Ipsy Glam Bag Plus September 2019 SPOILERS Round 2!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

We have more spoilers for the September 2019 Ipsy Glam Bag Plus! (These are some of the items that Ipsy is sending in September. There are different box versions every month, so you may not receive it in your Glam Bag Plus.)

Here are the some spoilers for the September 2019 Ipsy Glam Bag Plus:

And in case you missed the previous spoilers:

I DEW CARE Disco Kitten Illuminating Diamond Peel-Off Mask

Illamasqua Antimatter Lipstick in Midnight

EYEKO Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner

What do you think of the spoilers?

This subscription is $25 a month. Sign up here! (Check out our Ipsy Glam Bag Plus reviews to see what you can expect each month.) The waitlist is back on, so claim your spot on the waitlist now for a chance to get the September Glam Bag Plus as your first box.

And if you are new to the regular Ipsy, it is a $10 a month beauty and makeup subscription box. Check out all of our Ipsy reviews to see what’s been in past boxes. And check out our Ipsy Spoilers to see what’s coming up in future boxes!

How do subscribers rate Ipsy Glam Bag Plus?

218 subscribers rated this subscription
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to Ipsy Glam Bag Plus? Add your rating now!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Ipsy Glam Bag Plus Spoilers, Ipsy Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: ipsy glam bag plus | 100 comments


  1. Has anyone else not been able to find out what there getting in their August box? My payment went through a day late and now nothing.

    • You have to email ipsy asking them to reveal your products. Its a pain but happens to me all the time.

      • I’ve tried that but they keep saying my account is still updating and they can’t see what my combo is yet. So very frustrated.

        • 🙄 maybe just wait for it to come. Patience is a virtue.

          • That’s good advice. Thanks

  2. Why is it my Ipsy and Ipsy plus seem to frequently get stuck in Hebron Kentucky. I don’t like DSL and wish the US Postal service could deliver my items entirely.
    I get my boxy charm sooner because I don’t think they use DSL

  3. I would give anything if Ipsy actually followed my choices. I have highlighters as rarely, and what has been front and center for the past 6 months… you guessed it highlighters. I do not use them ever… this would be a skip month except for the hope of the Murad and the Berlin palette. Fingers crossed!!!

    • Berlin palette?????

    • October they will let us choose a product! and they stated they will go off our customization more. lets hope this is true!

  4. I am so tired of black eyeliner! Grrr

    • That reminds me, I need to email IpsyCare and ask them to opt me out of eyeliners.

  5. Does anyone’s Ipsy timeline say customization this month? Mine did last month on the 24th, but it is not showing up now.

    • Mine did on the 1st of the month or something like that, now it says in transit.

      What I find odd is my GBP is in transit with DHL and my regular glam bag is in transit with Fed Ex. Its my first getting the regular glam bag with my plus box (usually only get the plus) so I’m not sure if this is normal for ipsy to have two shipping carriers. I trust fed ex a lot more than DHL lol

      • Mine GBP (which just arrived) was the first ever shipment I have received from Ipsy that came FedEx instead of DHL.

      • My GBP still says its en route to DHL(5 dyas ago), with no updated info and no set delivery date. It makes me nervous because I really liked my curation and I’m wanting to avoid having to reach out to customer service. I hope I’ve really got nothing to worry about.

        • Mine is the same. I’m nervous, too. Especially since so many people a few months ago didn’t receive theirs. I like my box this month and added on 2 add one that I know they sold out of quickly. I have my fingers crossed I actually receive my box!

  6. Is this the same setting powder we got in FFF?

    • Sure is and I just got the Becca set and refresh powder this month in Boxycharm which is actually the only powder I use. I love the dewy look on myself and I don’t bake, so the other twenty powders in my drawer, are dust collectors lol

  7. I just got that setting powder in the IpsyHaul and it is nice. Excited for that Ofra palette!

  8. Still on pause. I got the Murad this month so don’t expect the serum which is the only product I would really want, even though the spoilers definitely improved.

  9. Really can’t figure out why my comments only post 1/4 of the time.

    I am actually really excited to see the Murad serum on here. I have been wanting to try it for months now but the price tag is a bit too steep. Hopefully I will receive it in my box, or have the option to add it on.

    The serum alone is all I need in the box to be completely thrilled! I wouldn’t mind the glamglow cleanser either!! I knew there would be better spoilers than what we saw in the first round 🙂

    • I bought the sample size at Ulta and it works with one application. my spots lightened and so did my hyperpigmentation. I hope to god I get this full-size Murad product.

      • Good to know, Kathy! Thanks for sharing because at 44 my biggest issue is hyperpigmentation. It was like I woke up with tons of giant “freckles” one day. The kind that don’t go away when summer ends. I haven’t found anything that works yet and they’re getting worse. I just cannot afford to get professional treatments for it. I’ve been eyeing this Murad product for a while but hated to risk wasting more money since most products take a while to work and by then it’s too late for a refund. I’m going to hope and pray I get the Murad in my Ipsy Plus. I don’t think I’ve ever seen them offer a Murad product as an add-on, at least not for me. But if I don’t get it I’ll just have to buy it from Sephora. If one use helped you hopefully it will work and be a good investment for me.
        Thanks again!

  10. The 1st three spoilers had me SUPER CLOSE to skipping September n I’ve never skipped a month with ipsy in the last full year + that I’ve been with them. But these NEW spoilers have me excited! 😍
    Id LOVE to get that Glamglow & Murad!

    • Girl, exactly! That is exactly how I feel. Plus I saw a spoiler somewhere with a really cool and adventurous shadow pallet. Berlin underground I think? Anyway, that Murad serum is all I need to be EXTREMELY happy. Even If I have to add it on, I’ll still be happy to get it for just 12 bucks.

      • Berlin Underground is on my wish list! It’s by Nomad Cosmetics and is completely vegan. I got a sample of one of the colors in my regular Ipsy a few months ago and it is very buttery shadow. I just ordered their Marrakesh Medina palette in Ipsy Shopper this morning (almost got the Berlin Underground).

        • That is so good to hear! I got a Natasha Denona single in an allure box a few months ago and it was SOO buttery! I was SHOOK! Hopefully the Berlin Underground pallet is similar to that and will end up in my box this month. They do usually send at least one pallet, and I have eyeshadow select as always and highlighter on rarely. That pallet and the Murad would be AAAAAMZING!! fingers crossed 🙂

  11. I am actually really excited to see the Murad serum on here. I have been wanting to try it for months now but the price tag is a bit too steep. Hopefully I will receive it in my box, or have the option to add it on.

    The serum alone is all I need in the box to be completely thrilled! I wouldn’t mind the glamglow cleanser either!!

    First round spoilers are usually trash, which turned out to be the case for September, but I’m very happy with these spoilers. YAY FOR MURAD!!

  12. I got the coolest email yesterday from Ipsy. They were apologizing for sending me the mini Thrive mascara again this month in my regular sub, I got the FS in my plus last month. They gave me 600 points to use. Thought that was pretty great especially because I could easily throw all my other mascaras out and only keep Thrive.

  13. Meh, not that excited about this. I will probably skip for sure.

  14. i have a feeling we’re all going to get a lipstick variation (unless opted out) 😅🙃

    • Well maybe I will finally use those Illamasqua lip liners I got a couple of months back lol they are still sealed in the box.

  15. I don’t feel like this is a crazy good month for Plus, but I’ll hang in there. I don’t have multiple subs and don’t feel like going through the hassle of pausing and picking up something else. They always send me one or two things I like or can use. I’m really in it for the skincare and we haven’t really seen much from that side of the box yet. I’m throwing caution to the wind, don’t make me regret it Ipsy! Lol!

  16. Ooof, not looking good for me. I just skipped both my GBPs. I may reactivate my regular bag if a better spoiler pops up in hopes that I can get it as an add on. But no FOMO so far on the Plus bags.

  17. Am I the only one who actually loves the I Dew Care masks? I have both disco kitten and sugar kitten.

    • If it makes you feel any better, I don’t totally hate it. LOL. But I do prefer the convenience of sheet masks over both peel off and rinse off masks.

    • Me and my husband love them. We haven’t tried this one but we do have the Space Kitten one.

  18. May have to skip a month for the first time. Nothing looks to exciting to me.

  19. I’m opted out of eyeliner and lipstick, so hopefully that’ll increase my chances for the Glamglow and Murad!!! Maybe I won’t skip for the second month in a row after all!

    • Same

  20. Still a pause month for me.

  21. This is became a really easy pass for me. Even if there was something I wanted in particular, for the past few months ipsy seems to purposefully choose items that don’t match my skin tone or hair type, and only makes those things available in the add-ons. This subscription has become basically paying to have to sell on ebay to recoup the cost and maybe get the chance to maybe buy something useable on sale.

    • I agree 💯%
      Constantly disappointed with shades and selection. Spent all this money and still have to run out to store.
      Took the fun out of it.
      Reg glam bag great.
      So back to $10 a month for me.

  22. That variation looks perfect and fits my profile but the past few months ipsy has been off with my personalization so fingers crossed 🤞🏻

    Gonna wait until more boxyluxe spoilers are released though. I’m trying to get both regular ipsy and GBP (maybe add-ons too) as well as boxyluxe. Going to depend on my budget 😅

  23. Omegerd. I must have that GlamGlow and serum.

    • Me too!!! I would love those choices!!!

    • hahahah ERRMEEERRRGERRRDDDD SAME!! Must have that Murad! At the very least please let it be available for add on.

  24. These are much better spoilers. I really do not want more Eyeko eyeliner though or another mask. I still might skip. Anyone know the date you have you skip by?

    • Last day of the month. I was able to skip August on July 31, as they don’t charge until the 1st.

    • They charge me at 11:59 p.m. on the last day of the month. It’s in their FAQ section if you want to check it out. If you want to skip, I would wait until the day before so you still have access to the daily flash sales.

    • I’ve always been billed in the last day of the month, on your membership it says please update your membership before 12 PM PT on 08/31/2019.

  25. Please, Ipsy…just give me the exact box on top. You can leave off all the rest. Just those five exact products…..😍😸

    1) Murad most wanted
    2) Lipstick in color featured in box
    3) Palette
    4) GlamGlow
    5) Setting Powder

    Y’all know I’m getting the Eyeko and the orangish red lipstick. Probably the mask too. 😑

    • You and me both! I want everything except the liner and the peel off mask =\

      At least i am opted out of liners, so hopefully i should not be getting that. But, there is a chance i could get the kitten mask sigh.

      Why do they exist, it serves no purpose other than leaving broken capillaries on the face!

    • That setting powder is really good! I got a sample awhile back in my regular glam bag. I’m 42, not all powders work out well for me, I love this one! Good luck! I hope you get your dream box. I’m off to change my opt outs, because I’d rather take blush and bronzer (which I hate) over Eyeko (which I hate even more). Blush and bronzer will at least be easier to trade.😂

  26. Ugh. No. Pass.

  27. Nothing is grabbing my attention.. I definitely do not need anymore cleanser!

  28. If I was for sure going to receive the Glamglow or Murad..if ONLY..I would commit to staying! But given my track record..I will probably get the Eyeko ( because I need another one..HA!) MORE Lipsticks I won’t wear..and YET another Blush that I will never use..HAHA! For now I will hang around for more spoilers..but maybe I will skip Plus and hope to add one of those items to Regular bag!

    • This is what I do, that way I’m not stuck with a bunch of stuff I won’t use.

  29. As much as I would like to believe that this dark spots serum will actually help with this problem, I just don’t. And it is the only item even remotely interesting in this box this month. I love bullet lipsticks, but already have this one. Another skip.

  30. Is the OFRA Madison Miller Palette blush?

  31. When I saw the first spoiler for September, I was so convinced to pause my sub but now I don’t know anymore!!! 😭😭😭

  32. Passssss!!! I don’t need anymore skincare, get tons of that in other boxes! I wanted Ipsy for the makeup. I’m pausing until I see what “The Box” from Fashionsta looks like the next couple of months. I think I’m going to end up dropping Ipsy again.

    • Sharon, do you mind sharing with me which subs you’re familiar with that offer the most skincare? I love skincare and currently only subscribe to Ipsy.

      • BeautyFix by Dermstore is mostly skincare.

      • Test tube by new beauty also has lots of skin care.

      • Victoria, I can tell you that New Beauty Test Tube is hands down my favorite sub box because it is mainly skin care. High end, a lot of full size products, and just a overall amazing box. I can’t sing its praises highly enough. Their website is a little janky, but if you have any issues you can call their customer service team and they are very lovely and helpful. Definitely check it out, or look at reviews of it on the MSA site.

  33. If I reactivate GBP now I will get the Sept one, right? Just want to make sure as I don’t want August’s.

    • I just unpaused mine and it said my next one would be September. For reactivating I heard that after August 5th you would get September, but it’s best if you ask Ipsy directly or check what it shows on your account what your next box would be.

      With Ipsy, sometimes you get the next month and sometimes you get the month you sign up in so it is hard to know for sure.

      • Great, thanks for the response!👍

  34. I’d love ❤️ to get the serum!!

  35. Ok, I’m here for the Murad and a lipstick. I rarely get a lipstick in either bag, but I finally feel like I might have a good chance to get one! 🙂 If not in the box, then add-ons please! Either way, I’m good with it!

  36. This is more like it!!🤩

  37. I didn’t care for the first three spoilers, but I really like all 5 of the new ones!

  38. Well I love the Murad, and it’s worth two or three of these boxes alone with RV, but I wish I was guaranteed at least one pick for the box. Hopefully they expand what they did last month to all of the subscribers and let us pick one product. If not, I may pause one of my boxes and get the other one for this month.

  39. I would LOVE to get the Ciate setting powder and Ofra highlighter but I’m sure I won’t cause I don’t get anything I want to receive. Definitely don’t want the eyeliner or lipstick. Contemplating September..

    • Message them. I did and I received the IT foundation, even after they said that customizations were closed and there was no guarantee I would receive it. They didn’t even offer to try. Maybe it was a coincidence but I received it. Usually I get twin boxes with my sister and she did not receive the IT foundation.

  40. Thinking I might skip. I’m looking forward to Madison’s collection, but that looks like blush/highlight, which I don’t really wear. I already have a skin care like than is so perfect that I don’t want skincare. This box is looking rather light in the makeup department, and what is there isn’t looking too exciting to me. Hoping there’s a couple more rounds of spoilers before I decide.

  41. I think I’m going to have to pass too. Last month was a bust and it’s making me lose a little faith in IGBP….

  42. This month is a NO

  43. I really wish they would give you an option to pick one guaranteed item. Some of these are very appealing to me, but some are very meh, and there’s never been enough of interest overall to convince me to subscribe yet, even as a longtime subscriber to the regular monthly glam bag.

  44. For those who have been subscribed since the beginning, during October 2018, some GBP boxes included the Eyeko Black Magic liquid eyeliner. You can easily check by clicking on the ‘previous bags’ link, and selecting the option for that month.
    I mention this only because they promise not to send repeat products. It’s not a bad product, but I certainly don’t want to receive it twice in less than twelve months!

    • That was the eyeko skinny, at least for me, so I think they could argue that it’s a different product.

    • I definitely got a repeat last month. To top it off, I wasn’t able to review it for points, because I had already reviewed it once! I ended up cancelling because I kept getting highlighters, even though I tried to opt out of them and gave them all terrible reviews.

    • I was exceptionally proud that Ipsy caught that they put the same mascara in both GB and GBP! THEN, to make it up to me, they gave me 600 points to order another product!!
      Plus I really liked the products I’m getting in both this month. But September…?? My first reaction was No No No!

    • Yes I was thinking the same thing, I already recieved the eyeliner, and would not want to recieve it again.

  45. It’s a great big yes to the Ofra Madison collab palette… All of round two’s spoilers look great. Round one’s spoilers were “meh”.

  46. Clearly everyone is getting a Illamasqua lipstick 🙄

  47. I’m always game for anything Murad and Ciate, but all the others are so “meh” for me, that I can’t risk it. Pass.

  48. I need the Murad!

  49. Oh this is an easy skip month for me. I really like Ipsy GBP but none of this excites me. It’s all nice products but colors I won’t use and items I don’t need. Fingers crossed for October.

    • Right… There’s just to many things I don’t want to take a chance on this box.

      • Agreed!! There isn’t one thing that totally wows me. Most months there had been a few good things and worth taking the chance. The worst I’ve had is two great products and three eh ones but would still use but not happily.

  50. Omg I want all of that – I was upset with the first spoilers but now I’ll unpause 🥰🥰

    • Agreed. Round two’s spoilers look really nice. I hope I receive the Ofra x Madison Miller palette.

    • Agreed! Ciaté London is my favorite makeup brand and I feel like it is so overlooked. The setting powder is phenomenal and the only one that doesn’t settle into my fine lines. Love anything by Ofra. This spoiler just saved me from cancelling completely!

Leave a Reply to Alexis R Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!