Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
Alltrue (formerly CAUSEBOX) is a seasonal lifestyle membership that unites a community of individuals who stand for good, seek truth, and take action. Every season, Alltrue members receive a curation of carefully vetted socially-conscious lifestyle products (from fashion and homewares to skincare... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I like it, but I can’t justify subscribing without knowing there’s at least 1 more thing in the box I will use. I think it’s sill that they’re revealing the spoilers so far apart. By the time we know what the 2nd one is I may have already spent my “monthly box cash” on something else I see.
Reply
Diana
The design is modern and fun. I’m not into the color palette and may not use it because of that. Were this in green or blue it would have been a favorite.
Reply
Ks
It looks like Mr. Hanky is in the mix?
Reply
Sara
😂
Reply
Lisa
OMG, THANK YOU for saying that! The first thing I thought when I saw this is it looks like a bunch of turds. I’m sorry for saying it but it does. I mean brown for Xmas. That’s just wrong!! Put a little Christmas hat and a face on it. Thanks for making me smile!!
Reply
Kelly
I’m getting cool frames and framing the wrapping paper to make neat decorative pictures. I think it’ll look cool on my huge statement wall.
Reply
Jen Chan
I was a little excited about wrapping paper since wrapping presents is my absolute favorite thing to do, and I quite liked the color scheme, but I was worried that I probably wouldn’t receive my box till January if the fall shipping schedule is any indication. Now that I’ve read all your comments, I can’t unsee the “poop” and I’m not sure if I want to use it at all! (> . <)
Reply
Keri
Yeah…this isn’t actually a ‘spoiler’. It is the ‘special surprise’ released with the artwork reveal. Yes, it is an ‘item’ in the box but it isn’t actually a spoiler. The first spoiler isn’t until Monday. I personally am really excited to be getting this wrapping paper. I love the design and it’s something useful that I can use.
Reply
Jenny
I think the paper is beautiful! I’m so excited to use it this season for friends and family gifts, especially for the adults!
Reply
Jessica
What am i supposed to do with this? Keep it in the bathroom for inspiration?
Reply
Michelle
Thank you! To me it looks like a big pile of stretched out doo doo. Hmmmm wonder what Dr Freud would think of me.
Reply
Jackie
LOL you could always frame it hahaha
Reply
Jessica
Really?? poop paper?
Reply
kjennifer70
I’m a fan of the box design and wrapping paper. What I’m most excited about is the video showing the box design and paper, what was behind it. Looks like a shawl or pashmina hanging on a rack, definitely goes with the cozy theme.
Reply
Lana
Not into the “brown fall leaves” gift wrap. I imagine it will come folded in the box vs rolled, which I personally find unusable. I might be in the minority, but I’d miss the postcard, I’m actually usually excited about those
Reply
Beth
These are way more useful than the postcard from previous boxes, so I’ll take it! Looking forward to the real spoilers
Reply
Courtney
it seems to me that this box fab fit fun and POPSUGAR are all pretty similar but that fab fit fun seems to have almost cheesy cheap products mixed in with one or two nice items. For this type of bucks which one would you guys really recommend for the price ?
Reply
Jenn R
And I’d recomment FFF, just not this season. Go through the reviews for annual, estimate your own value on the items, then see which subscription surpasses the cost of entry. For me, FFF passes the bar every time, and the addon value far exceeds what I pay for my annual sub. This past box is not great, but I have $100 in addons with at least a $300 value coming with it. And hero items (like last winter’s ExfolKate) completely make it worthwhile.
Reply
Noelle
I’d recommend PSMH. They are a bit more expensive, but the items are almost always high quality. I love the premise behind Causebox, but their shipping issues make me hesitant to buy another. Also, my pretty gray dot tote from the fall box has already broken. One of the straps fell clean off. However, this season I’m most interested in Happy Rebel. At $100, it’s more expensive than the other three, but their winter box offers customization for each item for all subscribers, not just annual.
Reply
socaldeb
They’re similar in the sense that they all incorporate a variety of personal care and lifestyle items. Beyond that, I see Causebox as different from the other two because of the fair trade, artisan aspect. Causebox is about empowering artisans who are using their craft to lift themselves out of poverty, or companies that use their profits to do that for others. No celebrity books in a Causebox.
Whether that makes them better, worse, or indifferent is up to you. I like the whole idea, but I’m not going to throw money at stuff I don’t want because of it. (Fortunately, I’m not – I liked my fall Causebox, and I’m perfectly OK with the tree-themed wrapping paper. Sure looking forward to the real spoilers though!)
Reply
Michelle
I agree that FFF quality is lacking. I got all 3 of these for fall and my favorite was causebox. I’m gifting a few of the FFF items for Christmas, it’s the only reason I purchased. As far as PSMH, it’s quite a bit more expensive, and I’m only using a few things. When it was finally cool enough for a scarf, I reached for the Causebox scarf, the PSMH scarf is still in it’s packaging.
Reply
Jen
Same with me!
Tlc
Is it me, or is Causebox really full of themselves….first the hype over “box design”, then special news about the same design on a sheet of paper….
Seems like these announcements would be better served at their company Happy Hour or Launch Party.
This is not what subscribers pay for…oh well. It’s pretty weird if you ask me…just weird.
Hurray for Causebox!! Thanks for sharing the design on the box that gets recycled and for including some wrapping paper, that will get thrown away also. Are we done yet??
Reply
Beth L
Lol I feel ya completely…. You made me laugh…
Reply
Lynn m.
The big difference is Causebox tends to go with legit artists designing their boxes as opposed to the current employee/free clip art/ etc
Reply
LB
It doesn’t seem any more odd to me than other subs announcing “themes” before the actual contents…like PSMH used to. Causebox has done this for years after they started making special box designs. Apparently no one cared much until they became more popular.
Reply
Tlc
I don’t mind themes since they heavily hint about the curation…imho 😊
Can’t wait to see real spoilers!!
PR
How big are the sheets?
Reply
Jenn
I have seen a lot of complaints about people not getting the fall box yet… will this one even arrive on time to use the wrap for christmas?
Reply
Meagan
This. I’ve tried to order their boxes twice, and neither has been timely. The first I finally cancelled, and the second I am still waiting on.
Reply
Cynthia
This is a freebie not a spoiler. Current members got this in an email yesterday. Monday the 12th is the first real spoiler.
Reply
Lisa
Seriously, I cant even with this right now as I’m sitting here still waiting on my Fall Box I ordered over a month ago!
Reply
T.Marie
That’s nice. I like using unconventional stuff. However, is this ONE sheet? Def a weird spoiler
Reply
LB
You get one sheet of each colorway, so a total of 3.
Reply
Suzanne
Seems VERY fall to me and not winter. I’m not enticed to buy this box so far.
Reply
Jen
Save it for next fall then or use it for other types of gifts. Not everyone celebrates Christmas anyway.
Reply
Meagan
Dose not read holiday or winter to me, either.
Reply
Jennyjenny
Lol these comments are hilarious. Maybe I’m the minority but I really like these. I like that it’s not red or green because this can be used to wrap fall birthday presents or Christmas presents.
But I will say that this isn’t what I’d choose as a first “spoiler” more like a bonus item I think…
Reply
Jessica
I like them, too! The design looks Scandinavian to me.
Reply
LB
I love the usefulness of this item and design too. I see how the leaves and browns seem more fall but I know I have 100 year old oak trees in my back yard that won’t be losing their brown leaves until at least January this year. LOL. Also, this is not really a first spoiler. It’s the “surprise” and subscribers got this email yesterday. The real spoiler is not until Monday. This is similar to how they released the postcard design for the summer box first since it was related to the box design.
Reply
Yuki
I’m with you. I love the wrapping paper.
Reply
Heidi
Mr. Hanky!!
Reply
Jen
That was my initial thought too!!
Reply
Jenn
😂😂
Reply
Jb
I get that the poop emoji shapes are supposed to be fall leaves, but maybe if the background were green or red this would be more festive?
Reply
Redhed36
I noticed that her signature is at the bottom right corner of each piece maybe (depending on presentation and quality) this is something you keep and in the event she becomes super famous you have them. I don’t know if I’d use these.
Reply
Redhed36
Very pretty, but not something to draw people in. Hopefully the rest of the items are A LOT better than this.
Reply
S
I’m not a fan. What occasion is brownish paper with unappealing lumps appropriate for? 🤔
Reply
Pamela
You guys are cracking me up with these comments. But aren’t these leaves? I mean maybe not, but that’s how I first saw them and thought it was kind of cute, but now I think I’d be hesitant to use it with all this negative feedback, lol.
Very true though, brown isn’t something I’d ever pick in wrapping paper, especially since by the time we get this it will be full-on Winter!!
Reply
T.Marie
I used brown wrapping paper last Christmas was Christmas trees on it. Part of my family is huge into the environment so, this was hit.
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.