brand spoilers.

    Kensie + Eva NYC being “ipster favorites” is a blatant lie.

  6. I love the bags, and I use them as gift for friends, or to hide my period stuff. I don’t care if I get the same item as long as I get something that will make me feel special for a bit. Match or mismatch, at least I’m getting something, and if it’s not what I want I just gift it to my friends whom I know might enjoy it better then me. So people stop complaining about getting or not getting what you want, be great full you are getting something. And if you don’t like it then the door is wide open and leave. Stop ruin the best for those who really care about their bags.

  7. I can only laugh when people think the mystery bags are picked, due to your profile or that it even considers what you’ve got already. It’s a MYSTERY BAG!

    This bag is cute but I, also, got the Black Friday bag and have the skincare mystery bag. Not to mention how many regular ipsy bags I’ve got over the years.
    I hope whoever buys this, enjoys it and the MYSTERY of it.

  8. These mystery bags would be great if Ipsy *actually* made them according to the “theme” description. However it doesnt seem like they ever actually stick to that they just use them as an excuse to get rid of whatever random items are still sitting around, so of course no one wants a “Bag of Random”. If they stuck to the descriptions and it truly was a Best of 2019 bag I would definitely get it, but since they never stick to that, I’ll pass.

    • Bag of Random sounds like it would be a fun prank thing to throw into a Dungeons & Dragons game.

      • Outstanding comment. Thank you.

  9. Still waiting in my December bag so no thanks.

    • My December bag and my five add ons never shipped. Fedex was notified…. that was it. All but one of my add ons are now sold out. And four of the five items in my bag spoiler are no longer available. I honestly believe that Ipsy is a little overwhelmed with trying to fulfill the three versions of the bag, the item selection and the add ons. Sorry that I purchased the annual sub. Two of my add ons were purchased as Christmas gifts. I had to head out on the 23rd to replace those gift items. I will not be buying from the shop at this point. And no add ons for me on January 2nd.

      • I got mine okay, but I ended up whining on their Facebook page over the weekend about my Flash Sale items being in process since December 19, and lo and behold, I got a shipping notice today.

  10. Every time I order a mystery bag I get burned. The Black Friday bag filled with repeats I owned 5/6 of was last straw.

    • I feel the same way, I got the neutrals bag and the Black Friday bag, and at least half of both I already had the items. So you know best of 2019 cough cough old stock, will be stuff everyone already has. These are great for those that are just starting Ipsy or for gifts for other people. I got one will be passing and won’t be getting another mystery bag.

  11. Is each mystery bag the same? I couldn’t find anything about if there are different variations or not. Thanks!

    • If this one is like the other mystery bags, then there will be variations.

    • They send variations.

    • I purchased two of the neutrals bag and both bags were exactly the same. I was pretty bummed. Thought I would get different stuff.

  12. This is so tempting but after getting the black Friday bag and the little ipsy surprise bags and not interested in another random bag of left overs. The bag is cute though.

    • 👍🙌

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.