BoxyLuxe September 2019 – Make Your Selections by 1 PM EST

ByLiz CadmanJul 19, 2019 | 56 comments

1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

FYI - Current Boxyluxe subscribers should check their email - it's time to let them know your preferences for the September 2019 BoxyLuxe box! (Thanks for the heads up, Lien!)

The subject line is "It's time to CUSTOMIZE!" and you'll get a specific survey link. You have until Friday, July 19th, at 1 PM EST to fill out your prefences. They will do their best to send you at least one of your preferences.

In case you missed it, here are the spoilers:

All subscribers to the September 2019 BoxyLuxe will receive:

Sutra Beauty 32mm Clipless Curling Iron OR MODA Makeup Brushes 8pc Brush Kit

In case you missed the previous spoiler:

Spongelle Mani Pedi Treatment and Clean Skin Water Bottle Infuser

Tarte Park Ave Princess Chisel Palette

In case you missed the first spoiler, each subscriber will receive:

Sunday Riley Tidal Brightening Enzyme Water Cream

Glow Recipe Pineapple-C Bright Serum

What do you think of the spoilers? Which items do you want?

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular Boxycharm box is $21 a month. BoxyLuxe is a once-a-quarter upgrade option you can add to your existing $21-a-month Boxycharm subscription. So for an additional $28.99, you’ll get the Luxe items, and be paying a total of $49.99 for that quarterly box.

Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Starting at $32.00

Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm

4.3 overall rating

1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

Spoilers

Deals

Reviews

Read customer reviews >

Posted in BoxyCharm, Subscription Box News

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Read More By Liz Cadman >

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Notify me of follow-up comments by email

56 comments

KerryD

The writeup above says “you can add to your existing $21-a-month Boxycharm subscription. So, for an additional $28.99 you get the luxe items…”
Just to clarify, does that mean you’ll get your regular monthly Boxycharm box PLUS the Boxyluxe box four times a year?

Dot

No one or the other quarterly

Mel

Well I for one love a good surprise! Sometimes I try don’t like and toss and sometimes I try later and sometimes I give away… right now one of my favorite products is a Neutrogena lip gloss which really hydrated my lips. But in all actuality I’d never be able to try
Some of these products if they weren’t in the sub boxes… I’m game for anything!

Moana

I found the brushes at Moda. $15.99 for the (4)large brushes and $14.99 for the (4)small brushes. Only difference is both sets included a little bag.

The value is not there = easy pass for me. Plus, I received a Moda brush from Allure bb, and it was so lightweight & flimsy(CHEAP!!). I gave it to my 4yo for play.

You can pick up a Moda 6 piece brush set on sale right now via Wallymart .com for $5.24 <3

pinkhoo

IDK what Moda brush you got in the Allure beauty box but almost every Moda brush I’ve ever gotten was excellent. Even if they cost less money than a clipless curling iron they’re still better than clipless curling irons because without the clip those irons are just burned fingers waiting to happen. They’re not safe, not uncommon, and not expensive (no matter what Boxy says this one is worth.)

Moda brushes are made by a company that first made (and still makes) artist paint brushes, so don’t think that just because they’re readily available they’re not good. Maybe that one in the in the Allure box was a fluke for you. The cost of something doesn’t indicate anything except who has access to it.

I contacted ELEMIS customers services and asked if there product are in boxycharm subscription box and they said NO??????

I’m wondering know how there getting there product or are they REAL?????

HOW CAN IBFIND OUT IF THIS IS REALLY PRODUCTS???????

the butter London palette color queen dont match with real palette either?????

And there number on the back are different??????

Katie P

Did you ask if they are specifically in August’s box? Maybe that’s why they said no. They are affiliated with Boxycharm and openly talk about what brands and products they include in Boxycharm boxes, they also tag the companies in their posts too. They gave everyone their Superfood Vital Veggie mask in July’s box.

I contacted ELEMIS customers services and asked if there product are in boxycharm subscription box and they said NO??????

I’m wondering know how there getting there product or are they REAL?????

HOW CAN IBFIND OUT IF THIS IS REALLY PRODUCTS???????

the butter London palette color queen dont match with real palette either?????

And there number on the back are different??????

I think this is a SCAM COMPANY!!!!

Should I cancel my subscription with???

TammyH

Should be interesting as I only chose one thing and surprise me for everything else! So we’ll see if I get the one thing I chose which was the spongelle/water bottle combo 😀

Dot

For the price of boxyluxe doesn’t look great sadly 🙁 hope I don’t get the crappy stuff since I missed customization email – missed the deadline – sorry I have to work and can’t check my email as often – sighs oh well,
As long as I get SR 🥰 I’d be a happy girl , pineapple doesn’t work for my sensitive skin plus don’t want another curl iron my hairs naturally curly – I’ll just sit back wait and see – hope you guys all get what you want 🤞

Kam

Am I the only one who NEVER receives emails from Boxycharm? I will occasionally catch a notification that one has come through and when I open it, it seems to disappear. I can’t find it anywhere- inbox, spam, etc. I think they quickly ‘unsend’ their emails and I contacted them about it several times. All I get is a “check spam” response for everything. 😠

Beth

I also NEVER get them, and when I contact Boxy they are insist I missed it in my spam, etc. which of course I don’t and thoroughly check for that. They basically say Oh Well. It’s infuriating that some get to customize and others don’t.

NikitaMarie

I always get them late, and I REALLY hope so can email customer service about my severe pineapple allergy.. I love Glow Recipe, and pineapple, but my once mild allergy has gotten much worse as I’ve aged.

Toni

Yeah I always received mine after the cut off

Cady

So from the way they worded it, it seems like we’re not really guaranteed our options. I’m glad I read that now before getting my hopes up & my mind set on certain products.

Renee

I resubbed to Boxy for the promo this week, then upgraded just after noon yesterday and immediately emailed about customization. CS sent me a link to customize. I chose surprise, Spongelle/infuser, and Glow Recipe (top choice) because my skin doesn’t like Tidal.

crystal lowden

In Case I get the Pineapple Serum since I am another that doesn’t get the Customization this month, Would you like to trade since I Absolutely Would like get the Tidal Cream Since I need one really bad lol.

Kathleen Hill

I got the email but was sick so didn’t see👀 it in the measly 24 hrs the link had. So now what? Another crappy palette? I’m tired of having to race to get anything decent and the Boxy pop-up was the same deal I don’t sleep with my computer on, Charm room is lousy too. Probably never be able to get anything good there.

John

Same. I didnt see the post .

pinkhoo

Wow, they sure didn’t give a lot of time, did they? I don’t go through my personal email every day. I missed choosing by a few hours. Very annoying.

Ali

I missed as well 🙁 so bummed!!! These choices are so polarizing for me too.. like a couple items I have zero use for & don’t want @ all.. others I’m DYING to get. Now I’m trying to decide if it’s even worth $50 to chance my luck.. or if I should just wait & try to buy the items I desperately want in groups.

Karissa

Even if you were able to pick, you’re still not guaranteed To get those items 🙄 so I kinda wish I didn’t even pick bc if I get items I didn’t choose, I’m gonna be kinda upset. Like I literally told you all I didn’t want that and still got it and from boxycharm, I’m definitely expecting one item at least that I didn’t want. I just really hope it’s not that damn water bottle…. but that’s my luck.

Becky

I got my email and completed the customization survey. Shouldn’t be surprised but Boxy is backsliding on customization. The only spoilers we have for the August Luxe box are all variants … and they’ll TRY to give you at least ONE of the items you want. At least we were able to choose between the flat iron OR palette in December Boxyluxe and whether we wanted the Tarte eyeshadow or face palette in the June Boxyluxe. This time, they’ll TRY to give us one of our 3 choices ?? (for those of us who were “lucky” enough to get the email!).

Cady

Yeah what is that?? Why even bother to offer customization if it’s not guaranteed. Seems like a way to get new subscribers and keep subscribers who don’t read the fine print.

Brandi

Yeah, it makes me feel like they aren’t actually paying any attention to these surveys and just sent them out to make people happy. The odds are good you will get at least one of the three things you were hoping to get just by chance alone, so I think that is what they are banking on. People will get one thing on their list and think it means they paid attention to their survey.

Luna

I chose the brushes, palette, and SR Tidal, with the SR being my top choice.

FWIW, I thought I’d also mention that I’m currently on the Boxy Luxe waitlist (was put on it a few days ago), and I got the email to customize.

Jamie

I made the exact selections with Sunday Riley being my top pick as well. 🤞

Belle

I emailed boxy too. They said check your spam box, which has no email. *sigh*

I’m so disappointed. I think I will just cancel bc I not happy with the fact that I didn’t get the option to customize. Customization is for 3 items that I really wanted. I’m on overload, your loss BC.

Flora

I guess I was lucky, I never saw the a notification for this email come in and when I saw the MSA post, I searched for “Boxy” and it had gone to my spam folder. I got to customize but most of my choices were mystery so I’m not sure how much of a customization was happening 😝 I guess the least part was I was choosing to not receive the choices 🤷🏻‍♀️

On a good note, I received a shipping confirmation for the pop up sale items, definitely excited about those.

Jennifer

I really wouldn’t be bummed with any of the choices, good job Boxy!

Amie B Streckfuss

I never received the customization e-mail and contacted Boxy about this. They basically said check your spam, which of course I already did – the e-mail never came. Their response was one of “oh well.” I’m sorry but that is HORRIBLE customer service – why couldn’t they just send me a link? Instead they simply don’t care, and I am out of luck.

Why do you keep deleting my comments on this?

Rosemary

Never write a post that mentions the “Canadian Tuxedo”. However most of my comments – both positive and negative – get posted.

Nicole

They don’t delete comments, sometimes they just take awhile to show up and occasionally they just don’t. We all deal with that on this site, so don’t worry, it’s not personal or anything you said.😉

KendylKent

I am already subscribed to BoxyCharm, if I upgrade today to BoxyLuxe would I be able to pick the items I want?

Jackie

Not everyone seems to get an email. I’m on a waitlist for BoxyLuxe, so you might be too if you upgraded today.

Amie B Streckfuss

I am a Luxe subscriber and received no e-mail….???

Dot

Me either 🙁

Jackie

Me either, think not everyone gets it.

Jackie

Oh, I guess I’m on the waitlist, July was my first box.

Amie B Streckfuss

I contacted Boxy about this and they basically said too bad. I AM FURIOUS! I checked spam, junk, trash, searched everything, they NEVER SENT ME THE LINK. They told me oh well they don’t care if I never got one! HORRIBLE I am going to cancel both my subs with them, and they were one of my favs. Unacceptable.

Molly

If I signed up for boxycharm today could I upgraded too boxyluxe right away & receive the July box?

Cam

Boxycharm and boxyluxe are separate. The next boxyluxe will be September. If you sign up today for boxyluxe in time, you could customize the upcoming boxyluxe.

Sharon

Only if you clear the waitlist.

Jackie

I did a few weeks ago, they ask you if you want to upgrade right away when you subscribe. I didn’t receive this option email though, asking for my preferences, just so you know.

Jackie

Actually my account says I’m on the waitlist for boxyluxe. Didn’t realize that when they asked if I wanted to upgrade that it was actually putting me on a waitlist.

Nikki

Yes, if you subscribe today you would get the free gift, July’s box, and be on the BoxyLuxe waitlist!

I chose the curling iron as the one thing I’d want and surprise me for the rest as I am fine with any of the other choices

Jackie

I didn’t get an email, I upgraded to boxy luxe but July was my first box. Most want that serum though 🙂

Rachael Rae

They had a lot more choices under the three main things. But it was all things i have multiples of.
1pick surprise me because i just got a really nice curling wand from fff and i have tons of brushes. 2 pick.Water bottle because i already have palette and the 3 pick Sunday Riley. And answer of what i wanted most was Sunday Riley. The August boxycharm and September boxyluxe are looking great so far.

Katie P

I chose all the cheaper items 🙂 I want a new curling iron and have more than enough makeup brushes (yay!) I do not want anymore cheek or face palettes so the water bottle + sponge are fine I suppose. I don’t care for Sunday Riley Tidal because I will use that up way too fast, so the serum seems like a way better deal for me. Plus the pineapple! Ugh, I can’t wait for this box!!

SamBam

Same here ! I got the curling iron, the palette since I didn’t do boxyluxe the first time around last year September and then the pineapple serum ! Can’t wait !!

Toni Marie

I mad Amy choice selextion.. I hope that I get the curling iron and the water bottle set…

crystal lowden

Hey Tonight, I’m still waiting for my box but I think I signed up too late to make my preference on the luxe box and I really wanted
the brushes (dont curl my hair) and the palette but in case I get either the curling iron and water bottle set, Would you like to trade?😊

Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

BoxyLuxe September 2019 – Make Your Selections by 1 PM EST

Advertise With MSA

Information

Company