Tell Us What Subscription Box To Review Next!


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Every week we pick out new boxes to review (based on reader requests, reviewer requests, and companies that reach out to ask for a review.) And we thought it was time to do a post asking for requests!

What subscription boxes would you like us to review next? Is there a specific box you want to see? A category of subscription boxes you’d like us to review more? Or a box we’re already reviewing that you’d like an additional perspective on? (For example, a different take on StitchFix, etc.)

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Subscription Box News| 111 comments

111 Comments

  1. Glamour Doll Eyes

    Surprise Monthly

  2. I’d like to see Pause and Unwind

  3. Bomibox and Bomibag; love the products every month and would love to hear more opinions on how others are using the K beauty skincare items.

    • Yes! I would like to see these too.

  4. I saw an ad on insta for Fabcrate, an activewear subscription box. I’m interested to see what that would include.

  5. The docolor suscription box thats coming soon!

  6. I would like to see if there are any subscriptions for cancer fighters and/or survivors. With so many people affected by this, you would think there would be at least one. Of course I may have missed it if there is! Thank you!

  7. You should review Storybook Cosmetic’s Book Club Subscription book. The first one launches in August and it looks super cool. I would love to see it reviewed here!

    • I second this!!!

    • Omg. I second this too!

    • I would love to see this!

  8. OK, one more:
    Ask-for-the-Nations Monthly handmade Jewelry box (Cratejoy) I like that they have $15 and $25 options.

    • This box looks cool. I personally love homemade jewelry that uses leather, beading, wood, precious stones, etc. This sort of jewelry is unique and pieces like these I hold onto for years.

      I second reviewing this box!

    • The jewelry looks beautiful from Ask for the Nations. I love homemade jewelry with natural materials. I second this request!

  9. Anchor of Hope box with items made by refugees and survivors of human trafficking (on Cratejoy)

    Em and Liz, which is for girls ages 3-10 (just saw it on Cratejoy).

    • My daughter gets Em and Liz and it is just the cutest for young girls! Shipping is really fast and reliable too!

  10. I’m toying about getting StitchFix for my 6 year old daughter so it would be great to see some reviews in that age range for girls.

  11. Explore Local Box! It’s a box that features artisans and small businesses in a different US city each month. I just bought a sub for my mom for her birthday. It’s a great box!

    • Please review Kimy Beauty Box.Need monthly reviews, and there is only one from last winter.

  12. That wallflower introvert box!

    • Just subscribed to The Wallflower box. Thanks for mentioning it here! Looks like a nice cozy happy box. And they give a 10% off code for the first box, which is worth $5.40.

    • Yes, the Wallflower Introvert box looks interesting and seems like it has quality items.

  13. Oceanista! Everything I have seen from them looks beautiful!

    • I agree. Oceanista would be great!

    • Sea glass rings! I love what they’re curating. Caved.

  14. Simply Beautiful by B.C. living

  15. I would love to see more than one Golden Tote review per month. I just love seeing the variation in the totes! I know sometimes you review a mini and a regular tote, but I just can’t get enough.

  16. I would like to see the London Pop box.

  17. I would like you to please start communicating with Luxe Provence again and reviewing their restructured boxes, the ” Blush” line which is the less expensive boxes. Their Luxe Provence ” Blush” quarterly box for fall looks very nice. I’m thinking of getting another subscription but I worry without any current or recent reviews ( NOT spoilers- not the same thing at all).

    Next up is Fall, which will ship in October. I have LOVED almost everything they’ve ever sent- Rose et Marius, many luxurious brands. Frette hand towels with inserted lace in one box and they are so hard to try to get shipped to the USA!

    • Also, I wish you’d have a new look at ” Wonderful Objects”. It was reviewed regularly, then they had a shipping delay or two in late 2017.
      I was a subscriber and got all my boxes. They’ve contacted me about renewing my subscription and have really beautiful stories to tell for the rest of 2018.

      I’m sick of makeup that’s not the right cool tone or light enough. I have enough really great skin care to last to the zombie apocalypse, and I buy my own clothing and shoes from my special favorite places.

      I’m wanting to branch out and hope MSA will consider more luxurious boxes rather than the always inexpensive ones. 🙂

      • I second that!

  18. Pink Parcel—UK-based period box with feminine supplies and beauty products and treats. $17.99 a month.

  19. Just saw an in boxing for Marier box on YouTube. It’s supposed to be a beauty and lifestyle box. Would love to see more info on it.

  20. Do you still review love goodly? I enjoyed that box. Also, I saw a facebook post for a box called cracked hippie. I was curious about it.

    • Love Goodly is still reviewed.

  21. I would love to see the jewelry sub. “Kloxet” reviewed. $25 a month

  22. Material World box or that goth corporate box discussed previously? I want to see what other clothing options are out there.

  23. It would be nice to have more reviews of subscription boxes, with reviews of the actual books (I can volunteer for that lol)

  24. Enchanted Gypsy Box

    • The box looks interesting, however “g*psy” is a slur and it’s sad to see so many companies use it ignorantly. I would not like to see it here.

      • There is actually a definition for the word gypsy and it appears accurate. True they have been portrayed in the past unfavorably but I am sure most companies with the name gypsy in it did not do it to intentionally slur anyone. Maybe you need to subscribe to the Hygge Box and chill out.

    • Oh yes I’d love to see Enchanted Gypsy box. They look like they have some great items

  25. I heard about a new coffee subscription, Beans of Motivation. It would be cool to read your review of it!

  26. Please please please start reviewing Goodbeing again!

    • Agreed! It’s one of my favorites and seems to be reviewed here and there.

  27. Mint mongoose

  28. Hygge box.

  29. I’d also like to see Toy Box Monthly reviewed again, preferably for boys. Eric did some reviews last year but only up to June, and he mentioned checking out other reviews but they’re even older, from 2016. Thanks!

  30. Fruit for Thought & North River Co

  31. Toy Box monthly for boy and for a girl I am nervous to sub I like value and feel like I can save some money verses buying retail.so anytime you want to review it I will be waiting..hehehehehe I have a 7yr old daughter who spends her money on surprise packs and I believe this sub has many but not quite sure.

  32. I would love to see fairyloot (a book box and bookish items) and gobstone alley (a Harry Potter box) reviewed!

  33. I’ve heard about these two new boxes.
    Tribebeauty and PrVault.

    • Look up tribe here for some past reviews. They have done reviews and there’s also been a lot of drama and controversy with that one.

  34. Coastal co box and Polepunzel

    • Ooh and also Sweet minerals box

      • Sweet Minerals has been reviewed here.

    • Pollepunzel…..That’s what I get for signing up on the waitlist before reading. It’s curated towards pole dancers. Hell I can barely floor dance.

  35. My Lit Box!

  36. Sanaya Set Sanaya Set Sanaya Set, please!
    Both things I put up for swap from them disappeared very quickly!

  37. You guys stopped reviewing My Hygge box, which is disappointing. So that or Hygge Love, the other one on cratejoy.

  38. I would love to see more Home centered boxes reviewed. I would love to see the range of options that exist. I know you did a review of the home centered boxes you guys currently review a while back- but I would like to see other options.

    Also, can you review the Bombay and Cedar mini? I would love to compare and contrast- see if it’s worth getting BOTH boxes instead of just the bigger one.

    • I want to second the request for Bombay & Cedar mini. I think many of us are really curious about this new option.

  39. I would love to see more Home centered boxes reviewed. I know a while back you had a review of a lot of the home boxes you already review, but I would love to see new ones. Hopefully that have a nice range of decorative pieces.

  40. I love my Sparkle Hustle Grow box!!!

  41. TRENDSEND please!

  42. TheInkyBox art pen subscription.

  43. mintMONGOOSE.

    • I was able to comment the same thing! Mint Mongoose seems amazing for the price.

      • Had never heard of it, now I’m subbed. Sounds too good to be true, pretty excited!

        • I received their April box and was blown away. The pieces feel like quality custom jewelry and the packaging was amazing.

          • That’s the best thing about this thread. Everyone is naming these boxes I’ve never heard of. Google search. Subscribed. LOL! My wallet hates it, but my jewelry-loving daughter is going to love MintMongoose. Thanks for the recommendation, ladies. Looks like a great box! I hope the MSA folks pick it up to review.

    • Agree

    • Agreed! MintMONGOOSE

    • Yup, I agree with that one. Great price and I wonder if the pieces are as nice as they look online!

      • Also I got my first box for $7 with code FIRST7

  44. I would love to find a box with good planner supplies. I’ve been on the hunt, and I haven’t seen anything I like. I would love to see a review of one you liked.

  45. Like the above post, I miss the consistent Sisley reviews. I always look for any posts on my favorite beauty sub!

    • Agreed! I love Sisley and would love more reviews. FYI, for those of us who love this brand it’s helpful to find a consultant in a local department store ie. Neimans. I’ve purcahsed a few favorite items and my consultant keeps me updated with specials and sends samples frequently. I’ve been able to try one of their products for a month using samples and the full size costs $595. I’ll have to save up awhile for that!!!!

  46. I would love to see Saucefly reviewed again!

    • I second this! Saucefly is so unique. I always got hungry reading the reviews.

  47. Adrians Boutique

    • Adrians Boutique yes that seems like a very nice shop there is a mermaid and my 7yr old would go gaga like most girls her age.

  48. Maybe a comparison of charity boxes (where some of the $ goes to charity or a good cause). Are there any wildlife /animal boxes that aren’t specifically for pets?

  49. Flont – Fine Jewelry Rental box

  50. Not a new box, but I miss your Nosejoy reviews. I would like to see those again.

    • Me, too. Nosejoy

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!