Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
We have more info for the spoilers for the December Allure Beauty Box just for MSA readers! We now have size info (lots of full size items!) and one item is a variant.
If you subscribe now, your first box will be the November box. And Allure is offering a Versace bonus for new subscribers! Use this link to save $5 off your first box and get a deluxe mini Versace Dylan Blue Pour Femme Eau de Parfum!
Each month, you'll get 6+ Allure-approved makeup and skincare picks delivered to your door ($100+ value for only $25). 6 or more products (at least 3 FULL-SIZE) valued at $100+ with only expert-approved products, hand-selected by Allure editors. Enjoy a new member gift valued at $15+ free shippin... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I have a feeling the products are only going to get worse because they are going to be sending out make up bags with each box. I was so happy the other day when I found out that Ipsy is going to quit sending bags with their boxes. I guess I just can’t get away from them 🙁 I could open a bag store with the inventory I have. Ipsy said that the value of the bag will be going towards better/bigger items. I assume the opposite will be true with Allure.
Reply
missann
Why do you assume the opposite for Allure? I try not to assume things because I’m usually wrong when I assume things without any facts. So, I just curious why you would say that….
Reply
Joan Miguel
I just called to cancel and they made no offers to keep my subscription. I didn’t want the December box, but hoped they’d try to entice me to stay:(
Reply
Maria
I’ve had an unbelievable number of problems with them so I finally did the same after they messed up my account so bad including changing my email and payment info without my permission (which caused me to miss a box and not be able to get into my account online (which is also attached to my magazine subscription account so that’s awesome.) I reached out via email to customer service numerous times to try and resolve it but they made no effort at all to acknowledge their mistakes or fix them. They pretty much ignored the specifics and sent me canned responses not applicable to the situation. I reiterated all my concerns and experiences when I finally canceled and requested (again) they fix my email for my magazine account since it’s prepaid for years. They didn’t mention that at all and just replied simply stating they processed my cancellation.
Clearly Allure doesn’t care about customers at all and/or the folks they hire for customer care are not exactly the sharpest tools in the shed. A company like Allure (which is just a branch of the gigantic Conde Nast group) that large having such abominable customer service is crazy.
As much as I despise them now, their boxes are often so good that I took other MSA readers’ advice and just joined through Amazon. It’s so easy to order when you like the spoilers (even late in the month), then cancel until you decide if you want the next month. The $10 a box subscriber retention deals are great (they offered me 4 months of them a while back) but this way you save almost as much money since you can skip months that don’t wow you, like December’s lame box. 😄
Reply
Oma
I wish Allure would stop it with the variations in boxes. It would be nice if they didn’t spoil their spoilers as well. I was actually excited about the pallet at first as I do need a good ‘basic bioch’ pallet but then they went and changed it to a mini version?
Reply
Jen
Oma how does this palette even condense to a mini version? We get what 3 shades? I agree..annoyed ab that. I love my allure but yeah if I hadnt read your comment when it comes I’d have been wth is this tiny thing? Where is my palette? Lol
Reply
michaela
That shown there IS the mini – 6 shades.
Oma
Hi Jen! I don’t wear eyeshadow like I used to but when the spoiler came out, I got excited! The full size palette is one I would’ve used for sure but then again, Christmas! I still have a teenager at home and a grown but young niece that I share stuff from my subs with. My niece was so excited about the “Basic B!tch”! Then the next day, BOOM! It’s a mini! The mini version has 6 shades. My niece will still take it. But at 1st, when it was the full size pallet (she’s a cosmetologist), she was pretty adamant that I keep it and use it. Now that it’s the mini, nope. I’ll be happy to pass it on. I’ve been getting subs since March of ‘16. Started w/ Ipsy & Birchbox, dumped BB for Play, dumped Play for BB5(no longer in business),dumped BB5 for Allure. I don’t do the Walmart at all anymore. I buy some Target boxes but haven’t in a few months. I’m basically down to Allure & Ipsy + some ipsy offers. Allure isn’t going to stop with the variations unless enough customers continue to CALL and complain. That’s exactly what I was told.
Cady
I hav the full size of that palette and I can say that the mini has the best shades from it so at least there’s that!
Reply
Kate
I mean, it’s annoying their spoilers come out so early but you could just…not look at them.
Reply
Barbara
I’m a bit baffled by so many people’s dissatisfaction with the November and December boxes…I think they are crazy great. The value, the curation and brands offered are knock outs, particularly for a $10-$15 box!
Reply
missann
I know right? I adore all my boxes, they are all very thought out.
Reply
Charlotte
The retail value for both is actually pretty low, for Allure, which promise $85 worth of products in every box but often delivers much more. But mostly, it’s a YMMV thing. The only product I’m excited about in November is the Glow Recipe mask; I have sensitive skin so the Glamglow is unusable for me, and the rest of the products are nothing special. And I do not care for the December box at all: drug store items, yet another liquid eyeliner and highlighter, a mask with denatured alcohol as a major ingredient? Just a big fail all around, for me. I will probably keep the Ofra highlighter since apparently it can be used as eyeshadow as well (two of the three colors are too dark for my pale skin), and put the rest up for swap.
Reply
Barbara
Charlotte: So if you take October’s box ($65.95) and December’s box ($73.50), I think you can safely say these 2 month’s are at the HIGH end of the spectrum…not the low end as you cite.
Now not liking the curation of these boxes in one thing and quite understandable as we are all so different in our needs, but let the actual numbers speak to your first objection. Best of luck in the swaps, hope you end up with what you want.
Barbara
Charlotte: Actually, November’s box had a retail value of approx $65.95 and this December box at $73.50 as close as I can see. And as far as your claim that Allure states their boxes to be a $85 value, well, I have never seen that one at all.
As a matter of fact, if you check their subscription page this is Allure’s actual claim: “Monthly box featuring beauty picks with a $50-90 value for only $15”. These boxes have a range in final retail and are not locked into one monthly price.
So if you take October’s box ($65.95) and December’s box ($73.50), I think you can safely say these 2 month’s are at the HIGH end of the spectrum…not the low end as you cite.
Now not liking the curation of these boxes in one thing and quite understandable as we are all so different in our needs, but let the actual numbers speak to your first objection. Best of luck in the swaps, hope you end up with what you want.
Angela
i hate the way people complain, this is your decision to purchase …save your money on something you might be GRATEFUL for then….
Reply
missann
2 Words. Chronic Malcontents. Why keep buying and complaining? Just say no or bubye but bullying a company does nothing but take up space in the comments. I would like to read about the products and how they do or don’t work for others. Complaints belong in an email or phone call to the company. What good does it do to write them here?
Reply
Jessica
I hate the way people complain about people complaining on a REVIEW sight…That’s what this sight is for is opinions on the curation and the products. This is exactly the place to come and praise or complain. If you can’t handle peoples opinions good or bad, maybe a REVIEW sight is not for you.
Reply
Angela
so excited to try this new pallet i have yet to try out the brand yet I see Nikki T useing it all the time
Reply
Jazzy
Yay! Allure! What a great way to end a year! Love it!
Reply
lila
when would i have to sign up for this box? the 1st?
Reply
Oja
They show their current box on their website, so I’d check the site on Dec 1st just to make sure they’ve switched over and then subscribe. You can also subscribe through Amazon, which is way easier to cancel/resubscribe and generally quicker to ship, but you won’t get the discount.
Reply
Heather
Feeling great about my decision to cancel.
Reply
Kailene
I might be alone here but a mini eyeshadow pallet really appeals to me as someone who subs to boxycharm, Ipsy plus, and how allure I’m on eyeshadow overload! I like the idea of a small travel pallet that’s wearable. I’m new to allure but to me they’ve been killing it.
Reply
crunkal
I agree. This box looks amazing and a purse or handbag sized travel palette would be so great.
Reply
Cat
Nov and Dec don’t have the same wow factor for me after the Oct box which was nice. Masks are good, but I don’t feel like I get as much when it’s all masks. I like Nikkie, but I’m not impressed with nyx lippie and Neutrogena wipes or bliss products that target carries now and puts in their boxes. Also, peel off masks no thank you. I like the mini Juvia’s palette and love their formula so that will be a great travel palette, very wearable colors.
Reply
Jen
I feel the same…for $15 and how much ALLURE HAS WOWED me for the past year, December is ….sad….the eyeliner may be ok since its waterproof, if i get the balm or eye foils that be ok..but nyx color/quality i will give away, idk ab the mini palette until.i see it, im.cool.colors, and the wipes and rest is …sad….of my 10 beauty subs Allure is one of my top 3 but December is..sad…LOL..did i mention sad? LOL…I know Allure isnt too christmas broke like the rest of us lol
Reply
Sarah
Allure is starting to become a disappointment. Not that the box isn’t always a great value, I’m just personally tired of the variations and changing products after the 1st spoiler.
Reply
Courtney
December’s box looks good to me… I like everything BUT the highlighter! We recently just got a full sized highlighter in our Allure box && we get them in so many other subscription boxes!!!! So sick of highlighters! You only use a little bit anyways were one would last forever, & I have literally like 10 already that I don’t use. Will definitely be giving this away! Ugh rant over…. But otherwise I am very happy with this box!!!
Reply
Barbara
Courtney:
I usually feel the same way about highlighters…heck I could paint my house with all that I have in my stash. BUT, the OFRA highlighter is truly different and is the single best highlighter I have ever used. Personally, this one is attractive to me since it gives us a trio of colors. Give it a shot, I can attest to the splendor that is the OFRA highlighter.
Reply
Jen
I am super disappointed – but not at all surprised- to get Nikki “anything for views” Tutorials overpriced $30 highlighter VS the full size $20 Nubian palette.. I hate the cheapness of Ofra’s packaging considering the price tag they put on it.. I have used Ofra highlighters in the past and I’m not impressed AT ALL when compared to the flood of other highlighting products on the market around that price point.. Wet and Wild cosmetics with a high end price tag to line “influencers” pockets – “Well I just scammed my fan base selling a $2 highlighter for $29. I don’t know what to do with this 6 million I just made, guess I’ll just go buy 10 more Cartier bracelets” … Girl, no ma’am, scam the house! I HATE IT SO MAAACH!!
Reply
Sarah v
Okay slightly disappointed. Was excited that it was going to be the full size Nubian palette from juvias
Reply
Emily
I was SO close to signing up, mostly because of that palette but then I saw it was on sale at Ulta and decided I had enough subscription boxes and I would just buy the palette. Glad I did, I would have been pretty bummed to find out it was a mini.
Reply
Michelle
I jumped back in with both feet!! I love love love Juvia’s place. I have 2 palettes { not this one though}, a lipstick, and their blush palette and I love them all. Beautiful, pigmented, lasts all day and not drying or chunky. I know I could buy this palette but I have been wanting to come back and this box did it for me.
Reply
Maggie
I’m really excited about this box! I’ve been wanting to try out some Juvia’s Place. Overall, I really like both the November & December boxes.
Reply
Toni Marie
I think in going to buy a extra box as a gift in Decemeber….this is an adorable box by allure.
Reply
Maria
I’m not loving this box. Since this was a special edition box I thought it would have more items to wow me like drunk elephant or more Sunday Riley.
Reply
Maria
It’s not just you. Is there a way we can skip a month?
Reply
Heather
Yup you can call them (and maybe email) to skip. I called and was planning on cancelling, but was offered a free gift if I stayed subscribed and allowed to skip until January.
Noelia
Deseando que sea diciembre, me encanta!!
Reply
Barbara
Overall, I adore ALLURE as well as BOXYCHARM. I have pretty much cancelled most other sub’s at this point.
Reply
Barbara
Tat: That was a bit rough…she was asking for some help.
Reply
amber
And she answered…maybe she didn’t have the 800 number memorized, but she told her that it was there to find.
Reply
Kim
I hope I don’t get the eye masks – not happy about that update . The rest of the box looks good to me
Reply
Charlotte
None of this is appealing to me. I’d cancel but I don’t want to lose my spot in “line” for the higher-value variations Allure’s been doing. If January is as disappointing as this, though – bye bye, Allure.
Reply
Jana
Yeah – I’m not feeling the December box either! I need to figure out when my 4 for $10 offer expires. I have so many subs and so much stuff and now after the Target Holiday boxes am pretty set – even though I just sent my daughter a huge box full of skin care, makeup and brushes.
Reply
Lily
I LOVE this box! 🙂
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.