MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Galentine’s Day Deal – Two Exclusive POPSUGAR Mystery Boxes!

The MSA Galentine’s Day Party starts now! Stay with us and celebrate with more deals & giveaways and through 3 PM Eastern today!

POPSUGAR Must Have has created two exclusive Mystery Boxes for the MSA Galentine’s Day Party!

These boxes contain a mix of favorite items from recent and past boxes. Supplies are limited so don’t wait!

Check out the details with full spoilers below:

POPSUGAR Mystery Box #1

POPSUGAR Galentine’s “Self Care So Sweet” Mystery Box – $39.95
(Total Retail Value $190+)

Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Box of 6 Masks
Kate Spade Gold Dot Desk Calendar
Lollia “In Love” Body Wash
Osea Essential Hydrating Oil (10 ml, Retail Value $32)
Apotheke Rosebud Votive Candle
Ashkahn Love Note Cards
Winky Lux Palette
Your Choice Of: Pehr Design Napkins OR Savvy Sleepers Pillow Case


POPSUGAR Mystery Box #2

POPSUGAR Galentine’s “The Ultimate Indulgence” Mystery Box – $59.95
(Total Retail Value $400+)

Tarte Tight & Bright Multi Mask
Bliss Facial Wipes
Umbra Accessories Holder
K.Hall Designs Lavender Sachet
Hum Killer Nails Supplement
Lipstick Queen Method in the Madness Lipstick
Jules Smith Jane Cuff in Gold
2x Rise and Shine Mugs
PS Beauty Be Bright Highlighter
Your Choice Of: Clare V Fold Over Clutch OR Tribe Alive Luxe Brass Handle Bag


Check out our Galentine’s Day Deals + Giveaways Page for more great offers + giveaways through 3 PM Eastern today!


How do subscribers rate POPSUGAR Must Have?

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about POPSUGAR Must Have!

Enable notifications () to get the latest POPSUGAR Must Have spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in Galentines Day 2019, POPSUGAR Must Have Box News| Tags: POPSUGAR Must Have Box | 120 comments

Comments (120)

  1. I ordered the $60 box with the Tribe bag. Everything arrived as expected. The bag is more of a small purse style. I noticed it never showed as going out for delivery. Even today it still shows as label created?! It arrived yesterday – Monday. It bites that napkins and pillowcase orders are reversed.

  2. Yuck! Like many of you I also got the napkins instead of the pillow case. This is what I wrote to costumer service.
    I came home today and like many others that were expressing their frustration on My Subscription Addiction in the comment section I too received the napkins instead of the pillow case in the Galentines box. I’m aware of the excuses that that pillow case or napkins were sold out but really with such a pattern of customers not getting what they ordered there’s only reason to believe there is a lot of incompetence going on at Popsugar. Where’s the quality control? Can I get a refund and send back the box or should I just declare a grievance with my credit card company?

  3. I just got my boxes and received a pillow case instead of napkins.

    • Yikes!

    • Hi Jacki! Any interest in swapping your pillowcase for my napkins??

      • Absolutely! If you’re on MSA swaps you can click my name on this reply to go to my page.

  4. Another incorrect order. I ordered Pehr napkins but got the pillowcase. Did they just mistakenly ship everyone the opposite of what they selected? Did anyone get their correct selection?

    • From the comments it looks more like incompetence at Popsugar then stock shortages. Fingers crossed my own order is correct. I find out after work today.

      • Yuck! I got the napkins too instead of the pillowcase. I’m aware of the excuses that that pillow case or napkins were sold out but really with such a pattern of customers not getting what they ordered there’s reason to believe a lot of incompetence going on at Popsugar. Where’s the quality control? Wonder if I can get a refund and send back the box? I’ll look deeper into the terms.

      • I really think they mixed up the orders and sent pillowcases to everyone that ordered napkins and vice versa. If you contact them they give you a $10 refund. Not sure about a complete return, I didn’t ask.

        Also, my candle is lilac scented instead of rose. Small detail, but I was really excited for the rose scent that they advertised.

      • Yes they did give me a $10 refund. I’m personally good with the candle scent. Sorry you were looking more forward to the rose scent.

  5. I got the pillowcase instead of the napkins I chose, and have been told the napkins are out of stock and they’ll send me a $10 credit. I would swap one of you for the napkins, but remembered my aunt was looking for one of these pillowcase, so will gift it to her. Definitely more of a mix-up then I’m used to with PopSugar.

  6. I see I’m not the only one receiving the wrong items. I ordered the self care box with the pillowcase and received the napkins instead. The candle I received is Lilac not Rose as was described. :(. I’ve emailed them but sounds like I’ll get an oops we sold out of the pillowcases response. Not happy.

  7. I’m not one to complain, however, I’m really mad. I ordered the self care box all because I wanted/needed that pillowcase. I did it first thing when the sale popped up. I got my box yesterday and when I opened it, it has the freakin napkins in it! So I emailed to let them know and I got a response that they’re sorry and out of stock of the pillowcase.

    I’m angry. I should have had the opportunity to cancel my order completely if your company ran out of stock. Not be given something I didn’t want and have no need for.

    This is bad customer service. BAD.

    • Lacy, and when I ordered I went ahead and chose the napkins figuring they’d at l east match the runner I got from them….and my box arrives and I got a single pillowcase!! Now, most would be thrilled with the pillowcase, however I’ve not been able to find a matching one (I would want a pair so they would match on my bed), so… Lacy – wanna swap your napkins for my single (unopened) pillowcase?? (contact me @ labcom AT aol DOT com) If not, I’ll just give it to my daughter ~ Cheers!

      • Yes please!!!

        I emailed you 🙂

      • Lacy – emailed you back. Did you get it?

        BTW – THIS is why I love MSA (thank you Liz!), and the entire community here. Helping one another, cheering one another on, to get feedback on a product, or situations like ours here makes this site such a treat to visit.

    • I just received my box today and the same thing, napkins, no pillowcase. I only ordered primarily for the pillowcase; I already have most of the other items in that box. Seriously, we should have been given the opportunity to opt out.

      • Right!

        Why are you giving people an option when you don’t have enough stock anyway?? I’m not saying it was a bad box, but yes, it was a lot of repeats for me. I just would have saved the money if I was aware that picking the pillow-case for just for sh!ts and giggles.

      • It’s pretty darn annoying!

      • Me too! Just got my box and got napkins instead of a pillowcase. I am so disappointed… and mad. I wouldn’t have gotten this box had I known. Has anyone gotten any options from customer service like a refund, etc? I emailed them and asked for a UPS label to return the box for a full refund. Not sure if that will be possible though. Glad I’m not a subscriber of the regular box if this is how they operate their business – bait and switch.

  8. Does anyone know when these will ship?

    • I just got shipping notification!

      • I did too! That was fast. Now I just want the Spring box to ship.

  9. Pillowcase is sold out! Going for the “Self Care” box anyway. Already have too many things from the other one.

  10. I think I would keep the POPSUGAR Galentine’s “The Ultimate Indulgence” Mystery Box and gift the other box to my BFF.

  11. Love these boxes! I would keep the clutch and share the rest with my mom, sister, and BFF!! ❤️

  12. Liz,

    which Savvy Sleepers pillowcase is it? There are lots on their site.
    Thanks for all the cool deals/giveaways + Happy Galentine’s AND Valentine’s day! 🙂

  13. They both have some great items in them..and I couldn’t help but to share first with my daughter, then have a grand old time letting my neighbor and a few other now single mom friends who could use a surprise gift..and try to keep at least the candle, the handbag and a pillow case. My children are 30 & 32, so I couldn’t help sharing with the other mom’s, as while I’m not rolling in money, I no longer have to work 2 jobs to have barely enough to get my two through high school and then their university degrees + housing, + food, etc. It’s not easy paying for it on your own. I still appreciate greatly a surprise treat, and I often share items from my few subscription’s always great fun for everyone.😃

    The price of the second box is actually fairly close to the price when the bags alone (the Tribe Alive at least was available, and I FORGOT to order it – grrr) were at 75% off at their last big sale..and you get ALL of those items for almost the same price! $168 @ 75% off=$42…$18 more and ALL of those extra items? WOW! (Items were 75% off then, weren’t they?)

    • That’s how I looked at it too, regarding the price of the second box. That’s Clare V clutch retails at $220, so when they sold them at 75% off it would have been $55. For $5 more you get all the rest of the items! I picked it up just for that clutch and I can gift and share the rest! Also, I got the silver cuff before so I may keep the gold for myself!

  14. Thank you for another fun Galentines Day and keeping the tradition alive! I look forward to enjoying another awesome Popsugar box!

  15. I bought the 2nd box! Been eyeing that purse from the subscription box a while ago. So happy this time the spoilers are out at the same time as the deal!

    Thanks MSA! Happy Galentine’s Day (even though I’m hours late to the deal! Lol)

  16. Would keep the napkins to complete my set from a previous box and the candle, calender and mugs. Gift either of purses to my daughter and share the rest with her, my mom, my girl friends and the teenager that helps care for my horse when my chronic illness keeps me in bed.

  17. These are lovely boxes, but the only thing I don’t have AND want is the Claire V. clutch. I will not buy the box because I don’t even use clutches – I am a suburban stay-at-home mom who doesn’t have a jet-set lifestyle. I have a few clutches I keep just because they are pretty, though. Can’t justify this purchase.

  18. I would keep the makeup cuff handbags and candle and I would gift the rest between my mom and friends!

  19. Really debating purchasing the second one! But all I want is the Tribe Alive purse…and I could spend $60 for the box…or save my $$ for the Vegas trip in April (which is where I would love to use the purse..) Ugh decisions, decisions.

    • I bought this bag new on eBay for $15.

      • Aaaagghhh THANK YOU!! I never considered that!

    • I’ll help you…Buy it!!! And go to Vegas to shop! Enjoy life! $60 is such a steal for the bag alone. I gift the items I do not use. I actually save money using subscription boxes. Show me another way where you receive that fab bag plus have gifts to give out for $60?

      • So true, Bunny! The Vegas trip is for my girlfriend’s bachelorette and bridal shower and her gifts are mostly from the Popsugar winter box…the cookbook, blanket, a Cheers! tray from several boxes ago. A nice homey gift that did not cost me a fortune! Thank you for your insight!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.