Ipsy Glam Bag Plus September 2019 SPOILERS!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

We have the first spoilers for the September 2019 Ipsy Glam Bag Plus! Thanks, Michelle, for the heads up! (These are some of the items that Ipsy is sending in September. There are different box versions every month, so you may not receive it in your Glam Bag Plus.)

Here are the first spoilers for the September 2019 Ipsy Glam Bag Plus:

I DEW CARE Disco Kitten Illuminating Diamond Peel-Off Mask

Illamasqua Antimatter Lipstick in Midnight

EYEKO Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner

What do you think of the first spoilers?

This subscription is $25 a month. Sign up here! (Check out our Ipsy Glam Bag Plus reviews to see what you can expect each month.) The waitlist is back on, so claim your spot on the waitlist now for a chance to get the September Glam Bag Plus as your first box.

And if you are new to the regular Ipsy, it is a $10 a month beauty and makeup subscription box. Check out all of our Ipsy reviews to see what’s been in past boxes. And check out our Ipsy Spoilers to see what’s coming up in future boxes!

How do subscribers rate Ipsy Glam Bag Plus?

194 subscribers rated this subscription
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to Ipsy Glam Bag Plus? Add your rating now!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Ipsy Glam Bag Plus Spoilers, Ipsy Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: ipsy glam bag plus | 222 comments


  1. You would think with the seasonal boxes coming up they would do better. Like everyone else this looks like a skip month.

    • Liz, how can I share my box photos with you so you can post more spoilers?

  2. I ha e tried the space kitten peeling Mason that I have gotten my regular ipsy glam bag. It is okay and not my favorite, I am waiting on the best set of spoilers to see how the September box will go.

  3. Still love Ipsy, but Ill skip Sept. So glad that is even an option!

    • How do you do that ?

      • Yeah I didn’t no u could skip a month if u don’t like the products?

  4. What in the Eyeko is going on here?

  5. Ipsy is one of my all time favorite subscription boxes/bags but these products have saddened me lol I’m definitely skipping and looking forward to BoxyLuxe

    • Same here, I’m skipping the this but I’m really excited for the September Boxy Luxe.

  6. Eyeko eyeliner? Oh please no! That should be in the regular Ipsy bag not the plus.

    • It’s already been in GBP twice.

      • So what if it’s already been in the plus bag? It still doesn’t belong.

    • Agreed! It would maybe be different if we received like a plum or brown. But seriously no Eyeko!

    • If it’s full size, which it has to be, I’m jazzed. It’s fantastic. I’ve loved everything Eyeko. When I finally tire of boxes I will buy this brand. Even their one mascara with a funky bent brush was great as soon as I straightened the brush.

  7. So far the lipstick is the only thing I’m interested in. I am a sucker for red lipstick. But enough with the freakin’ Eyeko already!!!! That brand is like a bad case of herpes!!!!

    • Hahahahahha it really is and thats such an accurate analogy. JUST GO AWAY, EYEKO!!!!

    • Oh my!!!, that’s so funny LOL

    • Omg Priceless! I probably have 58 in my beauty stash alone. It makes me mad when I see them now…like mad mad. Grrrrrr

      • Hook me up. Eyeko is good stuff but I’m too cheap to pay full price.

  8. I hope I get that eyeliner. I haven’t gotten an eyeko black one since last month.

    • Right?? 😂

    • 😂😂😂

      • 😆👌🏼 right!

    • 😹😹😹 for real

    • You joke but most people use their mascara and eyeliner (the pencils are safer, just sharpen) too long. A fresh one once a month should be suicide for these companies because after 6 weeks you should toss. Write it down. Eye infections aren’t cute, safe, or cheap!

      Thank you beauty boxes for helping me keep my eyes safe!

      • You are absolutely correct! I am with you! People keep their eye makeup WAY too long! I change mine monthly, so I adore receiving new mascaras. I never have to purchase any. First of the month…open new mascara. No-brainer for eye health! As an aside, why all the complaining about Eyeko products from some of these commenters?! Eyeko is high quality.

        • Go put on some of their waterproof mascara and let me know how you’re doing in two weeks when it still hasn’t come off…

          • Try the Too Faced Melt Away Mascara remover–I love the Eyeko Sport I got in my Beautyfix and it takes it off perfectly 🙂

  9. I think that eye liner is stalking me no matter which sub I have

    • That’s the way I feel about the Eyeko brand in general.

      • But Eyeko is good. I wouldn’t be mad if seafood dinners or Chris Pratt was following me, and I’m not mad to get Eyeko. (Id rather the seafood dinner of the three. They’re expensive in the Midwest and Pratt is married and so am I.)

        • To each her own, but I don’t like Eyeko at all. Just like a lot of people on here don’t like the red lipstick, which is the only spoiler that I like. It all comes down to personal preference.

  10. Unless there is an amazing second and third round of spoilers, I’ll be skipping, too. I was already irritated after my May box was lost in the mail so my add ons had to be refunded & my replacement box didnt have all of my items so I needed an additional refund. Then, July’s disappointing shade range for the foundation made me upset because they didnt even consider that there are women of color who also want to be included and get quality foundations. Now these items are lackluster. I got a peel off mask this month & dont need another one. I would rather skip than risk getting that eyeliner and I have so many lipsticks that this one doesnt excite me at all. May be an easy skip. Looks like lots of people agree which is sad.

    • Yes, many get “lost” in the mail monthly and it’s hell getting refunds from them. I actually had to go to PayPal before they’d even acknowledge not sending me items I ordered. On top of a lost plus bag, I had the entire Tetris set missing in a shipment that included two other palettes and I fortunately recorded myself opening the package since I don’t trust their handling at all. PayPal has to intervene since they ignored my emails.

    • I totally agree with the foundation choices! I’m Native American and it’s a pain in the ass to find a matching foundation. They need to make the profile more customizable towards foundation shades.

      • Megan, I’m Native American too, and they sent me the It foundation in medium lol. I am super dark this time of year. So, to be able to use it, I went ahead and purchased a foundation darkening and lightening drops set online at Ulta. I know it’s annoying to have to buy something else to be able to use a product, but it’s a quick solution so I can use the product. Just thought I’d mention this in case you want to check it out. 😉

        • I’m from Spain, even darker by the swimming pool sessions this season and same problem with the light medium foundation they sent me

          • I didnt even get a foundation– boohoo!! I think I may could do a light or light medium if you wanna trade something for it!??

        • It’s not comparable, but most people have to adjust their foundation seasonally. I’m sure your tone is underserved and that’s wrong. I’m between shades that ipsy offers so I never, ever get the right shade from them, but I can get my shade in any drug store so I know I’m still privileged.

    • Totally Agree!!!!

  11. I skipped August because nothing excited me, but oh yes, I’m coming back for Disco Kitten. I have deluxe samples of it, Space Kitten, and Sugar Kitten, and I’d just been thinking about buying a full-size Sugar Kitten. Besides being good skincare, I fully admit to using them partly for their Instagram fun factor.

  12. Oh Ipsy…..you’ve been doing so good but this,….this not so much. I’ve never skipped before but these spoilers are definitely making me consider it

  13. Looks like I might be skipping next month….none of those interests me. Although I bet my 10 year old would love the mask.

  14. Easy skip. If I just have a chance for eyeko liner – I’m pass!

  15. I could use a new liner but not this one. I really don’t like the brush tip on it, it’s way too soft. The formula is waaay too watery and it bleeds badly. *If* you can draw on an acceptable line, it does stay put, but it’s definitely not a good liner for beginners. I am not great at liner, but not terrible…unless I use this one.

    • Do you store it brush-down? Eyeliner pens are markers and have to be stored as such.

  16. Literally that eyeliner is haunting me ! Stop it’s horrible!!!!

    • I love Eyeko

      • Eyeko is fine stuff. Love it. Give it all day long. Someone said they would like to see plum. Yeah, plum or navy would be cool, but I use up my Eyeko. I don’t use up very much.

    • Same here! Oh my gosh, I am putting it on hold now. I swear I am gonna get the damn eyeliner if I am not on hold.

  17. Boring…

  18. And…I’m out

  19. Eww.

  20. As of right now not a fan. I don’t use any of the products featured. (Product family not brand)

  21. Ugh I want none of these – hoping the next spoilers are going to save it (though I always end up with everything I don’t want). I’ve never skipped a month – does anyone know how to do that or when the cut off is to do it? How long can I wait before successfully skipping this month?

    • I want to say 12pm PT on the 31st.

    • You need to make sure you skip before the 31st because that’s when they’ll charge you. If you go to Ipsy and click on account and then go edit account setting next to your name and go to membership you’ll see a skip the month option under the glam bag plus tab. You just click on that and you can choose to pause for 1, 2, or 3 months. Hope this helps!

  22. Red lips and black liner. Snooze. I’ll wait for a few more rounds of spoilers but it looks like I might be skipping September.

  23. Yeah.. I’ve had to skip the last 2 months due to a move and saw what they were sending & was glad I skipped. Think I’ll continue skipping.
    I’ve been be getting it since the start and was always thrilled. I think they are going downhill real quick. Shame.

  24. Oh dear. I just subscribed😕. Not liking any of these. Peel-off masks are gimmicky and black eyeliner is too harsh for aging eyes. Hoping I get the lipstick.

    • I couldn’t agree more.

  25. Very underwhelming

  26. They are all bad! Disappointing. They say peel off masks can damage your skins elasticity. At my age I’m scared to use them, my skin might not snap back!

    • 😂😂😂😂😂

    • I just used one for the first time in years (I’m 44 currently) and it was not a great experience to say the least. It was the Purlisse Watermelon Energizing Marshmallow Peel Off Mask. I love watermelon, love marshmallow more, and thought I would love not having to rinse the mask off (I love masks but hate that part).
      It smelled good but was super thick and gooey which made it difficult to get even coverage plus it took almost the whole sample tube (.5oz) to cover my face and a small part of my neck with a thin layer. But the worst part took me by surprise. It freakin’ HURT to peel it off. And it did pull my skin away from my face a bit. And then the places that didn’t have enough product left a white clingy dust I had to scratch off with my fingernail. Grant it, I haven’t derma planed my face in a while so my peach fuzz was likely a contributor. But still. Masks should be relaxing.
      However… I have to admit it was pretty effective. My face which has been very dry and flaky lately, was super smooth with no excess skin at all. That made me feel conflicted until I heard a tip today. Apply a layer of moisturizer before applying any peel off mask. So I’m gonna give it a go on however much of my face I have enough mask left for. If it works I’d love to try this mask spoiler but I definitely don’t want another red lipstick (the color I always get even though it’s marked as “Rarely”) or a fifth or sixth eyeko eyeliner.

      • Your post was so good, like reading a great thriller I swear! I needed popcorn! ❤

  27. I’d like the Illamasqua lipstick. Solid NOPE on the eyeliner and mask.

  28. Disco Kitten would be fun just for the name, but the rest of it? No thanks.

    • It’s not a great mask. I don’t have problems removing peel off masks like some people, but it was an adventure in nothing but a cute name. I’d be mad to get it. I’m going to adjust my profile to say I hate masks even though I don’t because I don’t want it. I’d rather have another highlighter or matte liquid lipstick and I hate these things so.very.much but they at least do what they say they do.

  29. I’ve never skipped before, but I just did. 🙁

  30. Easy skip

  31. Yikes! Not the least bit interested in any of these. September’s a skip for me for now, hoping for some better spoilers to come!

  32. I could deal with eyeliner, but Eyeko is a terrible brand and I don’t understand why they keep promoting it.

    • I agree!

    • Their mascara is awesome. They sell it in Anthropologie and the mascaras have 4 & 5 star reviews. I wasn’t crazy about the liquid liner though.

      • Personal preference. I have their mascara and it went in the garbage. It was just a clumpy mess. Everyone likes different things, but I personally don’t think much of it. Same with NYX.

  33. Out of these, I’m hoping for the lipstick. I’ve only gotten lipstick once that I can remember in my bags so far, so maybe I have a chance 🙂

  34. At least it’s Boxyluxe month!! Goodtime for me to skip this

    • I might skip or even cancel my Ipsy GBP (I’ll be keeping my regular Glam Bag subscription though) if the September Boxyluxe is good. The June Boxyluxe was okay but I wasn’t as excited about getting it as I was the December Boxyluxe.

  35. If I get the eyeko eyeliner I’m quitting. WHY is this everywhere? It sucks.

    • Yes it’s been everywhere I have like 10 . Ugh 😑

  36. Yuk! No thanks… I just got off the waitlist for The Box from Fashionsta I’m hoping to replace Ipsy plus.

    • Omg!! I am so jealous. Im tryna do the same thing! I got the email for the box to get off the waitlist and it had already closed!!! Ugh! I want it so bad and when i do im gonna drop ipsy gbp. It started out good but now its too many masks and i hate eyeko… The eyeliner is the worst! This month will still prob be a pass…. So unmoved!

  37. Oh nooooo!, i hate peel off masks and already have a bunch of them. Grrrrrrrrr!!!

  38. I have received a sample of the Disco Kitten in my regular bag and I loved it. I wouldn’t mind getting the full size 😃 I have opted out of receiving eyeliner and mascara, but Ipsy still sent me the Eyeko Mascara this month, so I’m not confident I won’t receive the eyeliner

  39. This is the first time I’ve been so underwhelmed by GBP spoilers. I bought that mask when it came out and returned it. It literally does nothing aside from looking cute bc it’s pearly white. I have 2 of those eyeliners I’ve never used that I’ve gotten from Ipsy in the past… and the lipstick shade is really unexciting. Maybe I’ll skip next month.

    • Going to skip next month as well unless they come out with an amazing palette and brush set

  40. I don’t need any of these, but I’m still hopeful

  41. I hope there are better spoilers coming.. these are awful!

  42. The disco kitten looks good, actually. And that lipstick would look good on me but the Eyeko 🙄

    • I have the I dew care mask and I love it!

  43. These are pretty underwhelming, but I’ll reserve judgement since sometimes Ipsy really hits it out of the park.

    • I know, I’m kinda hoping all the people saying they’re going to skip actually do, and the box turns out to be kickass, but it’s just a sub, so I don’t feel badly about being petty Betty at all!

  44. Blah

  45. Looks like a pause month for me!

  46. Oh the spoilers are horribly disappointingBut I’ve been horribly disappointed by first spoilers and then thrilled with my bag in the end before so I’m not throwing in the towel yet. However pausing or skipping seems to be eminently pointless with the subscription because if you didn’t get it this month you’re going to get it next month and I really dislike that

    • Yea, spoilers looked great for this month, but my box ended up being ok and all the good items were not add-on options.

    • Courtney- you are spot on. I truly don’t get the mentality behind “pausing”, because undoubtedly, *if* one un-pauses, the likelihood of ending up with items you initially were trying to avoid is high 90’s 🤷🏻‍♀️

  47. I’ve only liked one of the glam plus boxes out of the last four. Hitting pause again…

  48. Ir there any possibility of not getting that liquid eyeliners, they hurt my eyes

  49. Oh no! Eyeko..tired of getting eyeko😩

    • This box keeps getting worse.

  50. What on earth is that eyeko doing in the glam bag PLUS? Round two better be mind blowing or I will have to skip again. Or maybe just cancel since I can get a lot of the products as regular glam bag addons.

    • Agreed, seems like things that didn’t sell perhaps? That lipstick isn’t going to work for everyone either.

      • I love the lipstick color but I never heard of this brand. GBP is going way downhill.

        • Ilmasqua is a premium brand, but not well known. Their products are good, but expensive.

          I hope I get it, but if not, I hope it’ll be in the add-ons, because $12 is almost half off the full price.

    • I am more excited about the fact that I cancelled both my regular and plus than I was about a majority of the items I received over the last few months. If I had actually gotten the box that was suppose to have the Sunday Riley CEO I might have kept up hope but ipsy scamming me and so many people with the bait and switch made the decision easy.

    • Eyeko eyeliners have already been in GBP. Twice.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!