Galentine’s Day Deal – Two Exclusive POPSUGAR Mystery Boxes!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

The MSA Galentine’s Day Party starts now! Stay with us and celebrate with more deals & giveaways and through 3 PM Eastern today!

POPSUGAR Must Have has created two exclusive Mystery Boxes for the MSA Galentine’s Day Party!

These boxes contain a mix of favorite items from recent and past boxes. Supplies are limited so don’t wait!

Check out the details with full spoilers below:

POPSUGAR Mystery Box #1

POPSUGAR Galentine’s “Self Care So Sweet” Mystery Box – $39.95
(Total Retail Value $190+)

Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Box of 6 Masks
Kate Spade Gold Dot Desk Calendar
Lollia “In Love” Body Wash
Osea Essential Hydrating Oil (10 ml, Retail Value $32)
Apotheke Rosebud Votive Candle
Ashkahn Love Note Cards
Winky Lux Palette
Your Choice Of: Pehr Design Napkins OR Savvy Sleepers Pillow Case


POPSUGAR Mystery Box #2

POPSUGAR Galentine’s “The Ultimate Indulgence” Mystery Box – $59.95
(Total Retail Value $400+)

Tarte Tight & Bright Multi Mask
Bliss Facial Wipes
Umbra Accessories Holder
K.Hall Designs Lavender Sachet
Hum Killer Nails Supplement
Lipstick Queen Method in the Madness Lipstick
Jules Smith Jane Cuff in Gold
2x Rise and Shine Mugs
PS Beauty Be Bright Highlighter
Your Choice Of: Clare V Fold Over Clutch OR Tribe Alive Luxe Brass Handle Bag


Check out our Galentine’s Day Deals + Giveaways Page for more great offers + giveaways through 3 PM Eastern today!

How do subscribers rate POPSUGAR Must Have?

516 subscribers rated this subscription
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to POPSUGAR Must Have? Add your rating now!

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in Galentines Day 2019, POPSUGAR Must Have Box News| Tags: POPSUGAR Must Have Box | 120 comments


  1. Does anyone know if the Tribe Alive purse comes with a strap? The picture on the Tribe Alive website shows it worn with a strap over the shoulder, but I haven’t seen any pictures outside of the website showing it worn the same way.

    • It doesn’t come with a strap

      • Thanks!

  2. I would definitely keep the Tribe Alive tote bag, the eye masks, the Osea, the Tarte mask and the Lollia. The rest would be divided up among my daughters.

  3. I would keep the candle, lollia cream, tarte mask and hum vitamins and the satchel. Everything else would go into a mega basket for my little cousin, she is pregnant and due in April. Refusing a babyshower so I am building a jujube breast pump bag for the little one (unisex) with lanolin, breast shields etc., but a Mom mega box would be an amazing gift too! Good luck everyone

  4. Keep the mugs, share the calendar

  5. Happy galentines day yall!😘🖤💙💙🖤👑😍😍😍😘🤗👸👸👱‍♀️👱‍♀️🧚‍♀️🧜‍♀️🧝‍♀️🧞‍♀️👭😘

  6. I bought the second box with Clare V clutch. I wanted to buy this clutch during their winter boutique sale but it sold out. So happy I got it this time. The clutch itself is worth the price of the box.
    Thanks MSA!

    • I bought the one with the Clare V clutch, too! I was so disappointed I missed it in the sale, but now for $5 more you get everything else in the box! Score!

    • Same!!

  7. So……..not ONE Galentines Deal for Canadians? Boo! How disappointing 💔

  8. I’d keep the Jules Smith Gold Cuff and Kate Spade Calendar and let my family fight over the rest of it!

  9. The ultimate indulgence.

  10. I bought these boxes, so I dropped some FFF add-ons to cover the cost. Great timing!

  11. Oh man! I have been wanting that little black puse FOREVER!!!! But I already have most of everything else in that box, many of wyare still brand new. Darn. I just can’t justify $60 for that one item.

    • Oops!!!! 🤭. I meant PURSE! 😬

      • 😂

      • 😂😂😂

    • * which are.

      Wow I can’t type today! Must be all this Galentines excitement! 🤗

    • 😂😂😂😂

  12. I ordered the luxury box. I recently discovered that my Clare V clutch had some discoloration due to my storing it incorrectly, and I was heartbroken. Plus, I’ve been wanting another one of those accessory hangers and I love that Tarte mask. This box hit all my buttons. Thanks, Liz!

  13. Great boxes!!

  14. Those are awesome!!!

  15. I bought the self care box. I have almost all the items in the ultimate indulgence box. If anyone is thinking of getting the second box for the Tribe Alive bag, do it!

  16. I think these are a great deal and much better than the historic PSMH mystery boxes. Luckily for my wallet, I already have most of these items so I’m trying to restrain myself. I’m trying to cut back on spending anyways. But I LOVE that the full spoilers were released ahead of time, that people are given options for some of the items and, again, that the contents are not just filler. What an awesome deal for those that don’t already have the stuff or haven’t been subbed to PSMH!!! Thank you so much for all of your hard work Liz. Happy Galentine’s Day everyone!

  17. I ordered the 1st box with Osea and Margot Elena. ❤️ Love these PS mystery boxes!! 💖

  18. Love the self care box ❤️ Since I’m not already a Popsugar box subscriber I didn’t have any of these items! The face oil and Margot Elena body wash alone made it worth it to me. I’m excited to try the pillow case as well. Thanks so much for posting!!

  19. Since I can’t find a link to the second box, is it sold out already?? 🙁

    • Nevermind 🙂

    • After you click the link, scroll down the page it takes you to. The second box is farther down on the screen.

      • Thank you Eileen!! I was having a duh moment…. 🙂

  20. In the Self Care so Sweet box it says the candle is Rosebud but the box shows Lilac Petitgrain. On the Apotheke site the description of the Lilac Petitgrain includes clove and doesn’t sound like it would smell like Roses. Hoping it smells good.

    • I think it’s the Rosebud from the Outlander box. 👌

  21. I just purchased the Indulgence one with the Tribe Alive Black Bag! This is a total score as I was going to buy the Tarte Mask alone for $40.

  22. Grabbed one of each, gifts for me and gifts for others. 😊 Thanks and Happy Galentine’s Day!

    • Yay! Those are some good gifts! 🎉

  23. I would buy the first box it is wasnt already mid february. .. the calendar is a miss.

    • Unless you don’t have a pretty calendar at your desk already. Don’t need to miss out on 10 other months of use just because you didn’t get it before Jan 1

  24. If I knew I was getting the pillowcase I would have gotten the first. Sadness.

    • If I’m understanding you correctly, you want to pick the pillowcases? It does say “your choice of”

    • I just ordered the first box because of the pillowcase. You get to pick 🙂

    • It’s your choice, so you get to pick.

    • You can choose whichever you want when you order!

    • Okay maybe it would have been better had I kept my mistake to myself, now I really want it!!

  25. Alternately refreshing the FFF add-on sale and the MSA Galentine’s page ;D

    • Me too!

  26. Great boxes!

  27. The boxes are an awesome deal. Fortunately, I already received many of these items from their subscription box. So I am safe for now.

  28. That second box is a great deal, wasn’t that tribe alive purse around a $200 RV?

    • Yep…$168!

  29. Such great choices! Happy Galentine’s Day to everyone!

  30. Happy Galentine’s Day!!

  31. Happy Galentines Day my lovely box addicts!

    • You too beautiful (:

  32. got the 2nd box! i love my mystery boxes!

  33. A few items I have missed before, very nice deals!

  34. Happy Galentine’s Day to all of my friends on MSA, and all of my Swap Buddies!

  35. Good boxes but I have them so my wallet is safe.

  36. Happy Galentines Day! 😊

  37. Liz,
    What size Osea does it bring?

    • It’s the full size (10 ml) version. $32 retail value. Hope that helps!

      • Thank you Liz!!!

    • It looks like the 1/3 oz rollerball, but I could be wrong.

    • It should be the one ounce/30 mil bottle they sent in the Outlander giveaway box.

      I received it in Nov with the candle, cards and Lollia shower gel which is full sized too.

  38. Oh happy day… 🙂

  39. Happy Galentines Day Everyone !!!!

  40. I wish I could afford it but luckily they are just out of my price range right now.

  41. Never knew this box existed. Looks good!

  42. Happy Galentine’s Day! 🙂

  43. Easy Pass!

  44. So glad these boxes show everything, I would’ve definitely bought if they hadn’t lol, and i have most of these things! Phew!

  45. I like that full spoilers are given.

    Happy Galentine’s Day everyone 💕

  46. Happy Galentine’s Day!

  47. These are nice boxes, if I didn’t already have most of these items from my subscription. I do find it funny they call them “mystery boxes,” even though they provided full spoilers.

  48. I already have everything I like about each of these boxes…but I hope lots of others get what they like from them 🙂

  49. Just wanted to be the first to comment. Happy Galentine’s Day Everyone!

    • Happy Galentine’s Day!!!

  50. I’ve never been so happy to not want a box. Only because I knew I’d give in to PS FOMO but feel good about not getting it.

    • Happy Galentine’s Day to Everyone!😊💝❤️

      • Yes and Happy Galentines. I’ve been on a high buy or something for a few months, I’m sort of excited to not want everything.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!



Get alerts on your desktop for the best deals and spoilers!